题名

普世接受的人權條約，兒童階段的個案救濟－兒童權利公約個人申訴案件之分析

作者

廖福特

关键词

兒童權利宣言 ； 兒童權利公約 ； 兒童權利委員會 ； 申訴程序議定書 ； 個人申訴 ； 暫時措施 ； 個案建議 ； 通案建議 ； Declaration of the Rights of the Child ； Convention on the Rights of the Child ； Committee on the Rights of the Child ； Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on a communications procedure ； individual communication ； interim measure ； individual recommendation ； general recommendation

期刊名称

東海大學法學研究

卷期/出版年月

62期（2021 / 10 / 01）

页次

1 - 54

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

從兒童權利宣言到兒童權利公約，花費漫長的30年。兒童權利公約是最快速生效且最普世之人權條約。然而其個人申訴制度至2014年才開始運作，至今具體的個人申訴案件數量不算多，且絕大部分個案所牽涉之兒童都不是被告國之國民。個人申訴案件有超過三分之二的案件是程序結案，兒童權利委員會只在不到三分之一的案件表達實質意見，不過對於兒童最佳利益、自主發展、表意自由、家庭團聚權、健康權等有相當具體之論述及確保。申訴程序議定書已建立暫時措施，兒童權利委員會在具體案件實踐，但是當事國未遵循。兒童權利委員會已針對違反公約之個案提出個案建議及通案建議，並已建立審查各國實踐之準則。然而當事國不必然具體實踐這些建議。
英文摘要

The UN took 30 years moving from the Declaration of the Rights of the Child to the Convention on the Rights of the Child. The Convention is the quickest becoming effect and the most universal human right treaty. However, its individual communication did not begin until 2014. There were not many cases, and most of their applicants were not nationals of respondent states. More than two thirds of the cases were ended by discontinuance and inadmissibility decisions, which meant that the Committee of the Rights of the Child presented substantial views in less than one third cases. These substantial views however offered concrete protections of rights of the child. Interim measures were applied by the Committee in necessary cases, but respondent state did not implement them. When violations of the Convention occurred, the Committee offered individual and general recommendations. Principles of reviewing their implementations were also established. It is regret that respondent states did not fully comply with those recommendations.
主题分类 社會科學 > 法律學
参考文献
  1. Behravesh, Justin A.(2017).Ejab Mantin Majef: Corporal 1Punishment in Public Schools in the Marshall Islands.Minn. J. Int’l L.,26,113.
  2. Binford, Warren(2015).The Constitutionalization of Children’s Rights in South Africa.N.Y. L. Sch. L. Rev.,60,333.
  3. Cohen, Cynthia Price(1999).Implementing the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child.Whittier L. Rev.,21,95.
  4. Committee on the Rights of the Child, R.N. v. Finland, CRC/C/85/D/98/2019, 28 September 2020.
  5. Committee on the Rights of the Child, J.A.B. v. Spain, CRC/C/81/D/22/2017, 31 May 2019.
  6. Committee on the Rights of the Child, K.S.G. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/92/2019, 28 September 2020.
  7. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M.E.B. v. Spain, CRC/C/75/D/9/2017, 02 June 2017.
  8. Committee on the Rights of the Child, R.L. v. Spain, CRC/C/77/D/18/2017, 25 January 2018.
  9. Committee on the Rights of the Child, A.B. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/111/2020, 28 September 2020.
  10. Committee on the Rights of the Child, D.K.N. v. Spain, CRC/C/80/D/15/2017, 1 February 2019.
  11. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M.B. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/28/2017, 28 September 2020.
  12. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Y.M v. Spain, CRC/C/78/D/8/2016, 31 May 2018.
  13. Committee on the Rights of the Child, A.S. v. Denmark, CRC/C/82/D/36/2017, 26 September 2019.
  14. Committee on the Rights of the Child, J.G. v. Switzerland, CRC/C/81/D/47/2018, 31 May 2019.
  15. Committee on the Rights of the Child, K.A.B. v. Germany, CRC/C/78/D/35/2017, 31 May 2018.
  16. Committee on the Rights of the Child, X. v. Finland, CRC/C/81/D/6/2016, 15 May 2019.
  17. Committee on the Rights of the Child(2019).Committee on the Rights of the Child, Follow-up progress report on individual communications, CRC/C/82/2, 4 October 2019..
  18. Committee on the Rights of the Child, J.A.B.S. v. Costa Rica, CRC/C/74/D/5/2016, 17 January 2017.
  19. Committee on the Rights of the Child, U.G. v. Belgium, CRC/C/85/D/34/2017, 28 September 2020.
  20. Committee on the Rights of the Child, B.G. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/38/2017, 28 September 2020.
  21. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Y.B. and N.S. v. Belgium, CRC/C/79/D/12/2017, 27 September 2018.
  22. Committee on the Rights of the Child, L.D. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/37/2017, 28 September 2020.
  23. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Z.Y. and J.Y. v. Denmark, CRC/C/78/D/7/2016, 31 May 2018.
  24. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Fermin Navarro Presentación and Juana Medina Pascual v. Spain, CRC/C/81/D/19/2017, 31 May 2019.
  25. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Z.H. and A.H. v. Denmark, CRC/C/82/D/32/2017, 18 September 2019.
  26. Committee on the Rights of the Child, L.I. v. Denmark, CRC/C/85/D/49/2018, 28 September 2020.
  27. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M.B. v. Spain, CRC/C/78/D/39/2017, 31 May 2018.
  28. Committee on the Rights of the Child, D.N. et al v. Switzerland, CRC/C/81/D/61/2018, 31 May 2019.
  29. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Z.A.R.R. v. Denmark, CRC/C/82/D/43/2018, 27 September 2019.
  30. Committee on the Rights of the Child, A.D. v. Spain, CRC/C/80/D/14/2017, 1 February 2019.
  31. Committee on the Rights of the Child, I.A.M. v Denmark, CRC/C/77/D/3/2016, 25 January 2018.
  32. Committee on the Rights of the Child, E.H.R.S., A.I.R.S., y A.H.R.S. v. Argentina, CRC/C/85/D/90/2019, 28 October 2020.
  33. Committee on the Rights of the Child, S.C.S. v. France, CRC/C/77/D/10/2017, 25 January 2018.
  34. Committee on the Rights of the Child, V.A. v. Switzerland, CRC/C/85/D/56/2018, 28 September 2020.
  35. Committee on the Rights of the Child, D.D. v. Spain, CRC/C/80/D/4/2016, 31 January 2019.
  36. Committee on the Rights of the Child, D.C. v. Germany, CRC/C//D83/60/2018, 4 February 2020.
  37. Committee on the Rights of the Child, N.B.F. v. Spain, CRC/C/79/D/11/2017, 27 September 2018.
  38. Committee on the Rights of the Child, W.M.C. v Denmark, CRC/C/85/D/31/2017, 28 September 2020.
  39. Committee on the Rights of the Child, R.K. v. Spain, CRC/C/82/D/27/2017, 18 September 2019.
  40. Committee on the Rights of the Child, K.L. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/29/2017, 28 September 2020.
  41. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M.A.B. v. Spain, CRC/C/83/D/24/2017, 07 February 2020.
  42. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Y.F. v. Panama, CRC/C/83/D/48/2018, 3 February 2020.
  43. Committee on the Rights of the Child, A.A.A. v. Spain, CRC/C/73/D/2/2015, 30 September 2016.
  44. Committee on the Rights of the Child, J.J. et al. v. Finland, CRC/C/85/D/87/2019, 28 September 2020.
  45. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M.H. v. Finland, CRC/C/83/D/23/2017, 3 February 2020.
  46. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M. I. M. v. Spain, CRC/C/82/D/54/2018, 27 September 2019.
  47. Committee on the Rights of the Child, A.H.A. v. Spain, CRC/C/69/D/1/2014, 8 July 2015.
  48. Committee on the Rights of the Child, A.L. v. Spain, CRC/C/81/D/16/2017, 31 May 2019.
  49. Committee on the Rights of the Child, N.R. v. Paraguay, CRC/C/83/D/30/2017, 03 February 2020.
  50. Committee on the Rights of the Child, S.M.A. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/40/2018, 28 September 2020.
  51. Committee on the Rights of the Child, L.S. v. Switzerland, CRC/C/85/D/81/2019, 30 September 2020.
  52. Committee on the Rights of the Child, Anna Arganashvilli v. Georgia, CRC/C/83/D/45/2018, 07 February 2020.
  53. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M.T. v. Spain, CRC/C/82/D/17/2017, 18 September 2019.
  54. Committee on the Rights of the Child, J.S.H.R. v. Spain, CRC/C/81/D/13/2017, 15 May 2019.
  55. Committee on the Rights of the Child, E.P. and F.P. v. Denmark, CRC/C/82/D/33/2017, 25 September 2019.
  56. Committee on the Rights of the Child, J.A. and E.A. v. Switzerland, CRC/C/85/D/53/2018, 28 September 2020.
  57. Committee on the Rights of the Child, M.B.S. v. Spain, CRC/C/85/D/26/2017, 28 September 2020.
  58. Committee on the Rights of the Child(2020).Committee on the Rights of the Child, Follow-up progress report on individual communications, CRC/C/85/2, 13 October 2020..
  59. Committee under the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights(2020).Committee under the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Communication No. 52/2018, Rosario Gómez-Limón Pardo /Spain, E/C.12/67/D/52/2018, 5 March 2020..
  60. Committee under the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights(2019).Committee under the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Communication No. 37/2018, Maribel Viviana López Albán/Spain, E/C.12/66/D/37/2018, 11 October 2019..
  61. Committee under the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights(2019).Committee under the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Communication No. 51/2018, S.S.R. /Spain, E/C.12/66/D/51/2018, 11 October 2019..
  62. Davidson, Howard(2014).Does the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child Make a difference?.Mich. St. Int’l L. Rev.,22,497.
  63. Detrick, Sharon(1999).A Commentary on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
  64. Douglas, Alexandra M. C.(2015).UNRWA and the Convention on the Rights of the Child: Who is responsible for Violations in Education?.Cardozo J. Int’l & Comp. L.,23,377.
  65. Fottrel, Deirdre(ed.)(2000).Revisiting Children’s Rights 10 Years of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.Kluwer Law International.
  66. Gran, Brian K.(2017).An International Framework of Children’s Rights.Ann. Rev. L. & Soc. Sci.,13,79.
  67. Lee Strasburger, R., Jr.(2013).The Best Interests of the Child?: The Cultural Defense as Justification for Child Abuse.Pace Int’l L. Rev.,25,161.
  68. Lee, Soo Joe(2017).A Child’s Voice v.s. Parent’s Control: Resolving a Tenson Between the Convention on the Rights of the Child and U.S. Law.Colum. L. Rev.,117,687.
  69. Akshay Luhadia and Rohit Gupta, “The Spanish-Moroccan Migrant Crisis: Counting the Collateral Damage,” Oxford Human Rights Hub, available at https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/the-spanish-moroccan-migrant-crisis-counting-the-collateral-damage/ (last visited on 3 August 2021).
  70. Malone, Linda A.(2015).Maturing Justice: Integrating the Convention on the Rights of the Child into the Judgments and Processes of the International Criminal Court.Ga. J. Int’l & Comp. L.,43,599.
  71. McSweeney, Karen A.(1993).The Potential for Enforcement of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child: The Need to Improve the Information Base.B.C. Int’l & Comp. L. Rev.,16,467.
  72. O’Flaherty, Michael(2002).Human Rights and the UN: Practice before the Treaty Bodies.Kluwer Law International.
  73. Pachauri, S. K.(1999).Children and Human Rights.A. P. H. Publishing Corporation.
  74. Panjabi, Ranee Khooshie Lal(2017).The Syrian Crisis: Violations of Basic Human Rights and Particularly Children’s Rights.Ga. J. Int’l & Comp. L.,46,1.
  75. Pedone, Joanne,Kloster, Andrew R.(2012).New Proposal for Human Rights Treaty Body Reform.J. Transnat’l L. & Pol’y,22,29.
  76. Ransom, Marilee Manning(2011).The University of Alabama at Birmingham.
  77. Rios-Kohn, Rebecca(1998).The Convention on the Rights of the Child: Progress and Challenges.Geo. J. on Fighting Poverty,5,139.
  78. Roche-Mair, Aurelie(2017).Challenges to the Protection of Children’s Human Rights and the Perpetuated Marginalization of Children in Transnational Justice.Geo. J. Int’l L.,49,135.
  79. Schuz, Rhona(2015).The Dangers of Children’s Rights’ Disclosure in the Political Area: The Issue of Religious Male Circumstance as a Test Case.Cardozo J. L. & Gender,21,347.
  80. UNICEF(2007).Implementation Handbook for the Convention on the Rights of the Child.UNICEF.
  81. UNICEF(1998).Implementation Handbook for the Convention on the Rights of the Child.UNICEF.
  82. United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights(2013).Individual Complaint Procedures under the United Nations Human Rights Treaties.Fact Sheet,7(2)
  83. Verheyde, Mieke,Goedertier, Geert(2006).Article 43-45: the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child.Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
  84. Virzo, Roberto(2017).The United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child and the Protection of the “Fundamental Rights” of LGBTI Minors.Syracuse J. Int’l L. & Com.,45,59.
  85. Weissbrodt, David,Hansen, Joseph C.,Nesbitt, Nathaniel H.(2011).The Role of the Committee on the Rights of the Child in Interpreting and Developing International Humanitarian Law.Harv. Hum. Rts. J.,24,115.
  86. Young, Andrea.Advances in Children’s Rights over the Past Decade: The Inter-American Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Human Rights’ Progressive Incorporation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child.J. Am. Acad. Matrim. Law.,28,285.
  87. 王舒芸(2008)。從「兒童權利公約」到「適合兒童生長的世界及後五年宣言」。社會發展季刊，123，6-33。
  88. 李園會（編）(2006).兒童權利公約.內政部兒童局.
  89. 林沛君(2017)。兒少「表意權」實質意涵的初探－兒童權利公約之歷史發展及台灣參與。台灣人權學刊，4(1)，73-96。
  90. 施慧玲（編）,陳竹上（編）(2016).兒童權利公約.:台灣新世紀文教基金會.
  91. 廖福特(2013).聯合國與人權保障－監督機制、條約內涵、台灣實踐.:台灣新世紀文教基金會.
被引用次数
  1. 林慈偉(2022)。論兒童最佳利益在對父母或主要照顧者被告量刑中的考慮：兼談憲法法庭111年憲判字第8號判決之啟示及影響。臺大法學論叢，51(S)，1023-1090。
print cancel