题名

Exploring the Development of Design Thinking Based on Main Path Analysis

并列篇名

以主路徑分析法探討設計思考之發展趨勢

作者

林碧郁(Pi Yu Lin)；陳凱瀛(Kai Ying Che)；鄭辰仰(Chen Yang Cheng)；楊蒨旻(Chien Min Yang)

关键词

Design thinking ； Main path analysis ； Cluster analysis ； 設計思考 ； 主路徑分析 ； 集群分析

期刊名称

科技管理學刊

卷期/出版年月

27卷2期（2022 / 09 / 01）

页次

27 - 62

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

With the increasing interconnect and complexity of problems in the world, conservative methods is no longer considered relevant to solve them. Therefore, several effective methods have emerged, one of which is design thinking. Design thinking is adopted by many well-known organizations such as Apple, Google, Samsung, Airbnb, etc. In additions, it is also taught at many leading universities. This study uses the main path analysis method to explore the development trend of design thinking. All design-thinking relevant documents are collected from Scopus database, then Main Path 437 software is used to analyze the overall development trajectory. G-index and h-index are also used to find more influential journals. The documents are grouped based on similarity using cluster analysis. A wordle software is used to present the keywords grouping. The top five sub-clusters are: ＂The impact of design thinking on enterprise management innovation＂, ＂The impact of design thinking on education and healthcare＂, ＂The impact of design thinking on engineering design＂, ＂The impact of design thinking on the ability of inductive reasoning, and ＂The impact of design thinking on organization and management in various fields＂. Some authors' discussion and suggestion are provided.
英文摘要

本研究採用主路徑分析法來探討設計思維（Design thinking）於學術領域的發展趨勢，首先運用Scopus資料庫收錄相關文獻，再以Main Path 437軟體分析其總體發展軌跡並以g-index和h-index找出較具影響力的期刊，接著運用集群分析將具有相似主題的文獻分群，搭配Wordle軟體將各群體關鍵字以文字雲呈現並作為命名的參考，獲得前五大子集群分別為：「設計思維對企業管理創新之影響」、「設計思維對教育及醫療等領域之影響」、「設計思維對工程設計之影響」、「設計思維對歸納推理能力之影響」、「設計思維對各領域組織管理之影響」。最後，針對分析出之各集群發展軌跡逐一進行說明與結論，並透過此研究之資訊提出相關研究建議。
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. Hsu, J. S.,Tsai, W.(2021).Development of an Asynchronous Distance Teaching System that Uses Facial Expression Recognition to Study Learning Status Based on Design Thinking.Journal of Technology Management,26(2),25-53.
    連結：
  2. Lee, C. F.,Tseng, F. M.,Lu, L. Y. Y.(2018).The Development Trajectory of Virtual Reality Literature in Main Areas.Journal of Technology Management,23(2),61-95.
    連結：
  3. Ambrose, G.,Harris, P.(2009).Basics design 08: design thinking.Bloomsbury Publishing.
  4. Batagelj, V. (2003), "Efficient algorithms for citation network analysis". In Preprint series, University of Ljubljana, Institute of Mathematics, Physics and Mechanics, Department of Theoretical Computer Science.
  5. Batagelj, V.,Mrvar, A.(1998).Pajek-program for large network analysis.Connections,21(2),47-57.
  6. Batat, W.,Addis, M.(2021).Designing food experiences for well-being: a framework advancing design thinking research from a customer experience perspective.European Journal of Marketing,55(9),2392-2413.
  7. Beckman, S. L.,Barry, M.(2007).Innovation as a learning process: Embedding design thinking.California management review,50(1),25-56.
  8. Bennett, E. E.(2018).Exploring the Role of Virtual Human Resource Development.The internet of people, things and services: Workplace transformations
  9. Beverland, M. B.,Wilner, S. J.,Micheli, P.(2015).Reconciling the tension between consistency and relevance: design thinking as a mechanism for brand ambidexterity.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,43(5),589-609.
  10. Boni, A. A.,Weingart, L. R.,Evenson, S.(2009).Innovation in an academic setting: Designing and leading a business through market-focused, interdisciplinary teams.Academy of Management Learning & Education,8(3),407-417.
  11. Brenner, W.,Uebernickel, F.,Abrell, T.(2016).Design Thinking as Mindset, Process, and Toolbox.Design Thinking for Innovation
  12. Brooks, F. P., Jr(2010).The Design of Design: Essays From a Computer Scientist.NY:Pearson Education.
  13. Brown, T.(2008).Design thinking.Harvard business review,86(6),84.
  14. Carlgren, L.,Elmquist, M.,Rauth, I.(2014).Design thinking: Exploring values and effects from an innovation capability perspective.The Design Journal,17(3),403-423.
  15. Chang, C.-C.,Yen, W.-H.(2021).The role of learning style in engineering design thinking via project-based STEM course.Asia Pacific Journal of Education,1-19.
  16. Chen, H.-Y.(2020).Yuan Ze University.
  17. Chen, L. C.,Shih, I. C.,Liu, J. S.(2020).Identifying the Main Paths of Knowledge Diffusion in the Voice over Internet Protocol.Journal of Internet Technology,21(1),85-98.
  18. Chen, Y. C.,Chang, Y. S.,Chuang, M. J.(2022).Virtual reality application impacts cognitive load‐mediated creativity components and creative performance in engineering design.Journal of Computer Assisted Learning,38(1),6-18.
  19. Chuang, T. C.,Liu, J. S.,Lu, L. Y.,Lee, Y.(2014).The main paths of medical tourism: From transplantation to beautification.Tourism Management,45,49-58.
  20. Cortés Selva, L.,Wandosell Fernández de Bobadilla, G.(2018).Improving University student's results: a client-based experiment through design thinking and visual storytelling in communication.Educación,21(2)
  21. de Figueiredo, M. D.(2021).Design is cool, but… A critical appraisal of design thinking in management education.The International Journal of Management Education,19(1),100429.
  22. Dell'Era, C.,Magistretti, S.,Cautela, C.,Verganti, R.,Zurlo, F.(2020).Four kinds of design thinking: From ideating to making, engaging, and criticizing.Creativity and Innovation Management,29(2),324-344.
  23. Design thinking. (2022), In Wikipedia, From: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_thinking
  24. Dong, A.,Lovallo, D.,Mounarath, R.(2015).The effect of abductive reasoning on concept selection decisions.Design studies,37,37-58.
  25. Dörner, D.(1999).Approaching design thinking research.Design Studies,20(5),407-415.
  26. Dorst, K.(2010).The nature of design thinking.Design thinking research symposium
  27. Dorst, K.(2011).The core of ‘design thinking’and its application.Design studies,32(6),521-532.
  28. Dunne, D.,Martin, R.(2006).Design thinking and how it will change management education: An interview and discussion.Academy of Management Learning & Education,5(4),512-523.
  29. Dym, C. L.,Agogino, A. M.,Eris, O.,Frey, D. D.,Leifer, L. J.(2005).Engineering design thinking, teaching, and learning.Journal of engineering education,94(1),103-120.
  30. Eisenbart, B.,Bouwman, S.,Voorendt, J.,McKillagan, S.,Kuys, B.,Ranscombe, C.(2022).Implementing design thinking to drive innovation in technical design.International Journal of Design Creativity and Innovation,1-20.
  31. Elsbach, K. D.,Stigliani, I.(2018).Design thinking and organizational culture: A review and framework for future research.Journal of Management,44(6),2274-2306.
  32. Evans, D. L.(1990).Design in Engineering Education: Past Views of Future Directions.Engineering Education,80(5),517-522.
  33. Fan, S.-H.(2019).Yuan Ze University.
  34. Fu, Z.,He, J.,Chao, C.(2018).Key Elements of Design Thinking Tools: Learn from Storytelling Process in High School Student's Workshop.Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposium of Chinese CHI,Montreal QC Canada:
  35. Garbuio, M.,Lovallo, D.,Porac, J.,Dong, A.(2015).A design cognition perspective on strategic option generation.Cognition and strategy
  36. Girvan, M.,Newman, M. E.(2002).Community structure in social and biological networks.Proceedings of the national academy of sciences,99(12),7821-7826.
  37. Glen, R.,Suciu, C.,Baughn, C.(2014).The need for design thinking in business schools.Academy of management learning & education,13(4),653-667.
  38. Glen, R.,Suciu, C.,Baughn, C.C.,Anson, R.(2015).Teaching design thinking in business Schools.The International Journal of Management Education,13(2),182-192.
  39. Guenther, A.,Eisenbart, B.,Dong, A.(2017).Creativity as a way to innovate successfully.Proceedings of the 21st International Conference on Engineering Design,Vancouver, Canada:
  40. Ho, C. H.(2001).Some phenomena of problem decomposition strategy for design thinking: differences between novices and experts.Design Studies,22(1),27-45.
  41. Hove, K. H.,Berg-Knutsen, E.,Dahl, P. K.,Rones, N.(2020).An application of a combined framework to set the future direction of the Norwegian Home Guard.Defence Studies,20(4),412-435.
  42. Huang, W. -D.(2020).National Taiwan Normal University.
  43. Hummon, N. P.,Doreian, P.(1990).Computational methods for social network analysis.Social Networks,12(4),273-288.
  44. Hummon, N. P.,Doreian, P.(1989).Connectivity in a citation network: The development of DNA theory.Social Networks,11(1),39-63.
  45. Johansson‐Sköldberg, U.,Woodilla, J.,Çetinkaya, M.(2013).Design thinking: past, present and possible futures.Creativity and innovation management,22(2),121-146.
  46. Junginger, S.(2007).Learning to design: giving purpose to heart, hand and mind.Journal of Business Strategy,28(4),59-65.
  47. Kainzbauer, A.,Lowe, S.(2018).Embodied realism by design in Thai management education.The International Journal of Management Education,16(2),281-291.
  48. Kimbell, L.(2011).Rethinking design thinking: Part I.Design and culture,3(3),285-306.
  49. kogstad, P.,Currano, R. M.,Leifer, L. J.(2008).An experiment in design pedagogy transfer across cultures and disciplines.The International journal of engineering education,24(2),367-376.
  50. Kumar, V.,Holloway, M.(2009).How tangible is your strategy? How design thinking can turn your strategy into reality.Journal of Business Strategy,30(2/3),50-56.
  51. Kurtmollaiev, S.,Pedersen, P. E.,Fjuk, A.,Kvale, K.(2018).Developing managerial dynamic capabilities: A quasi-experimental field study of the effects of design thinking training.Academy of Management Learning & Education,17(2),184-202.
  52. Lande, M.(2012).Work in progress: Making Room: Creating design spaces for design practice.2012 Frontiers in Education Conference Proceedings
  53. Lande, M.,Leifer, L.(2010).Difficulties student engineers face designing the future.International Journal of Engineering Education,26(2),271.
  54. Lebid, A. Y.,Shevchenko, N. Y. A.(2020).Cultivation of the Skills of Design Thinking via the Project-Based Method as a Component of the Dual Model of Learning.European Journal of Contemporary Education,9(3),572-583.
  55. Leydesdorff, L.,Thor, A.,Bornmann, L.(2017).Further steps in integrating the platforms of WoS and Scopus: Historiography with HistCite™ and main-path analysis.Profesional de la Información,26(4),662-671.
  56. Li, J.-X.(2016).Ming Chuan University.
  57. Li, M.-Z.(2012).National Yunlin University of Science and Technology.
  58. Liedtka, J.(2015).Perspective: Linking design thinking with innovation outcomes through cognitive bias reduction.Journal of product innovation management,32(6),925-938.
  59. Liedtka, J.(2004).The Role of Hypotheses Generation and Testing.Managing as designing
  60. Liedtka, J.,Martin, R.,Fraser, H. M.(2007).The practice of breakthrough strategies by design.Journal of business strategy,28(4),66-74.
  61. Lin, D.-C.(2016).Ming Chuan University.
  62. Lin, K.-Y.,Wu, Y.-T.,Hsu, Y.-T.,Williams, P. J.(2021).Effects of infusing the engineering design process into STEM project-based learning to develop preservice technology teachers’ engineering design thinking.International Journal of STEM Education,8(1),1-15.
  63. Liu, J. S.,Lu, L. Y.(2012).An integrated approach for main path analysis: Development of the Hirsch index as an example.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,63(3),528-542.
  64. Liu, J. S.,Lu, L. Y.,Ho, M. H. C.(2019).A few notes on main path analysis.Scientometrics,119(1),379-391.
  65. Liu, J. S.,Lu, L. Y.,Lu, W. M.,Lin, B. J.(2013).A survey of DEA applications.Omega,41(5),893-902.
  66. Liu, Y. T.,Group, A.(1996).Is designing one search or two? A model of design thinking involving symbolism and connectionism.Design Studies,17(4),435-449.
  67. Lugmayr, A.(2011)."Applying" design thinking" as a method for teaching in media education.Proceedings of the 15th International Academic MindTrek Conference: Envisioning Future Media Environments
  68. Ma, Z.(2016).National Taiwan University of Science and Technology.
  69. Magistretti, S.,Dell'Era, C.,Doppio, N.(2020).Design sprint for SMEs: an organizational taxonomy based on configuration theory.Management Decision,58(9),1803-1817.
  70. Mahmoud-Jouini, S. B.,Midler, C.,Silberzahn, P.(2016).Contributions of design thinking to project management in an innovation context.Project Management Journal,47(2),144-156.
  71. Martin, R.,Martin, R. L.(2009).The design of business: Why design thinking is the next competitive advantage.US:Harvard Business Press.
  72. Micheli, P.,Wilner, S. J.,Bhatti, S. H.,Mura, M.,Beverland, M. B.(2019).Doing design thinking: Conceptual review, synthesis, and research agenda.Journal of Product Innovation Management,36(2),124-148.
  73. Mirman, D.(2017).Growth curve analysis and visualization using R.Chapman and Hall/CRC.
  74. Närvänen, E.(ed.),Mesiranta, N.(ed.),Mattila, M.(ed.),Heikkinen, A.(ed.)(2020).Food Waste Management.Cham:Palgrave Macmillan.
  75. Palla, G.,Barabási, A.-L.,Vicsek, T.(2007).Quantifying social group evolution.Nature,446(7136),664-667.
  76. Patel, M. I.,Moore, D.,Blayney, D. W.,Milstein, A.(2014).Transforming cancer care: are transdisciplinary approaches using design-thinking, engineering, and business methodologies needed to improve value in cancer care delivery?.Journal of oncology practice,10(2),e51-e54.
  77. Paton, B.,Dorst, K.(2011).Briefing and reframing: A situated practice.Design studies,32(6),573-587.
  78. Patrício, L.,Gustafsson, A.,Fisk, R.(2018).Upframing service design and innovation for research impact.Journal of Service Research,21(1),3-16.
  79. Petrakis, K.,Wodehouse, A.,Hird, A.(2021).Prototyping-driven entrepreneurship: towards a prototyping support tool based on design thinking principles.The Design Journal,24(5),761-781.
  80. Pierce, D.,Davies, M.,Kryder, B.(2019).Innovate with design thinking in the sport management capstone course.Sport Management Education Journal,13(1),26-34.
  81. Rowe, P.(1987).Design Thinking.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
  82. Sarooghi, H.,Sunny, S.,Hornsby, J.,Fernhaber, S.(2019).Design thinking and entrepreneurship education: Where are we, and what are the possibilities?.Journal of Small Business Management,57,78-93.
  83. Seidel, V. P.,Fixson, S. K.(2013).Adopting design thinking in novice multidisciplinary teams: The application and limits of design methods and reflexive practices.Journal of Product Innovation Management,30,19-33.
  84. Sheehan, N. T.,Gujarathi, M. R.,Jones, J. C.,Phillips, F.(2018).Using design thinking to write and publish novel teaching cases: Tips from experienced case authors.Journal of Management Education,42(1),135-160.
  85. Shute, V. J.,Becker, B. J.(2010).Innovative assessment for the 21st century.New York, NY:Springer.
  86. Simon, H.(1996).The Sciences of Artificial.Cambridge MA:The MIT Press.
  87. Takaoka, R.,Aoki, V.(2016).Education of patients with atopic dermatitis and their caregivers.Pediatric Allergy, Immunology, and Pulmonology,29(4),160-163.
  88. Takaoka, R.,Coelho, E.(2018).Patient Education in Atopic Dermatitis: Why It Is Needed and How to Improve It.Current Dermatology Reports,7(4),221-226.
  89. Tonkinwise, C.(2011).A taste for practices: Unrepressing style in design thinking.Design studies,32(6),533-545.
  90. Torres, A.,Miranda, C.(2020).Understanding Service Design and Design Thinking Differences Between Research and Practice: An Empirical Study.International Conference on Exploring Services Science,Cham:
  91. Tschimmel, K.(2012).Design Thinking as an effective Toolkit for Innovation.ISPIM Conference Proceedings
  92. Wilson, K.,Desha, C.,Bucolo, S.,Miller, E.,Hargroves, C.(2014).Emerging opportunities for ‘design thinking’to deliver sustainable solutions in the built environment.The International Journal of Design Management and Professional Practice,8(1),1-10.
  93. Wolniak, R.(2017).The Design Thinking method and its stages.Systemy Wspomagania w Inżynierii Produkcji,6(6),247-255.
  94. Xu, S.-L.(2013).Fu Jen Catholic University.
  95. Yeoman, P.,Carvalho, L.(2019).Moving between material and conceptual structure: Developing a card-based method to support design for learning.Design Studies,64,64-89.
  96. Yock, P. G.,Brinton, T. J.,Zenios, S. A.(2011).Teaching biomedical technology innovation as a discipline.Science translational medicine,3(92),92cm18-92cm18.
  97. Zhang, J.-H. (2020), Exploring the development of advertising industry by main path analysis. National Taiwan University of Science and Technology.
  98. Zhou, W.-T.(2019).National Defense University.
print cancel