應用設計導向學習於新產品管理課程以提升學生關鍵能力

Using Design-based Learning as the Pedagogy of New Product Management Course to Foster Undergraduate Students' Key Competencies

沈永祺(Yung-Chi Shen)

設計導向學習 ； 新產品管理 ； 關鍵能力 ； 高等教育 ； design-based learning ； new product management ； key competencies ； higher education

科技管理學刊

27卷3期（2022 / 12 / 01）

75 - 111

繁體中文;英文

教育部自2013年提出21世紀的學生必須具備溝通協調能力（Communication）、團隊合作能力（Collaboration）、解決複雜問題能力（Complex Problem Solving）、獨立思辨能力（Critical Thinking）、創造力（Creativity）等5C關鍵能力，才能因應未來的科技發展與社會變遷。欲培養這五項關鍵能力，必須要導入有別於傳統講述教學的新教學方法。設計導向學習是一種強調以學習者為中心的教學方法，結合設計思考與設計實作，透過解決定義不清的問題培養學生的探究技巧和整合跨領域知識的能力。在學習過程中，學生必須建立團隊、彼此溝通協調，觀察、定義現實生活中的設計問題，實際動手發展產品或服務方案，並測試設計。此教學方法極為適合實施於含有產品或服務設計內涵的新產品管理課程，故本研究旨在以設計導向學習做為新產品管理課程的教學方法，以培養大學生的5C關鍵能力。課程在嘉義的一所大學教學現場開課，共計65位管理學院大學部學生參與。經單組前後測前實驗結果顯示，經一學期的新產品管理課程輔以設計導向學習，學生們的5C關鍵能力較上課前有顯著提升。

Since 2013, Taiwan's Ministry of Education has encouraged students to be equipped with 5C competencies, i.e. communication, collaboration, complex problem solving, critical thinking, and creativity, to engage the technological development and social change in the future. Thus, it is necessary to introduce a proper pedagogy to cultivate these 5 competencies. The design-based learning is a learner-centered pedagogy which emphasizes design thinking and design practices to foster students' capabilities of exploring and interdisciplinary integration through indistinct problems. During the learning process, students have to build up their teams, coordinate with each other, observe, define the design problems in the real life, develop products or service solutions, and test. Therefore, the design-based learning is suitable for the course of new product management which covers the content of product or service development. This study adopts the design-based learning as the pedagogy of the course of new product management to cultivate college students' 5C competencies. The course is implemented in a management school of a university in Chiayi with 65 undergraduates who come from departments of biobusiness management, business administration, and visual arts taking. The result of one-shot case study shows that these undergraduates' 5 competencies are significantly enhanced after one semester of design-based learning in the course of new product management.

1. 王佳琪,宋世祥(2019)。設計思考融入職前師資培育課程之實施與成效：以適性教學為例。教育科學研究期刊，64(4)，145-173。
   連結：
2. 古士傑(2020)。在地文化主題結合 PBL 和資訊科技融入領域教學之研究－以一所國中為例。育達科大學報，48，57-80。
   連結：
3. 周信輝(2022)。商業生態系統發展基礎之服務設計思考。科技管理學刊，27(2)，1-25。
   連結：
4. 岳修平,鐘婉莉(2005)。專題式學習小組網路溝通互動之研究。教育學刊，25，1-23。
   連結：
5. 徐綺穗(2012)。大學教學的創新模式－「行動－反思」教學對大學生學習成就、批判思考意向及學業情緒影響之研究。課程與教學，15(1)，119-149。
   連結：
6. 馬于婷,黃淑賢,施如齡(2018)。數位心智圖導入數位說故事對學童 5C 能力之學習成效分析。數位學習科技期刊，10(2)，31-57。
   連結：
7. 張秀華,黃仲楷,林純如(2019)。大學校園智慧零售實作場域之人才培育個案研究。當代教育研究季刊，6(4)，1-12。
   連結：
8. 陳玉樹(2008)。創造力訓練課程成效分析：準 Solomon 四組設計。課程與教學，11(4)，187-212。
   連結：
9. 陳偉仁,黃楷茹,吳青陵,呂金燮(2018)。專業學習的建構：『設計本位學習』創新教學之行動研究。教學實踐與研究，31(2)，25-57。
   連結：
10. 陳毓凱,張賴妙理,楊坤原(2013)。八年級學生在科學問題本位學習歷程的自我導向學習行為表現。科學教育學刊，21(3)，345-370。
    連結：
11. 陳萩紋,廖遠光(2017)。應用教育 APP 輔助國中生數學閱讀理解之教學歷程與成效。中等教育，68(3)，34-47。
    連結：
12. 楊心怡,李啟嘉(2015)。問題導向學習對法律系大學生問題解決能力及自我導向學習之研究。教育科學研究期刊，60(1)，131-155。
    連結：
13. 楊朝陽,康仕仲,陳彥甫,林喬茵,王嫊淩,林怡萱(2018)。以『設計導向學習』模式初探智齡設計課程。科學教育學刊，26(特刊)，399-418。
    連結：
14. 歐素華(2022)。價值鏈結：由設計思考創新金融服務。科技管理學刊，27(2)，63-91。
    連結：
15. 蔡宗霖(2022)。創業機會創造之探討：以設計思考之觀點。科技管理學刊，27(2)，119-138。
    連結：
16. 駱信昌(2021)。以青銀共創導入福祉設計實務專題課程。設計學報，26(2)，93-110。
    連結：
17. 魏惠娟(2007)。「方案規劃」的創意教學設計與實施之行動研究。課程與教學，10(4)，63-83。
    連結：
18. Archer, L. B.(1979).Whatever Became of Design Methodology?.Design Studies,1(1),17-20.
19. Aspin, D. N.,Chapman, J. D.(2000).Lifelong Learning: Concepts and Conceptions.International Journal of Lifelong Education,19(1),2-19.
20. Bell, S.(2010).Project-based Learning for the 21st Century: Skills for the Future.The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas,83(2),39-43.
21. Berdrow, I.,Evers, F. T.(2010).Bases of Competence: An Instrument for Self and Institutional Assessment.Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education,35(4),419-434.
22. Braun, V.,Clarke, V.(2006).Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.Qualitative Research in Psychology,3(2),77-101.
23. Brown, T.(2008).Design Thinking.Harvard Business Review,86(6),85-92.
24. Chang, G. W.,Yeh, Z. M.,Pan, S. Y.,Liao, C. C.,Chang, H. M.(2008).A Progressive Design Approach to Enhance Project-based Learning in Applied Electronics through and Optoelectronic Sensing Project.IEEE Transactions on Education,51(2),220-233.
25. Chen, C. H.,Chiu, C. H.(2016).Employing Intergroup Competition in Multitouch Design-based Learning to Foster Student Engagement, Learning Achievement, and Creativity.Computers & Education,103,99-113.
26. Clavert, M.,Paloposki, T.(2015).Implementing Design-based Learning in Teaching of Combustion and Gasification Technology.International Journal of Engineering Education,31(4),1021-1032.
27. Commission of the European Communities(2005).Commission of the European Communities (2005), Proposal for A Recommendation of the European Parliament and of the Council on Key Competences for Lifelong Learning, Brussels: Commission of the European Communities..
28. Delors, J.,Mufti, I. A.,Amagi, I.,Carneiro, R.,Chung, F.,Geremek, B.(1996).Learning: The Treasure within.Paris:UNESCO.
29. Denayer, I.,Thaels, K.,Cander Sloten, J.,Gobin, R.(2003).Teaching a structured approach to the design process for undergraduate engineering student by problem-based education.European Journal of Engineering Education,28(2),203-214.
30. Denzin, N. K.(1978).Sociological Methods: A Sourcebook.New York:McGraw-Hill.
31. Dewey, J. (1910), How We Think, Boston: D.C. Health.
32. Duran, R. L.(1992).Communicative Adaptability: A Review of Conceptualization and Measurement.Communication Quarterly,4(3),253-268.
33. Ellis, G. W.,Zhang, Y. Z. Z.(2016).The Development of 21st Century Skills in the Knowledge Building Environment.International Journal of Engineering Education,32(3),1160-1170.
34. Etkina, E.,Karelina, A.,Ruibal-Villasenor, M.,Rosegrant, D.,Jordan, R.,Hmelo-Silver, C. E.(2010).Design and Reflection Help Students Develop Scientific Abilities: Learning in Introductory Physics Laboratories.The Journal of the Learning Sciences,19(1),54-98.
35. Field, J.(2001).Lifelong Education.International Journal of Lifelong Education,20(1/2),3-15.
36. Geber, E.,McKenna, A.,Hirsch, P.,Yarnoff, C.(2010).Learning to Waste and Wasting to Learn? How to Use Cradle-to-cradle Principles to Improve the Teaching of Design.International Journal of Engineering Education,26(2),314-323.
37. Goldman, S.,Carroll, M. P.,Kabayadondo, Z.,Britos, C. L.,Royalty, A. W.,Roth, B.,Kwek, S. H.,Kim, J.(2012).Assessing d.learning: capturing the journey of becoming a design thinker.Design Thinking Research: Measuring Performance in Context,London:
38. Gómez Puente, S. M.,van Eijck, M.,Jochems, W.(2015).Professional Development for Design-based Learning in Engineering Education: A Case Study.European Journal of Engineering Education,40(1),14-31.
39. Gupta, C.(2022).The Impact and Measurement of Today’s Learning Technologies in Teaching Software Engineering Course Using Design-based Learning and Project-based Learning.IEEE Transactions on Education
40. Hirsch, P. L.,Shwom, B. L.,Yarnoff, C.,Anderson, J. C.,Kelso, D. M.,Olson, G. B.,Colgate, J. E.(2001).Engineering Design and Communication: the Case for Interdisciplinary Collaboration.International Journal of Engineering Education,17(4),342-348.
41. Jeng, J. H.,Tang, T. I.(2004).A Model of Knowledge Integration Capability.Journal of Information, Technology and Society,4(1),13-45.
42. Johnson, P.(2009).The 21st century skills movement.Educational Leadership,67(1),11.
43. Kirschner, P. A.,Stoyanov, S.(2020).Educating Youth for Nonexistent/Not Yet Existing Professions.Educational Policy,34(3),477-517.
44. Kolodner, J. L.,Camp, P. J.,Crismond, D.,Fasse, B.,Gray, J.,Holbrook, J.,Puntambekar, S.,Ryan, M.(2003).Problem-based Learning Meets Case-based Reasoning in the Middle-school Science Classroom: Putting Learning by DesignTM into Practice.Journal of the Learning Sciences,12(4),495-547.
45. Koper, R.,Tattersall, C.(2004).New directions for lifelong learning using network technologies.British Journal of Educational Technology,35(6),689-700.
46. Li, Y.,Huang, Z.,Jiang, M.,Chang, T. W.(2016).The Effect on Pupils’ Science Performance and Problem-Solving Ability through Lego: An Engineering Design-based Modeling Approach.Educational Technology & Society,19(3),143-156.
47. Maase, E. L.,High, K. A.(2008).Activity Problem Solving and Applied Research Methods in A Graduate Course on Numerical Methods.Chemical Engineering Education,42(1),3-32.
48. Massey, A. P.,Ramesh, V.,Khatri, V.(2006).Design, Development and Assessment of Mobile Applications: the Case for Problem-based Learning.IEEE Transactions on Education,49(2),183-192.
49. McKenna, A.,Colgate, J. E.,Carr, S. H.,Olson, G. B.(2006).IDEA: Formalizing the Foundation for An Engineering Design Education.International Journal of Engineering Education,22(3),671-678.
50. Mintzberg, H.,Gosling, J.(2002).Educating Managers beyond Borders.Academy of Management Learning and Education,1(1),64-76.
51. Notari, M.,Baumgartner, A.,Herzog, W.(2014).Social Skills as Predictors of Communication, Performance and Quality of Collaboration in Project-based Learning.Journal of Computer Assisted Learning,30(2),132-147.
52. Nunnally, J. C.(1978).Psychometric Theory.New York:McGraw-Hill.
53. O’Flaherty, J.,Phillips, C.(2015).The Use of Flipped Classrooms in Higher Education: A Scoping Review.Internet and Higher Education,25,85-95.
54. Prince, M.,Felder, R.(2007).The Many Faces of Inductive Teaching and Learning.Journal of College Science Teaching,36(5),14-20.
55. Puslednik, L.,Brennan, P. C.(2020).An Australian-based Authentic Science Research Programme Transforms the 21st Century Learning of Rural High School Students.Australian Journal of Education
56. Rittel, H. W. J.,Webber, M. M.(1973).Dilemmas in A General Theory of Planning.Policy Sciences,4(2),155-169.
57. Roberts, L.(2001).Developing experimental design and troubleshooting skills in an advanced biochemistry lab.Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education,29(1),10-15.
58. Sampson, D.,Karampiperis, P.,Fytros, D.(2007).Developing A Common Metadata Model for Competencies Description.Interactive Learning Environments,15(2),137-150.
59. Schraw, G.,Dennison, R. S.(1994).Assessing Metacognitive Awareness.Contemporary Education Psychology,19(4),460-475.
60. Shanta, S.,Wells, J. G.(2020).T/E Design Based Learning: Assessing Student Critical Thinking and Problem Solving Abilities.International Journal of Technology and Design Education
61. Shyr, W. J.(2012).Teaching Mechatronics: An Innovative Group Project-based Approach.Computer Applications in Engineering Education,20(1),93-102.
62. van Rooij, S. W.(2010).Project Management in Instructional Design: ADDIE Is Not Enough.British Journal of Educational Technology,41(5),852-864.
63. Van Til, R. P.,Tracey, M. W.,Sengupta, S.,Fliedner, G.(2009).Teaching Lean with An Interdisciplinary Problem-solving Learning Approach.International Journal of Engineering Education,25(1),173-180.
64. Wijnen, W. H. F. W.(2000).,Eindhoven:Educational Service Centre, Eindhoven University of Technology.
65. Zhan, W.,Porter, J. R.(2010).Using Project-based Learning to Teach Six Sigma Principles.International Journal of Engineering Education,26(3),655-666.
66. Zhang, F.,Markopoulos, P.,Bekker, T.,Paule-Ruíz, M.,Schüll, M.(2022).Understanding Design-based Learning Context and the Associated Emotional Experience.International Journal of Technology and Design Education,32,845-882.
67. 文化部(2017)，「五大文化創意產業園區營運管理」，2020 年 10 月 3 日，取自 https://www.moc.gov.tw/information_302_34100.html
68. 周宜芳（譯）,Leifer, L.,Lewrick, M.,Link, P.,Langensand, N.(2019).設計思考全攻略.台北:天下.
69. 林幸台,王木榮(1994).威廉斯創造力測驗指導手冊.台北:心理.
70. 施孟綾(2015)。國立東華大學教育與潛能開發學系。
71. 張雅雯(2017)。國立高雄師範大學文化創意設計碩士學位學程。
72. 張鈿富,吳慧子,吳舒靜(2010)。歐盟、美、澳『公民關鍵能力』發展及其啟示。教育資料集刊，48，273-300。
73. 教育部(2013)，「教育部資訊及科技教育司楊鎮華司長談 5C 人才培育」，2020 年 9 月 13 日，取自 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pPhLXEu4FQo
74. 教育部資訊及科技教育司(2017)，「學生 5C 關鍵能力意向量表」，2020 年 10 月 3 日，取自https://dlearning.ncku.edu.tw/questionnaire?type_id=3
75. 許哲瑋(2019)。國立政治大學圖書資訊學數位碩士在職專班。
76. 陳佑庭(2017)。國立彰化示範大學工業教育與技術學系。
77. 陳毓凱,洪振方(2007)。兩種探究取向教學模式之分析與比較。科學教育月刊，305，4-19。
78. 黃國禎,朱蕙君,賴秋琳(2013)。教育部專題研究成果報告教育部專題研究成果報告,教育部。
79. 黃富廷(2016)。從「教師中心論」與「學生中心論」的兩次世紀大對決來探討啟智班教學的合理走向。台東特教，43，4-12。
80. 嘉義文化園區，遊園指引，2021 年 7 月 15 日，取自 http://www.g9park.com/TouristService.php#guide
81. 趙嘉浩(2016)。國立台灣科技大學數位學習與教育研究所。
82. 潘怡吟(2002)。台北市立師範學院科學教育研究所。
83. 鄭文綺(2018)。世新大學資訊傳播學研究所。