题名

服務創新保護模式探討－以統合觀點分析

并列篇名

Appropriability Modes in Service Sectors: Towards a Synthesis Approach

作者

陳旻男(Min-Nan Chen)；薄榮薇(Rung-Wei, Stacy Po)；張䕒心(Chia-Hsin Chang)

关键词

創新保護 ； 統合觀點 ； 公司具體性 ； Appropriability ； Synthesis approach ； Firm-specificity

期刊名称

科技管理學刊

卷期/出版年月

23卷3期（2018 / 09 / 01）

页次

1 - 34

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究旨在探討台灣服務創新保護模式，採用服務創新理論中統合觀點與公司具體性為理論基礎，同時考量正式化與非正式化創新保護機制，以發展服務創新保護模式。本研究選擇第二次台灣產業創新活動調查（2004-2006）中1,769服務業為實證對象，透過二階段集群分析方法，整合階層與非階層統計方式，提出四項台灣服務創新保護模式：（1）無明顯保護模式、（2）非正式化保護為基礎模式、（3）正式化保護為基礎模式、（4）混合保護為基礎模式。本研究認為服務業選擇創新保護模式是基於公司屬性與創新活動特性的不同，存在公司具體化差異，不同服務業中的企業可能存在相似的創新行為，選擇相同的保護模式；最後本研究針對這四項創新保護模式提出具體管理意涵與政策建議。
英文摘要

This study developed appropriablity modes in Taiwanese service firms. Derived from the synthesis approach and firm-specificity to study service innovations, we took both formal and informal appropribility forms into account. Based on the dataset of 1,769 service firms from Taiwan Innovation Survey (2004-2006), we conducted a two-step cluster analysis technique, combining the hierarchical and non-hierarchical methods to characterize the appropriability modes. The four distinct appropriability modes were identified as follows: (1) non-appropriability mode, (2) informal-oriented mode, (3) formal-oriented mode, and (4) joint use-oriented mode. The study revealed that appropriability modes in service sectors differ from ones in manufacturing that characterize the firm-specific features to conduct their protection patterns. Different service firms may conduct the homogeneous appropriability modes even if they were categorized into the different sectors. We concluded that the firm-specificity plays an impotanct role in conducting appropriabilie modes and innovation protection patterns. Finally, several management and policy implications for these appropriability modes were provided.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 陳旻男、張元杰、孫禎罄(2017)。知識密集型服務業的創新保護─以資訊服務業為例。管理評論，36(3)，1-20。
    連結：
  2. 陳旻男、張元杰、孫禎罄(2017)。知識密集型服務業的創新保護─以資訊服務業為例。管理評論，36(3)，1-20。
    連結：
  3. Amara, N.,Landry, R.,Traoré, N.(2008).Managing the Protection of Innovations in Knowledge-Intensive Business Services.Research Policy,37(9),1530-1547.
  4. Anderberg, M.R.(1973).Cluster Analysis for Applications.New York:Academic.
  5. Anderson, B.,Howells, J.(2000).Intellectual Property Rights Shaping Innovation in Services.USA:Edward Elgar.
  6. Archibugi, D.(2001).Pavitt's Taxonomy Sixteen Years On: A Review Article.Economics of Innovation and New Technology,10(5),415-425.
  7. Arora, A.,Ceccagnoli, M.(2006).Patent Protection, Complementary Assets, and Firms'incentives for Technology Licensing.Management Science,52(2),293-308.
  8. Arundel, A.(2001).The Relative Effectiveness of Patents and Secrecy for Appropriation.Research Policy,30(4),611-624.
  9. Arundel, A.,Kabla, I.(1998).What Percentage of Innovations Are Patented? Empirical Estimates for European Firms.Research Policy,27(2),127-141.
  10. Bader, M.A.(2008).Managing Intellectual Property in the Financial Services Industry Sector: Learning from Swiss Re.Technovation,28(4),196-207.
  11. Barney, J.B.(1991).Firm Resource and Sustained Competitive Advantage.Journal of Management,17(1),99-120.
  12. Berry, L.L.,Shankar, V.,Parish, J.T.,Cadwallader, S.,Dotzel, T.(2006).Creating New Markets through Service Innovation.MIT Sloan Management Review,47(2),56-63.
  13. Blind, K.,Edler, J.,Schmoch, U.,Andersen, B.,Howells, J.,Miles, I.,Roberts, J.,Green, L.,Evangelista, R.,Hipp, C.,Herstatt, C.,Evangelisto, R.(2003).Patents in the Service Industries.Karlsruhe:Fraunhofer ISI, European Commission.
  14. Boden, M.(Ed.),Miles, I.(Ed.)(2000).Services and the Knowledge-Based Economy.London:Continuum.
  15. Bolisani, E.,Paiola, M.,Scarso, E.(2013).Knowledge Protection in Knowledge-Intensive Business Services.Journal of Intellectual Capital,14(2),192-211.
  16. Boxall, P.(1998).Achieving Competitive Advantage through Human Resource Strategy: Towards a Theory of Industry Dynamics.Human Resource Management Review,8(3),265-288.
  17. Breschi, S.,Malerba, F.(1997).Sectoral Innovation Systems: Technological Regimes, Schumpeterian Dynamics, and Spatial Boundaries.Routledge press:London.
  18. Brusoni, S.,Prencipe, A.,Pavitt, K.L.(2001).Knowledge Specialization and the Boundaries of the Firm: Why Do Firms Know More Than They Make?.Administrative Science Quarterly,46(4),597-621.
  19. Castellacci, F.(2008).Technological Paradigms, Regime and Trajectories: Manufacturing and Service Industries in a New Taxonomy of Sectoral Patterns of Innovation.Research Policy,37(6-7),978-994.
  20. Chang, Y.C.,Chen, M.N.(2016).Service Regime and Innovation Cluters: An Empirical Study from Service Firms in Taiwan.Research Policy,45(9),1845-1857.
  21. Chang, Y.C.,Linton, J.D.,Chen, M.N.(2012).Service Regime: An Empirical Analysis of Innovation Patterns in Service Firms.Technological Forecasting and Social Chang,79(9),1569-1582.
  22. Chang, Y.C.,Yen, H.J.(2012).Introduction to the Special Cluster on Managing Technology-Service Fusion Innovation.Technovation,32(7-8),415-418.
  23. Clarkson, G.,Toh, P.(2010)."Keep out" Signs: The Role of Deterrence in the Competition for Resources.Strategic Management Journal,31(11),1202-1225.
  24. Cohen, W.M.,Goto, A.,Nagata, A.,Nelson, R.R.(2002).R&D Spillovers, Patents and the Incentives to Innovate in Japan and the United States.Research Policy,31(8-9),1349-1367.
  25. Cohen, W.M.,Nelson, R.R.,Walsh, J.P.(1996).New S&T indicators for the Knowledge-Based EconomyNew S&T indicators for the Knowledge-Based Economy,Paris:.
  26. Cohen, W.M.,Nelson, R.R.,Walsh, J.P.(2000).NBER working paperNBER working paper,National Bureau of Economic Research.
  27. Coombs, R.,Miles, I.(2000).Innovation, Measurement and Services: The New Problematique.Innovation Systems in the Service Economy,Springer:
  28. de Jong, J.P.J.,Marsili, O.(2006).The Fruit Flies of Innovations: A Taxonomy of Innovative Small Firms.Research Policy,35(2),213-229.
  29. Delerue, H.,Lejeune, A.(2010).Job Mobility Restriction Mechanisms and Appropriability in Organizations: The Mediating Role of Secrecy and Lead Time.Technovation,30(5-6),359-366.
  30. Dosi, G.(1988).Sources, Procedures, and Microeconomic Effects of Innovation.Journal of Economic Literature,26(3),1120-1171.
  31. Dosi, G.(1982).Technological Paradigms and Technological Trajectories: A Suggested Interpretation of the Determinants and Directions of Technical Change.Research Policy,11(3),147-162.
  32. Dosi, G.(1991).Perspective on Evolutionary Theory.Science and Public Policy,18,353-361.
  33. Drejer, I.(2004).Identifying Innovation in Surveys of Services: A Schumpeterian Perspective.Research Policy,33(3),551-562.
  34. Encaoua, D.,Guellec, D.,Martínez, C.(2006).Patent Systems for Encouraging Innovation: Lessons from Economic Analysis.Research Policy,35(9),1423-1440.
  35. Ernst, H.(2001).Patent Applications and Subsequent Changes of Performance: Evidence from Time-Series Cross-Section Analyses on the Firm Level.Research Policy,30(1),143-157.
  36. Evangelista, R.(2000).Sectoral Patterns of Technological Change in Services.Economics of Innovation and New Technologies,9(3),521-536.
  37. Fischer, T.,Henkel, J.(2013).Complements and Substitutes in Profiting from Innovation-a Choice Experimental Approach.Research Policy,42(2),326-339.
  38. Gadrey, J.,Gallouj, F.,Weinstein, O.(1995).New Modes of Innovation: How Services Benefit Industry.Industry Management,6(3),4-16.
  39. Gallié, E.P.,Legros, D.(2012).French Firms' Strategies for Protecting Their Intellectual Property.Research Policy,41(4),780-794.
  40. Gallouj, F.(2002).Innovation in the Service Economy: The New Wealth of Nations.Northamton:Edward Elgar.
  41. Gallouj, F.,Windrum, P.(2009).Service and Service Innovation.Journal of Evolutionary Economics,19(2),141-148.
  42. Grant, R.M.(1991).The Resource Based Theory of Competitive Advantage: Implications for Strategy Formation.California Management Review,33(3),114-135.
  43. Hair, J.F.,Anderson, R.E.,Tatham, R.L.,Black, W.C.(1998).Multivariate Data Analysis.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Pearson Prentice Hall.
  44. Hall, R.(1992).The Strategy Analysis of Intangible Resources.Straegic Management Journal,13(1),135-144.
  45. Hanel, P.(2006).Intellectual Property Rights Business Management Practices: A Survey of the Literature.Technovation,26(8),895-931.
  46. Harabi, N.(1995).Appropriability of Technical Innovations an Empirical Analysis.Research Policy,24(6),981-992.
  47. Hipp, C.,Grupp, H.(2005).Innovation in the Service Sector: The Demand for Service-Specific Innovation Measurement Concepts and Typologies.Research Policy,34(4),517-535.
  48. Hollenstein, H.(2003).Innovation Modes in the Swiss Service Sector: A Cluster Analysis Based on Firm-Level Data.Research Policy,32(5),845-863.
  49. Howells, J.,Blind, K.,Elder, J.,Evangelista, R.(2003).fraunhofer institute systems and innovation researchfraunhofer institute systems and innovation research,Karlsruhe, Germany:.
  50. Hurmelinna-Laukkanen, P.,Puumalainen, K.(2007).Nature and Dynamics of Appropriability: Strategies for Appropriating Returns on Innovation.R&D Management,37(2),95-112.
  51. Johnson, R.A.,Wichern, D.W.(2007).Applied Multivariate Statistical Analysis.Upper Saddle River, N.J:Prentice Hall.
  52. Ketchen, D.J.,Shook, C.L.(1997).The Application of Cluster Analysis in Strategic Management Research: An Analysis and Critique.Strategic Management Journal,17(6),441-458.
  53. Leiponen, A.,Byma, J.(2009).You Cannot Block, You Better Run: Small Firms, Co-Operative Innovation and Appropriability Strategies.Research Policy,38(9),1478-1488.
  54. Leiponen, A.,Drejer, I.(2007).What Exactly Are Technological Regimes? Intra-Industry Heterogeneity in the Organization of Innovation Activities.Research Policy,36(8),1221-1238.
  55. Levin, R.C.,Klevorick, A.K.,Nelson, R.R.,Winter, S.G.(1987).Appropriating the Returns from Industrial Research and Development.Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,1987(3),783-831.
  56. Lieberman, M.B.,Montgomery, D.B.(1998).First-Mover (Dis)Advantages: Retrospective and Link with the Resource-Based View.Straegic Management Journal,19(12),1111-1125.
  57. Lieberman, M.B.,Montgomery, D.B.(1988).First-Mover Advantages.Straegic Management Journal,9(1),41-58.
  58. Lopez, L.E.,Roberts, E.B.(2002).First-Mover Advantages in Regimes of Weak Appropriability: The Case of Financial Services Innovation.Journal of Business Research,55(12),997-1005.
  59. Lu, L.Y.(2007).Protecting Intellectual Property Rights.Research-Technology Management,50(2),51-56.
  60. Maurer, S.D.,Zugelder, M.T.(2000).Trade Secret Management in High Technology: A Legal Review and Research Agenda.The Journal of High Technology Management Research,11(2),155-174.
  61. Mauri, A.J.,Michaels, M.P.(1998).Firm and Industry Effects within Strategic Management: An Empirical Examination.Strategic Management Journal,19(3),211-219.
  62. Mendonça, S.,Pereira, T.S.,Godinho, M.M.(2004).Trademarks as an Indicator of Innovation and Industrial Change.Research Policy,33(9),1385-1404.
  63. Metcalfe, J.S.(Ed.),Miles, I.(Ed.)(2000).Innovation Systems in the Service Economy, Measurement and Case Study Analysis.Boston:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
  64. Miles, I.,Andersen, B.,Boden, M.,Howells, J.(2000).Service Production and Intellectual Property.International Journal of Technology Management,20(1/2),95-115.
  65. Milligan, G.W.,Sokol, L.W.(1980).A Two-Stage Clustering Algorithm with Robust Recovery Characteristics.Educational and Psychological Measurement,40(3),755-759.
  66. Miozzo, M.,Soete, L.(2001).Internationalization of Services: A Technological Perspective.Technological Forecasting and Social Change,67(4),159-185.
  67. Nelson, R.R.(1991).Why Do Firms Differ and How Does It Matter?.Strategic Management Journal,12,61-74.
  68. Nelson, R.R.,Winter, S.G.(1977).In Search of Useful Theory of Innovation.Research Policy,6(1),36-76.
  69. Nelson, R.R.,Winter, S.G.(1982).An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
  70. Nordenflycht, A.V.(2010).What Is a Professional Service Firm? Toward a Theory and Taxonomy of Knowledge-Intensive Firms.Academy of Management Review,35(1),155-174.
  71. OECD(2005).Oslo Manual: Guidelines for Collecting and Interpreting Innovation Data.Paris:Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
  72. Olander, H.,Hurmelinna-Laukkanen, P.,Mähönen, J.(2009).What's Small Size Got to Do with It? Protection of Intellectual Assets in Smes.International Journal of Innovation Management,13(3),349-370.
  73. Päällysaho, S.,Kuusisto, J.(2011).Informal Ways to Protect Intellectual Property (Ip) in Kibs Businesses.Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice,13(1),62-76.
  74. Päällysaho, S.,Kuusisto, J.(2008).Intellectual Property Protection as a Key Driver of Service Innovation: An Analysis of Innovative Kibs Businesses in Finland and Uk.International Journal of Services Technology and Management,9(3),268-284.
  75. Pavitt, K.(1984).Sectoral Patterns of Technical Change: Toward a Taxonomy and a Theory.Research Policy,13(6),343-373.
  76. Sanz, E.(2015).Copyright Indicators and the Costs of Symbolic Production: The Cultural Dimension of Telecommunications.Telecommunications Policy,39(3-4),208-217.
  77. Schmoch, U.(2003).Service Marks as Novel Innovation Indicator.Research Evaluation,12(2),149-156.
  78. Sirilli, G.,Evangelista, R.(1998).Technological Innovation in Services and Manufacturing: Results from Italian Surveys.Research Policy,27(9),881-899.
  79. Sofka, W.,Shehu, E.,de Faria, P.(2014).Multinational Subsidiary Knowledge Protection-Do Mandatesand Clusters Matter?.Research Policy,43(8),1320-1333.
  80. Sundbo, J.(1997).Management of Innovation in Services.The Service Industries Journal,17(3),432-455.
  81. Tether, B.S.,Hipp, C.,Miles, I.(2001).Standardization and Particularization in Services: Evidence from Germany.Research Policy,30(4),1115-1138.
  82. Tether, B.S. & Metcalfe, J.S. (2003), Services And'systems of Innovation'. University of Manchester, Manchester.
  83. Thomä, J.,Bizer, K.(2013).To Protect or Not to Protect? Modes of Appropriability in the Small Enterprise Sector.Research Policy,42(1),35-49.
  84. Vargo, S.L.,Lusch, R.F.(2004).Evolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing.Journal of Marketing,68(1),1-17.
  85. Wang, H.,Chen, W.R.(2010).Is Firm-Specific Innovation Associated with Greater Value Appropriation? The Roles of Environmental Dynamism and Technological Diversity.Research Policy,39(1),141-154.
  86. Wernerfelt, B.(1984).A Resource-Based View of the Firm.Straegic Management Journal,5(2),171-180.
  87. Windrum, P.,Garcia-Goni, M.(2008).A Neo-Schumpeterian Model of Health Service Innovation.Research Policy,37(4),649-672.
  88. 行政院主計處（2018）， 「中華民國行業標準分類，」行政院主計處網站，取自：https://www.dgbas.gov.tw。
  89. 吳思華(2013)。,未出版
  90. 楊智傑(2012)。著作權法：理論與實務。台北:學林出版社。
  91. 經濟部智慧財產權局（2014），「法規資訊」，經濟部智慧財產權局網站，取自：https://www.tipo.gov.tw/np.asp?ctNode=6861&mp=1。
  92. 詹炳耀(2009)。智慧財產權新論。台北:華立圖書。
被引用次数
  1. (2020)。混合式創新保護機制之動態歷程─資訊系統開發個案分析。產業與管理論壇，22(4)，60-79。
print cancel