臺灣醫療糾紛適用仲裁制度之研究－以美國ADR經驗為中心

張婷

醫療糾紛 ； 仲裁 ； 裁判外紛爭解決模式 ； 調解-仲裁 ； medical malpractice ； arbitration ； Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) ； Med-Arb

東海大學法學研究

51期（2017 / 04 / 01）

217 - 269

繁體中文

本文以醫療糾紛領域為論述範圍，參考美國經驗，主張臺灣以ADR 作為其爭端解決途徑有其趨勢可循。除法院的調解等途徑外，本文建議在依循當事人自主原則前提下，可分階段推廣實施仲裁與Med-Arb 制度。此外，鑒於醫病之間對於醫療相關訊息與知識常呈現落差，無論何種ADR 途徑，須落實武器對等原則，方可在醫病之間產生信賴，進而實質地定紛止爭，化解衝突。

This article focuses on the medical malpractice area. After taking experiences from the US, there is a trend showing that ADR could be one of the conflict resolution paths in Taiwan. Beside mediation in the court, this article suggests that arbitration and Med-Arb could be applied step by step, following the party autonomy premium. Moreover, due to the gap of medical related information and knowledge between patients and physicians, no matter what ADR is applied; the principle of equal weapon should be fulfilled. Thus, among patients and physicians, trust could be built and conflicts could be substantially resolved.

1. 立法院議事暨公報管理系統，立法院第103 卷第49 期(4158)上冊公報，http://lci.ly.gov.tw/LyLCEW/lcivCommQry.action#pageName_searchResult=3
2. (2012)。訴訟外紛爭解決機制。三民。
3. JAMS, JAMS Resolution Centers, http://www.jamsadr.com/locations/
4. 總統府， 公報與法令公報查詢，http://www.president.gov.tw/Default.aspx?tabid=84&lctl=view&itemid=11580&ctid=96&q=
5. 行政院衛生福利部，發文字號：署授藥字第1000001892 號，發文日期：2011 年6 月14 日。衛生福利法規檢索系統，http://mohwlaw.mohw.gov.tw/FINT/FINTQRY04.aspx?starDate=00000000&endDate=99991231&no=&n1=&n2=1000001892&kt=&kw=&kw2=&kw3=&kw4=&type=etype_&RowNo=1
6. 衛生福利部醫事司， 機構公開資訊查詢，http://mcia.mohw.gov.tw/openinfo/A100/A101-1.aspx
7. 衛生福利部醫事司，醫療糾紛鑑定案件、人民醫事爭議陳情處理等相關業務，全國各縣市97-102 年醫療糾紛調處案件量統計，http://www.mohw.gov.tw/CHT/DOMA/DM1_P.aspx?f_list_no= 608&fod_list_no=762&doc_no=44100
8. Baker, Tom,Lytton, Timothy D.(2010).Allowing Patients to Waive the Right to Sue for Medical Malpractice: A Response to Thaler and Sunstein.Nw. U. L. Rev.,104(1),233-251.
9. Bowe, Guy(2014).Skills & Values Alternative Dispute Resolution: Negotiation, Mediation, Collaborative Law and Arbitration.Y. B. On Arb. & Mediation,6,467-485.
10. Carroll, Aaron E.,Parikh, Parul Divya,Buddenbaum, Jennifer L.(2012).The Impact of Defense Expenses in Medical Malpractice Claims.J Law Med Ethics,40(1),135-142.
11. Clinton, L. Kelly(2013).Medical Malpractice Five Years After Going under the Knife, Med Mal Law is Still Feeling the Effects.Tenn.B.J.,49(11),12-17.
12. D'Alesio, Daniel J., Jr.(2014).The Benefits and Risks of Using Presuit Voluntary Binding Arbitration as An Alternative Dispute Resolution Process in Medical Malpractice Cases.FLA Bar J,88(10),20-27.
13. Daniels, Stephen,Martin, Joanne(2010).It is no longer viable from a practical and business standpoint": Damage Caps, "Hidden Victims", and the Declining Interest in Medical Malpractice Cases.IJTLP,17(1),59-82.
14. de Vera, Carlos(2004).Arbitrating Harmony: 'Med-Arb' And The Confluence Of Culture And Rule Of Law In The Resolution Of International Commercial Disputes In China.Colum. J. Asian L.,18,149-194.
15. Ebe, Robert L.(2011).A Different Approach To Conducting Med-Arb In Complex Commercial Litigation Matters.Alternatives to High Cost Litig.,29,65-73.
16. Ebe, Robert L.(2011).Results And Observations: How A Multistep Med-Arb Produced A Fast(er) Settlement.Alternatives to High Cost Litig.,29,83-85.
17. Fullerton, Richard(2010).Med-Arb And Its Variants: Ethical Issues For Parties And Neutrals.Disp. Resol. J.,65,52-61.
18. Gilbert, Jon(2011).Twelve Ways to Avoid A Determination of NICA Compensability in A Medical Malpractice Case.FLA Bar J,85(10),42-45.
19. Gu, Weixia(2014).The Delicate Art Of Med-Arb And Its Future Institutionalisation In China.UCLA Pac. Basin L.J.,31,97-126.
20. Hoffoss, J. Lee, Jr.(2014).Alternative Dispute Resolution: The New Norm for Young Lawyers.La. B. J.,62,232.
21. Hyman, Chris Stern,Liebman, Carol B.,Schechter, Clyde B.,Sage, William M.(2010).Interest-Based Mediation of Medical Malpractice Lawsuits: A Route to Improved Patient Safety?.J Health Polit Policy Law,35(5),797-828.
22. Lavi, Dafna(2014).Divorce Involving Domestic Violence: Is Med-Arb Likely To Be The Solution?.Pepp. Disp. Resol. L.J.,14,91-151.
23. Masland, John W.(2013).Evaluating New Hampshire's First-in-the-Nation Early Offer Alternative to Medical Malpractice Litigation.Am. J.L. & Med.,39,648-670.
24. McLean, David J.,Wilson, Sean-Patrick(2013).Compelling Mediation In The Context Of Med-Arb Agreements.Disp. Resol. J.,63,28-33.
25. Onyema, Emilia(2001).The Use Of Med-Arb In International Commercial Dispute Resolution.Am. Rev. Int'l Arb.,12,411-423.
26. Pappas, Brian A.(2015).Med-Arb And The Legalization Of Alternative Dispute Resolution.Harv. Negot. L. Rev.,20,157-203.
27. Parris, Amber Murphy(2013).Alternative Dispute Resolution: The Final Frontier of the Legal Profession?.J. Legal Prof.,37,295-307.
28. Peter, James T.(1997).Med-Arb In International Arbitration.Am. Rev. Int'l Arb.,8,83-116.
29. Phillips, Gerald F.(2005).It's More Than Just 'Med Arb': The Case For 'Transitional Arbitration'.Alternatives to High Cost Litig.,23,141-154.
30. Phillips, Gerald F.(2008).The Survey Says: Practitioners Cautiously Move Toward Accepting Same-Neutral Med-Arb, But Party Sophistication Is Mandatory.Alternatives to High Cost Litig.,26,101-104.
31. Phillips, Gerald F.(2008).Back To Med-Arb: Survey Indicates Process Concerns Are Decreasing.Alternatives to High Cost Litig.,26,73-79.
32. Phillips, Gerald F.(2007).A Case Study Demonstrates How The Entertainment Business-And Everyone Else-Can Benefit By Using Hybrid Med-Arb Processes.Alternatives to High Cost Litig.,25,67-72.
33. Price, Ned I.(2012).Binding Arbitration, Voluntary Trial Resolution, And Med-Arb Proceedings In Family Law.Fla. B.J.,86,48-52.
34. Rosenfeld, S. James(2012).It's Time for An Alternative Dispute Resolution Procedure.J. Nat'l Ass'n Admin. L. Judiciary,32,544-567.
35. Shurtz, Ity(2013).The Impact of Medical Errors on Physician Behavior: Evidence from Malpractice Litigation.J Health Econ,32,331-340.
36. Sloan, Frank A.,Chepke, Lindsey M.(2011).Medical Malpractice.J Leg Med,32,547-553.
37. Vorys, Yolanda(2007).The Best Of Both Worlds: The Use Of Med-Arb For Resolving Will Disputes.Ohio St. J. on Disp. Resol.,22,871-897.
38. Wu, C.-Y.,Lai, H.-J.,Chen, R.-C.(2009).Medical Malpractice Experience of Taiwan: 2005 Versus 1991.Intern Med J,39,237-242.
39. 古嘉諄。介紹美國法院體系內之附屬仲裁機制－兼談引進國內之可行性。律師雜誌，261，3-8。
40. 朱柔若、林東龍。醫療公道如何討？臺灣醫療糾紛處理機制弊病之探索。醫事法學，3-4，31-61。
41. 吳光明(2004)。仲裁法理論與判決研究。臺灣財產法暨經濟法研究協會。
42. 李伯璋、曾平杉(2010)。醫療紛爭在臨床醫學與法律實務的探討。新學林。
43. 林家祺、劉俊麟(2014)。民事訴訟法。書泉。
44. 林義龍。論醫療糾紛處理之法制與實務－ADR 臺中經驗。醫事法學，21(1)，1-14。
45. 邱慧洳。論醫師醫療行為之注意義務－評最高法院100年度台上字第2256號民事判決。法令月刊，66(2)，58-75。
46. 施茂林(2015)。醫病關係與法律風險管理防範。五南。
47. 財團法人臺灣醫療改革基金會。醫療爭議處理參考手冊第三版。
48. 張婷。行政院版本醫療糾紛處理及醫療事故補償法（草案）之評析與建議。醫事法學，20(1)，1-33。
49. 張婷。由美國Med-Arb經驗論應用於臺灣醫療糾紛之可能性。嶺東財經法學，8，171-189。
50. 張婷。以仲裁解決醫療糾紛之適法性研究－借鏡美國之經驗。玄奘法律學報，23，139-178。
51. 許振東。論醫療糾紛仲裁制度－兼評「醫療糾紛處理法」草案之「仲裁制度」。醫事法學，10(3)-11(1)，33-41。
52. 陳學德(2015)。改善醫療調解（處）制度芻議－從當事人情緒支持與醫病文化出發。第三屆臺中醫法論壇
53. 陳學德(2013)。加強調解解決醫療糾紛功能－從臺中地院試辦醫療調解制度談起。第一屆臺中醫法論壇
54. 陳學德。醫療糾紛處理與醫學倫理－臺中地院醫療試辦經驗分享。澄清醫護管理雜誌，10(3)，4-6。
55. 楊秀儀。臺灣醫療糾紛之迷思與真相－十五年回顧與展望。月旦民商法雜誌，45，56-73。
56. 楊秀儀、黃鈺媖(2015)。當法律遇見醫療：醫療糾紛立法論上的兩個主張。財團法人臺灣法學基金會勞動法及社會法研究中心醫療糾紛處理及醫療事故補償法（草案）政策研討會
57. 詹常輝(2015)。試論偵查程序中調解與鑑定之機制與成效－以醫糾案件為中心。第三屆臺中醫法論壇
58. 蔡秀男(2014)。99％醫療糾紛都是可以避免的。貓頭鷹。

1. 梁志鳴(2022)。論美國訴訟外醫療紛爭處理之歷史發展經驗：兼評我國現狀之反省與展望。歐美研究，52(4)，655-725。