操作技能對思考與實作表現影響之研究

The Effect of Practical Skills on Thinking and Hands-On Performance

10.6384/CIQ.201110.0162

林坤誼(Kuen-Yi Lin)；游光昭(Kuang-Chao Yu)；洪國峰(Guo-Fong Hong)

操作技能 ； 思考 ； 實作 ； 質性知識 ； 國中學生 ； practical skills ； thinking ； hands-on ； qualitative knowledge ； junior-high-school student

課程與教學

14卷4期（2011 / 10 / 01）

161 - 185

繁體中文

本研究著重於探究操作技能與思考和實作表現之間的關係，並分析強化學習者的操作技能，是否有助提升學習者思考的深度與實作表現的完整性。為達成前述目的，本研究以兩班共61名八年級學生為對象，採準實驗設計的不相等控制組設計來進行實驗研究，並透過質性與量化資料的分析獲得以下的具體結論：（1）強化國中生的操作技能並無法有效提升其思考的表現，而是需強化其概念性知識以提升思考能力；（2）強化國中生的操作技能對其實作表現雖稍有助益，但更重要的是，需強化其程序性知識以提升實作能力；（3）思考強且實作強的學生若不能瞭解及運用質性知識，仍不足以掌握科技實作的運作系統。

This study focuses on investigating the effect of practical skills on students' thinking and hands-on performance when working on a technology project. Also, this study tries to verify the effect of students' thinking and hands-on performance by enhancing their practical skills. Sixty-one 8th graders were investigated in this study. A nonequivalent control group design of quasi-experimental design was conducted, and following conclusions were made: (1) Enhancing students' practical skill did not necessarily promote their thinking performance. It was suggested that the conceptual knowledge was needed to further improve their thinking ability. (2) Enhancing students' practical skill had little effect on their practical performance. It was suggested that the conceptual knowledge was needed to further improve their practical performance. (3) Students with good thinking and practical ability did not necessarily fully understand the technology system, only if qualitative knowledge in technology was used.

1. 于富雲、陳玉欣(2007)。不同知識表徵建構的學習策略對自然科學習成效之影響。科學教育學刊，15(1)，99-118。
   連結：
2. 游光昭、林坤誼、洪國峰(2010)。從反思與實踐看國中生在科技實作活動中的學習歷程表現。課程與教學季刊，13(3)，219-250。
   連結：
3. Agassi, J.(1997).Thought, action and scientific technology.International Journal of Technology and Design Education,7(1-2),33-48.
4. Dewey, J.(1952).Experience and nature.Chicago, IL:Open Court Publishing Company.
5. Ihde, D.(1997).The structure of technology knowledge.International Journal of Technology and Design Education,7(1),73-79.
6. Lave, J.(1988).Cognition in Practice: Mind, Mathematics and Culture in EverydayLife.Cambridge, England:Cambridge University Press.
7. Levinson, R.,Murphy, P.,McCormick, R.(1997).Science and technology concepts in a design and technology project: A pilot study.Research in Science and Technological Education,15(2),235-255.
8. Lewis, T.(1999).Content or process as approaches to technology curriculum: Does it matter come Monday morning?.Journal of Technology Education,11(1),45-59.
9. McCormick, R.(2004).Issues of learning and knowledge in technology education.International Journal of Technology and Design Education,14(1),21-44.
10. Morlaix, S.(2010).Assessing pupils' skills: implications for research.Journal of Curriculum Studies,42(3),395-409.
11. Petrina, S.(2007).Advanced teaching methods for the technology classroom.Hershey, PA:Information Science Publishing.
12. Polanyi, M.(1962).Personal knowledge: Towards a post-critical philosophy.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
13. Roth, W. M.(2001).Learning science through technological design.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,38(7),768-790.
14. Rothkopf, E. Z.(ed.)(1988).Review of Research in Education.Washington, D.C.:American Educational Research Association.
15. Schoenfeld, A.(1996).In fostering communities of inquiry, must it matter that the teacher knows the answer?.For the Learning of Mathematics,14(1),44-55.
16. Sidawi, M. M.(2009).Teaching science through designing technology.International Journal of Technology and Design Education,19(3),269-287.
17. Singley, M. K.,Anderson, J. R.(1989).The transfer of cognitive skill.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
18. Tempelman, E.,Pilot, A.(2010).Strengthening the link between theory and practice in teaching design engineering: an empirical study on a new approach.International Journal of Technology and Design Education
19. Weaver, G. C.(1998).Strategies in K-12 science instruction to promote conceptual change.Science Education,82(4),455-472.
20. Zimmerman, B. J.(ed.),Schunk, D. H.(ed.)(1989).Self-regulated learning and academic achievement: Theory, research, and practice.New York:Springer-Verlag.
21. 朱益賢(2008)。從社會環境成份探討學生的實作技能與科技創造力—透過科技競賽策略從社會環境成份探討學生的實作技能與科技創造力—透過科技競賽策略,行政院國家科學委員會。
22. 游光昭、林坤誼、王詩婷(2007)。自然與生活科技領域統整課程的反思與實踐。當代教育研究，15(1)，143-180。

1. 張美珍、朱耀明、王麗雅、王裕宏(2013)。大學生參與博物館創意競賽之實作歷程及其影響因素。科技博物，17(3)，5-31。