人力資源管理透過全面品質管理影響照護績效

Human Resource Management through Total Quality Management to Affect Nursing Healthcare Performance

10.6386/CGN.202209_33(3).0001

黃珊(Shan Huang)；陳順宇(Shun-Yu Chen)；王正華(Zheng-Hua Wang)

人力資源管理 ； 全面品質管理 ； 照護績效 ； human resource management ； total quality management ； healthcare performance

長庚護理

33卷3期（2022 / 09 / 01）

1 - 14

繁體中文

本研究目的為探討護理人員感受人力資源管理，透過全面品質管理之中介及照護績效間之關係進行探討。研究對象為某醫療財團法人機構之護理人員，共收集護理人員計483人，研究結果發現人力資源管理對照護績效有顯著影響（c'=.59，P =.001）；全面品質管理對照護績效亦有顯著（b1=.601，P =.000）；同時人力資源管理對全面品質管理影響亦呈現顯著（a1=.872，P =.000）；人力資源管理對照護績效的間接效用影響（a*b = 0.87*0.60 = 0.522），路徑係數a1與b1的t值均大於3，依據Sobel檢定，間接效用顯著，表示照護績效受人力資源管理的影響，而全面品質管理人力資源管理對照護績效影響有中介效果。研究發現除提供未來對醫療機構相關議題有興趣者引文參考外，並就不同程度的醫療環境及醫療機構管理者，以運用人力資源管理來提升照護績效，並取得護理競爭優勢之實務參考，於未來執行實務時，對品管優勢模式有更明確的方向。

The purpose of this study is to explore the nursing staff's perception of human resource management, and induce a discussion through the relationship between the intermediary type of total quality management and nursing performance. The participants of this research are the nursing staff in a medical group. A total of 483 nursing staff participated. The research found that human resource management has a significant impact on nursing performance (c'=.59, P=.001), total quality management has a significant impact on nursing performance (b1=.601, P=.000). At the same time, human resource management also has a significant impact on total quality management (a1=.872, P=.000), the impact of human resource management on the indirect utility of nursing performance (a*b=0.87*0.60=0.522), the t values of the path coefficients a1 and b1 are both greater than 3, and the indirect utility is significant according to the Sobel test. The findings of this study showed that in addition to providing references for future citations for those who are interested in medical institution-related topics, it also provides practical reference for different levels of medical environment and medical institution managers to use human resource management to improve nursing performance and gain competitive advantages in nursing. In the implementation of practice, there is a clearer direction for the quality control advantages in the future.

1. 洪素英, S. Y.,吳泰熙, T. H.(2019)。考量醫護人力短缺及兼顧醫療品質之醫院經營績效評估模式─以台灣急性照護醫院為例。企業管理學報，44(4)，57-89。
   連結：
2. 曾淑穎, S. Y.,黃生, S.(2017)。運用大數據分析員工個人背景對教育訓練之影響─以旅館業為例。育達科大學報，45，33-49。
   連結：
3. Akdere, M.(2006).Quality management through human resources: An integrated approach to performance improvement.The Business Review,5(2),233-238.
4. Al-Dhaafri, H. S.,Al-Swidi, A. K.,Yusoff, R. Z. B.(2016).The mediating role of total quality management between the entrepreneurial orientation and the organizational performance.The TQM Journal,28(1),89-111.
5. Becker, B.,Gerhart, B.(1996).The impact of human resource management on organizational performance: Progress and prospectors.Academy of Management Journal,39(4),779-801.
6. Bogers, M.,Foss, N. J.,Lyngsie, J.(2018).The “human side” of open innovation: The role of employee diversity in firm-level openness.Research Policy,47(1),218-231.
7. Boon, O. K.,Arumugam, V.,Hwa, T. S.(2005).Does soft TQM predict employees’ attitudes?.The TQM Magazine,17(3),278-289.
8. Bowen, D. E.,Ostroff, C.(2004).Understanding HRM-firm performance linkages: the role of the strength of the HRM system.Academy of Management Review,29(2),203-211.
9. Combs, J.,Liu, Y.,Hall, A.,Ketchen, D.(2006).How much do high-performance work practices matter? A meta-analysis if their effects on organizational performance.Personnel Psychology,59(3),501-528.
10. Cummings, G. G.,Tate, K.,Lee, S.,Wong, C. A.,Paananen, T.,Micaroni, S. P.,Chatterjee, G. E.(2018).Leadership styles and outcome patterns for the nursing workforce and work environment: A systematic review.International Journal of Nursing Studies,85,19-60.
11. Demirbag, M.,Tatoglu, E.,Tekinkus, M.,Zaim, S.(2006).An analysis of the relationship between TQM implementation and organizational performance: Evidence from Turkish SMEs.Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management,17(6),829-847.
12. Dessler, G.(2017).Human resources management.Pearson.
13. Han, S. B.,Chen, S. K.,Ebrahimpour, B.(2007).The impact of ISO 9000 on TQM and business performance.Journal of Business and Economic Studies,13(2),1-21.
14. Hitt, M.,Duane Ireland, R.(2017).The intersection of entrepreneurship and strategic management research.The Blackwell Handbook of Entrepreneurship,3,45-63.
15. Hogreve, J.,Iseke, A.,Derfuss, K.,Eller, T.(2017).The service–profit chain: A meta-analytic test of a comprehensive theoretical framework.Journal of Marketing,81(3),41-61.
16. Jiménez, D.,Martínez, M.,Para, L.(2020).Implications of TQM in firm’s innovation capability.International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management,37(2),279-304.
17. Konecny, P. A.,Thun, J. H.(2011).Do it separately or simultaneously-An empirical analysis of a conjoint implementation of TQM and TPM on plant performance.International Journal of Production Economics,496-507.
18. Li, L. X.,Benton, W. C.(1996).Performance measurement criteria in health care organizations: Review and future research directions.European Journal of Operational Research,93,449-468.
19. Luo, X.,Slotegraaf, R. J.,Pan, X.(2006).Cross-functional ‘coopetition’: The simultaneous role of cooperation and competition within firms.Journal of Marketing,70(2),67-80.
20. Noe, R. A.,Hollnbeck, J. R.,Gerhart, B.,Wright, P. M.,王精文（譯）(2018).人力資源管理.商麥羅格希爾國際股份有限公司.
21. Prajogo, D. I.,Cooper, B.(2017).The individual and organizational level effects of TQM practices on job satisfaction.International Journal of Manpower,38(2),215-225.
22. Rafaela, A. l.,Juan A, M. G.,Carmen, M. L.(2012).Is worker commitment necessary for achieving competitive advantage and customer satisfaction when companies use HRM and TQM practices?.Universia Business Review,36,64-89.
23. Sitkin, S. B.,Sutcliffe, K. M.,Schroeder, R. G.(1994).Distinguishing control from learning in total quality management: A contingency perspective.Academy of Management Review,19(3),537-564.
24. Temtime, Z. T.(2003).The moderating impacts of business planning and firm size on total quality management practices.The TQM Management,15(1),52-60.
25. Zineldin, M.,Vasicheva, V.(2012).Total Relationship Management (TRM), and Quality of Labour Force performances in the Higher Education Sector in Sweden.Turkey and Egypt.Adapt International Bulletin,30,1-8.
26. Zineldin, M.,Zineldin, J.(2014).Total medical and healthcare quality, satisfaction and patient safety short: Total medical and healthcare quality(TMHQ).International Journal of Medical Science and Health Care,2(9),1-10.
27. 吳若杉, J. S.(2017)。成功大學經營管理系=National Cheng Kung University of Advanced Administation。
28. 馬先芝, H. J.,吳蕙汝, H. J.,趙正敏, C. M.,鄭博文, B. W.(2017)。醫院導入品管圈醫療品質成效之初探-以某地區教學醫院為例。醫療品質雜誌，11(4)，78-84。
29. 陳雅惠, Y.H.,侯貴圓, K. Y.,鄭嘉惠, C. H.,王拔群, P. C.(2016)。北部某醫療體系新版病人安全文化調查結果。醫療品質雜誌，10(3)，66-73。
30. 彭淑媛, S.Y.(2017)。臺北護理健康大學護理系=National Taipei University of Nursing and Health Sciences。
31. 黃同圳, T. Z.,Byars, Lloyd L.,Rue, Leslie W.(2015).人力資源管理：全球思維台灣觀點.普林斯頓國際公司=Gau Lih Book.
32. 黃芳銘, F. M.(2004).結構方程模式理論與應用.五南=Wumnan boooks.
33. 廖熏香, H. H.(2014)。談病人安全的基本課題─醫療照護提供者的照護。澄清醫護管理雜誌，10(2)，4-8。