女性主義生命倫理

Feminist Bioethics

10.6145/jme.200503_9(1).0002

蔡甫昌(Daniel Fu-Chang Tsai)；曾瑾珮(Chin-Pei Tseng)

女性主義生命倫理 ； 關懷倫理 ； 醫學倫理 ； 醫病關係 ； 代理孕母 ； feminist bioethics ； ethics of care ； medical ethics ； physician-patient relationship ； surrogate motherhood

Journal of Medical Education

9卷1期（2005 / 03 / 01）

18 - 32

繁體中文

本文探討「女性主義」、「女性主義倫理」及「女性主義生命倫理」，介紹其「定義」、「歷史沿革」、「理論及派別」、「批評與辯護」，並藉「代理孕母」及「醫病關係」兩案例之討論，作為「女性主義生命倫理進路」應用之說明，最後並提出操作法則。作者期望藉本文理論之回顧與分析，呈現女性主義生命倫理之豐富內涵、多元觀點與思維模式，及其將「性別觀點」帶入生命倫理領域之嘗試與貢獻，以作為進一步與其他生命倫理方法論對話之基礎；並希望透過此方法論之介紹，有助於醫護人員及生命倫理研究者，在面對及解決臨床醫學倫理問題時，能因參考此理論而發展出更豐富之倫理視域與思維。

This paper introduces the definitions. theories, schools, criticisms, and debates of ”feminism”, ”feminist ethics” and ”feminist bioethics”. Two cases concerning ”surrogate motherhood” and ”physician-patient relationship” have been proposed as examples for demonstrating the application of feminist approach to bioethics. A concise working formula is also presented. It is hoped that through the review and analysis of this paper, the gender perspectives of ethical reasoning proposed and promoted by feminist bioethicists can bring both medical professionals and bioethical researchers new horizon and rationale in their ethical deliberations of clinical ethical encounters.

1. Beauchamp TL,Childress JF(1994).Principles of Biomedical Ethics.Oxford University Press.
2. Chesler P(1972).Women and madness, Garden City.N.Y.:Doubleday.
3. Clement G(1998).Care, Autonomy, and Justice: Feminism and the Ethics of Care.Westview Press.
4. Gilligan C(1982).a Different Voice.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
5. Harding S(1991).Whose Science? Whose Knowledge?: Thinking From Women`s Lives.Milton Keynes:Open University Press.
6. Harding S(1986).The Science Question in Feminism.Cornell University Press.
7. Kass LR(1990).Practicing ethics: where`s the action.Hasting Center Report,20,5-12.
8. Lebacqz K(1995).Encyclopedia of Bioethics, Macmillan Library Reference.
9. Little MO(1996).Why a feminist approach to bioethics.Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal,6(1),1-18.
10. Manning RC,Kuhse H,Singer P (eds.)(1998).A care approach.A Companion to Bioethics, Blackwell,98-99.
11. Sherwin S,Wolf SM (ed.)(1996).Feminism & Bioethics: Beyond Reproduction.Oxford University Press.
12. Steinfels P(1993).Beliefs.New York Times:
13. Tong R(1996).Feminist bioethics: Toward developing a "feminist" answer to the surrogate motherhood question.Kennedy Inst Ethics J,6(1),37-52.
14. Tong R(1997).Feminist Approaches to Bioethics.Westview Press.
15. Tong R(1998).Encyclopedia of Applied Ethics.Academic Press.
16. Tong R,Wolf SM (ed.)(1996).Feminism & Bioethics: Beyond Reproduction.Oxford University Press.
17. Walker MU(1992).Feminism, ethics, and the question of theory.Hypatia,7,23-28.
18. West RC(1988).Jurisprudence and gender.University of Chicago Law Review,55,1-72.
19. Wolf SM,Wolf SM (ed.)(1996).Feminism & Bioethics: Beyond Reproduction.Oxford University Press.
20. 王瑞香、顧燕翎主編(1996)。女性主義理論與流派。台北:女書文化。
21. 吳秀瑾(2000)。從「自己的房間」到「自己的身體」－論女性與哲學。哲學雜誌：女性與哲學，33，13。
22. 林芳玫、顧燕翎主編(1996)。女性主義理論與流派。台北:女書文化出版。
23. 戴華(2001)。Gilligan的關懷倫理與康德的的道德觀點。台灣哲學會2001年學術研討會論文
24. 顧燕翎(1996)。女性主義理論與流派。台北:女書文化。

1. Lien-Jen Hwu,Hsiang-Chu Pai(2023)。Effects of Gender Equity Education on Gender Stereotypes, Gender Role Attitudes, and Gender Awareness。通識教育實踐與研究，33，1-30。
2. 李美秀(2020)。Noddings的關懷倫理學與護理實務。生命教育研究，12(2)，23-56。
3. 李素貞(2008)。關懷在護理倫理理論中之定位－女性主義觀點。弘光學報，53，43-54。