網路化檔案評量中學習者反思行為對學習成效之影響

Effects of Learners' Reflective Behaviors on Learning in Web-Based Portfolio Assessment

10.6173/CJSE.2010.1802.01

張基成(Chi-Cheng Chang)；陳政川(Cheng-Chuan Chen)

反思 ； 學習歷程檔案 ； 網路化檔案評量 ； Reflection ； Portfolio ； Web-based Portfolio Assessment

科學教育學刊

18卷2期（2010 / 04 / 01）

85 - 106

繁體中文

本研究探討網路化檔案評量中學習者反思行為（種類、表現）對學習成效的影響。以某國中二年級修習電腦應用課程的30名學生為實驗對象。以中文斷詞系統對反思內容進行斷詞，再依斷詞結果做分類。反思表現包括反思字數、瀏覽同儕反思次數、瀏覽同儕反思時間、反思成績。結果顯示網路化檔案評量過程中反思類型、反思字數對學習成效無顯著影響；瀏覽同儕反思次數對態度有顯著正面影響但不影響作品與測驗成績；瀏覽同儕反思時間對作品與態度有顯著正面影響但不影響測驗成績；反思成績對作品、測驗成績與態度皆有顯著正面影響。反思類型與四種表現在三種學習成效的效果量比較上，各有不同份量。整體而言，反思對態度的影響效果最大，作品居次，測驗最低。

This study aims to explore the effects of reflection behaviors (category and performance) on learning to use the Web-based Portfolio assessment. Experimental subjects were 30 second grade students in a Computer Application course at a senior high school. The Chinese Phrase Processing System was used to distinguish phrases of students' reflections. Based on the processing results, students' reflections were classified. Performance of reflection consists of the number of words in the reflection, amount of reading peer reflection, time of reading peer reflection, and grade of reflection. Research results show that the reflection category and number of words in reflection do not have a significant effect on learning performance (work, test and attitude). The number of reading in peer reflection shows a significantly positive effect on attitude, but do not show significant effects on the performances of work and test. Time of reading peer reflection shows significantly positive effects on work and attitude but do not show significant effects on test performance. Grade of reflection shows a significantly positive effect on work, test and attatude. Comparisons among the three effects of reflection category and four reflection performances on learning exhibits different effect sizes. As a whole, the effect on attitude is highest; and work is the second. Time on test was the lowest.

1. Wood, P. K. (2000). Summary of reflective judgment levels. Retrieved October 31, 2009, from http://web.missouri.edu/~wood/html/refl.judg.html
2. Tomkinson, B. (2002). A reflective approach to teaching and learning. Retrieved October 25, 2007, from http://ctls.concordia.ca/pdf/resources/reflective.approach.to.teaching.pdf
3. Barrett, H. C. (2004). Electronic portfolios as digital stories of deep learning. Retrieved October 31, 2009, from http://electronicportfolios.com/digistory/epstory.html
4. 蔡瑜方（2004）。中文斷詞與詞類標記系統簡介。2009 年11 月5 日，取自：http://dlm.ntu.edu.tw/dlm/93NDAP/professional/pro-930906-7/8B.pdf
5. 中央研究院資訊科學所（2007）。中文斷詞系統。2009 年11月5日，取自：http://ckipsvr.iis.sinica.edu.tw/。http://ckipsvr.iis.sinica.edu.tw/
6. Avrramidou, L.,Zembal-Saul, C.(2002).Exploring the influence of web-based portfolio development on learning to teach elementary science.Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching,New Orleans, Louisiana, USA:
7. Blatt, B.,Plack, M.,Maring, J.,Mintz, M.,Slmmens, S.(2007).Acting on reflection: The effect of reflection on students' clinical performance on a standardized patient examination.Journal of General Internal Medicine,22,49-54.
8. Cambridge, B. L.(Ed.),Kahn, S.(Ed.),Tompkins, D. P.(Ed.),Yancey, K. B.(Ed.)(2001).Electronic portfolios-Emerging practice in student, faculty, and institutional learning.Washington, DC:American Association for Higher Education Press.
9. Campbell, L.,Campbell, B.,Dickinson, D.(2002).Teaching and learning through multiple intelligences.Needham Heights, MA:Allyn & Bacon.
10. Chang, C.-C.(2008).Enhancing self-perceived effects using Web-based portfolio assessment.Computers in Human Behavior,24(3),1753-1771.
11. Chen, K. J.,Bai, M. H.(2000).Unknown word detection for Chinese by a corpus-based learning method.Computational Linguistics and Chinese Language Processing,3(1),27-44.
12. Chirema, K.(2007).The use of reflective journals in the promotion of reflection and learning in post-registration nursing students.Nurse Education Today,27(3),192-202.
13. Coombe, C.,Barlow, L.(2004).The reflective portfolio: Two case studies from the united arab emirates.Forum Online,42(1)
14. Costa, A. L.,Kallick, B.(2000).Assessing and reporting on habits of mind.Alexandria, VA:Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
15. Costello, J.(2002).Montreal, Canada,The Concordia University.
16. Davis, E. A.(2000).Scaffolding students' knowledge integration: Prompts for reflection in KIE.International Journal of Science Education,22(8),819-837.
17. Eppink, J. A.(2002).Iowa City, Iowa, USA,The University of Iowa.
18. Falls, J. A.(2001).Blacksburg, Virginia, USA,The Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.
19. Gama, C.(2004).Metacognition in interactive learning environments: The reflection assistant model.Lecture Notes in Computer Science,3220,668-677.
20. Gibson, H. L.,Bernhard, J.,Kropf, A.,Ramirez, M. A.,Van Strat, G.(2001).Enhancing the science literacy of preservice teachers through the use of reflective journals.Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching,St. Louis, Michigan, USA:
21. Grant, A.,Vermunt, J.,Kinnersley, P.,Houston, H.(2007).Exploring students' perceptions on the use of significant event analysis, as part assessment process in general practice, learning how to use reflection in learning.BMC Medical Education,7(1),1-8.
22. Irby, B. J.,Brown, G.(1999).A gendered dichotomy in written reflections in professional development portfolios.Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association,Montreal, Canada:
23. Lazear, D.(1999).Multiple intelligence approaches to assessment.Tucson, AZ:Zephyr Press.
24. Masui, C.,De Corte, E.(2005).Learning to reflect and to attribute constructively as basic components of self-regulated learning.British Journal of Educational Psychology,75(3),351-372.
25. McAlpine, D.(2000).Assessment and the gifted.Tall Poppies,25(1)
26. Morgan, B. M.(1999).Portfolios in a preservice teacher field-based program: Evaluation of a rubric for performance assessment.Education,119(3),416-426.
27. Morris, J.,Buckland, H.(2000).Electronic portfolios for learning and assessment.Annual Meeting of the Society for Information Technology and Teacher Education,San Diego, California, USA:
28. Murphy, J. I.(2004).Using focused reflection and articulation to promote clinical reasoning: An evidence-based teaching strategy.Nursing Education Perspectives,25(5),226-231.
29. Paris, S. G.,Ayres, L. R.(1994).Becoming reflective student and teachers.Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
30. Rees, C.,Shepherd, M.,Chamberlain, S.(2005).The utility of reflective portfolios as a method of assessing first medical students' personal and professional development.Reflective Practice,6(1),3-14.
31. Reid, L.(Ed.),Golub, J. N.(Ed.)(1999).Classroom practices in teachers of English.IL, Urbana:National Council of Teachers of English.
32. Saito, H.,Miwa, K.(2007).Construction of a learning environment supporting learners' reflection: A case of information seefing on the Web.Computers & Education,49(2),214-229.
33. Santos, M. G.(1997).Portfolio assessment and the role of learner reflection.English Teaching Forum online,35(2)
34. Sparks-Langer, G. M.,Simmons, J. M.,Pasch, M.,Colton, A.,Starko, A.(1990).Reflective pedagogical thinking: How can we promote it and measure it?.Journal of Teacher Education,41(5),23-32.
35. Van Manen, M.(1977).Linking ways of knowing with ways of being practical.Curriculum Inquiry,6,205-228.
36. Wickstrom, C. D.(1998).Student-teacher discourse in a college reading course using the portfolio process: The reflective portfolio conference-a conversation about learning.Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association,San Diego, California, USA:
37. Wielenga, D.,Kosters, J.,Ritzen, M.(1999).EFA's digital portfolio system.AAHE Assessment Conference,Denver, Colorado, USA:
38. Younes, M.(2004).Web-based student portfolio system at AAWC.2004 HCT Annual Conference Workshops,Arabian, Dubai:
39. Zembal-Saul, C.(2001).Web-based portfolios in a professional development school context.Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association,Seattle, Washington, USA:
40. 王妙里(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。台北市，台北市立教育大學課程與教學所。
41. 李啟讓(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。高雄市，國立高雄師範大學科教所。
42. 林秀娟(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。台南市，國立台南大學自然科教所。
43. 張基成、吳明芳(2009)。網路化檔案評量之信度與效度。2009 教育傳播暨科技學會學術研討會，台北市:
44. 張基成、童宜慧(2000)。網路化學習歷程檔案系統之建構與評鑑—一個電子化的真實性學習評量工具。遠距教育，13(14)，78-90。
45. 張麗麗(2000)。「怎樣的檔案才值得…？」談自主學習檔案的基本要素。屏縣教育季刊，4，5-12。
46. 鄭雅雯(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。台北市，國立台灣師範大學資教所。

1. 廖淑慧、張基成(2013)。數位化學習歷程檔案內中文寫作目標設定、自我反思與自我調整學習之關係：一個縱貫性質化研究。資訊傳播研究，4(1)，45-64。
2. 陸維元(2012)。完形理論應用於大學攝影教學之學習成效評估。藝術教育研究，24，73-109。
3. 薛亦倩、張基成(2013)。企業員工數位化生涯歷程檔案之構面與組成項目：使用層級分析法。教育傳播與科技研究，106，1-21。
4. 周保男(2014)。不同引導式學習策略對大學生電子化反思學習成效影響之個案研究。教育科學期刊，13(2)，35-53。
5. (2013)。大學生電子學習歷程檔案使用行為及其相關因素之研究：以某大學為例。教育研究月刊，234，58-72。