题名

中學階段氣候變遷議題教學之回顧：教什麼？如何教？

并列篇名

A Review of Climate Change Issue Teaching in Secondary Education-What and How

DOI

10.6173/CJSE.201812_26(4).0003

作者

游小旻(Hsiao-Min Yu)；張文華(Wen-Hua Chang)

关键词

中等教育 ； 全球暖化 ； 氣候變遷 ； Secondary Education ； Global Warming ； Climate Change

期刊名称

科學教育學刊

卷期/出版年月

26卷4期（2018 / 12 / 01）

页次

333 - 352

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

氣候變遷為一跨學科的當代社會性科學議題，由於它在時間與空間尺度上的抽象性與複雜性，使其適合作為發展學生科學素養的題材。近年來，已有愈來愈多的國家將氣候變遷或相關主題納入課程；臺灣的新版課程綱要更將氣候變遷之影響與調適訂為自然領域跨科概念的次主題之一。儘管此議題具有重要性與急迫性，但在教學實踐上卻仍缺乏清晰的指引。無論是普羅大眾抑或在校學生，甚至學校教師都可能對此議題相關內容存有迷思概念。而氣候變遷議題教學不應僅止於理解，更需要轉化為行動。由於覺察是產生行動的起點，本研究欲瞭解何種教學介入與課程脈絡能促使學生覺察氣候變遷，為此而搜尋美國教育部教育資源資訊中心所提供之國家級教育學書目資料庫（Education Resources Information Center ［ERIC］），分析49篇中學階段以氣候變遷為教學主題之實徵研究。本文呈現中學階段氣候變遷議題教學的研究趨勢，並由分析結果提出教學介入與課程脈絡的建議：採用諸如制定行動計畫、專題研究或實地考察等讓學生得以直接經驗氣候變遷的教學介入，有助於他們覺察氣候變遷；相較於以地區性或全球性氣候變遷為課程脈絡者，課程脈絡含有與學生關係較為密切的個人選擇，能同時提升學生對氣候變遷的認識與覺察。而如何將科學本質的培育納入氣候變遷教育的規劃，則是未來科學教育者可以再繼續努力的方向。
英文摘要

Climate change is an interdisciplinary and socio-scientific contemporary issue. Due to the complexity, abstraction, and criticality of climate change, it is a good theme for science researchers to develop students' scientific literacy. Over the last few years, more and more countries have brought climate change or related topics into curriculum frameworks. In Taiwan, climate change is subsumed a subtopic of interdisciplinary concept in science curriculum framework. Although it is an important issue, there is still no clear teaching guideline. Laypeople, students, and teachers may hold misconception of this issue. However, teaching climate change should be not only about facts and understanding, but also about behavior. Because awareness is the first step of behavior, we want to clarify what kinds of instructions and contexts could promote awareness. For this purpose, we searched Education Resources Information Center (ERIC) database and reviewed 49 related researches on teaching climate change in secondary education. Here, we showed the research trends of teaching climate change in secondary education, and brought a suggestion of teaching strategies and contexts. We found, firstly, studies used direct experiences, such as carrying out action plan, project-based learning, participating in a field trip, as teaching approaches that could not only facilitate understanding about climate change but also enable students to aware of climate change. Furthermore, professional consulting, role-playing, and demonstration may promote comprehension as well as perception. Secondly, the association between selected contexts for learning climate change and student learning outcomes indicated that comparing to local or global contexts, using personal contexts, such as transportation, home energy and appliance, food, or personal purchases, may enhance both understanding and awareness. Finally, we suggest that science educators could pay more attention to cultivate students' adequate understanding of the nature of science in planning climate change education.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. Ajaps, S.,McLellan, R.(2015)."We don't know enough": Environmental education and pro-environmental behaviour perceptions.Cogent Education,2,1124490.
  2. Albe, V.,Gombert, M.-J.(2012).Students' communication, argumentation and knowledge in a citizens' conference on global warming.Cultural Studies of Science Education,7,659-681.
  3. Alberta Education. (2002). Health and life skills guide to implementation: Kindergarten to grade 9. Retrieved October 23, 2018, from https://education.alberta.ca/media/1477143/healthgi.pdf
  4. Ándres Gómez, S.,Gaymard, S.(2014).The perception of school climate in two secondary schools during the implementation of a peer support programme.Electronic Journal of Research in Educational Psychology,12(2),509-540.
  5. Ardoin, N. M.,Bowers, A. W.,Roth, N. W.,Holthuis, N.(2018).Environmental education and K-12 student outcomes: A review and analysis of research.The Journal of Environmental Education,49(1),1-17.
  6. Arya, D. J.,Parker, J. K.(2015).Dialogic action in climate change discussions: An international study of high school students in China, New Zealand, Norway and the United States.Dialogic Pedagogy: An International Online Journal,3,A131-A157.
  7. Arya, D.,Maul, A.(2016).The building of knowledge, language, and decision-making about climate change science: A cross-national program for secondary students.International Journal of Science Education,38(6),885-904.
  8. Atabey, N.,Topcu, M. S.(2017).The development of a socioscientific issues-based curriculum unit for middle school students: Global warming issue.International Journal of Education in Mathematics, Science and Technology,5(3),153-170.
  9. Ballouard, J.-M.,Provost, G.,Barré, D.,Bonnet, X.(2012).Influence of a field trip on the attitude of schoolchildren toward unpopular organisms: An experience with snakes.Journal of Herpetology,46(3),423-428.
  10. Besson, U.,De Ambrosis, A.(2014).Teaching energy concepts by working on themes of cultural and environmental value.Science & Education,23(6),1309-1338.
  11. Bloom, B. S.(1956).Taxonomy of educational objectives: The classification of educational goals.Harlow, UK:Longman Group.
  12. Bodzin, A. M.,Fu, Q.(2014).The effectiveness of the geospatial curriculum approach on urban middle-level students' climate change understandings.Journal of Science Education and Technology,23(4),575-590.
  13. Bofferding, L.,Kloser, M.(2015).Middle and high school students' conceptions of climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies.Environmental Education Research,21(2),275-294.
  14. Boon, H. J.(2010).Climate change? Who knows? A comparison of secondary students and pre-service teachers.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,35(1),104-120.
  15. Breslyn, W.,McGinnis, J. R.,McDonald, R. C.,Hestness, E.(2016).Developing a learning progression for sea level rise, a major impact of climate change.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,53(10),1471-1499.
  16. Chang, C.-H.,Pascua, L.(2016).Singapore students' misconceptions of climate change.International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education,25(1),84-96.
  17. Chang, C.-H.,Pascua, L.(2015)."The hole in the sky causes global warming": A case study of secondary school students' climate change alternative conceptions.Review of International Geographical Education Online,5(3),316-331.
  18. Chang, C.-H.,Pascua, L.,Ess, F.(2018).Closing the "hole in the sky": The use of refutation- oriented instruction to correct students' climate change misconceptions.Journal of Geography,117(1),3-16.
  19. Chattuchai, S.,Singseewo, A.,Suksringarm, P.(2015).Development of knowledge, awareness, global warming decreasing behavior and critical thinking of grade 11 students using the four noble truths method with meta-cognitive techniques.Educational Research and Reviews,10(16),2268-2275.
  20. Colaianne, B.(2015).Global warning: Project-based science inspired by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.The Science Teacher,82(1),37-42.
  21. Core Writing Team(Ed.),Pachauri, R. K.(Ed.),Meyer, L. A.(Ed.)(2014).Climate change 2014: Synthesis report.Geneva, Switzerland:Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
  22. Dalelo, A.(2011).Global climate change in geography curricula for Ethiopian secondary and preparatory schools.International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education,20(3),227-246.
  23. Dawson, V.(2015).Western Australian high school students' understandings about the socio-scientific issue of climate change.International Journal of Science Education,37(7),1024-1043.
  24. Dawson, V.,Carson, K.(2017).Using climate change scenarios to assess high school students' argumentation skills.Research in Science & Technological Education,35(1),1-16.
  25. Dawson, V.,Carson, K.(2013).Australian secondary school students' understanding of climate change.Teaching Science,59(3),9-14.
  26. Dijkstra, E.,Goedhart, M.(2011).Evaluation of authentic science projects on climate change in secondary schools: A focus on gender differences.Research in Science & Technological Education,29(2),131-146.
  27. Duerden, M. D.,Witt, P. A.(2010).The impact of direct and indirect experiences on the development of environmental knowledge, attitudes, and behavior.Journal of Environmental Psychology,30(4),379-392.
  28. Dunkley, R. A.(2016).Learning at eco-attractions: Exploring the bifurcation of nature and culture through experiential environmental education.The Journal of Environmental Education,47(3),213-221.
  29. Edstrand, E.(2016).Making the invisible visible: How students make use of carbon footprint calculator in environmental education.Learning, Media and Technology,41(2),416-436.
  30. Eisenack, K.(2013).A climate change board game for interdisciplinary communication and education.Simulation & Gaming,44(2-3),328-348.
  31. Fančovičová, J.,Prokop, P.(2011).Plants have a chance: Outdoor educational programmes alter students' knowledge and attitudes towards plants.Environmental Education Research,17(4),537-551.
  32. Farmer, J.,Knapp, D.,Benton, G. M.(2007).An elementary school environmental education field trip: Long-term effects on ecological and environmental knowledge and attitude development.The Journal of Environmental Education,38(3),33-42.
  33. Feierabend, T.,Jokmin, S.,Eilks, I.(2011).Chemistry teachers' views on teaching "climate change"-An interview case study from research-oriented learning in teacher education.Chemistry Education Research and Practice,12(1),85-91.
  34. Field‚C. B.(Ed.),Barros‚V.(Ed.),Stocker‚T. F.(Ed.),Qin‚D.(Ed.),Dokken‚D. J.(Ed.),Ebi‚K. L.(Ed.)(2012).Managing the risks of extreme events and disasters to advance climate change adaptation.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  35. Frick, J.,Kaiser, F. G.,Wilson, M.(2004).Environmental knowledge and conservation behavior: Exploring prevalence and structure in a representative sample.Personality and Individual Differences,37(8),1597-1613.
  36. Gino, F.,Argote, L.,Miron-Spektor, E.,Todorova, G.(2010).First, get your feet wet: The effects of learning from direct and indirect experience on team creativity.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,111(2),102-115.
  37. Gold, A. U.,Kirk, K.,Morrison, D.,Lynds, S.,Sullivan, S. B.,Grachev, A.(2015).Arctic climate connections curriculum: A model for bringing authentic data into the classroom.Journal of Geoscience Education,63(3),185-197.
  38. Gold, A. U.,Oonk, D. J.,Smith, L.,Boykoff, M. T.,Osnes, B.,Sullivan, S. B.(2015).Lens on climate change: Making climate meaningful through student-produced videos.Journal of Geography,114(6),235-246.
  39. Gough, A.(2002).Mutualism: A different agenda for environmental and science education.International Journal of Science Education,24(11),1201-1215.
  40. Gough, N.(2002).Thinking/acting locally/globally: Western science and environmental education in a global knowledge economy.International Journal of Science Education,24(11),1217-1237.
  41. Herman, B. C.,Feldman, A.,Vernaza-Hernandez, V.(2017).Florida and Puerto Rico secondary science teachers' knowledge and teaching of climate change science.International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education,15(3),451-471.
  42. Iordanou, K.,Constantinou, C. P.(2015).Supporting use of evidence in argumentation through practice in argumentation and reflection in the context of SOCRATES learning environment.Science Education,99(2),282-311.
  43. Jeong, J.,Kim, H.,Chae, D. H.,Kim, E.(2014).The effect of a case-based reasoning instructional model on Korean high school students' awareness in climate change unit.Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education,10(5),427-435.
  44. Jeong, S.,Kim, H.(2015).The effect of a climate change monitoring program on students' knowledge and perceptions of STEAM education in Korea.Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education,11(6),1321-1338.
  45. Kahan, D. M.,Jenkins-Smith, H.,Braman, D.(2011).Cultural cognition of scientific consensus.Journal of Risk Research,14(2),147-174.
  46. Karahan, E.,Roehrig, G.(2016).Use of web 2.0 technologies to enhance learning experiences in alternative school settings.International Journal of Education in Mathematics, Science and Technology,4(4),272-283.
  47. Karpudewan, M.,Mohd Ali Khan, N. S.(2017).Experiential-based climate change education: Fostering students' knowledge and motivation towards the environment.International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education,26(3),207-222.
  48. Karpudewan, M.,Roth, W.-M.,Chandrakesan, K.(2015).Remediating misconception on climate change among secondary school students in Malaysia.Environmental Education Research,21(4),631-648.
  49. Kern, C. L.,Crippen, K. J.,Skaza, H.(2014).The fidelity and usability of 5-DIE: A design study of enacted cyberlearning.Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science Teaching,33(1),49-72.
  50. Kinslow, A.,Sadler, T.,Friedrichsen, P.,Zangori, L.,Peel, A.,Graham, K.(2017).From global to local: Connecting global climate change to a local ecosystem using a socioscientific issue approach.The Science Teacher,84(7),39-46.
  51. Klosterman, M. L.,Sadler, T. D.(2010).Multi-level assessment of scientific content knowledge gains associated with socioscientific issues-based instruction.International Journal of Science Education,32(8),1017-1043.
  52. Korsager, M.,Slotta, J. D.(2015).International peer collaboration to learn about global climate changes.International Journal of Environmental and Science Education,10(5),717-736.
  53. Koutalidi, S.,Psallidasb, V.,Scoullos, M.(2016).Biogeochemical cycles for combining chemical knowledge and ESD issues in Greek secondary schools part II: Assessing the impact of the intervention.Chemistry Education Research and Practice,17(1),24-35.
  54. Liarakou, G.,Athanasiadis, I.,Gavrilakis, C.(2011).What Greek secondary school students believe about climate change?.International Journal of Environmental and Science Education,6(1),79-98.
  55. Lin, J.(2017).Chinese grade eight students' understanding about the concept of global warming.Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education,13(5),1313-1330.
  56. Linn, M. C.,Eylon, B.-S.,Rafferty, A.,Vitale, J. M.(2015).Designing instruction to improve lifelong inquiry learning.Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education,11(2),217-225.
  57. Lombardi, D.,Brandt, C. B.,Bickel, E. S.,Burg, C.(2016).Students' evaluations about climate change.International Journal of Science Education,38(8),1392-1414.
  58. McGinnis, J. R.,McDonald, C.,Hestness, E.,Breslyn, W.(2016).An investigation of science educators' views of roles and responsibilities for climate change education.Science Education International,27(2),179-192.
  59. McNeal, K. S.,Libarkin, J. C.,Ledley, T. S.,Bardar, E.,Haddad, N.,Ellins, K.(2014).The role of research in online curriculum development: The case of EarthLabs climate change and earth system modules.Journal of Geoscience Education,62(4),560-577.
  60. McNeal, P.,Petcovic, H.,Reeves, P.(2017).What is motivating middle-school science teachers to teach climate change?.International Journal of Science Education,39(8),1069-1088.
  61. McNeill, K. L.,Vaughn, M. H.(2012).Urban high school students' critical science agency: Conceptual understandings and environmental actions around climate change.Research in Science Education,42(2),373-399.
  62. Monroe, M. C.,Hall, S.,Li, C. J.(2016).Can climate change enhance biology lessons? A quasi-experiment.Applied Environmental Education & Communication,15(2),125-137.
  63. Niebert, K.,Gropengießer, H.(2014).Understanding the greenhouse effect by embodiment- Analysing and using students' and scientists' conceptual resources.International Journal of Science Education,36(2),277-303.
  64. Nielsen, W. S.,Nashon, S.,Anderson, D.(2009).Metacognitive engagement during field-trip experiences: A case study of students in an amusement park physics program.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,46(3),265-288.
  65. Nussbaum, E. M.,Owens, M. C.,Sinatra, G. M.,Rehmat, A. P.,Cordova, J. R.,Ahmad, S.(2015).Losing the Lake: Simulations to promote gains in student knowledge and interest about climate change.International Journal of Environmental & Science Education,10(6),789-811.
  66. Orey, M.(2010).Emerging perspectives on learning, teaching, and technology.
  67. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development(2018).PISA for development assessment and analytical framework: Reading, mathematics and science.Paris, French:OECD.
  68. Pallant, A.,Lee, H.-S.(2015).Constructing scientific arguments using evidence from dynamic computational climate models.Journal of Science Education and Technology,24(2-3),378-395.
  69. Petrina, S.(Ed.)(2007).Advanced teaching methods for the technology classroom.Hershey, PA:IGI Global.
  70. Pongsophon, P.,Yutakom, N.,Boujaoude, S. B.(2010).Promotion of scientific literacy on global warming by process drama.Asia-Pacific Forum on Science Learning and Teaching,11(1),1-38.
  71. Pruneau, D.,Gravel, H.,Bourque, W.,Langis, J.(2003).Experimentation with a socio-constructivist process for climate change education.Environmental Education Research,9(4),429-446.
  72. Punter, P.,Ochando-Pardo, M.,Garcia, J.(2011).Spanish secondary school students' notions on the causes and consequences of climate change.International Journal of Science Education,33(3),447-464.
  73. Resnick, L. B.(1987).Education and learning to think.Washington, DC:National Academy Press.
  74. Roczen, N.,Kaiser, F. G.,Bogner, F. X.,Wilson, M.(2014).A competence model for environmental education.Environment and Behavior,46(8),972-992.
  75. Roychoudhury, A.,Shepardson, D. P.,Hirsch, A.,Niyogi, D.,Mehta, J.,Top, S.(2017).The need to introduce system thinking in teaching climate change.Science Educator,25(2),73-81.
  76. Schönfelder, M. L.,Bogner, F. X.(2017).Two ways of acquiring environmental knowledge: By encountering living animals at a beehive and by observing bees via digital tools.International Journal of Science Education,39(6),723-741.
  77. Schubert, J. C.(2015).Causes, processes and consequences of "desertification": Results of a qualitative study about the conceptions of 12- and 13-year-old students in Germany.International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education,24(2),148-166.
  78. Sellmann, D.,Bogner, F. X.(2013).Effects of a 1-day environmental education intervention on environmental attitudes and connectedness with nature.European Journal of Psychology of Education,28(3),1077-1086.
  79. Sellmann, D.,Liefländer, A. K.,Bogner, F. X.(2015).Concept maps in the classroom: A new approach to reveal students' conceptual change.The Journal of Educational Research,108(3),250-257.
  80. Shallcross, D. E.,Harrison, T. G.(2007).Climate change made simple.Physics Education,42(6),592-597.
  81. Stapleton, S. R.(2015).Environmental identity development through social interactions, action, and recognition.The Journal of Environmental Education,46(2),94-113.
  82. Stepath, C. M.(2006).Reefs and learning: Education evaluation techniques.National Marine Education Association Conference,New York:
  83. Sternäng, L.,Lundholm, C.(2012).Climate change and costs: Investigating students' reasoning on nature and economic development.Environmental Education Research,18(3),417-436.
  84. Strømsø, H. I.,Bråten, I.(2009).Beliefs about knowledge and knowing and multiple-text comprehension among upper secondary students.Educational Psychology,29(4),425-445.
  85. Sunassee, S. N.,Young, R. M.,Sewry, J. D.,Harrison, T. G.,Shallcross, D. E.(2012).Creating climate change awareness in South African schools through practical chemistry demonstrations.Acta Didactica Napocensia,5(4),31-48.
  86. Tasquier, G.,Levrini, O.,Dillon, J.(2016).Exploring students' epistemological knowledge of models and modelling in science: Results from a teaching/learning experience on climate change.International Journal of Science Education,38(4),539-563.
  87. Tasquier, G.,Pongiglione, F.(2017).The influence of causal knowledge on the willingness to change attitude towards climate change: Results from an empirical study.International Journal of Science Education,39(13),1846-1868.
  88. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization,United Nations Environment Programme(2011).Climate change starters guide book: An issues guide for education planners and practitioners.Paris, French:United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization..
  89. Vitale, J. M.,McBride, E.,Linn M. C.(2016).Distinguishing complex ideas about climate change: Knowledge integration vs. specific guidance.International Journal of Science Education,38(9),1548-1569.
  90. Wang, H.-Y.,Huang, I.,Hwang, G.-J.(2016).Effects of a question prompt-based concept mapping approach on students' learning achievements, attitudes and 5C competences in project-based computer course activities.Educational Technology & Society,19(3),351-364.
  91. Winn, W.,Stahr, F.,Sarason, C.,Fruland, R.,Oppenheimer, P.,Lee, Y.-L.(2006).Learning oceanography from a computer simulation compared with direct experience at sea.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,43(1),25-42.
  92. Zangori, L.,Peel, A.,Kinslow, A.,Friedrichsen, P.,Sadler, T. D.(2017).Student development of model-based reasoning about carbon cycling and climate change in a socio-scientific issues unit.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,54(10),1249-1273.
  93. Zhu, M.,Lee, H.-S.,Wang, T.,Liu, O. L.,Belur, V.,Pallant, A.(2017).Investigating the impact of automated feedback on students' scientific argumentation.International Journal of Science Education,39(12),1648-1668.
  94. 林慈薇(2008)。淺談資優學生的高層思考與教學。雲嘉特教，8，33-41。
  95. 國家教育研究院(2016年2月4日)。十二年國民基本教育課程綱要─國民中小學暨普通型高級中等學校：自然科學領域草案(更新附錄二)。查詢日期：2018年5月1日，檢自https://www.naer.edu.tw/ezfiles/0/1000/attach/90/pta_16506_654628_59074.pdf
被引用次数
  1. 曾鈺琪(2020)。高中教師氣候變遷教學經驗及合理性覺知對教學興趣之影響：兼論自我效能之中介效果。環境教育研究，16(2)，47-82。
print cancel