题名

遺傳學迷思概念之文獻探討及其在教學上的啓示

并列篇名

Literature Review of Genetics Misconceptions and Its Implications on Instruction

DOI

10.6173/CJSE.2004.1203.05

作者

楊坤原(Kun-Yuan Yang)；張賴妙理(Miao-Li Changlai)

关键词

遺傳學 ； 迷思概念 ； 教學 ； Genetics ； Misconception ； Instruction

期刊名称

科學教育學刊

卷期/出版年月

12卷3期（2004 / 09 / 01）

页次

365 - 398

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

遺傳學是各級學校的師生一致感到難以教和學的生物學單元之一。爲使國內外遺傳學迷思概念的研究能有效促進遺傳學的教學，本研究採文獻探討的研究方式，分析自1970年至2000年共48篇遺傳學迷思概念相關文獻，從中歸納出導致學生遺傳學迷思概念的來源與成因大致可分爲個人、家庭與社會文化和學校教學三大類。此外，本研究亦列舉各年級學生對細胞分裂（包括有絲分裂、減數分裂）、有性生殖（包括配子、性狀遺傳）、孟德爾遺傳定律（包括機率在遺傳學上的應用、基因型）、基因（包括對偶基因、DNA的化學組成與結構、顯（隱）性、共顯性和不完全顯性）、染色體（包括同源染色體、性染色體和性聯遺傳）、突變與遺傳工程等七類主要概念及其相關概念所出現之各項迷思概念。最後則參照各研究文獻的啟示與認知心理學的觀點，對遺傳學概念的教學提出各項建議。
英文摘要

There is a consensus among teachers and students that genetics is one of the most difficult units to teach and learn. To help promote the teaching and learning of genetics concepts, we analyzed forty-eight papers published from 1970 to 2000 about genetics misconceptions. From these we generalized three causes (personal, social, and school teaching) for genetics misconceptions and listed seven categories of students' misconceptions including: cell divisions (mitosis and meiosis), sexual reproduction (gamate and the inheritance of characteristics), Mendel's laws of inheritance (the application of probability and genotype), gene (allele, chemical components and structure of DNA, dominance and recessive, codominance, incomplete dominance), chromosome (homologus chromosome, sex chromosome, sex-linked inheritance), mutation, and genetic engineering. Based on the results, other research findings and the principles of cognitive psychology, suggestions for the teaching of genetics concepts are provided.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 張筱莉、林陳涌(2001)。學童眼中的科學專有名詞。科學教育學刊，9(3)，219-234。
    連結：
  2. 楊坤原、鄭湧涇(1997)。高一學生遺傳學解題表現與解題策略之研究。科學教育學刊,，5(4)，529-555。
    連結：
  3. Albaladejo, C.,Lucas, A. M.(1988).Pupil`s meanings for `mutation`.Journal of Biological Education,22(4),304-309.
  4. Amir, R.,Frankl, D. R.,Tamir, P.(1987).Paper presented at the Second International Seminar: Misconceptions and educational strategies in science and mathematics.Ithaca, NY.
  5. Ausubel, D. P.(1968).Educational psychology: A cognitive view.New York:Holt, Rinehart, & Winston.
  6. Bahar, M. B.,Johnstone, A. H.,Hansell, M. H.(1999).Revisiting learning difficulties in biology.Journal of Biological Education,33(2),84-86.
  7. Barrass, R.(1984).Some misconceptions and misunderstandings perpetuated by teachers and textbooks of biology.Journal of Biological Education,18(3),201-206.
  8. Bernstein, A. C.,Cowan, P. A.(1975).Children`s concepts of how people get babies.Child Development,46,77-91.
  9. Brown, C. R.(1990).Some misconceptions in meiosis shown by students responding to an advanced level practical examination question in biology.Journal of Biological Education,24(3),182-185.
  10. Brown, J. S.,Collins, A.,Duguid, P.(1989).Situated cognition and the culture of learning.Educational Researcher,18,32-42.
  11. Browning, M. E.,Lehman, J. D.(1988).Identification of student misconceptions in genetics problem solving via computer program.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,25(9),747-761.
  12. Campbell, N. A.,Reece, J. B.,Mitchell, L. G.(1999).Biology.New York:Addison-Wesley.
  13. Cavallo, A. M. L.(1996).Meaningful learning, reasoning ability, and students` understanding and problem solving of topics in genetics.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,33(6),625-656.
  14. Chandler, P.,Sweller, J.(1991).Cognitive load theory and the format of instruction.Cognition and Instruction,8(4),293-332.
  15. Chi, M. T. H.,Slotta, J. D.(1993).The ontological coherence of intuitive physics.Cognition and Instruction,10(2&3),249-260.
  16. Cho, H. H.,Kahle, J. B.,Nordland, F. H.(1985).An investigation of high school biology textbooks as sources of misconceptions and difficulties in genetics and some suggestions for teaching genetics.Science Education,69(5),707-719.
  17. Claxton, G.,P. J. Black,A. M. Lucas (Eds.)(1993).Children`s informal ideas in science.New York:Routledge.
  18. Clough, E. E.,Wood-Robinson, C.(1985).Children's understanding of inheritance.Journal of Biological Education,19(4),304-309.
  19. Collins, A.,Stewart, J. H.(1989).The knowledge structure of Mendelian genetics.The American Biology Teacher,51(3),143-149.
  20. Cooper, H.(1998).Synthesizing research-A guide for literature reviews.Thousand Oaks:Sage Publications.
  21. Costello, S. J.(1984).Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching.New Orleans, LA:
  22. Deadman, J. A.,Kelly, P. J.(1978).What do secondary school boys understand about evolution and heredity before they are taught the topics.Journal of Biological Education,12(1),7-15.
  23. Donovan, M. P.(1997).The vocabulary of biology and the problem of semantics.Journal of College Science Teaching,26(6),381-382.
  24. Dreyfus, A.,Jungwirth, E.(1989).The pupil and the living cell: A taxonomy of dysfunctional ideas about an abstract idea.Journal of Biological Education,23(1),49-55.
  25. Driver, R.(1983).The pupil as scientist.Philadelphia:Open University Press.
  26. Driver, R.,Easley, J.(1978).Pupils and paradigms: A review of the literature related to concept development in adolescent science students.Studies in Science Education,5,61-84.
  27. Driver, R.,Guesne, E.,Tiberghien, A.,R. Driver,E. Guesne,A. Tiberghien (Eds.)(1985).Children`s ideas in science.Philadelphia:Open University Press.
  28. Driver, R.,Guesne, E.,Tiberghien, A.,R. Driver,E. Guesne,A. Tiberghien (Eds.)(1985).Children`s ideas in science.Philadelphia:Open University Press.
  29. Driver, R.,Squires, A.,Rushworth, P.,Wood-Robinson, V.(1994).Making sense of secondary science-Research into children`s ideas.New York:Routledge.
  30. Duit, R.,Treagust, D. F.,B. J. Fraser,H. J. Walberg (Eds.)(1995).Improving science education.Chicago:The National Society for the Study of Education.
  31. Edwards, M.(1991).The newest biology.Bio-Science,41(3),136-138.
  32. Evans, J. S. B. T.,Over, D. E.(1996).Rationality and reasoning.Hove, Sussex:Psychology Press.
  33. Eylon, B-S.,Linn, M. C.(1988).Learning and instruction: An examination of four research perspectives in science education.Review of Educational Research,58(3),251-301.
  34. Finley, F. N.,Stewart, J. H.,Yarroch, W. L.(1982).Teachers` perceptions of important and difficult science content.Science Education,66(3),531-538.
  35. Fisher, K. M.,Lipson, J. I.,Hildebrand, A. C.,Miguel, L.,Schoenberg, N.,Porter, N.(1986).Student misconceptions and teacher assumptions in college biology.Journal of College Science Teaching,15(2),276-280.
  36. Fisher, K. M.,Moody, D. E.,K. M. Fisher,J. H. Wandersee,D. E. Moody (Eds.)(2000).Mapping biology knowledge.Dordrecht, the Netherlands:Klu-wer Academic Publishers.
  37. Gagne, E. D.,Yekovich, C. W.,Yekovich, F. R.(1993).The cognitive psychology of school learning.New York:HarperCollins College Publishers.
  38. Gilbert, J. G.,Watts, D. M.(1983).Concepts, misconceptions and alternative conceptions: Changing perspectives in science education.Studies in Science Education,10,61-98.
  39. Glynn, S. M.,Yeany, R. H.,Britton, B. K. (Eds.)(1991).The psychology of learning science.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Asso-ciates, Publishers.
  40. Goldman, R. J.,Goldman, D. G.(1982).How children perceive the origins of babies and the roles of mothers and fathers in procreation: A cross-national study.Child Development,53,491-504.
  41. Hackling, M.(1982).An examination of secondary students` understanding of inheritance concepts.The Australian Science Teachers Journal,28(1),13-20.
  42. Hackling, M. W.,Treagust, D.(1984).Research data necessary for meaningful review of grade ten high school genetics curriculum.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,21(2),197-209.
  43. Hackling, M. W.,Treagust, D. F.(1982).What lower secondary students should understand about the mechanisms of inheritance and what they do understand following instruction.Research in Science Education,12,78-88.
  44. Hallden, O.(1988).The evolution of the species: Pupil perspectives and school perspectives.International Journal of Science Education,10(5),541-552.
  45. Haslam, F.,Treagust, D. F.(1987).Diagnosing secondary students` misconceptions of photosynthesis and respiration in plants using a two-tier multiple choice instrument.Journal of Biological Education,21(3),203-211.
  46. Hendrix, J. R.,Mertens, T. R.,Baumgartner, R. S.(1981).Individualizing instruction through concept assessment.The American Biology Teacher,43(5),246-253.
  47. Herron, J. D.,Cantu, L. L.,Ward, R.,Srinivasan, V.(1977).Problems associated with concept analysis.Science Education,61(2),185-199.
  48. Hickman, F. M.,Kennedy, M. H.,McInerney, J. D.(1978).Human genetics education: Results of BSCS needs assessment survey.The American Biology Teacher,39(2),285-303.
  49. Kargob, D. B.,Hobbs, E. D.,Erickson, G. L.(1980).Children`s beliefs about inherited characteristics.Journal of Biological Education,25(3),137-146.
  50. Kindfield, A. C. H.(1991).Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching.Fontana, WI:ERIC Document Reproduction Service.
  51. Kindfield, A. C. H.(1994).Assessing understanding of biological process: elucidating students` models of meiosis.The American Biology Teacher,56(6),367-371.
  52. Kindfield, A. C. H.(1991).Confusing chromosome number and structure: A common student error.Journal of Biological Education,25(3),193-200.
  53. Kinnear, J. F.(1986).Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association.San Francisco, CA:ERIC Document Reproduction Service.
  54. Kinnear, J. F.,Martin, M. D.(1987).Symbol use and concept development in genetic engineering.Paper presented at the Second International Seminar: Misconceptions and educational strategies in science and mathematics,26-29.
  55. Koch, H.(1986).A small-scale interview study of college freshmen`s knowledge of concepts, principles and processes in molecular genetics before and after laboratory instruction.ERIC Document Reproduction Service.
  56. Lawson, A.,Thompson, L. D.(1988).Formal reasoning ability and misconceptions concerning genetics and natural selection.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,25(9),733-746.
  57. Lazarowitz, R.,Penso, S.(1992).High school students` difficulties in learning biology concepts.Journal of Biological Education,26(3),215-223.
  58. Lewis, J.,Wood-Robinson, C.(2000).Genes, chromosome, cell division and inheritance-Do students see any relationship.International Journal of Science Education,22(2),177-195.
  59. Lock, R.,Miles, C.(1993).Biotechnology and genetic engineering: students` knowledge and attitudes.Journal of Biological Education,27(4),267-272.
  60. Longden, B.(1982).Genetics-Are there inherent learning difficulties.Journal of Biological Education,16(2),135-140.
  61. Merrill, M. D.,Tennyson, R. D.,Posey, L. O.(1992).Teaching concepts: An instructional de sign guide.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Educational Technology Publications.
  62. Mertens, T. R.,Hendrix, J. R.(1990).The popular press, scientific literacy in human genetics, and bioethical decision-making.School Science and Mathematics,90(4),317-322.
  63. Mertens, T. R.,Walker, J. O.(1992).A paper-&-pencil strategy for teaching mitosis & meiosis, diagnosing learning problems & predicting examination performance.The American Biology Teacher,54(8),470-475.
  64. Mintzes, J. J.,Arnaudin, M. W.(1984).Children`s biology: A review of research on conceptual development in the life sciences.ERIC Document Reproduction Service.
  65. Moll, M. B.,Allen, R. D.(1987).Student difficulties with Mendelian genetics problem.The American Biology Teacher,49(4),229-233.
  66. Novak, J. D.,Gowin, D. B.(1984).Learning how to learn.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  67. Odom, A. L.,Barrow, L. H.(1995).Development and application of a two-tier diagnostic test measuring college biology students` understanding of diffusion and osmosis after a course of instruction.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,32(1),45-61.
  68. Osborne, R.,Freyberg, P.,P. Freyberg (Eds.)(1985).Learning in science.Hong Kong:Heinemann.
  69. Osborne, R.,P. Freyberg (Eds.)(1985).Learning in science.Hong Kong:Heinemann.
  70. Pashley, M.(1994).A-level students: their problems with gene and allele.Journal of Biological Education,28(2),120-126.
  71. Pearson, J. T.,Hughes, W. J.(1986).Design an A-level genetics course: I. Identifying the necessary concepts and considering their relationships.Journal of Biological Education,20(1),47-55.
  72. Pearson, J. T.,Hughes, W. J.(1988).Problems with the use of terminology in genetics education: A literature review and classification scheme.Journal of Biological Education,22(3),178-182.
  73. Peterson, R. F.,Treagust, D. F.,Garnett, P.(1989).Development and application of a diagnostic instrument to evaluate grade-11 and-12 students` concepts of covalent bonding and structure following a course of instruction.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,26(4),301-314.
  74. Radford, A.,Bird-Stewart, J. A.(1982).Teaching genetics in schools.Journal of Biological Education,16(3),177-180.
  75. Ramorogo, G.,Wood-Robinson, C.(1995).Batswana children`s understanding of biological inheritance.Journal of Biological Education,29(1),60-71.
  76. Russell, T.,P. J. Black,A. M. Lucas (Eds.)(1993).Children`s informal ideas in science.New York:Routledge.
  77. Simmons, P. E.(1987).Paper presented at the Second International Seminar: Misconceptions and educational strategies in science and mathematics.Ithaca, NY:
  78. Simmons, P. E.,Lunetta, V. N.(1993).Problem-solving behaviors during a genetics computer simulation: Beyond the expert/novice dichotomy.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,30(2),153-173.
  79. Slack, S. J.,Stewart, J.(1990).High school students` problem-solving performance on realistic genetics problems.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,27(1),55-67.
  80. Smith, M. U.(1991).Teaching cell division: student difficulties and teaching recommendations.Journal of College Science Teaching,41(1),28-33.
  81. Smith, M. U.,Good, R.(1984).Problem solving and classical genetics: Successful versus unsuccessful performances.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,21(9),895-912.
  82. Snow, R. E.,Lohman, D. F.,R. L. Linn (Ed.)(1989).Educational measurement.New York:Macmillan.
  83. Solomon, G. E. A.,Johnson, S. C.,Zaitchik, D.,Carey, S.(1996).Like father, like son: Young children`s understanding of how and why offspring resemble their parents.Child Development,67,151-171.
  84. Solomon, J.,P. J. Black,A. M. Lucas (Eds.)(1993).Children`s informal ideas in science.New York:Routledge.
  85. Springer, K.(1995).Acquiring a naïve theory of kinship through inference.Child Development,66,547-558.
  86. Springer, K.(1996).Young children`s understanding of a biological basis for parent-offspring relations.Child Development,67,2841-2856.
  87. Springer, K.(1992).Children`s awareness of the biological implications of kinship.Child Development,63,950-959.
  88. Springer, K.,Keil, F. C.(1989).On the development of biologically specific beliefs: The case of inheritance.Child Development,60,637-648.
  89. Stewart, J.(1983).Student problem solving in high school genetics.Science Education,67(4),523-540.
  90. Stewart, J. H.(1982).Difficulties experienced by high school students when learning basic Mendelian genetics.The American Biology Teacher,44(2),80-84.
  91. Stewart, J.,Dale, M.(1989).High school students` understanding of chromosome/gene behavior during meiosis.Science Education,73(4),501-521.
  92. Stewart, J.,Hafner, B.,Dale, M.(1990).Students` alternative views of meiosis.The American Biology Teacher,52(4),228-232.
  93. Stewart, J.,Maclin, R.(1990).Representing genotype-to-phenotype mappings.Journal of Biological Education,24(2),113-116.
  94. Tasker, R.,Osborne, R.,R. Osborne,P. Freyberg (Eds.)(1985).Learning in science.Hong Kong:Heinemann.
  95. Tolman, R. R.(1982).Difficulties in genetics problem solving.The American Biology Teacher,44(9),525-527.
  96. Treagust, D. F.(1988).Development and use of diagnostic tests to evaluate students` misconceptions in science.International Journal of Science Education,10(2),159-169.
  97. Wandersee, J. H.,Fisher, K. M.,Moody, D. E. (Eds.)(2000).Mapping biology knowledge.Dordrecht the Netherlands:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
  98. Wandersee, J. H.,Mintzes, J. J.,Novak, J. D.,D. L. Gabel (Ed.)(1994).Handbook of research on science teaching and learning.New York:Macmillan Publishing Company.
  99. Wood-Robinson, C.(1994).Young people`s ideas about inheritance and evolution.Studies in Science Education,24,29-47.
  100. Wood-Robinson, C.,S. M. Glynn,E. Duit (Eds.)(1995).Learning science in schools: Research reforming practice.Hillisade, NJ:LEA.
  101. 國立台灣師範大學科學教育中心(2000)。高級中學基礎生物。台北市:國立編譯館。
  102. 國立編譯館(2001)。國民中學生物教科書。台北市:國立編譯館。
  103. 陳世輝(1994)。國科會專題研究計畫成果報告國科會專題研究計畫成果報告,未出版
  104. 湯清二(1993)。我國學生生物細胞概念發展研究－迷思概念之晤談與概念圖。彰化師範大學學報，4，141-169。
  105. 湯清二(1991)。我國學生自然科概念發展與診斷教學之研究：生物細胞概念發展（一）。彰化師範大學學報，2，489-515。
  106. 湯清二(1990)。迷思概念與科學教學改進研究(I)「以遺傳學爲例」。彰化師範大學學報，1，367-397。
  107. 黃台珠(1990)。中學生遺傳相關概念錯誤類型的探討。科學教育月刊，133，34-53。
  108. 黃台珠(1993)。中學生遺傳學習的現況及問題。高雄師大學報，4，269-300。
  109. 黃台珠、鄭世暖、林明輝、蘇懿生、張學文、和趙大衛(1994)。國中生物遺傳教學的改進研究。高雄師大學報，5，113-135。
  110. 楊坤原、陳進利(1990)。中學生認知能力與遺傳學概念學習之相關研究。科學教育，1，63-75。
  111. 薛靜瑩(1998)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。台北市，國立台灣師範大學生物研究所。
被引用次数
  1. 黃怡銣(2016)。高職食品加工科學生對食品添加物迷思概念之探討。屏東科技大學技職教育研究所學位論文。2016。1-126。
print cancel