檢測住院兒童跌倒危險評估表

The Validation of Fall Risk Scale for Hospitalized Children

10.6386/CGN.201906_30(2).0001

卓燕華(Yen-Hua Cho)；許光宏(Kuang-Hung Hsu)；石惠美(Whei-Mei Shih)；林素雯(Su-Wen Lin)；張鈞竹(Chun-Chu Chang)

兒童跌倒 ； 跌倒危險評估工具 ； 住院兒童 ； children fall ； fall risk scale for hospitalized children ； hospitalized children

長庚護理

30卷2期（2019 / 06 / 01）

135 - 146

繁體中文

背景：使用自擬「住院兒童跌倒危險評估表」，2009～2012年住院兒童跌倒發生率（千分之0.35－0.5），均高於台灣臨床成效指標（Taiwan Clinical Performance Indicator, TCPI）及本院監控閾值（千分之0.3）。本研究目的在探討「住院兒童跌倒危險評估表」之敏感性、特異性及相似比，冀望能找出住院病童跌倒危險因子，有效預防病童跌倒。方法：本研究採回溯性病例對照，以二階段展開。第一階段：回顧2011年～2013年住院後第一次評估舊表「兒童跌倒危險因子評估表」、跌倒記錄，將六項危險因子與跌倒與否進行卡方檢定、邏輯斯迴歸分析，確認相關之危險因子。第二階段：2015年9月∼2016年2月於兒科病房全面實施測試新表「新兒童跌倒危險因子評估表」，刪除不相關危險因子，收集資料驗證新表之敏感性及特異性。結果：第一階段由醫療資訊系統下載共計40,703人，以邏輯斯迴歸分析發現於年齡、性別、用藥情形、跌倒經驗等四項危險因子與跌倒有相關（p＜.05），評估分數≥3分的跌倒發生率是＜3分的3.3倍。第二階段使用「新兒童跌倒危險因子評估表」，下載共計5,816人，以ROC曲線分析≥4分敏感度91.7%、特異性51.1%，曲線下面積AUC 0.656，以邏輯斯迴歸分析，≥4分的跌倒發生率是＜4分的9.6倍。結論／實務運用：「新兒童跌倒危險因子評估表」包含年齡、性別、用藥情形、跌倒經驗等四項危險因子，刪除不相關二項「活動力」「體能狀況」，全面資訊化運用於本院體系兒科病童。

Background: When using the self-established fall risk scale, the fall rate of hospitalized children from 2009-2012 was .35- .5% which was higher than Taiwan Clinical Performance Indicator and hospital threshold ( .3%). The purpose of this study was to test the sensitivity, specificity, and likelihood ratios of current risk scale for hospitalized children to find out risk factors for better children fall prevention. Methods: Two stages of retrospective chart review were proceeded. On the first stage, 2011-2013, fall record data from hospital information system using old fall risk scale were collected and six risk factors were used to analyze to identify fall risk factors by using chi-square test and multiple logistic regressions. On the second stage, September 1, 2015 - February 28, 2016, new fall risk scale was used for all pediatric units to assess its sensitivity, specificity, and likelihood ratios. Results: On the first stage, patient fall data of 40,703 patients were downloaded from hospital information system. Data were analyzed using logistic regression. Age, sex, medication, fall experience were associated with fall (p＜ .05). The occurrence of patient with a fall score ≥3 was 3.3 times higher than those with a score of ＜3. On the second stage, patient fall data of 5,816 patients were downloaded by using new revision fall risk scale. The results revealed that the sensitivity of a score ≥4 was 91.7%, specificity was 51.1%, and the area under curve was .656 by using ROC curve. The occurrence of patients with a fall score ≥4 was 9.6 times higher than those with a score of ＜4. Activity and physical condition were deleted to come up with a four-factor fall risk scale. Each factor weighted differently. Conclusion/ Implications for Practice: By deleting activity and physical condition, the revised fall risk scale with age, sex, medication, and fall experience, is currently used in all pediatric units.

1. 林小玲、溫明寰、陳玉枝(2010)。跌倒危險評估表準確度之研究。醫護科技期刊，20(1)，47-59。
   連結：
2. 張釭姍、蔡東杰、陳明招、陳泰瑞(2005)。住院老人精神疾病患者跌倒之危險因子。台灣精神醫學，19(3)，216-224。
   連結：
3. 蔡美容、熊淑菁、黃雪芬(2016)。降低學齡前期住院病童跌倒發生率。彰化護理，23(4)，22-35。
   連結：
4. Adolph, K. E.(2000).Specificity of learning: Why infants fall over a veritable cliff.Psychological Science,11,290-295.
5. Cooper, C. L.,Nolt, J. D.(2007).Development of an evidence-based pediatric fall prevention program.Journal of Nursing Care Quality,22(2),107-112.
6. Da Rin Della Mora, R.,Bagnasco, A.,Sasso, L.(2012).In-hospital pediatric accidents: An integrative review of the literature.International Nursing Review,59(4),466-473.
7. Fawcett, T.(2006).An introduction to ROC analysis.Pattern Recognition Letters,27(8),861-874.
8. Graf, E. (2005). Pediatric hospital falls: Development of a predictor model to guide pediatric clinical practice. Sigma Theta Tau International. Chicago: Children's Memorial Medical Center. Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/10755/147928
9. Graf, E.(2008).Pediatric fall risk assessment and classification: Two hallmarks for a successful inpatient fall prevention program.Society of Pediatric Nursing SPN News,17(2),3-5.
10. Graf, E.(2011).Magnet children's hospitals: Leading knowledge development and quality standards for inpatient pediatric fall prevention programs.Pediatric Nursing,26(2),122-127.
11. Hill-Rodriguez, D.,Messmer, P. R.,Williams, P. D.,Zeller, R. A.,Williams, A. R.,Wood, M.,Henry, M.(2009).The Humpty Dumpty Falls Scale: A case-control study.Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing,14(1),22-32.
12. Ignatavicius, D.(2000).Do you help staff rise to the fall-prevention challenge?.Nursing Management,30(1),27-30.
13. Jamerson, P. A.,Graf, E.,Messmer, P. R.,Fields, H. W.,Barton, S.,Berger, A.,Lunbeck, M.(2014).Inpatient falls in freestanding children's hospitals.Pediatric Nursing,40(3),127-135.
14. JCAHO. (2017). 2017 National Patient Safety Goals. Retrieved from https://www.jointcommission.org/standards_information/npsgs.aspx
15. Kramlich, D. L.,Dende, D.(2016).Development of a pediatric fall risk and injury reduction program.Pediatric Nursing,42(2),77-82.
16. Messmer, P. R.,Williams, P. D.,Williams, R.(2013).A case-control study of pediatric falls using electronic medical records.Rehabilitation Nursing,38,73-79.
17. Morse, J. M.(2002).Enhancing the safety of hospitalization by reducing patient falls.American Journal of Infection Control,30(6),376-380.
18. Morse, J. M.,Prowse, M.,Morrow, N.,Federspeil, G.(1985).A retrospective analysis of patient falls.Canadian Journal of Public Health,76,116-118.
19. Pauley, B. J.,Houston, L. S.,Cheng, D.,Johnston, D. M.(2014).Clinical relevance of the Humpty Dumpty Falls Scale in a pediatric specialty hospital.Pediatric nursing,40(3),137-142.
20. Razmus, I.,Davis, D.(2012).The epidemiology of falls in hospitalized children.Pediatric Nursing,38(1),31-35.
21. Razmus, I.,Wilson, D.,Smith, R.,Newman, E.(2006).Falls in hospitalized children.Pediatric Nursing,32,568-572.
22. Ryan-Wenger, N.,Kimchi-Woods, J.,Erbaugh, M. A.,LaFollette, L.,Lathrop, J.(2012).Challenges and conundrums in the validation of pediatric fall risk assessment tools.Pediatric Nursing,38(3),159-167.
23. 台灣病人安全資訊網(2017)。台灣病人安全通報系統2016 年TPR年報
24. 呂基燕、張美娟、張玉芳(2008)。兒科住院病童預防跌倒改善方案。志為護理─ 慈濟護理雜誌，7(1)，107-115。
25. 洪蘭(2005)。裡應外合。台北=Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC:遠流=Yuanliou。
26. 陳玉枝、林麗華、簡淑芬(2003)。跌倒危險因子。醫院，36(5)，42-54。
27. 黃美智校閱、蔣立琦校閱(2013)。兒科護理學。台北市=Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC:永大=Yongda。
28. 楊美虹、徐姍姍(2003)。住院病患跌倒之新觀念。護理雜誌，50(1)，86-92。
29. 葉郁菁校閱(2011)。人類發展學。台北市=Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC:永大=Yongda。
30. 謝秀玲、侯惠珍、鄭涵菁、楊美紅(2012)。兒科病房住院病童之跌倒改善專案。源遠護理，6(2)，39-48。