領域化與網絡化的多重張力──「地方」概念的理論性探討

Multiple Tensions in Territorialization and Networking: A Theoretical Enquiry of the 'Place' Concept

10.30008/CD.201509_(23).0002

王志弘(Chih-Hung Wang)

地方 ； 空間 ； 領域化 ； 網絡化 ； 地方政治 ； 地方存有論 ； place ； space ； territorialization ； networking ； politics of place ； ontology of place

城市與設計學報

23期（2015 / 09 / 01）

71 - 100

繁體中文

本文主張，晚近注重連結和網絡化的地方概念，必須以領域化向度來補充，不能視後者為保守落伍。地方的概念化應考慮政治與存有論，但地方的保守或進步性質取決於社會鬥爭及其價值立場，而非政治實作和存有論上的必然。本文首先整理地方的概念化，說明各學派對於區位、場所與意義����價值的不同偏重；地方與社會辯證觀的空間理論源流；以及社會變遷趨勢下，空間和地方的二元對照式界定和政治爭論。其次，本文借道哈維和瑪西的爭論，指出瑪西雖以進步的地方概念指責哈維過度擔憂地方政治的保守性，但相較於瑪西偏重多重性、關係性與過程的存有論，哈維的絕對、相對和關係空間並存辯證觀，卻有助於提醒地方領域化的必要。最後，作者挪用索雅的「第三空間」和兩兼其外觀點，主張地方概念應該兼納領域化和網絡化過程又超越之，展現為絕對與相對、物與非物、本質與建構、圈限與連結、固著與流動、特殊與普遍、局部與全局等多重張力的兩兼其外思考。

This article argues that the conceptualization of place in recent years, which emphasizes articulation and networking, should reconsider the dimension of territorialization and not regard it as conservative or regressive. The conceptualization of place must take ontology and politics into consideration, but the progressiveness or conservativeness of place concept is not intrinsic to its ontology. Firstly, the article gives an overview of the conceptualization of place, explaining theoretical development, the dialectics between place and society as well as the political contentions of the space-place dualisms. Secondly, by discussing the debate between David Harvey and Doreen Massey, the author attempts to point out the significance of re-emphasizing the territorial dimension of the place concept. Massey has proposed the idea of＂ progressive sense of place＂, which stresses multiplicity and relationality, to accuse Harvey of over-worrying the conservativeness of place. But Harvey's perspective on absolute space, relative space and relational space is a good reminder for us that territorialization is still essential to the conceptualization of place. Finally, the author adopts Edward Soja's＂ both and/ also＂ logic as well as the idea of＂ thirdspace＂, arguing that the place concept should include both territorialization and networking, and cannot be equated with the former items in dualisms such as absolute/relative, object/non-object, essence/construction, closure/connection, fixity/flow, particular/universal, and local/global, but contains all these tensions simultaneously.

1. 王志弘、沈孟穎、林純秀(2009)。族裔公共空間的劃界政治：台北都會區外圍東南亞消費地景分析。台灣東南亞學刊，6(1)，3-48。
   連結：
2. 王應棠(2009)。棲居與空間：海德格空間思維的轉折。地理學報，55，25-42。
   連結：
3. 曾旭正(2010)。地點、場所或所在—論“place”的中譯及其啟發。地理學報，58，115-132。
   連結：
4. 譚鴻仁(2007)。關係空間與鄉村發展：以龍潭椪風茶產業為例。地理學報，50，47-72。
   連結：
5. Agnew, John(1987).Place and Politics: The Geographical Mediation of State and Society.London:Allen and Unwin.
6. Agnew, John(ed.),Duncan, James S.(ed.)(1989).The Power of Place: Bringing Together Geographical and Sociological Imaginations.Boston:Unwin Hyman.
7. Bird, Jon(ed.),Curtis, Barry(ed.),Putnam, Tim(ed.),Robertson, George(ed.),Tickner, Lisa(ed.)(1993).Mapping the Futures: Local Cultures, Global Change.London:Routledge.
8. Casey, Edward S.(1997).The Fate of Place: A Philosophical History.Berkeley:University of California Press.
9. Castells, Manuel(1996).The Rise of Network Society.Cambridge, Mass.:Blackwell.
10. Cloke, Paul(ed.),Crang, Philip(ed.),Goodwin, Mark(ed.)(1999).Introducing Human Geographies.London:Arnold.
11. Cloke, Paul(ed.),Johnston, Ron(ed.)(2005).Spaces of Geographical Thought.London:Sage.
12. Cresswell, Tim(2004).Place: A Short Introduction.Oxford:Blackwell.
13. Cresswell, Tim(1996).In Place/Out of Place: Geography, Ideology and Transgression.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press.
14. Entriken, J. Nicholas(1991).The Betweenness of Place: Towards a Geography of Modernity.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press.
15. Feagan, Robert(2007).The Place of Food: Mapping Out the 'Local' in Local Food Systems.Progress in Human Geography,31(1),23-42.
16. Freiberg, J. W.(ed.)(1979).Critical Sociology: European Perspective.New York:Irvington.
17. Fuss, Diana(1989).Essentially Speaking: Feminism, Nature & Difference.New York:Routledge.
18. Giddens, Anthony(1984).The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Strcuturation.Berkeley:University of California Press.
19. Gieryn, Thomas F.(2000).A Space for Place in Sociology.Annual Review of Sociology,26,463-96.
20. Graham, Stephen(1998).The End of Geography or the Explosion of Place? Conceptualizing Space, Place and Information Technology.Progress in Human Geography,22(2),165-185.
21. Gregory, Derek(ed.),Johnston, Ron(ed.),Pratt, Geraldine(ed.),Watts, Michael J.(ed.),Whatmore, Sarah(ed.)(2009).The Dictionary of Human Geography.Oxford:Wiley-Blackwell.
22. Harvey, David(1990).Between Space and Time: Reflections on the Geographical Imagination.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,80(3),418-34.
23. Harvey, David(1989).The Condition of Postmodernity.Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
24. Harvey, David(1973).Social Justice and the City.Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
25. Harvey, David(1996).Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference.Oxford:Blackwell.
26. Harvey, David(2009).Cosmopolitanism and the Geographies of Freedom.New York:Columbia University Press.
27. Harvey, David(2006).Spaces of Global Capitalism: Towards a Theory of Uneven Geographical Development.London:Verso.
28. Harvey, David(1995).Militant Particularism and Global Ambition: the Conceptual Politics of Place, Space, and Environment in the Work of Raymond Williams.Social Text,42,69-98.
29. Holloway, Sarah L.(ed.),Rice, Stephen P.(ed.),Valentine, Gill(ed.)(2003).Key Concepts in Geography.London:Sage.
30. Holloway, Sarah L.(ed.),Rice, Stephen P.(ed.),Valentine, Gill(ed.)(2009).Key Concepts in Geography.London:Sage.
31. hooks, bell(1990).Yearning: Race, Gender, and Cultural Politics.Boston, MA:South End Press.
32. Hudson, Ray(ed.)(2001).Producing Places.New York:Guilford.
33. Johnston, R.J.(ed.),Gregory, Derek(ed.),Pratt, Geraldine(ed.),Watts, Michael(ed.)(2000).The Dictionary of Human Geography.Oxford:Blackwell.
34. Johnston, R.J.(ed.),Gregory, Derek(ed.),Smith, David M.(ed.)(1994).The Dictionary of Human Geography.Oxford:Blackwell.
35. Johnston, R.J.(ed.),Smith, David M.(ed.),Gregory, Derek(ed.),Haggett, Peter(ed.),Stoddart, D. R.(ed.)(1986).The Dictionary of Human Geography.Oxford:Blackwell.
36. Jonas, Andrew E.G.(2011).Region and Place: Regionalism in Question.Progress in Human Geography
37. Kogl, Alexandra(2008).Strange Places: The Political Potentials and Perils of Everyday Spaces.Lanham, MD:Lexington Books.
38. Lefebvre, Henri(1991).The Production of Space.Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
39. Massey, Doreen(1994).Space, Place and Gender.Cambridge:Polity Press.
40. Massey, Doreen(1991).A Global Sense of Place.Marxism Today,June,24-2.
41. Massey, Doreen(1992).Politics and Space/time.New Left Review,196,65-84.
42. Massey, Doreen(2005).For Space.London:Sage.
43. Massey, Doreen(ed.),Allen, John(ed.)(1984).Geography Matters! A Reader.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
44. Massey, Doreen(ed.),Jess, Pat(ed.)(1995).A Place in the World?.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
45. McDowell, Linda(1999).Gender, Identity and Place: Understanding Feminist Geographies.Cambridge:Polity Press.
46. McDowell, Linda(ed.)(1997).Undoing Places? A Geographical Reader.London:Arnold.
47. Paasi, Anssi(2004).Place and Region: Looking through the Prism of Scale.Progress in Human Geography,28(4),536-546.
48. Panitch, Leo(ed.),Leys, Colin(ed.)(2001).The Socialist Register 2002: A World of Contradictions.London:The Merlin Press.
49. Peet, Richard(1998).Modern Geographical Thought.Oxford:Blackwell.
50. Prazniak, Roxann(ed.),Dirlik, Arif(ed.)(2002).Places and Politics in an Age of Globalization.Lanham, MD.:Rowman and Littlefield.
51. Pred, Alan(1986).Place, Practice and Structure.Cambridge:Polity Press.
52. Pred, Alan(1984).Place as Historically Contingent Process: Structuration and the Time Geography of Becoming Places.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,74,279-97.
53. Proctor, James D.(ed.),Smith, David M.(ed.)(1999).Geography and Ethics: Journeys in a Moral Terrain.London:Routledge.
54. Relph, Edward(1976).Place and Placelessness.London:Pion.
55. Savage, Mike,Bagnall, Gaynor,Longhurst, Brian(2005).Globalization and Belonging.London:Sage.
56. Sayer, Andrew(1992).Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach.London:Routledge.
57. Sheppard, Eric(ed.),McMaster, Robert B.(ed.)(2004).Scale and Geographic Inquiry: Nature, Society, and Method.Oxford:Blackwell.
58. Sibley, David(1995).Geographies of Exclusion.London:Routledge.
59. Smith, Michael P.(2001).Transnational Urbanism.Oxford:Blackwell.
60. Soja, Edward(1996).Thirdspace: Journey to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-Imagined Places.Oxford:Blackwell.
61. Soja, Edward(1989).Postmodern Geographies.London:Verso.
62. Tuan, Yi-Fu(1977).Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience.London:Edward Arnold.
63. 王志弘(2001)。空間研究的歐美思潮與台灣課題。文化視窗，35，50-55。
64. 王志弘(1996)。女性主義與後現代主義的地理學鍵結—重要文獻之評介。國立臺灣大學建築與城鄉研究學報，8，117-128。

1. 蔡幸娟,林政逸(2019)。邊緣的再現空間政治：電影如何再現寶藏巖之地方感。地理學報，92，31-54。
2. 高郁婷,王志弘(2023)。文化與空間的再連結：「再造歷史現場」政策初探。文化研究，37，7-56。
3. 胡紹嘉(2020)。尋根或尋蹤：《莿桐最後的望族》與《留味行》的家族懷想及其中介。人文社會學報，20，31-64。
4. 黃子倫(2019)。成為市場人：臺中市建國市場拆遷過程的地方感形塑。中國地理學會會刊，64，33-48。