人力資源部門內部服務品質因子及其與組織績效之關係：中高階主管觀點

Internal Service Quality Factors of Human Resource Department and their Relationships with Organizational Performance: Top and Middle Managers' Viewpoints

10.6147/JHRM.2005.0502.03

溫金豐(Jin-Feng Uen)；王秉鈞(Bin-Jinn Wang)；陳文芳(Wen-Fang Chen)

人力資源管理 ； 內部服務品質 ； 內部行銷 ； 組織績效 ； human resource ； internal service quality ； internal marketing ； organizational performance

人力資源管理學報

5卷2期（2005 / 06 / 01）

39 - 66

繁體中文

內部服務品質是一個重要的議題，人力資源的主管和專業人員要改進內部服務的品質，必須瞭解他們的顧客對於內部服務的認知與態度。本研究是以顧客導向為基礎的，希望經由內部顧客的看法去評估人力資源部門的服務。研究發現，企業主管們對人力資源部門所期望的主要服務品質因素有「創新」、「週延性」、「解決問題」、「可靠性」、「積極性」、「結構與控制」、「實體資源」以及「專業能力」等八項因素，而「週延性」和「專業能力」是企業主管們認為最重要的二個變項，也是主管們的期望與實際情況差距最多的二項，他們對於人力資源部門在「可靠性」方面，有較高且一致的評價。另外，「結構與控制」和「可靠性」對組織的績效有很重大的影響力；本研究也發現，就二種服務品質模式對組織績效的預測力而言，採用「直接績效評量模式」的內部服務品質衡量對管理績效與市場績效的解釋能力皆優於「績效與期望差距模式」。

The management of internal service quality is a critical issue. If managers and specialists of human resource want to improve their internal service quality, they must understand the internal service quality factors which their customers consider important. This study assessed the human resource services quality through viewpoints of the internal customers, the managers in the organizations. It is found that the service quality factors which managers expected were: ”innovation,” ”completeness,” ”problem solving,” ”reliability,” ”aggressiveness,” ”structure and control,” ”physical resources,” and ”professional ability.” From the results, we found the completeness and professional ability were the most important two factors to the managers investigated. Managers also indicated that these two factors had the largest gaps between the real and expected levels. Most of the respondents thought the reliability was good for their HR departments. In addition, structure and control, and reliability of HR service had significant impacts on the organizational performance. Comparing the ”Direct Evaluation Model” with the ”Gap Model” of the internal service measurement, the first one had better explaining power to both management and market performance of the organizations.

1. Berry, L. L.(1981).The employee as customer.Journal of Retail Banking,3(March),33-40.
2. Berry, L. L.,Parasuraman, A.(1991).Marketing services: Competing through quality.New York:The Free Press.
3. Berry, L. L.,Zeithaml, V. A.,Parasuraman, A.(1985).Quality counts in services, too.Business Horizons,May-June,44-52.
4. Boulding, W.,Kalra, A.,Staelin, R.,Zeithaml, V. A.(1993).A dynamic process model of service quality: From expectation to behavioral intentions.Journal of Marketing Research,30(February),7-27.
5. Brooks, R. F.,Lings, I. N.,Botschen, M. A.(1999).Internal marketing and customer driven wavefronts.The Service Industries Journal,19(4),49-67.
6. Brown, S. W.,Swartz, T. A.(1989).A gap analysis of professional service quality.Journal of Marketing,53(April),92-98.
7. Brown, T. J.,Churchill, G. A.,Peter, J. P.(1993).Research note: Improving the measurement of service quality.Journal of Retailing,69(Spring),127-139.
8. Carman, J. M.(1990).Consumer perceptions of service quality: An assessment of the SERVQUAL dimensions.Journal of Retailing,66(Spring),33-55.
9. Chaston, I.(1995).A typology for evaluating branch-level perceptions of internal customer management processes within the UK clearing banks.The Service Industries Journal,15(3),332-349.
10. Collins, B.,Payne, A.(1991).Internal marketing: A new perspective for HRM.European Management Journal,9(3),261-270.
11. Cronin, J. J.,Taylor S. A.(1992).Measuring service quality: A reexamination and extension.Journal of Marketing,56(July),55-68.
12. Daft, R. L.(2004).Organizationtheory and design.Ohio:South-Western College.
13. Davis, T. R. V.(1992).Satisfying internal customer: The link to external customer satisfaction.Planning Review,20(1),34-37.
14. Delaney, J. E.,Huselid, M. A.(1996).The impact of human resource management practices on perceptions of organizational performance.Academy of Management Journal,39(4),949-969.
15. Dyer, L.,Reeves, T.(1995).Human resource strategies and firm performance: What do we know and where do we need to go?.The 10th World Congress of the International Industrial Relations Association,Washington, DC:
16. Edvardsson, B.,Larson, G.,Setterlind, S.(1997).Internal service quality and the psychosocial work environment: An empirical analysis of conceptual interrelatedness.The Service Industries Journal,17(2),252-263.
17. Finn, D. W.,Baker, J.,Marshall, G. W.,Anderson, R.(1996).Total quality management and internal customers: Measuring internal service quality.Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,4(3),36-51.
18. Fisk, R. P.,Brown, S. W.,Bitner, M. J.(1993).Tracking the evolution of the services marketing literature.Journal of Retailing,69(1),61-103.
19. Geroge, W. R.,Gronroos C.,C. A. Congram,M. L. Friedman （Eds.）(1989).Handbook of services marketing.New York:AMACOM.
20. Gomez-Mejia, L. R.,Balkin, D. B.,Cardy, R. L.(2001).Managing human resources.NJ:Prentice Hall.
21. Gronroos, C.(1982).An applied service marketing theory.European Journal of Marketing,16(7),30-41.
22. Gronroos, C.,J. H. Donnelly,W. E. George （Eds.）(1981).Marketing of services.American Marketing Association Proceedings Series.
23. Gummeson, E.(1987).Using internal marketing to develop a new culture-The case of Ericsson quality.Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing,2(Summer),23-28.
24. Hallowel, R.,Schlesinger, L. A.,Zornitsdy, J.(1996).Internal service quality, customer and job satisfaction: Linkages and implications for management.Human Resource Planning,19(2),20-31.
25. Heskett, J. L.(1987).Lessons in the service sector.Harvard Business Review,65(March-April),118-126.
26. Lehtinen, U.,Lehtinen, J.(1982).Service quality: A study of quality dimensions.Proceedings of the 2nd World Marketing Conference,Stirling:
27. Mali, S. L.,Jacobs, R. L.(1998).HRD service-management model.Proceedings of the Academy of Human Resource Development.
28. McDermott, L.C.,Emerson, M.(1991).Training & Development Journal.45(1),61-64.
29. Mels, G.,Boshoff, C.,Nel, D.(1997).The dimensions of service quality: The original European perspective revisited.The Service Industries Journal,17(1),173-189.
30. Olshavsky, R. W.,J. Jacoby,J. Olson （Eds.）(1985).Perceived quality.Lexington, MA:Lexington Books.
31. Parasuraman, A.,Zeithaml, V. A.,Berry, L. L.(1985).A conceptual model of service quality and its implications for future research.Journal of Marketing,49(4),41-50.
32. Parasuraman, A.,Zeithaml, V. A.,Berry, L. L.(1993).The nature and determinants of customer expectations of service.Journal of the Acdemy of Marketing Science,21(Winter),1-12.
33. Parasuraman, A.,Zeithaml, V. A.,Berry, L. L.(1988).SERVQUAL: A multiple -item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality.Journal of Retailing,64(1),12-40.
34. Rafiq, M.,Ahmed, P. K.(1993).The scope of internal marketing: Defining the boundary between marketing and human resource management.Journal of Marketing Management,9,219-232.
35. Reeves, C.,Bednar, D.(1994).Defining quality: Alternatives and implications.Academy of Management Review,19,419-445.
36. Schlesinger, L. A.,Zornitsky, J.(1991).Job satisfaction, service capability, and customer satisfaction: An examination of linkages and management implications.Human Resource Planning,14(2),141-149.
37. Schneider, B.,Bowen, D. E.(1993).The service organization: Human resources management is curcial.Organizational Dynamics,21(4),39-52.
38. Shirine, L. M.(2000).Managing the HRD function and service quality: A call for a new approach.Human Resource Development Quarterly,11(1),81-86.
39. Sower, V.,Duffy, J.,Kilbourne, W.,Kohers, G.,Jones, P.(2001).The dimensions of service quality for hospitals: Development and use of the KQCAH scale.Health Care Management Review,26(2),47-59.
40. Stanley, L. L.,Wisner, J. D.(1998).Internal service quality in purchasing: An empirical study.International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,3,50-60.
41. Ulrich, D.,Losey, M. R.,Lake, G.(1997).Tomorrow`s HR management: 48 Thought leaders call for change.New York:John Wiley & Sons, Inc..
42. Zeithaml, V. A.,J. Donnelly,W. George （Eds.）(1981).Marketing of services.Chicage:American Marketing.
43. 方世榮譯、Kotler, P.原著(2000)。行銷管理學。台北:東華書局股份有限公司。
44. 巫喜瑞(2000)。中山大學企業管理研究所。
45. 郭德賓(1999)。中山大學企業管理研究所。
46. 溫金豐(1998)。中山大學企業管理研究所。
47. 趙必孝(2000)。服務業內部行銷的人力資源管理對顧客導向行為的因果模式之研究。行政院國家科學委員會科學技術資料中心。
48. 謝益銘(2000)。中國文化大學國際企業管理研究所。
49. 蘇雲華(1996)。中山大學企業管理研究所。

1. 陳冠霖、許順旺、張姮燕、吳紀美(2017)。國際觀光旅館的組織氣候能影響員工績效表現嗎？探討服務品質的中介效果。企業管理學報，114，89-115。
2. 楊東震、黃泰源、吳孟爵(2007)。運動休閒服務業服務品質衡量模式之研究。臺灣體育運動管理學報，5，45-67。
3. (2009)。企業人力資源彈性運用策略—以人力派遣公司觀點為例。樹德科技大學學報，11(2)，97-112。