「行動－反思」教學及其在大學教育實習課程的應用

The "Action-Reflection" Teaching and Its Applications in a Teaching Practicum Course

10.6384/CIQ.201307_16(3).0009

徐綺穗(Chi-Sui Hsu)

「行動─反思」教學 ； 反思 ； 教育實習 ； "action-reflection" teaching ； reflection ； teaching practicum

課程與教學

16卷3期（2013 / 07 / 01）

219 - 253

繁體中文

本研究目的在於探討以一「行動─反思」教學模式為基礎，調整及規劃運用於教育實習課程的教學流程，並探討接受此一教學之實習學生其教學知識、策略的變化，及對學習方法的省思。本研究採用行動研究法，以某國立大學教育系四年級修習教育實習課程之學生為研究對象。研究發現共有下列幾項：1.「行動─反思」教學應用於教育實習其實施教學流程分為實習準備、實習行動及實習後檢討三階段，每一個階段都包含（1）個人反思（2）小組對話反思（3）課堂對話（4）教師的引導統整三者的循環，促使實習學生多次反思，達成行動與理論的統整。2.實習學生其教學知識理解的變化包括：（1）理解「了解學生」對教學的重要性，及學生特質與經驗具有特殊性（2）從個別評量方法的認知，到評量與教學目標、學童發展相互關係的理解（3）教學節奏流暢與教室秩序維持互為消長，良好教學設計可以化解兩難困境（4）從與同儕說話一般稍快的速度，轉變至速度適中的教師口語表達（5）理解時間掌控的內涵隨著教學情境的變化而不同3.實習學生對學習方法的省思：（1）行動學習小組的合作，有助於順利完成學習任務（2）反思有助於個人學習過程的正向情緒（3）行動帶來豐富的學習（4）反思的報告增添課業的負荷。

The purposes of this study were to explore the adaptation of ”action- reflection” teaching model for the implementation of teaching practicum course. It also tried to understand the students' comprehension on their teaching knowledge after they received an ”action-reflection” teaching. During the course, students' reflections of learning method were also discussed. This study applied an action research with a group of forty college students enrolling in a course of teaching practicum.The main findings included: (1) The cycle of ”action-reflection” teaching consisted of personal reflection, group reflection and teacher guided reflection, and integration within the whole class. (2) What students gained more about certain specific concepts of teaching were actually from their reflections on teaching in real contexts. (3) Students became more aware that many factors should be considered simultaneously when evaluating children's performances. (4) The balance between teaching and discipline should be achieved by a well-designed lesson plan. (5) Students became more confident and efficient in using several teaching strategies, such as oral presentation and timing control. (6) Students believe that it was helpful to conduct a team-work to complete learning tasks within their own group. Finally, they all agreed that knowledge was constructed and integrated by involving themselves doing reflections after teaching.

1. 周水珍(2003)。師院生集中實習的教學轉化歷程之研究。花蓮師院學報，17，31-54。
   連結：
2. 林淑梤、張惠博、段曉林(2009)。促進實習教師教學學習的夥伴式實習輔導。教育科學研究期刊，54(1)，23-53。
   連結：
3. 徐綺穗(2007)。行動學習理論及其在大學教學的應用─建構「行動─反思」教學模式。課程與教學季刊，10(4)，49-62。
   連結：
4. 徐綺穗(2012)。大學教學的創新模式─「行動─反思」教學對大學生學習成就、批判思考意向及學業情緒影響之研究。課程與教學季刊，15(1)，119-150。
   連結：
5. 徐綺穗(2011)。從Grossman 的反思層次來分析學生的行動反思內涵。教育學誌，25，29-53。
   連結：
6. 許淑玫(2005)。教育實習經驗的意義解析─以一名國小實習教師為例。課程與教學季刊，8(3)，105-125。
   連結：
7. 陳國泰(2011)。反省取向的「二階段集中實習課程」對國小師資聲實務知識發展的影響。教育實踐與研究，24(1)，25-66。
   連結：
8. 黃哲彬(2005)。論行動學習之理念及其在教師進修上的啟示。學校行政，36，52-59。
   連結：
9. Altrichter, N.(1993).Teachers investigate their work: An introduction to the methods of action research.New York, NY:Routledge.
10. Argyris, M.,Schön, D.(1974).Theory in practice: Increasing professional effectiveness.London, UK:Jossey-Bass.
11. Binkley, N.,Brandes, G., M.(1995).Reflection: Meanings and interpretations.Curriculum Inquiry,25(2),207-212.
12. Brockbank, A.,McGill, I.(1998).Facilitating reflective learning in higher education.Buckingham, UK:Open University Press.
13. Calderhead, J.(Ed.),Gates, P.(Ed.)(1993).Conceptualizing reflection in teacher development.London, UK:The Falmer Press.
14. Carlgren, I.(Ed.),Handal, G.(Ed.),Vaage, S.(Ed.)(1994).Teachers' minds and actions: Research on teachers' thinking and practice.Brictol, PA:Falmer Press.
15. Clandinin, J.(1985).Personal practical knowledge: A study of teachers' classroom images.Curriculum Inquiry,15(4),361-385.
16. Corcoran, C. A.,Leahy, R.(2003).Growing professionally through reflective practice.Kappa Delta Pi Record,40(1),30-33.
17. De John, T. A.,LaBoskey, M.,Haig, Y.,Sharp, S.,Spiers, S.(2011).Enabling group-based learning in teacher education: A case study of student experience.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,36(5),92-105.
18. Dinham, S.,Aubusson, P.,Brady, L.(2008).Distributed leadership as a factor in the outcome of teacher action learning.International Electronic Journal for Leadership in earning,12(4),1-19.
19. Elbaz, F.(1991).Research on teacher's knowledge: The evolution of a discourse.Journal of Curriculum studies,23(1),1-19.
20. Gipe, J. P.(1992).Reflective thinking and growth in novices' teaching abilities.Journal of Educational Research,86(1),52-57.
21. Grossman, R.(2008).Structures for facilitating student reflection.College Teaching,57(1),15-22.
22. Grushka, K.,McLeod, J. H.,Reynolds, R.(2005).Reflecting upon reflection: Theory and practice in one Australian University teacher education program.Reflective Practice,6(2),239-246.
23. Johnson, C.,Spicer, D. P.(2006).A case study of action learning in an MBA program.Education and Training,48(1),39-54.
24. Johnston, S.(1992).Images: A way of understanding the practical knowledge of student teachers.Teaching and Teacher Education,8,123-136.
25. Kim, J.,Choy, D.(2008).Learning to toot your own horn: Preservice teachers integrating music into a childhood classroom.Journal of Research in Childhood Education,22(4),405-423.
26. Lee, H. J.(2005).Understanding and assessing preservice teachers' reflective thinking.Teaching and Teacher Education,21(6),699-715.
27. Lee, I.(2011).Teachers as presenters at continuing professional development seminars in the English-as-a-foreign-language context: I find it more convincing.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,36(2),30-42.
28. Lee, I.(2008).Fostering preservice reflection through response.Teacher Education Quarterly,35(1),117-139.
29. Lizzio, A.,Wilson, K.(2004).Action learning in higher education: An investigation of its potential to develop professional capability.Studies in Higher Education,29(4),470-488.
30. MacNaughton, G.,Hughes, P.,Smith, K.(2007).Rethinking approaches to working with children who challenge: Action learning for emancipatory practice.International Journal of Early Childhood,39(1),39-57.
31. Mager, R. F.(1962).Preparing instruction objectives.San Francisco, CA:Fearon.
32. McGill, I.,Beaty, L.(1995).Action learning: A guide for professional, managerial and educational development (2nd ed.).London, UK:Kogan Page.
33. McIntyre, J. D.(Ed.),Byrd, D. M.(Ed.)(2000).Research on effective models for teacher education.Thousand Oaks, CA:Corwin Press.
34. Mills, G., E.(2011).Action research: A guide for teacher researcher.London, UK:Pearson.
35. Nilsson, P.(2009).From lesson plan to new comprehension: Exploring student teachers' pedagogical reasoning in learning about teaching.European Journal of Teacher Education,32(3),239-258.
36. Pella, S.(2011).A situative perspective on developing writing pedagogy in a teacher professional learning community.Teacher Education Quarterly,38(1),107+125.
37. Rodam, G., J.(2010).Facilitating the teaching-learning process through the reflective engagement of pre-service teachers.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,35(2),20-34.
38. Rodgers, C.(2002).Defining reflection: Another look at John Dewey and reflective thinking.Teachers College Record,104(4),842-866.
39. Schmidit, M.(2010).Learning from teaching experience: Dewey's theory and preservice teachers' learning.Journal of Research in Music Education,58(2),131-146.
40. Schon, D. A.(1987).Educating the reflective practitioner: Toward a new design for teaching and learning in the profession.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
41. Sergiovanni, T. J.(1995).The principalship: A reflective practice perspective (3rd ed.).Boston, MA:Allyn and Bacon.
42. Vanhulle, S.(2005).How future teachers develop professional knowledge through reflective writing in a dialogical frame.L1-Educational Studies in Language and Literature,5(3),287-314.
43. Zahra, A.,Pavia, C.(2012).A unique approach to work-integrated learning: Meeting industry, student and educator needs through academic and experiential elements.The ACPET Journal for Private Higher Education,1(2),41-49.
44. 吳清山(2006)。師資培育的理念與實踐。教育研究與發展期刊，2(1)，1-32。
45. 李咏吟編、陳美玉編、甄曉蘭編(2003)。新教學實習手冊。臺北:心理。
46. 徐綺穗(2008)。大學教學創新─大學生對以行動學習理論為基礎的「行動─反思」教學的看法及其對教學的啟示。教育行政與政策學術研討會論文集，花蓮:
47. 徐綺穗(2012)。教師參與行動學習團體促進教師專業發展之探討。教育研究月刊，215，30-39。
48. 陳國泰(2006)。國小自然與生活科技資深專家教師實務知識的發展之個案研究。國立臺北教育大學學報，19(2)，31-64。
49. 陳添球(2001)。博士論文(博士論文)。臺北，國立政治大學教育學系。
50. 黃政傑編(1997)。教學原理。臺北:師大書苑。
51. 黃美瑛(1995)。意象：幼兒教師實際知識的運作之研究。屏東:睿煜。

1. 胡正申(2020)。社會心理學課程應用體驗與反思教學之研究。長庚人文社會學報，13(1)，107-151。
2. 黃雅新,陳琬云,林秀玲,吳相儀(2020)。「大學生感恩課程」之教學歷程研究。教育研究集刊，66(1)，35-76。
3. 黃志雄(2017)。翻轉教室模式在大學課程中的實踐與反思。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊，10(1)，1-30。
4. 黃志雄(2020)。翻轉教學模式在「特殊幼兒教育」課程之再行動。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊，13(2)，59-84。
5. 黃志雄、田育芬(2016)。大學教師參與問題導向學習之專業發展社群個案研究。教育研究與發展期刊，12(1)，147-172。
6. 李慧琪,白慧娟(2021)。華德福教育理念啟發的做中思：氣質教學歷程探究。教育科學期刊，20(2)，23-44。
7. 廖瑞琳、黃志雄(2016)。校外實習教師專業學習社群發展之個案研究：以一所科技大學為例。學校行政，103，82-103。
8. 劉唯玉(2017)。案例撰寫與討論引導架構促進實習教師反省思考層次之研究。教育實踐與研究，30(1)，71-104。
9. 姚經政、林呈彥(2017)。雲端行動學習app 融入實作課程：以手擲機為例。科技與人力教育季刊，3(4)，1-13。
10. 張金蘭(2021)。文化體驗教學模式在華語教學師培課程之實踐成效－以華人社會與文化課程為例。中原華語文學報，21，111-143。
11. 周水珍,方舟(2023)。教學實習課程協同師徒制師資生專業成長之研究。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊，16(1)，1-27。
12. (2024)。設計本位學習導入經典教育提升醫學大學學生自我效能：以論語為例。通識教育學刊，33，65-126。