Analgesic Effect of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation on Medically Unexplained Pain in Patients with Medication-resistant Depression

重覆透顱磁刺激對於憂鬱症病人之內外科無法解釋疼痛之效應

李正達(Cheng-Ta Li)；林韋丞(Wei-Chen Lin)；陳牧宏(Mu-Hong Chen)；蘇東平(Tung-Ping Su)；白雅美(Ya-Mei Bai)；謝仁俊(Jen-Chuen Hsieh)

憂鬱 ； 透顱磁刺激 ； 正子造影 ； 身體型疾患 ； depression ； transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) ； positron emission tomography (PET) ； somatoform disorders

台灣精神醫學

30卷1期（2016 / 03 / 01）

35 - 44+iii

英文

目的：內外科無法解釋的疼痛(medically unexplained symptoms of pain, MUS-pain)在憂鬱症患者身上是常見的，且會影響憂鬱症的治療成效。過去研究顯示：左背外側前額葉的重覆透顱磁刺激(repetitivetranscranial magnetic stimulation, rTMS)能治療抗憂鬱劑治療頑固型憂鬱症，且rTMS也對慢性疼痛有療效。然而，rTMS對於MUS-pain是否有效仍不清楚。方法：我們設計一個隨機合併有假性刺激控制組(sham-controlled) 的實驗，來研究是否左前額葉 rTMS（10Hz, 1,600發／次，共 10次）對於憂鬱症之MUS-pain (n = 24)能有改善。此外，在另一個用同樣rTMS參數來研究10次rTMS治療對於憂鬱症狀是否改善的研究中，我們用rTMS治療二星期並且再追蹤16位憂鬱症合併MUS-pain及10位無疼痛之憂鬱症患者另外三個月，以了解疼痛症狀與憂鬱症狀之間的關連性。結果：在此研究中，我們共招募了40位帶有內外科無法解釋的疼痛的病人，以10位沒有無法解釋的疼痛的病人。我們發現兩星期10Hz rTMS於左前額葉的治療，相較於假性刺激組，能顯著的改善 MUS-pain (p ＜ 0.05)，而且其止痛的療效與抗憂鬱的療效是獨立、不相關連的。此外，我們也發現了若憂鬱症個案之疼痛症狀對於rTMS沒有反應，則其憂鬱症狀在追蹤下有顯著較高的復發率。結論：本研究發現左前額葉高頻rTMS治療對於憂鬱症患者所表現出之內外科無法解釋的疼痛有著顯著止痛療效。我們的研究也暗示憂鬱症患者的疼痛症狀需被正視，因為疼痛症狀對於其憂鬱症狀的長期穩定有著負面的影響。

Objectives: Medically unexplained symptoms of pain (MUS-pain) are common in patients with depression and can worsen clinical outcomes. High-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) over the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) has been proven effective for managing treatment-resistant depression and chronic pain, and might relieve chronic MUS-pain. But whether left prefrontal rTMS has analgesic effects on MUS-pain remains unclear. Methods: A randomized sham-controlled rTMS study (10-Hz, 1600 pulses/session, 10 sessions) was conducted for 2 weeks to determine whether rTMS is effective in treating medication-resistant depressed patients with MUS-pain (n = 24). Furthermore, in another left prefrontal 10-Hz rTMS study originally targeting at antidepressant effects, we applied a 10-session rTMS therapy in patients with depression and MUS-pain (n = 16) and those with depression alone (n = 10) and followed them for another three months, in order to investigate the interaction between painful and depressive symptoms. Results: In this study, we totally recruited 40 patients with MUS-pain and 10 patients without MUS-pain. We found that a two-week navigated 10-Hz rTMS over the left DLPFC was signifi cantly more effective in treating MUS-pain than sham rTMS (p ＜ 0.05), and the analgesic effects of the treatment was independent of its antidepressant effects. We also found a higher rate of relapse for depression in patients whose MUS-pain responded poorly to rTMS. Conclusion: Our report has identifi ed an rTMS analgesic effect for MUS-pain in depressed patients. Our data strongly indicate that MUS-pain should be aggressively identifi ed in patients with major depressive disorder because of its detrimental effect on treatment outcome.

1. Avery, DH,Holtzheimer, PE, 3rd(2006).A controlled study of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in medication-resistant major depression.Biol Psychiatry,59,187-194.
2. Avery, DH,Holtzheimer, PE, III,Fawaz, W(2007).Transcranial magnetic stimulation reduces pain in patients with major depression: a sham-controlled study.J Nerv Ment Dis,195,378-381.
3. Bair, MJ,Robinson, RL,Eckert, GJ,Stang, PE,Croghan, TW,Kroenke, K(2004).Impact of pain on depression treatment response in primary care.Psychosom Med,66,17-22.
4. Borckardt, JJ,Smith, AR,Reeves, ST(2009).A pilot study investigating the effects of fast left prefrontal rTMS on chronic neuropathic pain.Pain Med,10,840-849.
5. Brighina, F,Piazza, A,Vitello, G(2004).rTMS of the prefrontal cortex in the treatment of chronic migraine: a pilot study.J Neurol Sci,227,67-71.
6. Burton, C(2003).Beyond somatisation: a review of the understanding and treatment of medically unexplained physical symptoms (MUPS).Br J Gen Pract,53,231-239.
7. Gundel, H,Valet, M,Sorg, C(2008).Altered cerebral response to noxious heat stimulation in patients with somatoform pain disorder.Pain,137,413-421.
8. Henningsen, P,Zimmermann, T,Sattel, H(2003).Medically unexplained physical symptoms, anxiety, and depression: a meta-analytic review.Psychosom Med,65,528-533.
9. Hofbauer, RK,Rainville, P,Duncan, GH,Bushnell, MC(2001).Cortical representation of the sensory dimension of pain.J Neurophysiol,86,402-411.
10. Leiknes, KA,Finset, A,Moum, T,Sandanger, I(2007).Course and predictors of medically unexplained pain symptoms in the general population.J Psychosom Res,62,119-128.
11. Li, CT,Chen, MH,Juan, CH(2014).Efficacy of prefrontal theta-burst stimulation in refractory depression: a randomized sham-controlled study.Brain,137,2088-2098.
12. Li, CT,Chou, YH,Yang, KC,Yang, CH,Lee, YC,Su, TP(2009).Medically unexplained symptoms and somatoform disorders: diagnostic challenges to psychiatrists.J Chin Med Assoc,72,251-256.
13. Li, CT,Lin, CP,Chou, KH(2010).Structural and cognitive deficits in remitting and non-remitting recurrent depression: a voxel-based morphometric study.NeuroImage,50,347-356.
14. Li, CT,Su, TP,Hsieh, JC,Ho, ST(2013).Efficacy and practical issues of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on chronic medically unexplained symptoms of pain.Acta Anaesthesiol Taiwanica,51,81-87.
15. Li, CT,Su, TP,Wang, SJ,Tu, PC,Hsieh, JC(2015).Prefrontal glucose metabolism in medication-resistant major depression.Brit J Psychiatry,206,316-323.
16. Li, CT,Wang, SJ,Hirvonen, J(2010).Antidepressant mechanism of add-on repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in medication-resistant depression using cerebral glucose metabolism.J Affect Disord,27,219-229.
17. Lorenz, J,Minoshima, S,Casey, KL(2003).Keeping pain out of mind: the role of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in pain modulation.Brain,126,1079-1091.
18. O’Reardon, JP,Fontecha, JF,Cristancho, MA,Newman, S(2007).Unexpected reduction in migraine and psychogenic headaches following rTMS treatment for major depression: a report of two cases.CNS Spectr,12,921-925.
19. Rumi, DO,Gattaz, WF,Rigonatti, SP(2005).Transcranial magnetic stimulation accelerates the antidepressant effect of amitriptyline in severe depression: a double-blind placebo-controlled study.Biol Psychiatry,57,162-166.
20. Short, EB,Borckardt, JJ,Anderson, BS(2011).Ten sessions of adjunctive left prefrontal rTMS significantly reduces fibromyalgia pain: a randomized, controlled pilot study.Pain,152,2477-2484.
21. Simon, GE,VonKorff, M,Piccinelli, M,Fullerton, C,Ormel, J(1999).An international study of the relation between somatic symptoms and depression.N Engl J Med,341,1329-1335.
22. Smith, MT,Edwards, RR,Robinson, RC,Dworkin, RH(2004).Suicidal ideation, plans, and attempts in chronic pain patients: factors associated with increased risk.Pain,111,201-208.
23. Smith, RC,Gardiner, JC,Lyles, JS(2005).Exploration of DSM-IV criteria in primary care patients with medically unexplained symptoms.Psychosom Med,67,123-129.
24. Stoeter, P,Bauermann, T,Nickel, R(2007).Cerebral activation in patients with somatoform pain disorder exposed to pain and stress: an fMRI study.NeuroImage,36,418-430.
25. Valet, M,Gundel, H,Sprenger, T(2009).Patients with pain disorder show gray-matter loss in pain-processing structures: a voxel-based morphometric study.Psychosom Med,71,49-56.