馬克思主義對工具理性的批判及其在師資教育的啟示

The Critique of Marxism at Instrumental Rationality and Its Reflections on Teacher Education

10.6384/CIQ.200607.0015

姜添輝(Tien-Hui Chiang)

馬克思主義 ； 工具理性 ； 師資教育 ； Marxism ； instrumental rationality ； teacher education

課程與教學

9卷3期（2006 / 07 / 01）

15 - 33

繁體中文

由於大部分教師忽視社會文化對學生學習表現的影響，致使教育結果的不均等現象被合理化。改善此種現象需求寬廣的文化視野與批判思維，然而大部分教師被指責欠缺此種素養，他們展現工具理性的思維與技術效能的行為。本文試圖追溯此種現象的鉅觀面成因，文中分析顯示此種現象根源於社會的價值體系，當科學技術在生產體系取得主導地位時，實證科學的屬性逐漸轉變為個體與外界互動的依據，甚至被融入社會價值體系中。此種情境使師資培育課程產生科學化，其焦點是實務運用以及技術效能導向，致使大部分教師將教育目標、教學內容、過程與結果化約為技術效能層面。

Due to the fact that the majority of teachers ignore the influence of social cultures on students' performances, the inequality of educational results has consistently remained. Improving this phenomenon requires an open vision and critical mind on analyzing the interaction between children's cultural competence and curriculum contents. However, it was argued that most teachers did not possess such a vision or mind. Their minds were generally confined within the scope of instrumental rationality. Therefore, their behaviours can be characterized as techno-effectiveness orientation. This essay attempts to explore the macro-level factors molding such simple minds. The arguments of relevant literature suggest that this phenomenon was rooted in social value system. When the effectiveness of scientific technology in productive system was proofed, positivism commenced to expend its influence and, was finally fused into social value system. Under such a circumstance, the assumptions of positivism, such as neutrality and generalization, tend to dominate the individual's mind and attitude towards others. This scientific movement makes teacher education curriculum focus on the scope of practical application and techno-effectiveness. Such a curriculum is much likely to mold its takers a simple mind as witnessed by the fact that in terms of the perspectives of educational goals, teaching materials, processes and results, most teachers tend to be instrumental-rational oriented.

1. 姜添輝(2003)。教師是專業或是觀念簡單性的忠誠執行者：文化再製理論的檢證。教育研究集刊，49(4)，97-131。
   連結：
2. 姜添輝(2002)。九年一貫課程政策影響教師專業自主權之研究。教育研究集刊，48(2)，157-198。
   連結：
3. 駱明慶(2002)。誰是台大學生？－性別、省籍與城鄉差異。經濟論文叢刊，30(1)，113-147。
   連結：
4. 謝孟穎(2002)。。
   連結：
5. Adorno, T.W.,J. Storey(1994).Cultural Theory and Popular Culture.N.Y.:Harvester Wheatsheaf.
6. Althusser, L.(1971).Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays.London:NLB.
7. Apple, M.W.(1990).Ideology and Curriculum.N.Y.:Routledge.
8. Apple, M.W.,J. Ozga(1988).Schoolwork: Approaches to the Labour Process of Teaching.Milton Keynes:Open University Press.
9. Ball, S.J.,Bowe, R.,Gewirtz, S.,A.E. Halsey,H. Lauder,P. Brown,A.S. Wells(1997).Education, Culture, Economy, and Society.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
10. Bell, D.(1976).The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism.N.Y.:Basic Books.
11. Bernstein, B.(1990).The Structuring of Pedagogic Discourse.London:Routledge.
12. Bernstein, B.(1996).Pedagogy, Symbolic Control and Identity.London:Taylor & Francis.
13. Bernstein, B.,A.H. Halsey,J. Floud,C.A. Anderson(1961).Education, Economy and Society.N.Y.:The Free Press.
14. Bernstein, B.,M. Apple(1982).Cultural and Economic Reproduction in Education: Essays on Class, Ideology and the State.London:RKP.
15. Bourdieu, P.(1993).The Field of Cultural Production: Essays on Art and Literature.Cambridge:Polity.
16. Bourdieu, P.,Passeron, C.(1977).Reproduction in Education, Society and Culture.London:Sage.
17. Bowlen, S.,Gintis, H.(1976).Schooling in Capitalist America.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
18. Braveman, H.(1974).Labour and Monopoly Capital.N.Y.:Monthly Review.
19. Cohen, A.K.(1971).Delinquent Boys.London:Collier Macmillan.
20. Dale, R.,J. Demaine(2001).Sociology of Education Today.N.Y.:Palgravee.
21. Davis, K.,Moore, W.E.,R. Bendix,M. Lipset(1966).Class, Status, and Power.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
22. Durkheim, E.(1933).The Division of Labour in Society.N.Y.:The Free Press.
23. Giroux, H.A.(1981).Ideology, Culture, and the Process of Schooling.Philadelphia:Temple University Press.
24. Giroux, H.A.(1997).Pedagogy and the Politics of Hope: Theory, Culture, and Schooling.Oxford:Westview Press.
25. Goldthorpe, J.H.,Breen, R.(1999).British Journal of Sociology.
26. Goldthorpe, J.H.,Llewellyn, C.,Payne, C.(1987).Social Mobility and Class Structure in Modern Britain.Oxford:Clarendon.
27. Hebdige, D.(1979).Subculture: The Meaning of Style.N.Y.:Methuen.
28. Illich, I.(1973).Deschooling Society.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
29. Jackson, P.W.(1968).Life in Classroom.London:Teachers College Press.
30. Liberman, A.,Miller, L.(1992).Teachers-Their World and Their Work.N. Y.:Teachers College, Columbia University.
31. Lortie, D.C.(1975).School-Teacher: A Sociological Study.London:The University of Chicago Press.
32. Lukács, G.(1971).History and Class Consciousness.London:Merliin.
33. Marcuse, H.(1964).One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society.Boston:Beacon.
34. Marx, K.(1976).Capital (volume one).Middlesex:Penguin.
35. Marx, K.,E. Fromm(1961).Economic and Philosophical Manscripts.N.Y.:Frederick Ungar.
36. Marx, K.,Engels, F.(1970).Karl Marx and Frederick Bagels: Selected Works.London:Lawrence and Wishart.
37. Marx, K.,T. Burns(1969).Industrial Man.London:Penguin.
38. Marx, K.,T. Burns(1969).Industrial Man.London:Penguin.
39. McLaren, P.(1994).Life in Schools.N.Y.:Longman.
40. Poulantzas, N.(1979).Classes in Contemporary Capitalism.London:NLB.
41. Schön, D.(1983).The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action.N.Y.:Basic Books.
42. Schutz, A.(1997).The Phenomenology of the Social World.Chicago:Northwestern University Press.
43. Swingewood, A.,Thompson, E.P.(1977).Marx and Modern Social Theory.London:Macmillan.
44. Thompson, E.P.(1966).The Making of the English Working Class.N.Y.:Vintage.
45. Tunstall, J.,P. Worsley(1973).Modern Sociology.London:Penguin.
46. Veblen, T.(1994).The Theory of the Leisure Class.N.Y.:Dover.
47. Weber, M.(1962).Basic Concepts in Sociology.N.W.:Philosophical Library.
48. Weber, M.(1949).The Methodology of the Social Sciences.N.Y.:Free.
49. Wells, C.G.(1987).The Meaning Makers: Children Learning Language and Using Language to Learn.London:Hodder & Stoughton.
50. Wells, C.G.(1985).Language Development in the Pm-School Years.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
51. Willis, P.(1977).Learning to Labor: How Working Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs.N.Y.:Columbia University Press.
52. Wolff, J.(1993).The Social Production of Art.London:Macmillan.
53. 王渝華(2005)。台南市，。
54. 石中英(2001)。知識轉型與教育改革。北京市:教育科學出版社。
55. 吳淑琪(1996)。解讀報紙瘦身廣告之女性意涵。
56. 林彩岫(2001)。師範教育的課程與教學之社會學分析。
57. 林湘慧(2003)。。
58. 姜添輝(2000)。教育與社會研究。
59. 姜添輝(2005)。社會價值重建的課程與教學。高雄:復文。
60. 姜添輝(2001)。評論馬克思主義的普羅化論點及在教師專業與階級意識的意義。臺灣教育社會學研究，1(2)，33-58。
61. 姜添輝(2002)。資本社會中的社會流動與學校體系：批判教育社會學的分析。台北:高等教育。
62. 姜添輝、R. Dale、楊深坑(2005)。比較教育論述之形成。台北市:高教。
63. 唐宗清、K. Harris(1994)。教師與階級。台北:桂冠。
64. 宮敬才(1993)。盧卡奇的哲學思想。台北市:唐山。
65. 馬信行(1997)。一九九○年人口普查中教育與職業資料之分析。國立政治大學學報，75，29-66。
66. 張慶熊、E. Husserl(1988)。歐洲科學危機與超驗現象學。上海:上海譯文。
67. 張錦華(2000)。1982至1999台灣瘦身廣告研究－多面向的研究。廣告學研究，15，67-114。
68. 陳志強(2004)。。
69. 陳珊華(2004)。。
70. 陳麗如(2003)。。
71. 陳麗華(1995)。實習教師的社會科教學推理－結構與意識的辯證。台北市:師苑。
72. 黃淑君(2000)。。
73. 黃瓊慧(1996)。解讀電視廣告中的女性意涵－以美體瘦身廣告為例。
74. 楊瑩(1994)。教育均等－教育社會學的探究。台北市:師苑。
75. 劉北成｜楊遠嬰、M. Foucault(1992)。規訓與懲罰－監獄的誕生。台北:桂冠。
76. 鄭泰承(2000)。科技、理性與自由。台北市:桂冠。
77. 戴曉霞、歐用生(1997)。新世紀的教育發展。台北市:師苑。

1. 李榮豐(2011)。現代化衝擊下高雄市客家族群文化認同發展及其教育省思。教育學誌，26，33-78。
2. (2010)。批判教學論的要點及其對師生互動的啟示。教育資料與研究，95，1-26。
3. (2011)。國小教師教學生活世界宰制與覺醒。臺灣教育社會學研究，11(2)，87-127。
4. (2022)。以三師共學落實偏鄉教育實踐：以屏東大學偏鄉USR計畫為例。教育研究月刊，334，20-33。