台灣學術創業之發展與挑戰：科技基本法之省思與期許

The Development and Challenges of University Spin-off in Taiwan: Reflections and Expectations of Science & Technology Basic Law

胡欣怡(Hsin-Yi Hu)；吳豐祥(Feng-Shang Wu)

大學衍生企業 ； 學術創業 ； 技術移轉 ； 科技基本法 ； University Spin-off ； Academic Entrepreneurship ； Technology Transfer ； Science & Technology Basic Law

科技管理學刊

25卷2期（2020 / 06 / 01）

61 - 89

繁體中文

近年來產學合作的發展逐漸受到各國的重視，許多專家學者甚至認為它是影響國家產業競爭力最為關鍵的因素之一。透過產學互動，可以將大學的研究成果移轉到產業，或者衍生新創企業。而後者更具有其挑戰性，除了須有前瞻的技術與專業的經營團隊之外，整體基礎環境、制度與相關的法規、政策等，也都是影響大學能否順利發展衍生企業（Spin-off）的關鍵因素。台灣亦非常重視這方面的發展，自1999年起通過科技基本法，始將政府研發專案成果之智慧財產權轉授給各個執行機構，以推動研究機構研發成果之商業化。然而，與歐美日等各國相較，在相關的基礎建設、制度、法規與政策上，似乎還有很多亟需努力之處。有鑑於此，本研究乃透過質性研究的方法與次級資料的收集，深入了解大學在發展衍生企業時所面臨的制度、環境、法規、與政策等重要因素，並探討法規政策對於學術創業之影響，希望同時呈現出理論上與實務上的貢獻。

In recent years, the development of industry-university cooperation has gradually attracted more attention of all countries. Many experts and scholars think that it is one of the most critical factors affecting national industrial competitiveness. Through the interaction of industry and university, the research results of the university can be transferred to the industry or derive a new enterprise. However, to establish start up is more challenging. In addition to the frontier technology and professional management team, the economic environment, national systems, infrastructures and related regulations and policies also affect the creation and development of the university spin offs. Taiwan government also attaches great importance to academica entrepreneurship. Since 1999, through the Science & Technology Basic Law, the intellectual property rights of government research and development projects have been transferred to various implementing agencies to promote the commercialization of research and development results from public oragnizations. However, compared with countries in Europe and the United States, a lot of hard work can be improved in related infrastructure, systems, regulations and policies in Taiwan. This study uses qualitative research method for comprehensive understanding of the university's institutional, environmental, regulatory, and policy factors in the development of university spin offs. The purpose of the study is to explore the influence of Science & Technology Basic Law for academic entrepreneurship and to present both theoretical and practical contributions.

1. 黃婉玲(2016)。研發成果商業化政策對大學校院基礎科學研究的影響。科技管理學刊，21(4)，1-32。
   連結：
2. Berbegal-Mirabent, J.,Ribeiro-Soriano, D. E.,GarcÝa, J. L. S.(2015).Can a Magic Recipe Foster University Spin-off Creation?.Journal of Business Research,68(11),2272-2278.
3. Bok, D.(2003).Universities in the Marketplace: the Commercialization of Higher Education.NJ:Princeton University Press.
4. Brown, R.(2016).Mission Impossible? Entrepreneurial Universities and Peripheral Regional Innovation Systems.Industry and Innovation,23(2),189-205.
5. Chang, Y.-C.,Yang, P. Y.,Chen, M.-H.(2009).The Determinants of Academic Research Commercialization: Towards an Organizational Ambidexterity Perspective.Research Policy,38,936-946.
6. David, F.,Van Der Sijde, P.,Van Den Besselaar, P.(2018).Academics Coping with Business Logic: A Study at Indonesian Universities.Journal of Engineering and Technology Management,49,91-108.
7. Djokovic, D.,Souitaris, V.(2008).Spinouts from Academic Institutions: A Literature Review with Suggestions for Further Research.The Journal of Technology Transfer,33(3),225-247.
8. Duval ‐ Couetil, N.(2013).Assessing the Impact of Entrepreneurship Education Programs: Challenges and Approaches.Journal of Small Business Management,51(3),394-409.
9. Etzkowitz, H.(1998).The Norms of Entrepreneurial Science: Cognitive Effects of the New University-Industry Linkages.Research Policy,27(8),823-833.
10. Fini, R.,Fu, K.,Mathisen, M. T.,Rasmussen, E.,Wright, M.(2017).Institutional Determinants of University Spin-off Quantity and Quality: A Longitudinal, Multilevel, Cross-Country Study.Small Business Economics,48(2),361-391.
11. Fini, R.,Rasmussen, E.,Siegel, D.,Wiklund, J.(2018).Rethinking the Commercialization of Public Science: from Entrepreneurial Outcomes to Societal Impacts.Academy of Management Perspectives,32(1),4-20.
12. Goldfarb, B.,Henrekson, M.(2003).Bottom-Up Versus Top-Down Policies Towards the Commercialization of University Intellectual Property.Research Policy,32,639-658.
13. Grimaldi, R.,Kenney, M.,Siegel, D. S.,Wright, M.(2011).30 Years After Bayh-Dole: Reassessing Academic Entrepreneurship.Research Policy,40(8),1045-1057.
14. Huynh, T.,Patton, D.,Arias-Aranda, D.,Molina-Fernández, L.M.(2017).University Spin-Off’s Performance: Capabilities and Networks of Founding Teams at Creation Phase.Journal of Business Research,78,10-22.
15. Kew, J.,Herrington, M.,Litovsky, Y.,Gale, H.(2013).,Cape Town:Global Entrepreneurship Monitor.
16. Kochenkova, A.,Grimaldi, R.,Munari, F.(2016).Public Policy Measures in Support of Knowledge Transfer Activities: A Review of Academic Literature.The Journal of Technology Transfer,41(3),407-429.
17. Link, A. N.,Scott, J. T.(2005).Opening the Ivory Tower’s Door: An Analysis of the Determinants of the Formation of U.S. University Spin-off Companies.Research Policy,4(7),1106-1112.
18. Lockett, A.,Wright, M.(2005).Resources, Capabilities, Risk Capital and the Creation of University Spin-Out Companies.Research Policy,34(7),1043-1057.
19. Meoli, M.,Pierucci, E.,Vismara, S.(2018).The Effects of Public Policies in Fostering University Spinoffs in Italy.Economics of Innovation and New Technology,27,479-492.
20. Mowery, D. C.,Sampat, B. N.(2005).The Bayh-Dole Act of 1980 and University-Industry Technology Transfer: A Model for Other OECD Governments.The Journal of Technology Transfer,30,115-127.
21. Mowery, D.C.,Nelson, R.R.,Sampat, B.,Ziedonis, A.(2004).Ivory Tower and Industrial Innovation.State of California:Stanford University Press.
22. Muscio, A.,Quaglione, D.,Ramaciotti, L.(2016).The Effects of University Rules on Spinoff Creation: the Case of Academia in Italy.Research Policy,45(7),1386-1396.
23. Ndonzuau, F. N.,Pirnay, F.,Surlemont, B.(2002).A Stage Model of Academic Spin-off Creation.Technovation,22,281-289.
24. Nicolaou, N.,Birley, S.(2003).Academic Networks in a Trichotomous Categorisation of University Spinouts.Journal of Business Venturing,18(3),333-359.
25. O’Shea, R. P.,Allen, T. J.,Morse, K. P.,O’Gorman, C.,Roche, F.(2007).Delineating the Anatomy of an Entrepreneurial University: the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Experience.R & D Management,37(1),1-16.
26. Pache, A. C.,Santos, F.(2013).Inside the Hybrid Organization: Selective Coupling as a Response to Competing Institutional Logics.Academy of Management Journal,56(4),972-1001.
27. Powers, J.B.,McDougall, P. P.(2005).University Start-Up Formation and Technologylicensing with Firms That Go Public: A Resource-Based View of Academicentrepreneurship.Journal of Business Venturing,20,291-311.
28. Rasmussen, E.,Borch, O. J.(2010).University Capabilities in Facilitating Entrepreneurship: A Longitudinal Study of Spinoff Ventures at Mid-Range Universities.Research Policy,39(5),602-612.
29. Rasmussen, E.,Mosey, S.,Wright, M.(2011).The Evolution of Entrepreneurial Competencies: A Longitudinal Study of University Spin-off Venture Emergence.Journal of Management Studies,48(6),1314-1345.
30. Rasmussen, E.,Wright, M.(2015).How Can Universities Facilitate Academic Spin-Offs? An Entrepreneurial Competency Perspective.The Journal of Technology Transfer,40(5),782-799.
31. Roberts, B.,Malone, D.(1996).Policies and Structures for Spinning off New Companies from Research and Development Organizations.R&D Management,26(1),17-48.
32. Roig-Tierno, N.,Alcázar, J.,Ribeiro-Navarrete, S.(2015).Use of Infrastructures to Support Innovative Entrepreneurship and Business Growth.Journal of Business Research,68,2290-2294.
33. Rosenberg, N.,Nelson, R. R.(1994).American Universities and Technical Advance in Industry.Research Policy,23(3),323-348.
34. Shane, S.(2005).Academic Entrepreneurship: University Spin-Offs and Wealth Creation.USA:Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc.
35. Shane, S.(2001).Technology Regimes and New Firm Formation.Management Science,47(9),1173-1190.
36. Shane, S.(2004).Encouraging University Entrepreneurship? The Effect of the Bayh-Dole Act on University Patenting in the United States.Journal of Business Venturing,19(1),127-151.
37. Soetanto, D.,Jack, S.(2016).The Impact of University-Based Incubation Support on the Innovation Strategy of Academic Spin-Offs.Technovation,50-51(3),25-40.
38. Stevens, A. J.(2004).The Enactment of Bayh-Dole.The Journal of Technology Transfer,29(1),93-99.
39. Swamidass, P. M.,Vulasa, V.(2009).Why University Inventions Rarely Produce Income? Bottlenecks in University Technology Transfer.The Journal of Technology Transfer,34,343-363.
40. Thornton, P.H.,Ocasio, W.(1999).Institutional Logics and the Historical Contingency of Power in Organizations: Executive Succession in the Higher Education Publishing Industry, 1958-1990.American Journal of Sociology,105(3),801-843.
41. Timmons, J. A.(1999).New Venture Creation: Entrepreneurship for the 21st Century.Irwin McGraw Hill.
42. Villani, E.,Rasmussen, E.,Grimaldi, R.(2017).How Intermediary Organizations Facilitate University-Industry Technology Transfer: a Proximity Approach.Technological Forecasting and Social Change,114,86-102.
43. Vohora, A.,Wright, M.,Lockett, A.(2004).Critical Junctures in the Development of University High-Tech Spinout Companies.Research Policy,33(1),147-175.
44. 溫肇東(2004)。科技管理與大學衍生企業在日本的發展。政大智慧財產評論，2(1)，74-96。

1. 陳冠宇,林士平(2021)。大學創業教育生態系統影響大學生創業警覺性養成之因素重要性研究。科技管理學刊，26(2)，55-76。
2. (2023)。完成台灣科技廊帶最後一哩路：以多準則分析探討屏東科學園區發展之政策工具。科技管理學刊，28(3)，37-69。