题名

推廣教育之市場導向與組織績效關聯性研究：內部行銷與組織承諾之中介角色

并列篇名

A Study of Continuing Education on Market Orientation and Organizational Performance: The Mediator of Internal Marketing and Organizational Commitment

DOI

10.6147/JHRM.2010.1004.03

作者

廖述賢(Shu-Hsien Liao)；張文榮(Wen-Jung Chang)；胡大謙(Da-Chian Hu)

关键词

市場導向 ； 內部行銷 ； 組織承諾 ； 組織績效 ； 大學 ； market orientation ； internal marekting ； organizational commitment ； organizational performance ； university

期刊名称

人力資源管理學報

卷期/出版年月

10卷4期（2010 / 12 / 01）

页次

55 - 82

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

一個服務績效的良窳乃取決於組織是否能有效地將市場導向的觀念推廣至組織內部員工，並藉由積極的內部行銷作爲提升員工對組織的凝聚力。在終身學習觀念普及的今日，傳統大學是否能像一般企業般地經營推廣教育市場，將是本研究所關注的議題。本研究以國內經營推廣教育業務的70所大專技職院校爲研究母體並回收有效問卷261份，透過線性結構化方程式將內部行銷與組織承諾在市場導向與組織績效的中介效果進行驗證。實證結果發現：在市場導向與組織績效的關聯性中，只有組織承諾成功扮演完全中介的角色。另外，本研究也發現內部行銷對組織承諾有正向影響。
英文摘要

A better performance for service firms mainly depends on its effective implementation of the market orientation among its employees and its enhancement of their commitments to organization through continuous internal marketing programs. Such practice has interested traditional universities in managing their new business in continuing education when life-long learning is winning wide acceptance today, and thus has become the focus of this paper. Based on data collected from 261 valid respondents from 70 universities, we explore the mediated effects of internal marketing and organizational commitment on the relationship between market orientation and organizational performance by structural equation modeling (SEM), whose results show that organizational commitment alone serves as a complete mediator between market orientation and organizational performance. Moreover, internal marketing has a positive effect on organizational commitment.
主题分类 社會科學 > 心理學
社會科學 > 社會學
社會科學 > 經濟學
社會科學 > 管理學
社會科學 > 法律學
参考文献
  1. Liao, S. H.,Fei, W. C.,Wang, Y. W.(2006).A study on the relationships among trust, job satisfaction and knowledge sharing.Journal of Human Resource Management,6(3),23-44.
    連結：
  2. 彭台光,高月慈,林鉦棽(2006)。管理研究中的共同方法變異：問題本質、影響、測試和補救。管理學報，23(1)，77-98。
    連結：
  3. 廖述賢,胡大謙,鐘慧瑩(2008)。國際觀光旅館主管與部屬關係、工作滿足與組織承諾關聯性之研究。人力資源管理學報，8(1)，1-23。
    連結：
  4. Agarwal, S.,Erramilli, M. K.,Dev, C. S.(2003).Market orientation and performance in service firms: Role of innovation.Journal of Service Marketing,17,68-82.
  5. Aldas-Manzano, J.,Kuster, I.,Vila, N.(2005).Market orientation and innovation: An inter-relationship analysis.European Journal of Innovation Management,8,437-452.
  6. Anderson, J. C.,Gerbing, D. W.(1988).Structural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approach.Psychological Bulletin,103,411-423.
  7. Appiah-Adu, K.(1998).Market orientation and performance: Empirical tests in a transition economy.Journal of Strategic Marketing,6,25-45.
  8. Appiah-Adu, K.,Ranchhod, A.(1998).Market orientation and performance in the biotechnology industry: An exploratory empirical analysis.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management,10,197-210.
  9. Aragón-Correa, J. A.,García-Morales, V. J.,Cordón-Pozo, E.(2007).Leadership and organizational learning’s role on innovation and performance: Lessons from Spain.Industrial Marketing Management,36,349-359.
  10. Bagozzi, R. P.,Yi, Y.(1988).On the evaluation of structural equation models.Academic of Marketing Science,16,74-94.
  11. Baker, W. E.,Sinkula, J. M.(1999).The synergistic effect of market orientation and learning organization on organizational performance.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Sciences,27,411-427.
  12. Baker, W. E.,Sinkula, J. M.(1999).Learning orientation, market orientation and innovation: Integrating and extending modes of organizational performance.Journal of Market Focused Management,4,295-308.
  13. Baker, W. E.,Sinkula, J. M.(2005).Market orientation and the new product paradox.Journal of Product Innovation Management,22,483-502.
  14. Baron, R. M.,Kenny, D. A.(1986).The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,51,1173-1182.
  15. Benkhoff, B.(1997).Ignoring commitment is costly: New approaches establish the missing link between commitment and performance.Human Relations,50,701-726.
  16. Berry, L. L.,Parasuraman, A.(1991).Marketing services: Competing through quality.New York:Free Press.
  17. Bouranta, N.,Mavridogloum, G.,Kyriazopoulos, P.(2005).The impact of internal marketing to market orientation concept and their effects to bank performance.Operational Research,5,349-362.
  18. Bowen, F. E.,Rostami, M.,Steel, P.(2010).Timing is everything: A meta-analysis of the relationships between organizational performance and innovation.Journal of Business Research,63,1179-1185.
  19. Cahill, D. J.(1995).The nanagerial implications of the learning organization: A new tool for internal marketing.Journal of Service Marketing,9(4),43-51.
  20. Calantone, R. J.,Cavusgil, S. T.,Zhao, Y. S.(2002).Learning orientation, firm innovation capability, and firm performance.Industrial Marketing Management,31,515-524.
  21. Caruana, A.,Calleya, P.(1998).The effect of internal marketing on organisational commitment among retail bank managers.International Journal of Bank Marketing,16(3),108-116.
  22. Caruana, A.,Pitt, L.,Berthon, P.(1999).Excellence-market orientation link: Some consequences for service firms.Journal of Business Research,44,5-15.
  23. Chen, C. F.(2006).Job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and flight attendants’ turnover intentions: A note.Journal of Air Transport Management,12,274-276.
  24. Chen, S. C.,Quester, P. G.(2009).A value-based perspective of market orientation and customer service.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,16(3),197-206.
  25. Cheng, S. C.,Chang, Y. R.(2002).A study on the relationship among internal marketing, job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and customer orientation -- A case of theme park in Taiwan.Tourism Management Research,2(2),79-99.
  26. Choi, B.,Lee, H.(2003).An empirical investigation of KM styles and their effect on corporate performance.Information & Management,40,403-417.
  27. Collins, B.,Payne, A.(1991).Internal marketing: A new perspective for HRM.European Management Jounal,9,261-270.
  28. Conduit, J.,Mavondo, F. T.(2001).How critical is internal customer orientation to market orientation?.Journal of Business Research,51,11-24.
  29. Congram, C. A.(Ed.) \Friedman, M. L.(Ed.)(1989).Handbooks of services marketing.New York:AMACOM.
  30. Darroch, J.(2005).Knowledge management, innovation and firm performance.Journal of Knowledge Management,9(3),101-115.
  31. Day, G. S.(1994).The capabilities of market-driven organization.Journal of Marketing,58(4),37-52.
  32. Delaney, J. T.,Huselid, M. A.(1996).The impact of human resource management practices on perceptions of organizational performance.Academy of Management Journal,39,949-969.
  33. Demirbag, M.,Koh, S. C. L.,Tatoglu, E.,Zaim, S.(2006).TQM and market orientation’s impact on SMEs’ performance.Industrial Management & Data Systems,106,1206-1228.
  34. Deshpandé, R.,Farley, J. U.,Webster, F. E.(1993).Corporate culture, customer orientation, and innovations in Japanese firms: A quadrad analysis.Journal of Marketing,57,23-37.
  35. Doyle, P.,Wong, V.(1998).Marketing and competitive performance: An empirical study.European Journal of Marketing,32,514-535.
  36. Drew, S.(1997).From knowledge to action: The impact of benchmarking on organizational performance.Long Range Planning,30,427-441.
  37. Evanschitzky, H.(2007).Market orientation of service networks: Direct and indirect effects on sustained competitive advantage.Journal of Strategic Marketing,15,349-368.
  38. Ewing, M. T.,Caruana, A.(1999).An internal marketing approach to public sector management: The marketing and human resources interface.The International Journal of Public Sector Management,12,17-29.
  39. Farrell, M. A.,Oczkowski, E.,Kharabsheh, R.(2008).Market orientation, learning orientation and organizational performance in international joint ventures.Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics,20,289-308.
  40. Ferris, K. R.,Aranya, N.(1983).A comparison of two organizational commitment scales.Personnel Psychology,36,87-98.
  41. Foreman, S. K.,Money, A. H.(1995).Internal marketing: Concepts, measurement and application.Journal of Marketing Management,11,755-768.
  42. Gomez, P. J.,Lorente, J. J. C.,Cabrera, R. V.(2004).Training practices and organizational learning capability: Relationship and implications.Journal of European Industrial Training,28,234-256.
  43. Gounaris, S. P.(2006).Internal-market orientation and its measurement.Journal of Business Research,59,432-448.
  44. Gray, B.(2010).Fine tuning market oriented practices.Business Horizons,53,371-383.
  45. Greene, W. E.,Walls, G. D.,Schrest, L. J.(1994).Internal marketing: The key to external marketing success.Journal of Services Marketing,8(4),5-13.
  46. Gronroos, C.(1985).Internal marketing -- Theory and practice.American Marketing Association’s Service Conference,Chicago:
  47. Gronroos, C.(1984).A service quality model and its marketing implications.European Journal of Marketing,18(4),36-44.
  48. Gummesson, E.(1991).Marketing-orientation: The crucial role of the part-time marketer.European Journal of Marketing,25(2),60-75.
  49. Hair, J. F.,Tatham, R. L.,Anderson, R. E.,Black, W.(1998).Multivariate data analysis.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
  50. Hammond, K. L.,Webster, R. L.,Harmon, H. A.(2006).Market orientation, top management emphasis and performance within university schools of business: Implications for universities.Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,14(1),69-85.
  51. Han, J. K.,Kim, N.,Srivastava, R. K.(1998).Market orientation and organizational performance: Is innovation a missing link?.Journal of Marketing,62(4),30-52.
  52. Henderson, R.,Cockburn, I.(1994).Measuring competence? Exploring firm effects in pharmaceutical research.Strategic Management Journal,15(Supplement S1),63-84.
  53. Homburg, C.,Pflesser, C.(2000).A multiple-layer model of market-oriented organizational culture: Measurement issues and performance outcomes?.Journal of Marketing Research,37,449-462.
  54. Hurley, R. F.,Hult, G. T. M.(1998).Innovation, market orientation, and organizational learning: An integration and empirical examination.Journal of Marketing,62(3),42-54.
  55. Hwang, I. S.,Chi, D. J.(2005).Relationships among internal marketing, employee job satisfaction, and international hotel performance: An empirical study.Interantional Journal of Management,22(2),285-293.
  56. Jaworski, B. J.,Kohli, A. K.(1993).Market orientation: Antecedents and consequences.Journal of Marketing,57(3),53-70.
  57. Kohli, A. K.,Jaworski, B. J.(1990).Market orientation: The construct, research propositions, and managerial implications.Journal of Marketing,54(2),1-18.
  58. Kohli, A. K.,Jaworski, B. J.,Kumar, A.(1993).MARKOR: A measure of market orientation.Journal of Marketing Research,30,467-477.
  59. Laforet, S.(2008).Size, strategic, and market orientation affects on innovation.Journal of Business Research,61,753-764.
  60. Lau, C. M.,Ngo, H. Y.(2004).The HR system, organizational culture, and product innovation.International Business Review,13,685-703.
  61. Lee, K. C.,Lee, S.,Kang, I. W.(2005).KMPI: Measuring knowledge management performance.Information & Management,42,469-482.
  62. Lee, T. S.,Tsai, H. J.(2005).The effects of business operation mode on market orientation, learning orientation and innovativeness.Industrial Management & Data Systems,105(3),325-348.
  63. Lehrer, M.,Nell, P.,Garber, L.(2009).A national systems view of university entrepreneurialism: Inferences from comparison of the German and US experience.Research Policy,38,268-280.
  64. Li, J. J.,Zhou, K. Z.(2010).How foreign firms achieve competitive advantage in the Chinese emerging economy: Managerial ties and market orientation.Journal of Business Research,63,856-862.
  65. Liao, S. H.,Chang, J. C.,Cheng, S. C.,Kuo, C. M.(2004).Employee relationship and knowledge sharing: A case study of Taiwanese finance and securities firm.Knowledge Management Research & Practice,2,24-34.
  66. Liao, S. H.,Fei, W. C.,Chen, C. C.(2007).Knowledge sharing, absorptive capacity, and innovation capability: An empirical study on Taiwan’s knowledge intensive industries.Journal of Information Science,33,340-359.
  67. Liao, S. H.,Hu, D. C.(2007).Knowledge transfer and competitive advantage on environmental uncertainty: An empirical study of the Taiwan semiconductor industry.Technovation,27,402-411.
  68. Lytle, R. S.,Timmerman, J. E.(2006).Service orientation and performance: An organizational perspective.Journal of Services Marketing,20(2),136-147.
  69. Martínez-Lorente, A. R.,Dewhurst, F.,Dale, B. G.(1999).TQM and business innovation.European Journal of Innovation Management,2,12-19.
  70. Matear, S.,Osborne, P.,Garrett, T.,Gray, B. J.(2002).How does market orientation contribute to service firm performance? An examination of alternative mechanisms.European Journal of Marketing,36,1058-1075.
  71. Mathieu, J. E.,Zajac, D. M.(1990).A review and meta-analysis of the antecedents, correlates and consequences of organizational commitment.Psychological Bulletin,108,171-194.
  72. Mattila, A. S.,Enz, C. A.(2002).The role of emotions in service encounters.Journal of Services Research,4,268-277.
  73. Mavondo, F. T.,Chimhanzi, J.,Stewart, J.(2005).Learning orientation and market orientation: Relationship with innovation, human resource practices and performance.European Journal of Marketing,39,1235-1263.
  74. Mavondo, F.,Farrell, M.(2003).Cultural orientation: Its relationship with market orientation, innovation and organizational performance.Management Decision,41,241-249.
  75. Menguc, B.,Auh, S.(2006).Creating a firm-level dynamic capability through capitalizing on market orientation and innovativeness.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,34(1),63-73.
  76. Meyer, J. P.,Allen, N. J.(1990).Affective and continuance commitment to the organization: Evaluation of measures and analysis of concurrent and time-lagged relations.Journal of Applied Psychology,75,710-720.
  77. Meyer,Stanley, D. J,Herscovitch, L.,Topolaytsky, L.(2002).Affective, continuance and normative commitment to the organisation: A meta-analysis of antecedents, correlates and consequences.Journal of Vocational Behaviour,61,20-52.
  78. Mohr-Jackson, I.(1991).Broadening the market orientation: An added focus on internal customers.Human Resources Management,30,455-467.
  79. Mowday, R. T.,Steers, R. M.,Poter, L. W.(1982).Employee-organization linkage -- The psychology of commitment absenteeism and turnover.San Diego, CA:Academic Press.
  80. Narasimha, S.(2000).Organizational knowledge, human resource management, and sustained competitive advantage: Toward a framework.Competitiveness Review,10(1),123-135.
  81. Narver, J. C.,Slater, S. F.(1990).The effect of a market orientation on business profitability.Journal of Marketing,54(4),20-35.
  82. Narver, J. C.,Slater, S. F.,Tietje, B.(1998).Creating a market orientation.Journal of Market Focused Management,2,241-255.
  83. O’Cass, A,Ngo, L. V.(2007).Balancing external adaptation and internal effectiveness: Achieving better brand performance.Journal of Business Research,60(1),11-20.
  84. O’Reilly, C,Chatman, J.(1986).Organizational commitment and psychological attachment: The effects of compliance, identification, and internalization on prosocial behavior.Journal of Applied Psychology,71,492-499.
  85. Organ, D. W.(1988).Organizational citizenship behavior: The good soldier syndrome.Lexington, MA:Lexington Books.
  86. Podsakoff, P. M.,MacKenzie, S. B.,Paine, J. B.,Bachrach, D. G.(2000).Organizational citizenship behaviors: A critical review of the theoretical and empirical literature and suggestions for future research.Journal of Management,26,513-563.
  87. Porter, L. W.,Steers, R. M.,Mowday, R. T.,Boulian, P. V.(1974).Organizational commitment, job satisfaction, and turnover amongpsychiatric technicians.Journal of Applied Psychology,59,603-609.
  88. Price, J. L.,Mueller, C. W.(1986).Handbook of organization measurement.Marshfield, MA:Pitman.
  89. Qu, R.,Ennew, C.(2003).An examination of the consequences of market orientation in China.Journal of Strategic Marketing,11,201-214.
  90. Raju, P. S.,Lonial, S. C.,Gupta, Y. P.,Ziegler, C.(2000).The relationship between market orientation and performance in the hospital industry: A structural equations modeling approach.Health Care Management Science,3,237-247.
  91. Rashid, M. Z. A.,Sambasivan, M.,Johari, J.(2003).The influence of corporate culture and organisational commitment on performance.The Journal of Management Development,22,708-728.
  92. Sandvik, I. L.,Sandvik, K.(2003).The impact of market orientation on product innovativeness and business performance.International Journal of Research in Marketing,20,355-376.
  93. Santos-Vijande, M. L.,Sanzo-Perez, M. J.,Alvar-Gonzalez, L. I.,Vazquez-Casielles, R.(2005).Organizational learning and market orientation: Interface and effects on performance.Industrial Marketing Management,34,187-202.
  94. Sasser, W. E.,Arbeit, S. P.(1976).Selling jobs in the service sector.Business Horizons,6(3),61-65.
  95. Sin, L. Y. M.,Tse, A. C. B.,Heung, V. C. S.,Yim, F. H. K.(2005).An analysis of the relationship between market orientation and business performance in the hotel industry.International Journal of Hospitality Management,24,555-577.
  96. Sin, L. Y. M.,Tse, A. C. B.,Yau, O. H. M.,Chow, R.,Lee, J. S. Y.(2003).Market orientation and business performance: A comparative study of firms in mainland China and Hong Kong.European Journal of Marketing,37,910-936.
  97. Singh, R.(2009).Unlocking the relationship between market-orientation and service performance.Library Review,58(1),28-43.
  98. Sivaramakrishnan, S.,Zhang, D.,Delbaere, M.,Bruning, E.(2008).The relationship between organizational commitment and market orientation.Journal of Strategic Marketing,16,55-73.
  99. Slater, S. F.,Narver, J. C.(1995).Market orientation and the learning organization.Journal of Marketing,59(3),63-74.
  100. Tansuhaj, P.,Randall, D.,McCullough, J.(1991).Applying the internal marketing concept within large organizations: As applied to a credit union.Journal of Professional Services Marketing,6(2),193-202.
  101. Taylor, C. R.,Kim, K. H.,Ko, E.,Park, M. H.,Kim, D. R.,Moon, H. I.(2008).Does having a market orientation lead to higher levels of relationship commitment and business performance? Evidence from the Korean robotics industry.Industrial Marketing Management,37,825-832.
  102. Tsai, K. H.,Chou, C.,Kuo, J. H.(2008).The curvilinear relationships between responsive and proactive market orientations and new product performance: A contingent link.Industrial Marketing Management,37,884-894.
  103. Twomey, D. F.,Harris, D. L.(2000).From strategy to corporate outcomes: Aligning human resource management systems with entrepreneurial intent.International Journal of Commerce & Management,10(3),43-55.
  104. Varey, R. J.(1995).Internal marketing: A review and some interdisciplinary research challenges.International Journal of Service Industrial Management,6(1),40-63.
  105. Venkatraman, N.,Ramanujam, V.(1986).Measurement of business performance in strategy research: A comparison of approaches.Management Science,11,801-814.
  106. Weerawardena, J.,O’Cass, A.(2004).Exploring the characteristics of the market-driven firms and antecedents to sustained competitive advantage.Industrial Marketing Management,33,419-428.
  107. Weerawardena, J.,O’Cass, A.,Julian, C.(2006).Does industry matter? Examining the role of industry structure and organizational learning in innovation and brand performance.Journal of Business Research,59,37-45.
  108. Wei, Y.,Atuahene-Gima, K.(2009).The moderating role of reward systems in the relationship between market orientation and new product performance in China.International Journal of Research in Marketing,26,89-96.
  109. Wong, C. S.,Wong, Y. T.,Hui, C.,Law, K. S.(2001).The significant role of Chinese employees’ organizational commitment: Implications for managing employees in Chinese societies.Journal of World Business,36,326-340.
  110. Woodruff, R. B.(1997).Customer value: The next source for competitive advantage.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,25,139-153.
  111. Wu, F.,Cavusgil, S. T.(2006).Organizational learning, commitment, and joint value creation in interfirm relationships.Journal of Business Research,59,81-89.
  112. Yusuf, S.(2008).Intermediating knowledge exchange between universities and businesses.Research Policy,37,1167-1174.
  113. Zhao, Y.,Cavusgil, S. T.(2006).The effect of supplier’s market orientation on manufacturer’s trust.Industrial Marketing Management,35,405-414.
  114. Zhou, K. Z.,Gao, G. Y.,Yang, Z.,Zhou, N.(2005).Developing strategic orientation in China: Antecedents and consequences of market and innovation orientations.Journal of Business Research,58,1049-1058.
  115. 王精文(2000)。行政院國科會專題研究報告行政院國科會專題研究報告,行政院國科會。
  116. 巫喜瑞(2001)。國立中山大學企業管理學系。
  117. 李是惠(2002)。國立中山大學人力資源管理研究所。
  118. 沈進成,張延蓉(2002)。內部行銷、組織承諾、工作滿足與顧客導向服務關係之研究－以主題樂園為例。旅遊管理研究，2(2)，79-99。
  119. 蕭富峰(1997).內部行銷.台北:天下文化.
被引用次数
  1. 陳美莉,張文榮(2022)。「外部行銷與內部行銷」，誰才握有卓越績效的籌碼？以大學推廣教育為例。台灣管理學刊，22(1)，1-20。
  2. 許順旺、曹建南、張姮燕、吳紀美(2013)。五星級旅館內部行銷、組織承諾與績效表現之相關研究─以內、外控人格特質為干擾變項。東吳經濟商學學報，83，43-78。
  3. 黃識銘,范凱棠(2019)。師徒職涯功能對工作績效之影響：中介與干擾的混合影響。管理學報，36(1)，83-116。
  4. 蕭惠文,張東生,吳肇展,伍玥(2023)。推廣教育品質之研究－以大學推廣教育為例。商管科技季刊，24(1)，41-73。
  5. 楊瑞霞、丁學勤(2014)。高雄市偏鄉小學教師內部行銷與組織承諾關係之研究。教育經營與管理研究集刊，10，93-127。
  6. 鄭中平(2015)。結構方程模型徑路係數的檢定力分析。人力資源管理學報，15(3)，75-96。
  7. 莊素增、林靖傑、吳琮璠(2015)。強制以XBRL申報財務報告能否降低資訊不對稱？。會計評論，60，1-33。
  8. (2016)。建構高等教育機構行政人員內部關係品質模型與實務之研究：以領導成員交換與內部關係投資為干擾變數。教育與心理研究，39(3)，1-37。
  9. (2018)。參與學習過程經驗及組織脈絡因素對樂齡學習中心學習者績效表現知覺之影響：階層線性模式分析。成人及終身教育學刊，30，51-98。
  10. (2018)。以多層次模式驗證影響樂齡學習中心績效表現觀感之研究。中正教育研究，17(2)，1-15。
print cancel