從父權荒野的放逐到親密母土的回歸─女性主義課程理論的奧狄賽之旅

From the Patriarchal Wilderness to Intimate Motherland-The Odyssey of Feminist Curriculum Theories

10.6384/CIQ.200610.0001

周珮儀(Pei-I Chou)

女性主義課程理論 ； 父權 ； 發聲 ； feminist curriculum theories ； patriarchy ； voice

課程與教學

9卷4期（2006 / 10 / 01）

1 - 17

繁體中文

本文旨在分析當代女性主義課程理論的主要論點。首先概述女性主義課程理論的發展過程；繼而討論教育經驗的性別特質；第三分析女性（互為）主體性的特質與對教育的影響；第四，剖析女性如何打破沉默、發出自己的聲音去抗拒父權的知識結構與學校體系；第五，探討女性主義理想的課程型態與課程探究方式。期能透過本文的分析，為女性主義的課程理論發聲，也為課程領域引入更多的關注、關懷、親密和連結。

This study is to analyze the main issues of current feminist curriculum theories. First, it is to summarize the developing process of feministic curricular theory. Secondly, it is to discuss the gender traits in educational experience. After that, it is to analyze feministic inter-subjectivity and its influence on education. The fourth part is to analyze how women break silence and deliver their voice against patriarchal knowledge structures and school system. The final section is to discuss ideal curricular pattern and exploration method of feminism. After discussion, we expect that this article would not only voice for feminist curriculum theories, but also attract more concern caring, affiliation, and connection for the field of curriculum.

1. Acker, S.(1994).Gendered education. Sociological reflections on women, teaching, and feminism.Bristol, PA:Open University Press.
2. Biklen, S. K.(1995).School work: Gender and the culture construction of teaching.New York:Teachers College Press.
3. Blake, B. E.(1997).She say, he say: Urban girls write their lives.Albany:State University of New York Press.
4. Brady,L.(1995).Curriculum development.Melbourne, Australia:Prentice-Hall.
5. Brodkey, L.(1987).Writing critical ethnographic narratives.Anthropology and Education Quarterly,18,67-76.
6. Bunch, C.(1966).Feminism and education.Quest,5(1),13-14.
7. Butler, J.(1990).Gender trouble: Feminism and the subversion of identity.New York:Routledge.
8. Christia-Smith, L.,Kellor, L.(1998).Everyday knowledge and uncommon truths: Life writing and women' s experiences in and outside the academy.Boulder, CO:Westview.
9. Clifford, G.J.,Guthrie, J. W.(1988).Ed school: A brief for professional education.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
10. Ellsworth, E.(1997).Teaching positions: difference, pedagogy, and the power of address.New York:teachers College Press.
11. Ellsworth, E.(1991).I pledge allegiance: The politics of reading and using educational films.Curiculum Inquiry,21(1),41-64.
12. Ellsworth, E.(1989).Why doesn' t this feel empowering? Working throught the repressive myths of critical pedagogy.Harvard Educational Review,59(3),297-324.
13. Foster, F. S.(1979).Voices unheard, stories untold.Radical Teacher.
14. Foucault, M.(1980).Power/knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings, 1972-1977.Sussex, UK:Harvester Press.
15. Gaskell, J. (Eds.),Willinsky, J.(Eds.)(1995).Gender in/forms curriculum: Closing the gap.Albany:State University of New York Press.
16. Gilmore, L.(1994).Autobiographics: A feminist theory of women' s self-representation.Ithaca:Comell University Press.
17. Glunk, S.(1977).What' s special about women: Women' s oral history. Frontier.A Journal of Women Studies,2,3-5.
18. Goodman, J.,Kelly, T.(1988).Out of the mainstream: Issues confronting the male profeminist elementary school teacher.Interchange,19(2),1-14.
19. Grumet, M.R.(1988).Bitter milk: Women and teaching.Amherst:University of Massachusetts Press.
20. Grumet, M.R.(1981).Pedagogy for patriarchy: The Feminization of teaching.Interchange,12(23),165-184.
21. Haraway, W.(1991).Simians, cyborgs, and women: The reinvention of nature.New York:Rootledge.
22. Harding, S.,L. Alcoff(Eds.),B. Potter(Eds.)(1993).Feminist Epistemologies.New York:Routledge.
23. Henry,A.(1998).Taking back control: African Canadian women, teachers' lives and practice.Albany:state University of New York Press.
24. Jacobs, M.,Munro, P.,Adams, N.(1995).Palimpsest: Re/reading women' s lives.Qualitative Inquiry,1(3),327-345.
25. Jipson, J.,Monro, P.,Victor, S.,Jones, K. F.,Freed-Rowland, G.(1995).Repositioning feminism & education: Perspectives on educating for social change.Westport, CT:Bergin & Garvey.
26. Kenway,J.,Blackmore, J.,Willis, S.(1996).Beyond feminist authoritarianism.Curriculum Perspectives,16(1),1-12.
27. Krall, F.(1988).From the inside out: Personal history as education research.Educational Theory,38,467-479.
28. Krall, F.(1981).Navajo tapestry: A curriculum for ethno-ecological perspectives.JCT: The Journal of Curriculum Theorizing,3(2),165-208.
29. Krasno, F.(1977).On teaching a feminist writing a workshop.Women' s Studies Newsletter,V,16-17.
30. Lather, P.(1986).Research as praxis.Harvard Educational Review,56(3),257-277.
31. Lather, P.(1984).Critical theory, curricular transformation, and feminist mainstreaming.Journal of Education,166,49-62.
32. Lather, P.(1991).Getting smart: feminist research and pedagogy with/in the postmodern.London:Routledge.
33. Lather, P.(1989).Postmodernism and the politics of enlightenment.Educational Foundations,3,7-28.
34. Lather, P.(1987).The absent present: Patriarchy, capitalism, and the nature of teacher work.Teacher Education Quarterly,14(2),25-28.
35. Lewis, M. G.(1994).Without a word: teaching beyond women' s silence.New York:Routledge.
36. Lewis, M. G.,Simon,R.I.(1986).A discourse not intended for her: Learning and teaching within patriarchy.Harvard Educational Review,56(4),457-472.
37. Macdonald, J.,Macdonald, S.,W.F. Pinar(Ed.)(1988).Contemporary curriculumdiscourses.Scottsdale, AZ:Gorsuch Scarisbrick.
38. Martin, B.,Mohanty, C.,T. deLauretis(Ed.)(1986).Feminist studies, critical studies.Bloomington:Indiana University Press.
39. Martin, J. R.(1994).Changing the educational landscape: Philosophy, women, and curriculum.New York:Routledge.
40. Miller, J. L.(1992).Shifting the boundaries: Teachers challenge contemporary 2curriculum thought.Theory into Practice,31(1),245-251.
41. Miller, J. L.(2005).Sound of silence breaking: women, autobiography, curriculum.New York:Peter Lang.
42. Miller, J.L.(1986).Women as teacher: Enlarging conversations on issues of gender and self-concept.Journal of curriculum and supervision,1(2),111-121.
43. Miller, J.L.(1986).Making paper and making time: Issues of self-concept in women and men who teach.Teaching and Learning: The Journal Inquiry,1(1),26-38.
44. Miller, J.L.,E. Weed(Ed.)(1989).Coming to Terms: Feminism, Theory, Politics.New York:Routledge.
45. Mitrano, B.S.(1981).Feminism and curriculum theory: Implications for teacher education.JCT: The Journal of Curriculum Theorizing,3,5-85.
46. Munro, P.(1998).Subject to fiction: Women teachers' life history narratives and culture polities of resistance.Bristol, PA:Open University Press.
47. Munro, P.,W. F. Pinar(Ed.)(1999).Contemporary curriculum discourse : Twenty Years of JCT.New York:Peter Lang.
48. Neumann, A.(Eds.),Peterson, P. L.(Eds.)(1997).Learning from our lives: Women, research, and autobiography in education.New York:teachers College Press.
49. Pagano, J.(1990).Exiles and communities: Teaching in the patriarchal wilderness.Albany, NY:State University of New York Press.
50. Pagano, J.,W. Pinar(Ed.)(1988).Contemporary curriculum discourse.Scottsdale, AZ:Gorsuch Scarisbrick.
51. Pinar, W. F.(2004).What is curriculum theory?.New Jersey:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
52. Pinar, W. F.,Reynolds, W. M.,Slattery, P.,Taubman, P. M.(1995).Understanding curriculum.New York:Peter Lang.
53. Pinar,W.F.,Grumet,M.(1976).Toward a poor curriculum.Dubuque, IA:Kendall/ Hunt.
54. Proweller, A.(1998).Constructing female identities: Meaning making in an upper middle class youth culture.Albany:State University of New York Press.
55. Reiniger,M.(1988).Traces of misogyny in women' s schooling: Autobiographical search for gyn/ecology.JCT: The Journal of Curriculum Theorizing,8,7-89.
56. Rich, A.(1979).On lies, secrets and silence.New York:W.W. Norton and Company.
57. Roman, L. G.,Apple, M.W.,E.W. Eisner(Eds.),A. Peshkin(Eds.)(1990).Qualitative inquiry in education: The continuing debate.New York:Teachers College Press.
58. Ropers-Huilman, B.(1998).Feminist teaching in the theory and practice: Situating power and knowledge in post-structure classrooms.New York:teachers College Press.
59. Rorty, R.(1979).Philosophy and the mirror of nature.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
60. Rose, E.C.(Eds.),Mayberry, M.(Eds.)(1999).Meeting the challenge: Innovative feminist pedagogies in action.New York:Routledge.
61. Schubert, W. H.(1986).Curriculum.N.Y.:Macmillan.
62. Schubert, W.H.,Schubert, A.L.L.,Thomas, T.P.,Carrol, W.M.(2002).Curriculum books: The first hundred years.New York:Peter Lang.
63. Sedgwick, E.K.(1990).Epistemology of the closet.Berkeley:University of California Press.
64. Silvers, R.(1984).Teaching phenomenology.Phenomenology + Pedagogy,2(1),18-31.
65. Walkerdine,V.(1985).Science and the female mind: The burden of proof.PsychCritique,1(1),1-20.
66. Wallenstein, S.(1979).New York,University of Rochester, Rochester.
67. Weiner, G.(1994).An introduction.Bristol, PA:Open University Press.
68. Wexler, P.(1987).Social analysis of education.New York:Routledge.
69. Young, I.,L. Nicholson(Ed.)(1990).Feminism/Postmodemism.New York:Routledge.
70. 周珮儀(1999)。從社會批判到後現代－季胡課程理論之研究。台北:師大書苑。

1. 黃振豊、何俊青(2015)。杜威、赫欽斯與羅蒂對博雅教育的不同看法及其對通識教育的啟示。通識教育學刊，15，33-49。
2. (2016)。Nel Noddings「教學即關係性實踐」之析論。教育研究學報，50(1)，1-22。