國民小學校長領導實現社會正義的現況與策略探究－來自八位校長的經驗

Status and Strategy of Elementary School Principal Leadership in Social Justice Implementation: The Practical Experience of Eight Principals

10.3966/199679772014063101002

蔡金田(Chin-Tien Tsai)

國民教育 ； 教育領導 ； 社會正義 ； national education ； educational leadership ； social justice

新竹教育大學教育學報

31卷1期（2014 / 06 / 30）

47 - 76

繁體中文

本研究旨在透過訪談與焦點座談來探究校長對社會正義領導的認知與實踐情形，於2011年9月進行訪談，同年11及12月舉辦兩次焦點座談。經由資料蒐集與分析後發現如下：一、校長能秉持道德以及公平理念，針對弱勢學生提供足夠的教育機會與教育環境來實現社會正義領導。二、學校存在不符合社會正義的現象，包括語言與文化環境的不足以及特殊教育支援系統的缺乏。三、有效的社會正義領導策略，包括實施學生課後輔導以及爭取教育資源。四、實施社會正義領導的主要阻力，包括家長教育觀念的偏差以及校內成員之社會正義理念認知不足。校長經由加強觀念的溝通與爭取資源來克服所遭遇之阻力。五、學校實踐社會正義領導成效，包括實施課後輔導進行補教教學以及特色課程的設計。六、社會正義領導應具備的能力，包括社會正義的理念以及教育熱忱。

The purpose of this study was to explore principals' knowledge and practical implementation of social justice leadership by using interviews and focus groups. Researchers collected data through interviews in September 2011 and focus group discussions in November and December 2011. The results indicated that principals can implement social justice leadership by upholding the concepts of morality and fairness to provide adequate educational opportunities and environments for disadvantaged students. The principals reported phenomena that are not socially just, such as a lack of language and cultural environments and inadequate special education support systems. Effective measures for implementing social justice leadership include providing after-school tutoring, additional educational resources, effective curriculum, and activity planning. Major obstacles encountered by principals during the implementation of social justice leadership were differing opinions from parents and limited social justice awareness by school staff and faculty. By strengthening communication about ideas and contending for resources, the principals were able to overcome resistance. The principals' achievements in social justice implementation were afterschool tutoring, remedial education, and the design of special courses. A social justice leader should have social justice awareness and enthusiasm for education.

1. Amrein, A. L., & Berliner, D. C. (2002). The impact of high stakes tests on student academic performance: An analysis of NAEP results in states with high stakes tests and ACT, SAT, and AP results in states with high school graduation exams. Retrieved from: http://edpolicylab/org
2. 康新貴（2009）。是公平與正義？還是效率優先？兼顧公平？取自http://big5.China-labour.org.hk/chi/node/79347
3. 教育部（2004）。2001年教育改革行動方案。取自http://www.edu.tw/EDU_MGT/E0001/EDUION001/menu03/sub02/03020201.htm
4. Alexander, K. L.,Entwisle, D. R.,Olsen, L. S.(2001).Schools, achievement, and inequality: A seasonal perspective.Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis,23(2),171-191.
5. Alinsky, S. D.(1971).Rules for radicals: A practical primer for realistic radicals.New York, NY:Random House.
6. Arnove, R. F.(Ed.),Torres, C. A.(Ed.)(1999).Comparative education: The dialectic of the global and the local.Lanham, MD:Rowan & Littlefield.
7. Bickman, L.(Ed.),Rog, D. J.(Ed.)(1998).Handbook of applied social research methods.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
8. Bishop, R.,Glynn, T.(1999).Culture counts: Changing power relations in education.Palmerston North, New Zealand:Dunmore.
9. Blackmore, J.(2002).Leadership for socially just schooling: More substance and less style in high risk, low trust times?.Journal of School Leadership,12(2),198-222.
10. Bogdan, R. C.,Biklen, S.(1998).Qualitative research for education: An introduction to theory and methods.Needham Heights, MA:Allyn & Bacon.
11. Bogotch, I.(2002).Educational leadership and social justice: Practice into theory.Journal of School Leadership,12(2),138-156.
12. Brown, K. M.(2004).Leadership for social justice and equity: Weaving a transformative framework and pedagogy.Educational Administration Quarterly,40,77-108.
13. Cambron-McCabe, N.,McCarthy, M. M.(2005).Educating leaders for social justice.Educational Policy,19,201-222.
14. Conrad, C. F.(Ed.),Haworth, J. G.(Ed.),Lattuca, L. R.(Ed.)(2001).Qualitative research in higher education: Expanding perspectives.Boston, MA:Pearson Custom Publishing.
15. Conrad, C.,Neumann, A.,Haworth, J. G.,Scott, P.(1993).Qualitative research in higher education: Experiencing alternative perspectives and approaches.Needham Heights, MA:Ginn Press.
16. Dantley, M.(2002).Uprooting and replacing positivism, the melting pot, multiculturalism, and other impotent notions in education leadership through an African American perspective.Education and Urban Society,34(3),334-352.
17. Deal, T.,Peterson, K.(1999).Shaping school culture: The heart of leadership.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
18. English, F.(Ed.)(2005).The Sage handbook of educational leadership.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
19. Esparo, L. J.,Rader, R.(2001).The leadership crisis: The shortage of qualified superintendents is not going away.American School Board Journal,188(5),46-48.
20. Furman, G. C.,Gruenewald, D. A.(2004).Expanding the landscape of social justice: A critical ecological analysis.Educational Administration Quarterly,40(1),47-76.
21. Gerstl-Pepin, C.(2001).Administrative licensure and social justice in Georgia.American Educational Research Association annual meeting,Seattle, WA.:
22. Kincheloe, J. L.(Ed.),Steinberg, S. R.(Ed.)(1995).Thirteen questions.New York, NY:Peter Lang.
23. MacKinnon, D.(2000).Equity, leadership, and schooling.Exceptionality Education Canada,10(1 & 2),5-21.
24. Marshall, C.(2004).Social justice challenges to educational administration: Introduction to a special issue.Educational Administration Quarterly,40,3-13.
25. Marshall, C.,Oliva, M.(2010).Leadership for social justice: Making revolutions in education.New York, NY:Allyn & Bacon.
26. McBride, S. R.,McKee, W.(2001).,未出版
27. McKenzie, K. B.,Scheurich, J. J.(2004).Equity traps: A useful construct to preparing principals to lead schools that are successful with racially diverse students.Educational Administration Quarterly,40,601-632.
28. McLaren, P. L.(1985).The ritual dimensions of resistance: Clowning and symbolic inversion.Journal of Education,167(2),84-97.
29. Murphy, J.(Ed.)(2002).The education leadership challenge: Redefining leadership for the 21st century.Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
30. Oakes, J.,Quartz, K. H.,Ryan, S.,Lipton, M.(2000).Becoming good American schools.PhiDelta Kappan,81(8),568-576.
31. Oliva, M.,Menchaca, V.(2001).Texas educator sertification and social justice.American Educational Research Association annual meeting,Seattle, WA.:
32. Palmer, P.(2000).Let your life speak: Listening for the voice of vocation.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
33. Rapp, D.(2002).Social justice and the importance of rebellious imaginations.Journal of School Leadership,12(3),226-245.
34. Riester, A. F.,Pursch, V.,Skrla, L.(2002).Principals for social justice: Leaders of school success for children from low-income homes.Journal of School Leadership,12,281-304.
35. Sergiovanni, T.(1998).Leadership as pedagogy, capital development and school effectiveness.International Journal of Leadership in Education,1(1),33-41.
36. Shields, C. M.(2003).Good intentions are not enough: Transformative leadership for communities of difference.Lanham, MD:Scarecrow.
37. Shields, C. M.(2004).Dialogic leadership for social justice: Overcoming pathologies of silence.Educational Administration Quarterly,40(1),111-134.
38. Shields, C. M.,Mazawi, A. E.,Bishop, R.(2002).Overcoming deficit thinking: De-pathologizing the lived experiences of children.annual conference of the New Zealand Association for Research in Education,Palmerston North, New Zealand:
39. Shields, C. M.,Oberg, S. L.(2000).Year-round schooling: Promises and pitfalls.Lanham. MD:Scarecrow/Technomics.
40. Theoharis, G. T.(2004).Toward a theory of social justice educational leadership.Paper presented at the University Council of Educational Administration,Kansas City, MO.:
41. Touchton, D.,Acker-Hocevar, M.(2001).Using a lens of social justice to reframe principals' interviews from high poverty, low performing schools.Annual Meeting of the University Council for Educational Administration,Cincinnati, OH.:
42. 邱國良、王文君(2007)。社會正義的闡釋與我國城鄉教育公平。江西社會科學，2007(11)，218-220。
43. 范麗娟(2007)。臺灣弱勢者教育的現況分析與未來展望。教育資料與研究，專刊，77-90。
44. 張鈿富、張曉琪(2010)。社會公義領導：促動教育界革命。當代教育研究季刊，18(1)，147-156。
45. 潘佑廷(2012)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。嘉義縣，南華大學。
46. 簡良平(2009)。偏遠國小學校課程實踐脈絡分析：教育促成社會正義之觀點。初等教育學刊，34，1-24。

1. 范熾文,胡中平,紀惠英(2018)。國小女性校長領導風格與學校組織氣氛之相關研究。學校行政，116，1-21。
2. 張臺隆、張文權(2018)。弱勢關懷的新焦點：偏遠地區中小學校長社會正義領導之研究。中等教育，69(3)，27-43。
3. (2018)。偏遠地區學校發展與澳洲昆士蘭相關政策案例探討。教育研究月刊，287，96-111。
4. (2018)。校長社會正義領導的理論與實踐：以臺灣中部一所小學為例。臺灣教育社會學研究，18(2)，89-134。
5. (2020)。為社會正義而領導：編織公平正義的學校教育環境。教育研究月刊，318，4-17。