Students' Perception and Acceptance of Problem-based Learning (PBL) in a Hybrid Traditional-PBL Curriculum

10.6145/jme.201112_15(4).0005

Si Mui Sim；Lay Hoong Lian；M. S. Kanthimathi；Meow Keong Thong；Nget Hong Tan

problem-based learning (PBL) ； students' perception ； students' acceptance ； hybrid traditional-PBL curriculum ； undergraduate medical curriculum

Journal of Medical Education

15卷4期（2011 / 12 / 01）

361 - 371

英文

Even though there are several variants in its implementation, problem-based learning (PBL) is essentially a form of student-centred learning that involves enquiry-based discussion triggered by a problem and facilitated by a tutor in small groups. In a hybrid traditional-PBL curriculum where PBL runs parallel with conventional didactic teaching, there is always a concern that such curricular arrangement may produce undesirable learning behaviour. Therefore, this paper evaluated the students' perception and acceptance of PBL in such a learning environment. PBL was introduced in a gradual manner into the first three years of a revised undergraduate medical curriculum at the University of Malaya (UM) in 1999/2000. Self-administered questionnaires were distributed to students of Phases I, II (first two preclinical years) and IIIA (first of the three clinical years) after completing their respective final examination papers. The study compared the responses of at least nine cohorts of students (2001 to 2009) on questions related to PBL. Students were asked to respond to each question based on their own experience using a 5-point Likert scale. Across the board, progressively over the years, students from all the phases reported an improvement in their critical thinking, integration of knowledge, appreciation of understanding rather than merely memorising facts, communication skills, and braveness to counter-propose opinions. The effects were more obvious with Phase I students compared with students from the other two phases. Written comments from the students also showed a shift from resistance and outright call for the abolishment of PBL tutorials, to positive call to increase PBL tutorials.

1. Azila, N.M.A.,Sim, S.M.(2005).The status of problem-based learning in the medical schools in Malaysia.J Med Educ,9,121-30.
   連結：
2. Azila, N.M.A.,Tan, C.P.L.,Sim, S.M.(2002).Problem-based learning: monitoring and searching for an appropriate tune.J Med Educ,6,224-9.
   連結：
3. Kwan, C.Y.,Tam, L.(2009).Commentary: hybrid PBL-what is in a name?.J Med Educ,13,157-65.
   連結：
4. Brief History of the Asia-Pacific Association for Problem-Based Learning in Health Sciences (APA-PHS). Available at: [http://www.2010jointpbl.tw/ConferenceInformation.html] Accessed 21 Jun, 2010.
5. Achike, F.I.(2003).Sustaining the effectiveness of PBL in a medical curriculum.J Med Educ,7,92-6.
6. Albanese, M.A.,Mitchell, S.(1993).Problem-based learning: a review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issue.Acad Med,68,52-81.
7. Azila, N.M.A.,Sim, S.M.,Atiya, A.S.(2001).Encouraging learning how to fish: an uphill but worthwhile battle.Ann Acad Med Singapore,30,375-8.
8. Azila, N.M.A.,Tan, N.H.,Sim, S.M.(2003).Critical thinking development in a "hybrid" model of problem-based learning programme.J Med Educ,7,306-12.
9. Camp, G.(1996).Problem-based learning: a paradigm shift or a passing fad?.Med Educ Online,1,2.
10. Doig, K.,Werner, E.(2000).The marriage of a traditional lecture-based curriculum and problem-based learning: are the offspring vigorous?.Med Teach,22,173-8.
11. Hussain, R.M.R.,Mamat, W.H.W.,Salleh, N.(2007).Problem-based learning in Asian universities.Studies in Higher Education,32,761-72.
12. Khoo, H.E.(2003).Implementation of problem-based learning in Asian medical schools and students' perceptions of their experience.Med Educ,37,401-9.
13. Littlewood, W.(2000).Do Asian student really want to listen and obey?.ELT Journal,54,31-6.
14. Sim, S.M.,Azila, N.M.A.,Lian, L.H.(2006).A simple instrument for the assessment of student performance in problem-based learning tutorials.Ann Acad Med Singapore,35,634-41.
15. Van Berkel, H.,Schmidt, H.(2005).On the additional value of lectures in a problem-based curriculum.Educ for Health,18,45-61.
16. Wood, D.F.(2003).ABC of learning and teaching in medicine: problem-based learning.Br Med J,326,328-30.

1. Wu, Lii-Tzu,Wu, Hsi-Chin,Tu, Ming-Gene,Sun, Shung-Shung,Kwan, Chiu-Yin,Hsu, Li-Chuan(2012).The Change of Student Perception toward PBL in a Medical School with a hybrid-PBL Preclinical Curriculum in Taiwan.醫學教育,16(3),97-113.