How Do Patients' Attendance Profiles Influence Psychotherapy Terminations? A Preliminary Exploration

10.4103/TPSY.TPSY_21_20

Ta-Ho Yang；Shuh-Ren Jin

cancellation ； dropout ； no show ； premature termination

台灣精神醫學

34卷2期（2020 / 06 / 01）

84 - 91

英文

Objectives: In this study, we intended to examine the differences in patients' attendance profile during psychotherapy process among three patient groups who ultimately completed treatment, prematurely terminate treatment with or without informing therapist in advance. We also attempted to find an effective predicting model to discriminate those three groups. Methods: We used the data of the process notes of 982 time-limited individual therapy sessions over five years, composing of 97 adult patients who were treated by a therapist in a Taiwan psychiatric center. We analyzed 10 attendance variables retrospectively in coded session by session. Results: Three patient groups existed with notable differences in their punctuality, cancellation, no-show, treatment-stage attendance, and overall attendance rates. But no clear difference was observed in the other six variables (time change, early or delayed leave, between-session contact, and evaluation-stage attendance rates). Cancellation and no show were effective variables to distinguish three patient groups. The overall correct predicting rate of the regression model was 67%, and the individual correct predicting rate for treatment completers, informers, and noninformers was 75%, 52.8%, and 75.9%, respectively. No show as a variable clearly discriminated completers from noninformers and informers from noninformers, whereas cancellation variable clearly distinguished completers from informers. Conclusion: Patients with and without informing their therapists before premature termination showed different characteristics. Cancellation and no show in each therapy session were pre-dropout warning signs for later premature termination. Those two behaviors had substantial implications and strong predicting power on the patients' termination conditions.

1. Yang, T,Jing, S(2018).Predicting termination conditions in individual psychotherapy from patients’ variables.Taiwan J Psychiatry,32,126-135.
   連結：
2. Barrett, MS,Chua, WJ,Crits-Christoph, P(2008).Early withdrawal from mental health treatment: implications for psychotherapy practice.Psychotherapy,45,247-267.
3. Beckham, EE(1992).Predicting patient dropout in psychotherapy.Psychotherapy,29,177-182.
4. Berrigan, LP,Garfield, SL(1981).Relationship of missed psychotherapy appointments to premature termination and social class.Br J Clin Psychol,20,239-242.
5. Corning, AF,Malofeeva, EV(2004).The application of survival analysis to the study of psychotherapy termination.J Couns Psychol,51,354-367.
6. Dahl, H(ed.),Kachele, H(ed.),Thoma, H(ed.)(2012).Psychoanalytic Process Research Strategies.Berlin:Springer.
7. Dale, P,Allen, J,Measor, L(1998).Counselling adults who were abused as children: clients’ perceptions of efficacy, client-counsellor communication, and dissatisfaction.Br J Guid Couns,26,141-157.
8. Dreher, AU(2000).Foundation for Conceptual Research in Psychoanalysis.London:Karnac Books.
9. Gans, JS,Counselman, EF(1996).The missed session: a neglected aspect of psychodynamic psychotherapy.Psychotherapy,33,43-50.
10. Green, J(2019).Storrs, Connecticut, USA,University of Connecticut.
11. Gülüm, IV,Soygüt, G,Safran, JD(2018).A comparison of pre-dropout and temporary rupture sessions in psychotherapy.Psychother Res,28,685-707.
12. Horner, MS,Diamond, D(1996).Object relations development and psychotherapy dropout in borderline outpatients.Psychoanal Psychol,13,205-223.
13. Johnson, E,Mellor, D,Brann, P(2009).Factors associated with dropout and diagnosis in child and adolescent mental health services.Aust N Z J Psychiatry,43,431-437.
14. Joyce, AS,Piper, WE,Ogrodniczuk, JS(2007).Termination in Psychotherapy. A Psychodynamic Model of Processes and Outcomes.Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
15. Klein, EB,Stone, WN,Hicks, MH(2003).Understanding dropouts.J Ment Health Couns,25,89-100.
16. Mann, J(1973).Time-limited Psychotherapy.Cambridge, United Kingdoms:Harvard University Press.
17. Mann, J,Goldman, R(2004).A Casebook in Time-Limited Psychotherapy.Maryland, USA:Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
18. McGuff, R,Gitlin, D,Enderlin, M(1996).Clients and therapists confidence and attendance at planned individual therapy sessions.Psychol Rep,79,537-538.
19. McLeod, J(2011).Qualitative Research in Counselling and Psychotherapy.London:Sage.
20. Murphy, MJ,DeBernardo, CR,Shoemaker, WE(1998).Impact of managed care on independent practice and professional ethics: a survey of independent practitioners.Prof Psychol Res Pr,29,43-51.
21. Norcross, JC(ed.)(2011).Psychotherapy Relationships That Work: Therapists Contributions and Responsiveness to Patients.Oxford, United Kingdoms:Oxford University Press.
22. O’Keeffe, S,Martin, P,Goodyer, IM(2018).Predicting dropout in adolescents receiving therapy for depression.Psychother Res,28,708-721.
23. Piper, WE,Ogrodniczuk, JS,Joyce, AS(1999).Prediction of dropping out in the time-limited, interpretive individual psychotherapy.Psychotherapy,36,114-122.
24. Rennie, DL(1994).Clients’ accounts of resistance in counseling: a qualitative analysis.Canadian J Couns,28,43-57.
25. Roseborough, DJ,McLeod, JT,Wright, FI(2016).Attrition in psychotherapy: a survival analysis.Res Soc Work Pract,26,803-815.
26. Sharf, J,Primavera, LH,Diener, MJ(2010).Dropout and therapeutic alliance: a meta-analysis of adult individual psychotherapy.Psychotherapy,47,637-645.
27. Strupp, HH,Binder, J(1984).Psychotherapy in a New Key: A Guide to Time-Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy.New York:Basic Books.
28. Swift, JK,Greenberg, RP(2012).Premature discontinuation in adult psychotherapy: a meta-analysis.J Consult Clin Psychol,80,547-559.
29. Swift, JK,Greenberg, RP(2015).Premature Termination in Psychotherapy: strategies for Engaging Clients and Improving Outcomes.Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
30. Swift, JK,Greenberg, RP,Tompkins, KA(2017).Treatment refusal and premature termination in psychotherapy, pharmacotherapy, and their combination: a meta-analysis of head-to-head comparisons.Psychotherapy,54,47-57.
31. Toukmanian, SG(ed.),Rennie, DL(ed.)(1992).Psychotherapy Process Research: Paradigmatic and Narrative Approaches.Newbury Park, California, USA:Sage.
32. Wallerstein, RS(1994).Psychotherapy research and its implications for a theory of therapeutic change. a forty-year overview.Psychoanal Study Child,49,120-141.
33. Weiss, J,Sampson, H(1986).Mount Zion Psychotherapy Research Group: The Psychoanalytic Process: Theory, Clinical Observation, and Empirical Research.New York:Guilford Press.
34. Xiao, H,Hayes, JA,Castonguay, LG(2017).Therapist effects and the impacts of therapy nonattendance.Psychotherapy,54,58-65.

1. Ta-Ho Yang(2023)。A Psychodynamic Study on Premature Termination of Therapy Sessions。臺灣精神醫學，37(1)，21-28。