實證醫學小組教學工作坊對住院醫師之影響評估

Assessing the Influence of Small Group Evidence-based Medicine Workshop on Residents

10.6145/jme.200803_12(1).0005

黃靜宜(Chin-Yi Huang)；廖以誠(Yi-Cheng Liao)；賴鈺嘉(Yu-Jia Lai)；曹龍彥(Lon-Yen Tsao)

實證醫學 ； 醫學教育 ； 小組教學 ； 住院醫師 ； evidence-based medicine ； medical education ； small-group teaching ； medical residents

Journal of Medical Education

12卷1期（2008 / 03 / 01）

36 - 44

繁體中文

Objective: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact on residents who attended a small group evidence-based medicine workshop. Methods: We designed a small group of evidence-based medicine (EBM) workshop that consisted of two half-day sessions, Each study group consisted of six to ten members, The first half-day session included an introduction to EBM, formulating PICO questions, online searching practice and discussion. Then the residents appraised one Copy of literature about therapy themselves between sessions. The second half-day session was held one week later and included a guide to quick critical appraisal, applying evidence to a clinical situation, and a wrap-up period. Self-rating questionnaires were filled out before and after the workshop, which evaluate the residents' attitude, their self-reported skills and their general concept about EBM practice. In addition, the residents' satisfaction with the EBM workshop was also surveyed. Results: In total, 126 residents attended the EBM workshops from October 2003 to July 2004, and 116 completed the questionnaires. The residents had a clearer general concept of FBM after the w workshop (pre-workshop mean 2.0±1.2, post-workshop mean 3.7±1.0, p＜0.001). In terms of attitude toward EBM, ideas that had changed significantly were Al (FBM is realistic), A2 (EBM is useful), A7 (EBM is a cookbook), and A9 (filters improve quality). All the questions asked about EBM skills were significantly improved after workshop. The residents also had a high satisfaction score (mean 5.2±0.8) with the EBM workshop's utilization of a small interactive group. Conclusion: A well-designed and prepared small group EBM workshop is able to affect residents' attitudes toward EBM positively and effectively improve their EBM skills. The residents' satisfaction with such a workshop was high.

Objective: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact on residents who attended a small group evidence-based medicine workshop. Methods: We designed a small group of evidence-based medicine (EBM) workshop that consisted of two half-day sessions, Each study group consisted of six to ten members, The first half-day session included an introduction to EBM, formulating PICO questions, online searching practice and discussion. Then the residents appraised one Copy of literature about therapy themselves between sessions. The second half-day session was held one week later and included a guide to quick critical appraisal, applying evidence to a clinical situation, and a wrap-up period. Self-rating questionnaires were filled out before and after the workshop, which evaluate the residents' attitude, their self-reported skills and their general concept about EBM practice. In addition, the residents' satisfaction with the EBM workshop was also surveyed. Results: In total, 126 residents attended the EBM workshops from October 2003 to July 2004, and 116 completed the questionnaires. The residents had a clearer general concept of FBM after the w workshop (pre-workshop mean 2.0±1.2, post-workshop mean 3.7±1.0, p＜0.001). In terms of attitude toward EBM, ideas that had changed significantly were Al (FBM is realistic), A2 (EBM is useful), A7 (EBM is a cookbook), and A9 (filters improve quality). All the questions asked about EBM skills were significantly improved after workshop. The residents also had a high satisfaction score (mean 5.2±0.8) with the EBM workshop's utilization of a small interactive group. Conclusion: A well-designed and prepared small group EBM workshop is able to affect residents' attitudes toward EBM positively and effectively improve their EBM skills. The residents' satisfaction with such a workshop was high.

1. 余光輝、陳永昌、田亞中(2007)。實診書學的醫學教育。醫學教育，11，13-20。
   連結：
2. AkI EA,lzuchukwu IS,El-Dika S(2004).Integrating an evidence-based medicine rotation into an internal medicine residency program.Acud Med,79,897-904.
3. Antman EM,Lau J,Kupelnick B(1992).A comparison of results of meta-analyses of randomized control trails and recommendations of clinical experts. Treatments for myocardial infarction.JAMA,268,240-248.
4. Barzansky B,Etzel SI(2003).Educational programs in US medical schools, 2002-2003.JAMA,290,1190-1196.
5. Med Educ Online [serial online]
6. Bhandari M,Montori V,Devereasix PJ(2003).Challenges to the practice of evidence-bused medicine during residents` surgical training: a qualitative study using grounded theory.Acad Med,78,1183-1190.
7. Bradley P,Nordheim L,Harpe D(2005).A systematic review of qualitative literature on educational interventions for evidence-bused practice.Learn Health Soc Care,4,89-109.
8. Coomarasamy A,Khan KS(2004).What is the evidence that postgraduate teaching in evidence based medicine changes anything? A systematic review.BMJ,329,1017-1019.
9. EPPI Centre(2001).The HIVSA Workshop, EPPI-Center report.London:Social Science Research Unit Institute of Education.
10. Evidence-based Medicine Working Group(1992).Evidence based medicine. A new approach to teaching the practice of medicine.JAMA,268,2420-2425.
11. Fritsche L,Greenhalgh T,Falck-Ytter Y(2002).Do short courses in evidence based medicine improve knowledge and skills? Validation of Berlin questionnaire and before and after study of courses in evidence based medicine.BMJ,325,1338-1341.
12. Green M(2000).Evidence-based medicine training in internal medicine residency programs: a national survey.Gen Intern Med,15,129-133.
13. Green ML(1999).Graduate medical education training in clinical epidemiology, critical appraisal, and evidence-based medicine: a critical review of curricula.Acad Med,74,686-694.
14. Green ML,Ellis PJ(1997).Impact of an evidence-basest medicine curriculum based on adult learning theory.Gun Intern Med,2,742-750.
15. Guyatt G,Haynes B,Jueschke R,Rennie D (eds.)(2002).User's Guide to the Medical Literature.Chicago:AMA Press.
16. Holloway R,Nesbit K,Donald B(2004).Teaching and evaluating first and second year medical students` practice of evidence-based medicine.Med Educ,38,868-878.
17. Johnston JM,Leung GM.,Fielding R.(2003).The development and validation of a knowledge, attitude and behaviour questionnaire to assess undergraduate evidence-based practice teaching and learning.Med Educ,37,992-1000.
18. Kitclsens JM,Pfeifer MP(1989).Teaching residents to read the medical literature: a controlled trial of curriculum in critical appraisal clinical epidemiology.J Gen Intern Med,4,384-387.
19. Nicholson U,Shieh LV(2005).Teaching evidence-bused medicine on a busy hospitalist service: residents rate pilot curriculum.Acad Med,80,607-609.
20. Norman ER,Shannon SI(1998).Effectiveness of instruction in critical appraisal (evidence-based medicine) skills: a critical appraisal.CMAJ,158,177-181.
21. Seelig CB(1991).Affecting residents literature reading attitudes. behaviors, and knowledge through a journal club intervention.J Gen Intern Med,6,330-334.
22. Staus SE,Richardson WS,Glasziou P.(2005).Evidence-based medicine how to practice and teach EBM..ELSFVIER,xiv-1
23. Stern DT,Linzer M,O`Sullivan PS(1995).Evaluating medical residents` literature appraisal skills.Acad Med,70,152-154.
24. Williams BC,Stern DT(1997).Exploratory study of residents` conceptual framework for critical appraisal of the literature.Teach Learn Med,9,270-275.
25. Wood EJ(2004).Problem-based learning: exploiting knowledge of boo people learning to promote effective learning.BEE-j,3,3-5.
26. 黃天祥(2004)。畢業後一般醫學訓練。醫學教育，8，125-126。

1. 楊甯貽、楊宗翰、陳勇志、施昭寧、余光輝、王正旭(2010)。醫師與其他臨床人員在實證工作坊表現之比較。醫學教育，14(1)，49-57。