Educating Medical Students to Appreciate the Value of Life: Implementing Practices for Teaching Empathy at the MedicalUniversity Level

10.6145/jme.201112_15(4).0003

Yu-Hua Liu；Wing P. Chan

active-learning ； empathy ； medical education ； self-introspection

Journal of Medical Education

15卷4期（2011 / 12 / 01）

343 - 350

英文

Purpose: The aim of this study was to assess our teaching the value and meaning of life to our freshman medical students before they received their medical education, using a two stage approach known as ”Life Gardener.” Methods: We prospectively recruited 165 Year-1 medical students. In the first stage (”Sapling Care Operations”), which started at the beginning of the semester, students looked after a small flowering houseplant commonly known as the ”African violet” for sixteen weeks. The purpose of the care process was to inspire students to observe the life and death struggle and to contemplate factors affecting quality of care. In the second phase (”Empathy Patient Care Operations”), which started at the end of the semester, students who completed 10 hours of empathy skills training were assigned to one of our three affiliated hospitals to experience how to care for patients. Results: We identified five items of self-reflection (observations of life, self insight and emotional response to providing care, clarification of attitudes toward the care of living creatures, inner thoughts on the future as a medical professional, and use of resources to understand life) in stage I and three areas of concern in response to these triggers (the development of empathic responses, initial thoughts on communication with others, and development of a holistic view of care) in stage II identified from students' records and feedback. The feedback of ten participants was quoted as evidence supporting the goal and learning process of the project. Conclusion: The results showed that our approach taught students to appreciate the value of life, a lesson that would help them in their future medical career.

1. Chan, C.I.、Tsai, D.F.C.(2008)。Internship as a new form of bioethics education: introduction to the Yale University Summer Bioethics Internship Program。J Med Education，12(4)，241-50。
   連結：
2. Hong, H.L.、Chang, L.J.(2005)。Evaluation of the effects of role-playing with dying patients using the death constructs of medical college students。J Med Education，9(2)，162-74。
   連結：
3. Lue, B.H.、Chen, H.J.、Kao, M.Y.(2006)。Exploring medical students' orientation toward physician empathy。J Med Education，10(4)，276-82。
   連結：
4. Shiau, S.J.、Chaing, Y.T.、Huang, Y.C.(2006)。The life cultivation of nursing education touched by care, concern and compassion。J Med Education，10(1)，1-7。
   連結：
5. Tsai, S.L.、Yang, C.W.、Yeh, C.C.(2010)。Effect of patient-doctor communications curriculum on medical student clinical performance。J Med Education，14(1)，23-35。
   連結：
6. (1998).Curriculum development for medical education: a six-step approach.Baltimore:The Johns Hopkins University Press.
7. Chen, D.,Lew, R.,Hershman, W.,Orlander, J.(2007).A cross-sectional measurement of medical student empathy.J Gen Intern Med,22(10),1434-8.
8. Côté, L.,Turgeon, J.(2005).Appraising qualitative research articles in medicine and medical education.Med Teach,27(1),71-5.
9. Crandall, S.J.,Marion, G.S.(2009).Commentary: identifying attitudes towards empathy: an essential feature of professionalism.Acad Med,84(9),1174-6.
10. Deloney, L.A.,Graham, C.J.(2003).Wit: using drama to teach first-year medical students about empathy and compassion.Teach Learn Med,15(4),247-51.
11. Evans, B.J.,Stanley, R.O.,Burrows, G.D.(1993).Measuring medical students' empathy skills.Br J Med Psych,66,122-33.
12. Glaser, K.M.,Markham, F.W.,Adler, H.M.(2007).Relationships between scores on the Jefferson Scale of physician empathy, patient perceptions of physician empathy, and humanistic approaches to patient care: a validity study.Med Sci Monit,13(7),CR291-4.
13. Leung, G.M.,Fielding, R.,Chan, M.F.(2002).The development and evaluation of an integrated community-based, patient-centered learning activity at the University of Hong Kong.Med Educ,36(10),992-5.
14. Levinson, W.,Gorawara-Bhat, R.,Lamb, J.(2000).A study of patient clues and physician responses in primary care and surgical settings.J Am Med Assoc,284(8),1021-7.
15. Markham, B.(1979).Can a behavioural science course change medical students' attitudes?.J Psychiatr Educ,3,44-54.
16. Shield, R.R.,Tong, I.,Tomas, M.(2011).Teaching communication and compassionate care skills: an innovative curriculum for pre-clerkship medical students.Med Teach,33(8),e408-16.
17. Stewart, M.,Brown, J.B.,Donner, A.(2000).The impact of patient-centered care on outcomes.J Fam Pract,49,796-804.
18. Waldstein, S.R.,Neumann, S.A.,Drossman, D.A.(2001).Teaching psychosomatic (biopsychosocial) medicine in United States medical schools: survey findings.Psychosom Med,63(3),335-43.
19. Wilkes, M.,Milgrom, E.,Hoffman, J.R.(2002).Towards more empathic medical students: a medical student hospitalization experience.Med Educ,36,528-33.
20. Wu, S.B.(2006).Theories of Life Education and Teaching Program.Psychological Publishing Co..
21. Yuen, E.,Passow, E.,Maxwell, T.,Sifri, R.(2003).Cultivating compassionate love and empathy within a medical school curriculum.Works of Love,Villanova, Pennsylvania:
22. Yuen, J.K.,Breckman, R.,Adelman, R.D.(2006).Reflections of medical students on visiting chronically ill older patients in the home.J Am Geriatr Soc,54(11),1778-83.