题名

由學習理論的變遷探討大學物理教學革新動向

并列篇名

Learning Theories and Teaching Innovation in University Physics

DOI

10.6384/CIQ.200904.0077

作者

張慧貞(Whei-Jen Chang)

关键词

教學革新 ； 個人建構 ； 社會文化觀 ； 物理教育 ； 學習理論 ； teaching innovation ； personal constructivism ； sociocultural views ； physics education ； learning theories

期刊名称

課程與教學

卷期/出版年月

12卷2期（2009 / 04 / 01）

页次

77 - 105

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

近年來，大學物理教學改革的風潮已在國外快速興起，並逐漸擴及國內。本文首先論述近代重要學習理論的內涵與對教學的啓發，接著介紹當前國內外改革方案之策略及教學資源，最後根據學習理論檢視革新主流之特點與盲點。本文主旨有二：（一）喚起國內從事大學物理教育之學者，能省思傳統教學模式之缺失，誘導其課堂改革的意願；（二）對已進行改革的物理教授／教師們，能充實其對知識論與學習觀的涵養，以體會改革策略背後的學理根據及目的。除了「個人建構」(Personal Constructivism)所強調的認知衝突、概念改變…等「實證理性」的主張之外。更能領略晚近所崛起「社會文化觀」(sociocultural views)所突顯的「非理性」、「文化融合」任務，包含熟悉科學工具(artifacts)、掌握科學社群特有之觀點、規範、習俗…等，以落實「教學革新」的預期成效。
英文摘要

Recently, a burgeoning amount of literature has reported on the innovative teaching programs in university physics in western countries, and this trend has gradually drawn physicists' attention in Taiwan. Although these innovative programs have been found to reflect several notions of learning theories which have emerged in recent decades, there still are some aspects which appear to have been overlooked. This article begins by elaborating on the notions of three major learning theories, i.e., behaviorism, personal constructivism, and socio-cultural views. It then describes the features, outcomes and resources of the most influential programs in physics teaching. Lastly, based on the notions of learning theories, the author examines the strengths and critiques the drawbacks in the existing innovation programs, and provides suggestions for further modifications. The aims of this article are (1) to stimulate physics instructors to notice the stagnation of traditional teaching and be willing to modify their teaching style, (2) to highlight the importance of grasping the notions of learning theories for implementing teaching innovation. By means of being informed by pedagogical knowledge, practitioners can find the optimal point between innovation and tradition, and realize the goal of achieving better learning.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 張慧貞(2003)。由哈佛到逢甲：普通物理互動教學的實施與成效。科學教育學刊，11(4)，391-406。
    連結：
  2. Andersson, B.,Bach, F.(2005).On designing and evaluating teaching sequences taking geometrical optics as an example.Science Education,89(2),196-218.
  3. Proceedings of the 2000 Annual Meeting of the American Society for Engineering Education
  4. Belcher, J.(2001).Studio Physics at MIT.MIT Physics Department Newsletter,Fall,1.
  5. Bell, B.(2003).Theorizing pedagogy-Guest editorial.Waikato Journal of Education,9,3-9.
  6. Bell, B.(2005).Learning in science: The Waikato research.Abingdon:Routledge Falmer.
  7. Bell, B.,Cowie, B.(2001).Formative assessment and science education.The Netherland:Kluwer Academic.
  8. Berg, C. A.,Smith, P.(1994).Assessing students' abilities to construct and interpret line graphs: Disparities between multiple-choice and free-response instruments.Science Education,78,527-554.
  9. Besson, U.(2004).Some features of causal reasoning: common sense and physics teaching.Research in Science & Technological Education,22(1),113-125.
  10. Bowen, M.,Roth, W.-M.(2002).Why students may not learn to interpret scientific inscriptions.Research in Science Education,32(3),303-327.
  11. Bransford, J. D.,Brown, A. L.,Cocking, R.,Donovan, M.,Pellegrino, S.(Ed.)(2000).How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school.Washington DC:National Academic Press.
  12. Bruner, J.,I.V. Wertsch(Ed.)(1985).Culture, communication and cognition: Vygotskian perspectives.England:Cambridge University Press.
  13. Buncick, M. C.,Betts, P. G.,Horgan, D. D.(2001).Using demonstrations as a contextual road map: enhancing course continuity and promoting active engagement in introductory college physics.International Journal of Science Education,23(12),1237-1255.
  14. Casperson, J. M.,Linn, M. C.(2006).Using visualization to teach electrostatics.American Journal of Physics,74(4),316-323.
  15. Chang, W.(2005).Impact of constructivist teaching on students' beliefs about teaching and learning in introductory physics.Canadian Journal of Science, Mathematics & Technology Education,5(1),95-109.
  16. Chang, W.(2007).Utilising theme demonstrations and concept maps to integrate electrostatics teaching.Paper presented to the Ninth International History, Philosophy & Science Teaching Conference,Calgary, Canada:
  17. Chang, W.(2005).The rewards and challenges of teaching innovation in university physics: Four years' reflection.International Journal of Science Education,27(4),407-425.
  18. Chang, W.,Bell, B.(2002).Making content easier or adding more challenge in year one university physics.Research in Science Education,32(1),81-96.
  19. Chang, W.,Bell, B.,Jones, A..Development of Newton's Laws of Motion: Discovery or Invention.
  20. Chi, M. T. H.,Slotta, J. D.,da Leeuw, N.(1994).From things to processes: A theory of conceptual change for learning science concepts.Learning and Instruction,4,27-43.
  21. Cohen, B.,Whitman, A.(1999).Isaac Newton: The principia mathematical principles of natural philosophy.Berkeley:University of California Press.
  22. Coleman, L.,Griffith, D.,E. F. Redish(Eds.),J. S. Ridgen(Eds.)(1997).The changing role of physics departments in modem university, Proceedings of ICUPE.New York:American Institute of Physics.
  23. Costa, S.,Hughes, T.,Pinch, T.(1998).Bringing it all back home: some implications of recent science and technology studies for the classroom science teacher.Research in Science Education,28(1),9-21.
  24. Crouch, C. H.,Mazur, E.(2001).Peer instruction: Ten years of experience and results.American Journal of Physic,69(9),970-977.
  25. Crouch, C.,Fagan, A. P.,Callan, J. P.,Mazur, E.(2004).Classroom demonstrations: Learning tools or entertainment.American Journal of Physics,72,835-838.
  26. Di Stefano, R.(1996).Preliminary IIJPP results: Students reactions to in-class demonstrations and the presentation of coherent themes.American Journal of Physics,64(1),58-68.
  27. Driver, R.,Asoko, H.,Leach, J.,Mortimer, E.,Scott, P.(1997).Constructing scientific knowledge in the classroom.Educational Researcher,23(7),5-12.
  28. Duit, R.,Treagust, D. F.,B. J. Fraser(Eds.),K. G. Tobin(Eds.)(1998).International handbook of science education.UK:Kluwer Academic.
  29. Elton, L.(1997).University physics teaching in reducing circumstances.Physics Education,32(5),346-350.
  30. Fagen, A. P.,Crouch, C. H.,Mazur, E.(2002).Peer instruction: Results from a range of classrooms.The Physics Teacher,40(40),206-209.
  31. Finkelstein, N. D.,Pollock, S. J.(2005).Replicating and understanding successful innovations: Implementing tutorials in introductory physics.Physical Review-Physics Education research,1(1),1-13.
  32. French, A.(1988).Some thoughts on introduction physics courses.American Journal of Physics,56(2),110-113.
  33. Galili, I.(1995).Mechanics background influences students' conceptions in electromagnetism.International Journal of Science Education,17(3),371-387.
  34. Galili, I.(2001).Weight versus gravitational force: historical and educational perspectives.International Journal of Science Education,23(10),1073-1093.
  35. Gautreau, R.,Novemsky, L.(1997).Concepts first-A small group approach to physics learning.American Journal of Physics,65(5),418-428.
  36. Geelan, D.(1997).Epistemological anarchy and the many forms of constructivism.Science and Education,6(1),15-28.
  37. Hake, R. R.(1998).Interactive-engagement versus traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses.American Journal of Physics,66(1),64-74.
  38. Halloun, I. A.,E. F. Redish(Eds.),J. S. Ridgen(Eds.)(1997).The changing role of physics departments in modem universities. Proceedings of ICUPE.New York:American Institute of Physics.
  39. Halloun, I. A.,Hestenes, D.(1985).The initial knowledge state of college physics students.American Journal of Physics,53(11),1043-1055.
  40. Hammer, D.(1996).More than misconceptions: Multiple perspectives on student knowledge and reasoning, and an appropriate role for education research.American Journal of Physics,64(10),1316-1325.
  41. Hennessy, S.(1993).Situated cognition and cognitive apprenticeship: Implications for classroom learning.Studies in Science Education,22,1-41.
  42. Hestenes, D.,E. F. Redish(Eds.),J. S. Ridgen(Eds.)(1997).The changing role of physics departments in modern university. Proceedings of ICUPE.Woodbury, NY:American Institute of Physics.
  43. Hewitt, P.(1994).Concepts before computation.The Physics Teacher,32(4),224.
  44. Hilborn, R.(1988).Redesigning college-and university-level introductory physics.American Journal of Physics,56(1),14-17.
  45. Kelly, G. A.,B. Maher(Ed.)(1969).Clinical psycho logy and personality: The selected papers of George Kelly.New York, NY:Wiley.
  46. Lasry, N.(2008).Clickers or flashcards: Is there really a difference.The Physics Teacher,46(4),242-244.
  47. Lave, J.,Wenger, E.(1991).Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  48. Leach, J.,Scott, P.(2002).Designing and evaluating science teaching sequences: An approach drawing upon the concept of learning demand and a social constructivist perspective on learning.Studies in Science Education,38,115-142.
  49. Leach, J.,Scott, P.(1995).The demands of learning science concepts: Issue of theory and practice.School Science Review,76(277),47-52.
  50. Linder, C. J.(1993).A challenge to conceptual change.Science Education,77(3),293-300.
  51. Matthews, M.(1992).Constructivism and empiricism An incomplete divorce.Research in Science Education,22,299-307.
  52. Mazur, E.(1996).Peer instruction: A users' manual.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
  53. McDermott, L.(1993).How we teach and how students learn-A mismatch.American Journal of Physics,61(4),295-298.
  54. McDermott, L. C.,Shaffer P. S.(2002).Tutorials in introductory physics and homework package.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
  55. McDermott, L. C.,Shaffer, P. S.(1992).Research as a guide for curriculum development: An example from introductory electricity. Part I: Investigation of student understanding.American Journal of Physics,60,994-1003.
  56. Meheut, M.(2004).Teaching-learning sequences: aims and tools for science education research.International Journal of Science Education,26(5),515-535.
  57. Meltzer, D.,Manivannan, K.(2002).Transforming the lecture-hall environment: The fully interactive physics lecture.American Journal of Physics,70(6),639-654.
  58. Mercer, N.(2008).Changing out minds: A commentary on 'conceptual change: a discussion of theoretical, methodological and practical challenges for science education'.Cultural Studies of Science Education,3,351-362.
  59. Millar, R.(1989).Constructive criticisms.International Journal of Science Education,11(5),587-596.
  60. Mills, D.,McKittrick, B.,Mulhall, P.,Feteris, S.(1999).CUP: cooperative learning that works.Physics Education,34(1),11-15.
  61. Mintzes, I.,Wandersee, I.,Novak, I. D.,G. D. Phye(Ed.)(1997).Handbook of academic learning.Orlando, FL:Academic Press.
  62. Novak, I. D.(1991).Clarify with concept maps.The Science Teacher,58(7),45-49.
  63. Novak, I. D.,Gowin, D. B.(1984).Learning how to learn.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
  64. Novak, I. D.,Ridley, D. R.(1988).Assessing student learning in light of how students learn.Washington, DC:The American Association for Higher Education Assessment Forum.
  65. Nuthall, G.,B. Biddle(Eds.),T. Good(Eds.),I. Goodson(Eds.)(1997).The international handbook of teachers and teaching.Dordrecht:Kluwer Academic.
  66. O''Loughlin, M.(1992).Rethinking science education: Beyond Piagetian constructivism toward a sociocultural model of teaching and learning.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,29,791-820.
  67. Pea, R.,G. Salomon(Ed.)(1993).Distributed cognitions: Psychological and educational considerations.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
  68. Perkins, D.,G. Salomon(Ed.)(1993).Distributed cognitions: Psychological and educational considerations.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  69. Piaget, J.,P. Mussen(Ed.)(1970).Carmichael's manual of child psychology.New York, NY:Wiley.
  70. Pintrich, P. R.,Marx, R. W.,Boyle, R. A.(1993).Beyond cold conceptual change: The role of motivational beliefs and classroom contextual factors in the process of conceptual change.Review of Educational Research,63(2),167-199.
  71. Pope, M.,Keen, T.(1981).Personal construct psychology and education.London:Academic Press.
  72. Posner, G. J.,Strike, K. A.,Hewson, P. W.,Gertzog, W. A.(1982).Accommodation of a scientific conception: Toward a theory of conceptual change.Science Education,66(2),211-227.
  73. Redish, E. F.(1994).Implications of cognitive studies for teaching physics.American Journal of Physics,62(90),796-803.
  74. Ridgen, J. S.,Holcomb, P. F.,Di Stefano, R.(1993).The introductory university physics project.Physics Today,46(4),32-37.
  75. Rogoff, B.,R. Wozniak(Eds.),K. Fisher(Eds.)(1993).Development in context: Acting and thinking in specific environments.Hilisdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  76. Roth, W.-M.,McGinn, M. K.(1998).Graphing: Cognitive ability or practice.Science Education,81(1),91-106.
  77. Roth, W.-M.,McRobbie, C. J.,Lucas, K. B.,Boutonne, S.(1997).Why may students fail to learn from demonstrations? A social practice perspective on learning in physics.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,34(5),509-533.
  78. Roth, W.-M.,Roychoudhury, A.(1994).Physics students' epistemologies and views about knowing and learning.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,31(1),5-30.
  79. Salomon, G.(Ed.)(1993).Distributed cognitions: Psychological and educational considerations.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
  80. Salomon, G.,G. Salomon(Ed.)(1993).Distributed cognitions: Psychological and educational considerations.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
  81. Savinainen, A.,Scott, P.,Viiri, J.(2005).Using a bridging representation and social interactions to foster conceptual change: Designing and evaluating an instructional sequence for Newton's third law.Science Education,89(2),175-195.
  82. Schecker, H. P.(1992).The paradigmatic change in mechanics: Implications of historical processes for physics education.Science & Education,1,71-76.
  83. Shulman, L.(1977).Knowledge and teaching: Foundations of the new reform.Harvard Educational Review,57(1),1-22.
  84. Singh, C.(2006).Student understanding of symmetry and Gauss's law of electricity.American Journal of Physics,74(10),923-938.
  85. Solomon, J.(1983).Learning about energy: How pupils think in two domains.European Journal of Science Education,5,49-59.
  86. Steinberg, M. S.,Brown, D. E.,Clement, J.(1990).Genius is not immune to persistent misconceptions: conceptual difficulties impeding Isaac Newton and contemporary physics students.International Journal of Science Education,12(3),265-273.
  87. Strike, K. A.,Posner, G. J.,R. Duschl(Eds.),R. Hamilton(Eds.)(1992).Philosophy of science, cognitive, psychology and educational theory and practice.Albany, NY:State University of NY.
  88. Thornton, R.,Sokoloff, D.(1990).Learning motion concepts using real-time microcomputer-based laboratory tools.American Journal of Physics,58(9),858-866.
  89. Toa, P. K.,Gunstone, R.(1999).The process of conceptual change in force and motion during computer-supported physics instruction.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,36(70),859-882.
  90. Tobias, S.,P. Connolly(Eds.),T. Vilardis(Eds.)(1989).Writing to learn mathematics and science.New York, NY:Teachers College Press.
  91. Tobin, K.(1993).Referents for making sense of science teaching.International Journal of Science Education,15(3),241-254.
  92. Tornkvist, S.,Pettersson, K.,Transtromer, G.(1993).Confusion by representation: On student's comprehension of the electric field concept.American Journal of Physics,61(4),335-338.
  93. Von Glaserfeld, E.,F. Steier(Ed.)(1991).Research and reflexivity.London:Sage.
  94. Well, G.(2008).Learning to use scientific concepts.Cultural Studies of Science Education,3,329-350.
  95. Wertsch, J. V.(1991).Voices of the mind: A sociocultural approach to mediated action.Cambridge, Massachusetts:Harvard University Press.
  96. Westfall, R. S.(1980).Never at rest: A biography of Isaac Newton.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  97. White, R. T.(1973).Research into learning hierarchies.Review of Educational Research,43,361-375.
  98. Whitrow, G.(1971).The laws of motion.The British Journal for the History of Science,5(19),217-234.
  99. 張慧貞(2007)。創新物理教材教法：理論與錦囊。臺中:逢甲大學出版社。
  100. 湯兆崙、黃鼎凱、蔡宜君(2006)。多媒體促進互動教學－TEAL普通物理的實施與成效。物理雙月刊（物理教育專輯），28(3)，544-553。
  101. 黃台珠、熊召弟、王美芬、余曉清、靳知勤、段曉林、熊同鑫譯、J. J. Mintzes、J. H. Wandersee、J. D. Novak編著(2002)。促進理解之科學教學：人本建構取向觀點。臺北:心理。
  102. 黃福坤(2006)。透過物理模擬動畫進行物理教學與學習－介紹簡易模擬動畫設計環境Easy Java Simulation。物理雙月刊（物理教育專輯），28(3)，556-543。
被引用次数
  1. 蘇慧慈、陳俊卿(2010)。皮亞傑認知發展論對體育教學之啟示。大專體育，108，30-37。
print cancel