The Ethics of Killing, an Amoral Enquiry

殺人的倫理學－從非道德觀點來看

蔡承志(Cheng-Chih Tsai)

killing ； totally-disabling ； infanticide ； second person perspective

應用倫理評論

59期（2015 / 10 / 01）

25+27 - 49

英文

In 'What Makes Killing Wrong?' Sinnott-Armstrong and Miller make the bold claim that killing in itself is not wrong, what is wrong is totally-disabling. In 'After-Birth Abortion: Why Should the Baby Live?' Giubilini and Minerva argue for allowing infanticide. Both papers challenge the stigma commonly associated with killing, and emphasize that killing is not wrong at some margins of life. In this paper, we first generalize the above claims to the thesis that there is nothing morally wrong with killing per se, so long as it is instant and unannounced. Then, from the perspective of social evolution, we explain why people refrain from killing others, the general guideline being that it is unadvisable to kill someone with whom you associate a Second Person Perspective (SPP). Finally, drawing from a seminal paper of Press and Dyson on the Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma, we stress that an SPP without an SP (Second Person), or the other way around, can both lead to unwelcome results.

1. Axelrod, R. M.,Hamilton, W.(1981).The Evolution of Cooperation.Science,211,1390-1396.
2. Bevins, M.(2013).Dependent Relational Animals.Journal of Medical Ethics,39(1),15-16.
3. DeGrazia, D.(2013).On the Wrongness of Killing.Journal of Medical Ethics,39(1),9.
4. Driver, J.(2013).On 'What Makes Killing Wrong?'.39(1),8.
5. Feinberg, J.(1984).Harm to Others.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
6. Fletcher, J.(1975).The Cognitive Criterion of Personhood.Hasting Center Report,4,4-7.
7. Giubilini, A.,Minerva, F.(2013).After-Birth Abortion: Why Should the Baby Live?.Journal of Medical Ethics,39(5),261-263.
8. Marquis, D.(1989).Why Abortion is Immoral.Journal of Philosophy,86(4),183-202.
9. Maynard Smith, J.,Price, G. R.(1973).The Logic of Animal Conflict.Nature,246(5427),15-18.
10. McMahan, J.(2002).The Ethics of Killing, Problems at the Margins of Life.Oxford University Press.
11. McMahan, J.(2013).Killing and Disabling: a Comment on Sinnott-Armstrong and Miller.Journal of Medical Ethics,39(1),10-11.
12. Miller, F. G.,Troug, R. D.(2012).Death, Dying, and Organ Transplanatation.New York:Oxford University Press.
13. Nagel, T.(1979).Mortal Questions.New York:Cambridge University Press.
14. Parfit, D.(1984).Reasons and Persons.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
15. Paul, J.(ed.)(1981).Reading Nozick: Essays on "Anarchy, State and Utopia".Totowa, NJ:Rowman & Littlefield.
16. Press, W. H.,Dyson, F. J.(2012).Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma Contains Strategies that Dominate any Evolutionary Opponent.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA,109,10409-10413.
17. Singer, P.(ed.),Wells, D.(ed.)(1985).Making Babies.New York:C. Scribner's Sons.
18. Sinnott-Armstrong, W.,Miller, F. G.(2013).What Makes Killing Wrong?.Journal of Medical Ethics,39(1),3-7.
19. Sinnott-Armstrong, W.,Miller, F. G.(2013).Killing Versus Totally Disabling: a Reply to Critics.Journal of Medical Ethics,39(1),12-14.
20. Stewart, A. J.,Plotkin, J. B.(2012).Extortion and Cooperation in the Prisoner's Dilemma.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA,109,10134-10135.
21. Tsai, C-C.(2013).The Unbearable Lightness of Personal Identity -Messages from Bioethics.Applied Ethics: Risk, Justice and Liberty
22. Veatch, R. M.(2008).Donating Hearts After Caridiac Death-Reversing the Irreversible.New England Journal of Medicine,369,672-673.
23. Veatch, R. M.(2010).Transplanting Hearts After Death Measured by Cardiac Criteria: The Challenge to the Dead Donor Rule.Journal of Medicine and Philosophy,35(6),313-329.