探討結合虛擬實境與擴增實境細胞分裂學習系統對學生概念理解與科學學習動機的影響

Effects of a Cell Division Learning System Combining Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality on Students' Conceptual Understanding and Science Learning Motivation

10.6173/CJSE.202303_31(1).0001

邱文彬(Wen-Pin Chiu)；唐文華(Wernhuar Tarng)；李易儒(Yih-Ru Lee)；王姿陵(Tzu-Ling Wang)

科學學習動機 ； 細胞的分裂 ； 虛擬實境 ； 概念理解 ； 擴增實境 ； Science Learning Motivation ； Cell Division ； Virtual Reality ； Conceptual Understanding ； Augmented Reality

科學教育學刊

31卷1期（2023 / 03 / 01）

1 - 25

繁體中文;英文

虛擬實境（VR）和擴增實境（AR）技術讓學習者可以接觸到新的環境和增強體驗。本研究的目的在探討結合VR和AR技術的「細胞分裂學習系統」對國中學生概念理解和學習動機的影響。此細胞分裂學習系統是依據「細胞的分裂」單元的個別概念不同特性結合VR和AR的相應優勢發展而成。此學習系統包含三個主題：「遺傳物質的介紹」、「同源染色體的介紹」和「細胞的分裂方式」。研究對象來自桃園市一所國中七年級四個班級，其中二班為實驗組49人，進行細胞分裂學習系統教學，另二班為對照組51人，進行一般教學。本研究採準實驗前後測設計，二組教學時間皆為三節課，每節課45分鐘，共135分鐘，實驗教學歷經二週。測驗工具為「細胞的分裂二階段診斷測驗」和「科學學習動機量表」。研究結果顯示細胞分裂學習系統教學比一般教學更能促進學生在「細胞的分裂」整個單元概念理解和個別概念理解，例如：「細胞分裂的過程與結果」、「同源染色體的定義」、「基因、DNA與染色體」、「雙套染色體的定義」和「減數分裂的過程與結果」。研究結果也顯示細胞分裂學習系統教學對提升學生科學學習動機顯著優於一般教學。本研究的啟示是當概念的特性與AR或VR的獨特優勢相匹配時，學習系統可以有效提高學習效果。

Virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) technologies expose learners to new environments and enhanced experiences. This study aimed to examine the effects of the cell division learning system combined with VR and AR technologies on junior high school students' conceptual understanding and learning motivation. This cell division learning system is developed based on the different characteristics of the individual concepts of the cell division unit combined with the corresponding advantages of VR and AR. It includes three topics: genetic materials, homologous chromosomes, and cell division. The participants came from four classes of seventh grade in a junior high school in Taoyuan City. Two of the classes were the experimental group with 49 students, who adopted the cell division learning system, and the other two classes were the control group, with a total of 51 students, who adopted general teaching. This study adopted a quasi-experimental pretest-posttest design. The teaching time of the two groups was three classes, each class was 45 minutes, a total of 135 minutes, and the experimental teaching lasted for two weeks. The research instruments included a two-tier cell division diagnosis test and the science learning motivation scale. The results showed that students who adopted the teaching of cell division learning system can promote students' understanding of the whole unit and individual concepts of cell division better than those who adopted general teaching. The results also showed that the teaching of the cell division learning system is significantly better than the general teaching in promoting students' science learning motivation. The implication of this study is that when the characteristics of the concept match the unique advantages of AR or VR, the learning system can effectively improve the learning effect.

1. 周惠柔, H.-J.,林弘昌, H.-C.(2018)。應用虛擬實境技術與6E教學模式於高中生活科技課程之結構教學單元設計。科技與人力教育季刊，4(3)，67-89。
   連結：
2. 許一珍, Y.-C.(2018)。學童使用擴增實境之學習動機與學習成效研究—以八大行星學習為例。國際數位媒體設計學刊，10(1)，32-38。
   連結：
3. 楊坤原, K.-Y.,張賴妙理, M.-L.(2004)。遺傳學迷思概念之文獻探討及其在教學上的啓示。科學教育學刊，12(3)，365-398。
   連結：
4. 楊坤原, K.-Y.,張賴妙理, M.-L.(2004)。發展和應用二段式診斷工具來偵測國中一年級學生之遺傳學另有概念。科學教育學刊，12(1)，107-131。
   連結：
5. 謝旻儕, M.-C.,林語瑄, Y.-H.(2017)。虛擬實境與擴增實境在醫護實務與教育之應用。護理雜誌，64(6)，12-18。
   連結：
6. Amiati, A.(2019).The effect of virtual reality laboratory on conceptual understanding in electrolytes and non-electrolytes.Journal of Education and Learning (EduLearn),13(3),362-369.
7. Ausburn, L. J.,Ausburn, F. B.(2004).Desktop virtual reality: A powerful new technology for teaching and research in industrial teacher education.Journal of Industrial Teacher Education,41(4),1-16.
8. Azuma, R. T.(1997).A survey of augmented reality.Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments,6(4),355-385.
9. Bahar, M.(2003).Misconceptions in biology education and conceptual change strategies.Educational Sciences: Theory & Practice,3(1),55-64.
10. Banet, E.,Ayuso, E.(2000).Teaching genetics at secondary school: A strategy for teaching about the location of inheritance information.Science Education,84(3),313-351.
11. Barak, M.,Ashkar, T.,Dori, Y. J.(2011).Learning science via animated movies: Its effect on students’ thinking and motivation.Computers & Education,56(3),839-846.
12. Bimber, O.,Raskar, R.(2005).Spatial augmented reality: Merging real and virtual worlds.A K Peters/CRC.
13. Burdea, G. C.,Coiffet, P.(2003).Virtual reality technology.John Wiley & Sons.
14. Cai, S.,Chiang, F.-K.,Sun, Y.,Lin, C.,Lee, J. J.(2017).Applications of augmented reality-based natural interactive learning in magnetic field instruction.Interactive Learning Environments,25(6),778-791.
15. Chen, S.-Y.,Liu, S.-Y.(2020).Using augmented reality to experiment with elements in a chemistry course.Computers in Human Behavior,111,106418.
16. Chi, M. T. H.(2005).Commonsense conceptions of emergent processes: Why some misconceptions are robust.Journal of the Learning Sciences,14(2),161-199.
17. Chiang, T. H. C.,Yang, S. J. H.,Hwang, G.-J.(2014).An augmented reality-based mobile learning system to improve students’ learning achievements and motivations in natural science inquiry activities.Educational Technology & Society,17(4),352-365.
18. Cohen, J.(1988).Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences.Routledge.
19. Cooper, A.,Poinar, H. N.(2000).Ancient DNA: Do it right or not at all.Science,289(5482),1139.
20. Dalgarno, B.,Hedberg, J.,Harper, B.(2002).The contribution of 3D environments to conceptual understanding.Winds of change in the sea of learning: Proceedings of the 19th annual conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education
21. Dunleavy, M.,Dede, C.,Mitchell, R.(2009).Affordances and limitations of immersive participatory augmented reality simulations for teaching and learning.Journal of Science Education and Technology,18(1),7-22.
22. El Sayed, N. A. M.,Zayed, H. H.,Sharawy, M. I.(2010).ARSC: Augmented reality student card.2010 International Computer Engineering Conference (ICENCO)
23. Field, A.(2009).Discovering statistics using SPSS.Sage.
24. Fisher, K. M.,Wandersee, J. H.,Moody, D. E.(2002).Mapping biology knowledge.Springer.
25. George, D.,Mallery, P.(2003).SPSS for Windows step by step: A simple guide and reference, 11.0 update.Allyn & Bacon.
26. Ibáñez, M.-B.,Di-Serio, Á.,Villarán-Molina, D.,Delgado-Kloos, C.(2015).Augmented reality-based simulators as discovery learning tools: An empirical study.IEEE Transactions on Education,58(3),208-213.
27. Jacobson, R.(1993).After the “virtual reality” gold rush: The virtual worlds paradigm.Computers & Graphics,17(6),695-698.
28. Kancherla, A. R.,Rolland, J. P.,Wright, D. L.,Burdea, G.(1995).A novel virtual reality tool for teaching dynamic 3D anatomy.Computer vision, virtual reality, and robotics in medicine
29. Kock, N.(2006).Book review: Virtual reality technology.International Journal of e-Collaboration,2(1),61-64.
30. Lazarowitz, R.,Penso, S.(1992).High school students’ difficulties in learning biology concepts.Journal of Biological Education,26(3),215-223.
31. Lewis, J.,Wood-Robinson, C.(2000).Genes, chromosomes, cell division and inheritance—Do students see any relationship?.International Journal of Science Education,22(2),177-195.
32. Limniou, M.,Roberts, D.,Papadopoulos, N.(2008).Full immersive virtual environment CAVETM in chemistry education.Computers & Education,51(2),584-593.
33. Makransky, G.,Petersen, G. B.(2019).Investigating the process of learning with desktop virtual reality: A structural equation modeling approach.Computers & Education,134,15-30.
34. Milgram, P.,Kishino, F.(1994).A taxonomy of mixed reality visual displays.IEICE Transactions on Information and Systems,E77-D(12),1321-1329.
35. Mintz, R.,Litvak, S.,Yair, Y.(2001).3D-virtual reality in science education: An implication for astronomy teaching.Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science Teaching,20(3),293-305.
36. Nasharuddin, N. A.,Khalid, N. A.,Hussin, M.(2021).InCell VR: A virtual reality-based application on human cell division for mobile learning.International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies,15(2),55-71.
37. Novak, J. D.,Gowin, D. B.(1988).Aprendiendo a aprender.Martínez roca.
38. Ozcan, T.,Yildirim, O.,Ozgur, S.(2012).Determining of the university freshmen students’ misconceptions and alternative conceptions about mitosis and meiosis.Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences,46,3677-3680.
39. Özmen, H.(2011).Effect of animation enhanced conceptual change texts on 6th grade students’ understanding of the particulate nature of matter and transformation during phase changes.Computers & Education,57(1),1114-1126.
40. Öztap, H.,Özay, E.,Öztap, F.(2003).Teaching cell division to secondary school students: An investigation of difficulties experienced by Turkish teachers.Journal of Biological Education,38(1),13-15.
41. Papagiannakis, G.,Singh, G.,Magnenat-Thalmann, N.(2008).A survey of mobile and wireless technologies for augmented reality systems.Computer Animation and Virtual Worlds,19(1),3-22.
42. Parong, J.,Mayer, R. E.(2018).Learning science in immersive virtual reality.Journal of Educational Psychology,110(6),785-797.
43. Rojas-Sola, J. I.,Aguilera-García, Á.(2018).Virtual and augmented reality: Applications for the learning of technical historical heritage.Computer Applications in Engineering Education,26(5),1725-1733.
44. Schneps, M. H.,Ruel, J.,Sonnert, G.,Dussault, M.,Griffin, M.,Sadler, P. M.(2014).Conceptualizing astronomical scale: Virtual simulations on handheld tablet computers reverse misconceptions.Computers & Education,70,269-280.
45. Schnotz, W.,Preuß, A.(1999).7 Task-dependent construction of mental models as a basis for conceptual change.Advances in Psychology,128,131-167.
46. Sesli, E.,Kara, Y.(2012).Development and application of a two-tier multiple-choice diagnostic test for high school students’ understanding of cell division and reproduction.Journal of Biological Education,46(4),214-225.
47. Squire, K.,Barnett, M.,Grant, J. M.,Higginbotham, T.(2004).Electromagnetism supercharged! Learning physics with digital simulation games.International Conference of the Learning Sciences 2004: Embracing diversity in the learning sciences
48. Stull, A. T.,Hegarty, M.(2015).Learning with concrete and virtual manipulative models: Are models scaffolds or crutches?.37th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society (CogSci 2015)
49. Tarng, W.,Tseng, Y.-C.,Ou, K.-L.(2022).Application of augmented reality for learning material structures and chemical equilibrium in high school chemistry.Systems,10(5),141.
50. Wang, T.-L.,Tseng, Y.-K.(2018).The comparative effectiveness of physical, virtual, and virtual-physical manipulatives on third-grade students’ science achievement and conceptual understanding of evaporation and condensation.International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education,16(2),203-219.
51. Wexelblat, A.(1993).The reality of cooperation: Virtual reality and CSCW.Virtual reality: Applications and explorations
52. Wojciechowski, R.,Cellary, W.(2013).Evaluation of learners’ attitude toward learning in ARIES augmented reality environments.Computers & Education,68,570-585.
53. Yoon, S.,Anderson, E.,Lin, J.,Elinich, K.(2017).How augmented reality enables conceptual understanding of challenging science content.Educational Technology & Society,20(1),156-168.
54. 古芝如, Z.-R.(2013)。國立新竹教育大學=National Hsinchu University of Education。
55. 吳文龍, W.-L.,唐尉天, W.-T.,徐俊龍, C.-L.(2018)。擴增實境(Augmented Reality)於國中小微觀粒子教學之應用與展望。科學教育月刊，408，20-26。
56. 吳延慶, Y.-C.(2008)。國立臺北教育大學=National Taipei University of Education。
57. 邱美虹, M.-H.(2000)。概念改變研究的省思與啟示。科學教育學刊，8(1)，1-34。
58. 康軒文教事業=Kang Hsuan Educational Publishing(2021).自然科學國民中學第二冊備課用書.作者=Author.
59. 楊凱悌, K.-T.,王子華, T.-H.,邱美虹, M.-H.(2011)。生物學細胞分裂主題之資訊融入教學設計原則。科學教育月刊，342，9-19。