醫院職場暴力的通報與申訴：曾遭受職場暴力的護理人員之經驗

Reporting and Complaint-Filing of Workplace Violence: Experiences of Nurses Who Had Encountered Workplace Violence

10.6386/CGN.201909_30(3).0001

邊立中(Li-Chung Pien)；黃玉妮(Yu-Ni Huang)；鄭雅文(Ya-wen Cheng)

職場暴力 ； 通報 ； 護理人員 ； 管理 ； workplace violence ； reporting ； health care workers ； management

長庚護理

30卷3期（2019 / 09 / 01）

281 - 295

繁體中文

背景：職場暴力的通報與申訴，是減緩職場暴力之負面影響的重要機制，但職場暴力的通報制度與後續申訴流程若缺乏便利性或隱私保護性，則可能影響職場暴力受害者的申訴意願。目的：本研究旨在探討遭受職場暴力的護理人員之通報與申訴經驗。方法：透過社群網路（FaceBook、PTT）招募17位曾遭職場暴力並有通報或申訴經驗的醫院臨床護理人員進行深度訪談，採匿名方式進行。結果：醫院內部大都設有職場暴力通報與申訴制度，但實務運作上卻存有不少障礙，包括：主管未主動協助申訴及後續事宜、護理人員不了解職場暴力相關法規、醫院內部申訴流程不便、申訴過程對受害工作者的保護措施不足、院方未主動提供法律資源與協助等。此外，人力不足問題亦是職場暴力未被妥善處置的重要脈絡因素。結論／實務應用：本研究指出醫院職場暴力通報與申訴機制之實務面向問題，並對此提出改善建議。

Background: The reporting and complaint-filing mechanisms are important for ameliorating negative impacts of workplace violence. However, lack of convenience and confidentiality may reduce workers' motivation to make uses of these mechanisms. Purpose: This study was designed to explore the experiences of hospital nurses in the reporting and complaint-filing processes after encountering workplace violence. Methods: Eligible participants were hospital nurses who had experienced workplace violence and had made notification or filed legal complaints. A total of 17 nurses recruited through social media advertisement agreed to participate in face-to-face in-depth interviews. The interviews were conducted anonymously. Results: Findings of this study suggested that while reporting systems for workplace violence have been established in many hospitals, there were barriers in practice, including: lack of support from supervisors in assisting reporting and follow-up; lack of awareness among nurses with regard to labor regulations and organizational systems of workplace violence; inconvenience in reporting procedures; insufficient protection of victimized workers during the processes; and lack of legal resource and assistance from the management. Besides, lack of sufficient manpower also contributed to organizational inadequacy in handling workplace violence. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: We identified several problems in the reporting systems of workplace violence in hospital settings and provided recommendations for their improvement.

1. 明金蓮、黃惠美、洪曉佩、曾麗華、黃美淑、江淑華、董貞吟(2016)。以系統性文獻回顧探討護理人員職場暴力現況與影響。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，35(2)，116-135。
   連結：
2. 邊立中、鄭雅文、陳怡欣、陳秋蓉(2014)。職場暴力盛行率與受雇者健康狀況之相關。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，33(1)，36-50。
   連結：
3. Björkdahl, A.,Hansebo, G.,Palmstierna, T.(2013).The influence of staff training on the violence prevention and management climate in psychiatric inpatient units.Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing,20(5),396-404.
4. Buchko, A. A.,Buscher, C.,Buchko, K. J.(2017).Why do good employees stay in bad organizations?.Business Horizons,60(5),729-739.
5. Chappell, D.,Di Martino, V.(2006).Violence at work.International Labour Organization.
6. Chirilă, T.,Constantin, T.(2013).Understanding Workplace Bullying Phenomenon through its Concepts: A Literature Review.Procedia -Social and Behavioral Sciences,84,1175-1179.
7. Choi, S. H.,Lee, H.(2017).Workplace violence against nurses in Korea and its impact on professional quality of life and turnover intention.Journal of Nursing Management,25(7),508-518.
8. Dillon, B. L.(2012).Workplace violence: impact, causes, and prevention.Work,42(1),15-20.
9. Farrell, G. A.,Shafiei, T.(2012).Workplace aggression, including bullying in nursing and midwifery: A descriptive survey (the SWAB study).International journal of nursing studies,49(11),1423-1431.
10. Hall, G. B.,Dollard, M. F.,Winefield, A. H.,Dormann, C.,Bakker, A. B.(2013).Psychosocial safety climate buffers effects of job demands on depression and positive organizational behaviors.Anxiety, Stress & Coping,26(4),355-377.
11. Hogarth, K. M.,Beattie, J.,Morphet, J.(2016).Nurses' attitudes towards the reporting of violence in the emergency department.Australasian emergency nursing journal,19(2),75-81.
12. Holm, P.,Møller, B.(2007).Violence at the workplace.
13. Hsieh, H. F.,Chang, S. C.,Wang, H. H.(2016).The relationships among personality, social support, and resilience of abused nurses at emergency room and psychiatric ward in Taiwan.Women and health,57(1),40-51.
14. Human Resources and Skills Development Canada(2010).Guide to Violence Prevention in the Work Place.
15. Hutchinson, M.,Vickers, M. H.,Wilkes, L.,Jackson, D.(2009)."The worse you behave, the more you seem, to be rewarded": bullying in nursing as organizational corruption.Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal,21(3),213-229.
16. ILO. (2003). Code of practice on workplace violence in services sectors and measures to combat this phenomenon. Retrieved from http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/@ed_protect/@protrav/@safework/documents/normativeinstrument/wcms_107705.pdf
17. Jones, J.,Lyneham, J.(2001).Violence: Part of the job for Australian nurses?.Australian Emergency Nursing Journal,4(1),10-14.
18. Kwan, S. S. M.,Tuckey, M. R.,Dollard, M. F.(2016).The role of the psychosocial safety climate in coping with workplace bullying: A grounded theory and sequential tree analysis.European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,25(1),133-148.
19. Law, R.,Dollard, M. F.,Tuckey, M. R.,Dormann, C.(2011).Psychosocial safety climate as a lead indicator of workplace bullying and harassment, job resources, psychological health and employee engagement.Accident Analysis & Prevention,43(5),1782-1793.
20. Leka, S.,Jain, A.(2010).Health Impact of The Psychosocial Hazards of Work: An Overview.
21. Martino, V. d. (2002). Workplace Violence in the Health Sector: Country case studies: Brazil, Bulgaria, Lebanon, Portugal, South Africa, Thailand, and an Additional Australian Study. Geneva, Switzerland: ILO/ICN/WHO/PSI Joint Programme on Workplace Violence in the Health Sector. Retrieved from http://cdrwww.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/violence/activities/workplace/WVsynthesisreport.pdf
22. NIOSH. (1996). Current intelligence bulletin 57: Violence in the workplace. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/96-100/introduction.html
23. Occupational Safety and Health Administration=OSHA(2016).Guidelines for preventing workplace violence for health care social service workers.OSHA.
24. Olsen, E.,Bjaalid, G.,Mikkelsen, A.(2017).Work climate and the mediating role of workplace bullying related to job performance, job satisfaction, and work ability: a study among hospital nurses.Journal of Advanced Nursing,73,2709-2719.
25. Parent-Thirion, A.,Vermeylen, G.,van Houten, G.,Lyly-Yrjänäinen, M.,Biletta, I.,Cabrita, J.(2012).Fifth European Working Conditions Survey-Overview Report, 2012.Luxembourg:Puboications Office of the European Union.
26. Pich, J.,Hazelton, M.,Sundin, D.,Kable, A.(2010).Patient related violence against emergency department nurses.Nursing & health sciences,12(2),268-274.
27. Pien, L. C.,Chen, D. R.,Chen, C. J.,Liang, K. M.,Cheng, Y.(2015).Associations of neighborhood-level workplace violence with workers' mental distress problems: a multilevel analysis of Taiwanese employees.Journal of occupational health,57(6),555-564.
28. Shiao, J. S. C.,Tseng, Y.,Hsieh, Y. T.,Hou, J. Y.,Cheng, Y.,Guo, Y. L.(2010).Assaults against nurses of general and psychiatric hospitals in Taiwan.International archives of occupational and environmental health,83(7),823-832.
29. Wall, A. E.,Smith, R. A.,Nodoushani, O.(2017).Workplace bullying: A growing epidemic.Competition Forum,15(2),251-258.
30. Wax, J. R.,Pinette, M. G.,Cartin, A.(2016).Workplace violence in health care-It's not "Part of the Job".Obstetrical & gynecological survey,71(7),427-434.
31. Zhang, L.,Wang, A.,Xie, X.,Zhou, Y.,Li, J.,Yang, L.,Zhang, J.(2017).Workplace violence against nurses: A cross-sectional study.International journal of nursing studies,72,8-14.
32. 行政院勞委會職訓局( 無日期)‧ 職場霸凌？還是駕凌？ 拒絕成為被霸凌者！ ‧ 取自http://file.ejob.gov.tw/happy/career/No_113/113a.html [Council of Labor Affairs Council VTC (No date). Workplace bullying? Or domineer over others? Refused to be bullied!. Retrieved from: http://file.ejob.gov.tw/happy/career/No_113/113a.html]
33. 張芬芬(2010)。質性資料分析的五步驟： 在抽象階梯上爬升。初等教育學刊，35，87-120。
34. 勞動部(2013)‧職業安全衛生法‧ 取自https://laws.mol.gov.tw/FLAW/FLAWDAT0201.aspx?lsid=FL015013 [Ministry of Labor, Taiwan, ROC. (2013). Occupational Safety and Health Act. Retrieved from https://laws.mol.gov.tw/FLAW/FLAWDAT0201.aspx?lsid=FL015013]
35. 勞動部(2014)‧ 勞動部工作生活平衡網：如何處理職場霸凌‧ 取自https://wlb.mol.gov.tw/page/Content.aspx?id=71 [Ministry of Labor, Taiwan, ROC. (2014). How to deal with workplace bullying. Retrieved from: https://wlb.mol.gov.tw/page/Content.aspx?id=71]
36. 勞動部職業衛生安全衛生署(2017)‧執行職務遭受不法侵害預防指引(第二版) ‧取自http://www.osha.gov.tw/1106/1113/1115/18198/[Occupational Safety and Health Administration, Ministry of Labor, Taiwan, ROC. (2017). Guidelines for Preventing of illegal infringement in workplace (Second Edition). Retrieved from http://www.osha.gov.tw/1106/1113/1115/18198/]
37. 蔡曉婷、韓錦樺、陳麗芳、周汎澔(2014)。護理職場霸凌與離職傾向及其相關因素探討。護理雜誌，61(3)，58-68。
38. 衛生福利部(2017)。台灣病人安全通報系統2016 年TPR 年報

1. 邊立中,鄭婉汝(2022)。醫院安全氛圍與護理人員心理健康－以職場暴力為例。護理雜誌，69(5)，21-26。
2. 李睿軒,石惠美(2021)。急診職場暴力與護理人員之韌性。長庚護理，32(4)，39-47。