臺灣社區整合照顧的經驗與挑戰：以健康照護專業服務為例

The Experience and Challenge of Community - Based Integrated Care in Taiwan: The Example of Health Care Services

10.6785/SPSW.201912_23(2).0005

李佩芳(Pei-Fang Lee)；鄭清霞(Ching-Hsia Cheng)

長期照顧 ； 整合式照顧 ； 健康照護專業服務 ； Long-term Care ； Integrated Care ； Health Care Service

社會政策與社會工作學刊

23卷2期（2019 / 12 / 01）

179 - 223

繁體中文

為了實踐在地老化並降低醫療與長期照護成本，以居家社區為基礎的長期照護服務整合模式，受到老化國家的重視與推廣，臺灣也積極發展整合服務，為此，本研究以剛起步的臺灣長期照顧2.0制度運作的整合服務為研究標的，採用焦點團體、深度訪談與實地觀察方法，以Reed et al.（2005）之微觀、中觀及鉅觀三種層次架構，分析當前臺灣社區整合照顧發展的經驗與挑戰，希望能提供政策發展參考。本研究主要發現如下：（1）支付制度讓競爭關係大於整合關係，建議增強整合誘因與機制；（2）欠缺品質檢核機制，應透過專業對話，建立專業的權限、角色、責任與問責；（3）個案資訊取得不易，造成整合服務的高門檻與困難度；（4）整合服務缺乏統整、協調的決策者，建議照管專員或A個管承擔此角色發揮功能。

In order to practice aging in place and reduce the cost of medical care and long-term care, the home and community-based integration model is valued and promoted by the aging countries. Taiwan is also actively developing integrated care. Hence, the purpose of this research is to observe the integration care practice under the Taiwan's long-term care 2.0 system, and provide suggestions for policy development through the practical experience analysis. This study uses focus group, depth interviews and observation research methods to collect the integrate care practice information and uses the micro, meso and macro views constructed by Reed et al. (2005) to analyze the current experience and challenges of integrated care in Taiwan. The main results of this research are:(1) The payment system makes the competition relationship greater than the integration relationship between the professional workers, and it should be recommended to enhance the integration incentives and mechanisms; (2) The system lacks a quality supervision mechanism. This system should be developed through discussion between different professional worker to clarify the different professional worker's authority, role, and responsibility; (3) It is difficult to obtain client's information, which leads to the barriers in integrated care; (4) The system lacks a decision-makers to enhance the consolidation and coordination of the integrated care. The care manager or case manager should play this role.

1. Béland, F.,Bergman, H.,Lebel, P.,Clarfield, A. M.,Tousignant, P.,Contandriopoulos, A. P.,Dallaire, L.(2006).A System of Integrated Care for Older Persons with Disabilities in Canada: Results from a Randomized Controlled Trial.The Journals of Gerontology Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences,61(4),367-373.
2. Bernabei, R.,Landi, F.,Gambassi, G.,Sgadari, A.,Zuccala, G.,Mor, V.,Rubenstein, L. Z.,Carbonin, P.(1998).Randomised Trial of Impact of Model of Integrated Care and Case Management for Older People Living in the Community.British Medical Journal,316(7141),1348-1351.
3. Bird, S. R.,Kurowski, W.,Dickman, G. K.,Kronborg, I.(2007).Integrated Care Facilitation for Older Patients with Complex Health Care Needs Reduces Hospital Demand.Australian Health Review,31(3),451-461.
4. Coleman, E. A.,Boult, C.(2003).Improving the Quality of Transitional Care for Persons with Complex Care Needs: Position Statement of the American Geriatrics Society Health Care Systems Committee.Journal of the American Geriatrics Society,51(4),556-557.
5. Eng, C.,Pedulla, J.,Eleazer, G. P.,McCann, R.,Fox, N.(1997).Program of All Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE): An Innovative Model of Integrated Geriatric Care and Financing.Journal of the American Geriatrics Society,45(2),223-232.
6. Gilmour, J. A.(2002).Dis/Integrated Care: Family Caregivers and In Hospital Respite Care.Journal of Advanced Nursing,39(6),546-553.
7. Goodwin, N.,Dixon, A.,Anderson, G.,Wodchis, v(2014).Providing Integrated Care for Older People with Complex Needs: Lessons from Seven International Case Studies.London:The King’s Fund.
8. Gröne, O.,Garcia-Barbero, M.(2001).A position paper of the WHO European office for integrated health care services.Int J Integr Care,1
9. Ham, C.,Curry, N.(2011).Integrated Care: What is it? Does It Work? What Dose It Mean for the NHS?.London:The King’s Fund.
10. Johri, M.,Beland, F.,Bergman, H.(2003).International Experiments in Integrated Care for the Elderly: A Synthesis of the Evidence.International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry,18(3),222-235.
11. Kodner, D. L.(2002).The Quest for Integrated Systems of Care for Frail Older Persons.Aging Clinical and Experimental Research,14(4),307-313.
12. Kodner, D. L.,Spreeuwenberg, C.(2002).Integrated Care: Meaning, Logic, Applications, and Implications–A Discussion Paper.International Journal of Integrated Care
13. Loader, B. D.,Hardey, M.,Keeble, L.(2008).Health Informatics for Older People: A Review of ICT Facilitated Integrated Care for Older People.International Journal of Social Welfare,17(1),46-53.
14. Matsuda, S.,Yamamoto, M.(2001).Long-Term Care Insurance and Integrated Care for the Aged in Japan.International Journal of Integrated Care
15. Mur-Veeman, I.,Hardy, B.,Steenbergen, M.,Wistow, G.(2003).Development of Integrated Care in England and the Netherlands: Managing Across Public–Private Boundaries.Health Policy,65(3),227-241.
16. Nies, H.(ed.),Berman, P.C.(ed.)(2004).Integrated Services for Older People: A resource book for managers.Dublin:EHMA.
17. Reed, J.,Cook, G.,Childs, S.,McCormack, B.(2005).A Literature Review to Explore Integrated Care for Older People.International Journal of Integrated
18. Shaw, S.,Rosen, R.,Rumbold, B.(2011).What is Integrated Care.London:Nuffield Trust.
19. Valentijn, P. P.,Schepman, S. M.,Opheij, W.,Bruijnzeels, M. A.(2013).Understanding Integrated Care: A Comprehensive Conceptual Framework Based on the Integrative Functions of Primary Care.International Journal of Integrated Care
20. Vedel, I.,De Stampa, M.,Bergman, H.,Ankri, J.,Cassou, B.,Mauriat, C.,Blanchard, F.,Bagaragaza, E.,Lapointe, L.(2009).A Novel Model of Integrated Care for the Elderly: COPA, Coordination of Professional Care for the Elderly.Aging Clinical and Experimental Research,21(6),414-423.
21. World Health Organization(2017).Integrated Care for Older People: Guidelines on Community-Level Interventions to Manage Declines in Intrinsic Capacity.København:World Health Organization.
22. World Health Organization(1999).Health21: The Health for All Policy Framework for the WHO European Region.København:World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe.
23. 衛生福利部（2017）。《長期照顧（照顧服務、專業服務、交通接送服務、輔具服務及居家無障礙環境改善服務）給付及支付基準》。衛福部長照專區網頁（https://1966.gov.tw/LTC/cp-4212-44992-201.html）。
24. 衛生福利部（2016）。《長期照顧十年計畫 2.0》。衛福部長照專區網頁（https://1966.gov.tw/LTC/cp-4001-42414-201.html）。
25. 衛生福利部（2018）。《長照專業服務手冊》。衛生福利部網頁（https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-49634-4dcee073-bc31-45e0-88f8-f31876d506b1.html）。
26. 鄭清霞,李佩芳(2018)。嘉義縣政府社會局委託研究報告嘉義縣政府社會局委託研究報告,未出版

1. 黃源協,莊俐昕(2021)。「以社區為基礎」的照顧模式之檢視：網絡治理觀點的分析。臺大社會工作學刊，44，133-173。
2. 詹弘廷,梁鎧麟,張力亞,李希昌,江大樹(2020)。建置社區巷弄長照站的培力與治理策略：水沙連區域的行動研究。社會政策與社會工作學刊，24(2)，143-182。
3. 鄭清霞,鄭如婷,李佩芳,王靜怡(2022)。社區照顧的創新：初探嘉義東石「耆樂居」。人文社會科學研究，16(1)，53-84。
4. (2022)。從長照人力媒合平臺興起探討我國長照政策未竟事宜。社區發展季刊，178，404-415。