網路健康資訊之批判思考技能發展之方案規畫研究

A Study of Program Design to Enhance Critical Thinking Skills toward Internet Health Information

10.6384/CIQ.201210.0217

黃明月(Ming-Yueh Hwang)

批判思考技能 ； 網路健康資訊 ； 批判思考技能培訓 ； critical thinking skill ； health information ； critical thinking skill training

課程與教學

15卷4期（2012 / 10 / 01）

217 - 239

繁體中文

本研究主要目的在針對中小學教師，發展一個教學活動方案，提升其對網路健康資訊的批判思考技能，並透過實地教學實驗了解其成效。以中小學教師為主的成人團體為研究對象，共25位，年齡分布於28歲至55歲之間，大部分為女性。參考了Ennis批判思考教學模式，本研究以澄清、診斷、練習與評鑑等階段來規畫教學活動。本研究以網路流傳頻率高且受試者關心的議題為主，每隔一週上課，共計九次活動。本研究摘錄網路健康資訊，並經專家審定後，作為研究材料，提供師生閱讀與討論之文本，以了解受試者批判思考技能運作與改變情形。此外，以「批判思考能力測驗第二級」為前後測工具，了解其學習成效。研究發現，在澄清與診斷階段中，受試者運用較多的批判思考技能是「質疑」、「論證評鑑」與「比較」，經由教學者於課程中不斷地強調「論證評鑑」、「證據」的重要性，從練習階段開始，「證據」與「論證評鑑」的使用頻率開始增加。此外，後測分數大為提升，受試者在論證評鑑、辨認假設與歸納的技能上，皆有明顯的進步，顯示了批判思考技能培訓方案的教學成效。本研究未來需繼續加強與專業社群的互動，透過轉化學習的歷程，以促進辨認假設的覺知，進而運作高層次的批判思考。

The purpose of this study is to develop the instructional program for teachers to enhance their critical thinking skills. Furthermore, field experiment is applied to evaluate the effectiveness of the program.The subjects for this study are 25 teachers from primary and secondary schools. The program is implemented following Ennis's instructional stages: clarification, diagnosis, practice and evaluation. In order to understand the subjects' operation of critical thinking skills, online health information is excerpted and examined by experts as research materials to provide subjects for reading and discussion. In addition, ”second-level critical thinking ability test” is adopted as the tool for preand post- test to evaluate the effectiveness of the program.The study finds that during the diagnostic phase, the subjects use more critical thinking skills such as ”questioning”, ”argument evaluation” and ”Comparison”. However, the subjects start to use more thinking skills such as ”evidence searching” and ”argument evaluation” during the practice phase. In addition, a significant difference is found in post-test scores, and subjects make more progress in argument evaluation, assumptions identification and logical reasoning. The findings show the effectiveness of the critical thinking skills training program. This study suggests the need to strengthen the interaction with the professional community, and through the transformative learning process to promote the awareness of identifying assumptions, and then to enhance the operation of the higher level critical thinking skills.

1. 葉玉珠（2008）。批判思考教學理論與設計。2010 年 1 月 3 日檢索自http://ctld.ntu.edu.tw/epaper?p=1000
2. NSF (2006). Science and Engineering Indicators 2006. Retrieved Sep.23,2007,from http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/seind06/
3. 資策會(2002)。網際網路趨勢調查報告。台北：財團法人資策會出版。
4. 陳文典（2005）。科學素養的內涵。2008 年 10 月 9 日，檢索自http://www.phy.ntnu.edu.tw/nstsc/doc/book94.11/01.doc
5. Facione, P. A. (2010). Critical thinking: what is and why it counts. Retrieved Jan 10, 2010 from http://www.insightassessment.com.update
6. Burst Media (2007). Health Information Online. Online Insights(Aug. 2007), Retrived Sep. 28, 2009, from http://www.burstmedia.com/pdfs/research/2007_08_01.pdf
7. 梁德馨(2011)。2011臺灣無線網路使用調查報告。臺灣網路資訊中心。2011年11日檢索自http://www.twnic.net.tw/NEWS/1746.PDF
8. Angeli, C.,Valanides, N.(2009).Instructional effects on critical thinking: performance on ill-defined issues.Learning and Instruction,19,322-334.
9. Baker, L.,Wagner,T. H.,Singer, S.,Bundorf, M. K.(2003).Use of the internet and e-mail for health care information: results from a national survey.JAMA,289(18),2400-06.
10. Edward, S. L.(2007).Critical thinking: a two-phase framework.Nurse Education in Practice,7,303-314.
11. Ennis, R. H.(1985).A logical basis for measuring critical thinking skills.Educational Leadership,43(2),44-48.
12. Eysenbach, G.,Kohler, C.(2002).How do consumers search for and appraise health information on the world wide web? Qualitative studyusing focus groups, usability tests, and in-depth interviews.British Medical Journal,324,573-577.
13. Facione, P. A.(2002).The California critical thinking skills test(CCTST): Form 2000.Millbrac, CA:California Academic Press.
14. Facione, P. A.,Sanchez, C. A.,Facione, N. C.,Gainen, J.(1985).The Disposition toward critical thinking.Journal of General Education,44(1),1-25.
15. Facione, P.A.,Facione, N.C.(1992).The California critical thinking disposition inventory.The California Academic Press.
16. Fauske, J.,Wade, S. E.(2003).Research to practice online: conditions that foster democracy, community and critical thinking in computer-mediated discussion.Journal of Research on Technology in Education,36(2),137-153.
17. Frijters, S.,Dam, G.,Rijlaarsdam, G.(2008).Effecs of dialogic learning on value-loaded critical thinking.Learning & Instruction,18,66-82.
18. Goodin, H. J.,Stein, D.(2009).The use of deliberative discussion to enhance the critical thinking abilities of nursing students.Journal of Public Deliberation,5(1),1-18.
19. Green, M.C.(2005).Athabasca University.
20. Grunig, J. E.(1979).Time budgets, level of involvement, and use of the mass media.Journalism Quarterly,56,248-26.
21. Grunig, J. E.(1978).Defining publics in public relations: the case ofa suburban hospital.Journalism Quarterly,55,109-118.
22. Hall, S.(1973).Encoding and decoding in the television discourse.Birmingham:Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies.
23. Harris, J.,Eleser, C.(1997).Developmental critical thinking: Melding two imperatives.Journal of Developmental Education,21(1),12-19.
24. Heath, R. L.,Liao, S. H.,Douglas, W.(1995).Effects of perceived economic harms and benefits on issue involvement, use of information sources, and actions: A study in risk communication.Journal of Public Relations Research,7,89-109.
25. Hoijer, B.(1992).Socio-cognitive structures and television reception.Media, Culture and Society,14(4),583-603.
26. Jensen, K. B.,Rosengren, K. E.(1990).Five Traditions in Search of the Audience.European Journal of Communication,5(2),207-238.
27. Jones, J.(1989).North Carolina State University.
28. Jones, J.,Safrit, R.(1994).Developing Critical Thinking Skills in Adult Learners through Innovative Distance Learning.International Conference on the Practice of Adult Education and Social Development,Jinan, China:
29. Kunter, M.,Greenberg, E.,Jin, Y.,Paulson, C,(2006).,Washington, DC:US Dept. of Education, National Center for Education Statistics.
30. Lipman, M.(2003).Thinking in education.NY:Cambridge University Press.
31. McQuail, D.(2000).McQuail's Mass Communication Therory.Lodnon:Sage.
32. McQuail, Denis、陳芸芸譯、劉慧雯譯(2003)。特新大眾傳播理論。台北:韋伯文化。
33. Morgan, D. L.(1996).Focus group as qualitative research.Newburg Park,CA:Sage.
34. Mottola, C. A.,Murphy, P.(2001).Antidote dilemma - an activity to promote critical thinking.The Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing,32(4),161-164.
35. Newman, D. R.,Webb, B.,Cochrane, C.(1995).A content analysis method to measure critical thinking in face-to face and computer supported learning.Interpersonal Computing and Instruction,3,56-77.
36. Nikander, P.(1995).The Turn to the Text : The Critical Potential of Discursive Social Psychology.Nordiske Udkast,2,3-15.
37. Parker, R.,Moore, B.N.(2001).Critical thinking.Mountain View, CA:Mayfield.
38. Parvis, C. A.(2009).Athens, GA,University of Georgia.
39. Paul, R. W.(1995).Critical thinking: How to prepare students for a rapidly changing world.Santa Rosa, CA:Foundation for Critical Thinking.
40. Paul, R. W.,Elder, L.(2006).Critical thinking tools for taking changes of your learning and your life.New Jersey:Prentice-Hall.
41. Rogers, E. M.(1996).The field of health communication today: An up-to-date report.Department of Communication and Journalism,1(1),24-32.
42. Wilson, P.(2002).How to find the good and avoid the bad or ugly: A short guide to tools for rating quality of health information on the internet.British Medical Journal,324,598-600.
43. Witte, P. G.(2010).Health literacy: can we live without it?.Adult Basic Education And Literacy Journal,4(1),3-12.
44. Yang, Y. T. C.,Newby, T.,Bill, R.(2008).Facilitating interactions through structured web-based bulletin boards: a quasi-experimental study on promoting learners' critical thinking skills.Computer & Education,50,1527-1585.
45. 王秋絨(1996)。葉尼斯、貝爾、馬克貝刻的批判思考觀在成人批判教學上的意義。社會教育學刊，25，89-108。
46. 王貞儀、詹其峰、陳恆順、陳慶餘、劉宏文(2003)。專家對網路健康資訊的真偽判讀標準。國際醫學資訊研討會論文集，台灣:
47. 吳筱玫(2002)。網路傳播槪論。台北:智勝文化。
48. 李承宇(2002)。教師應具備之資訊素養：批判思考觀點。國民教育，42(6)，67-73。
49. 張玉成(1993)。思考技巧與教學。臺北:心理出版社。
50. 陳翌函(2007)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北市，中國文化大學新聞研究所。
51. 黃台珠(2007)。,國科會。
52. 黃惠鈴(2000)。上網搜尋健康。康健雜誌，18，107-112。
53. 楊雅婷(2005)。,國科會。
54. 鄭維理(2006)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北市，台北醫學大學醫學資訊研究所。
55. 謝炫達(2001)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北市，國立政治大學廣告研究所。
56. 謝慧欣(1999)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北市，台灣大學衛生政策與管理研究所。

1. 楊淑晴、許琬甄、江佳勳(2015)。大學生網路健康素養量表建構及其與健康行為之關係研究。中華心理衛生學刊，28(3)，389-420。
2. (2014)。啟發大學生批判思考之教學成效探究：以傳播科系為例。成人及終身教育學刊，22，33-68。