The Effect of Integrating Learning Style with Mobile Cooperative Learning on Learning Achievement and Attitude

學習風格結合行動合作學習環境學習成效之研究

10.6384/CIQ.201504_18(2).0008

陳又菁(Yu-Ching Chen)

行動合作學習 ； 學習風格 ； 拼圖法 ； mobile cooperative learning ； learning style ； jigsaw

課程與教學

18卷2期（2015 / 04 / 01）

201 - 234

英文

在結合科技的學習環境中，良好的互動是不可或缺的，而合作學習便常運用在教學當中以提升互動性，但傳統桌上型電腦並不完全適合運用在面對面溝通的情況，日益受到重視的行動載具提供了較為自然的互動環境，此外，電腦輔助溝通也被發現無法完全協助低成就者提升學習效果及互動程度，學習風格的導入對於影響行動學習所帶來的高認知負荷量具有潛力，因此，提供符合個人需求的適性化學習更顯重要。本研究發展了學習風格融入行動合作學習的環境（LSIMCL），並與未考量學習風格的行動合作學習環境進行比較，及探討對於低、中、高成就者及不同學習風格者在學習成效及態度上的影響。結果顯示LSIMCL的學習成效高於控制組，低成就者的進步幅度最大；LSIMCL組在適用性、互動性及滿意度上都較控制組高，且低成就者有較高的滿意度及互動性，控制組中的低成就者認為閱讀電子書有較高的困難度、需較高的心力及注意力，但LSIMCL中低成就者相較於其他程度者並無顯著差異；而各學習風格者之間在學習成效及態度上並無顯著差異，此結果對於結合行動合作學習及學習適性化之課程及教材設計將有相當的助益。

In a learning environment that integrates technology with cooperative learning, interaction is believed to be essential to improving learning. However, traditional desktop computers are not suitable for face-to-face interaction while mobile tools enable students to interact naturally. Moreover, computer-mediated communication may not totally benefit low achievers' performance and interaction. The heavy cognitive load from mobile learning deteriorates performance and learning style may affect cognitive load. More assistance to individual students becomes indispensable. This study developed a learning style, integrated with mobile cooperative learning environment system (LSIMCL). The results showed that the LSIMCL group performed better than the non-LSIMCL group. The low achievers outperformed the medium and high achievers in their learning increase. Moreover, the LSIMCL students had more score growth and perceived the environment to be more adaptable, interactive, and satisfying than the non-LSIMCL group. In the non-LSIMCL group, the low achievers had more difficulty, needed more effort and attention when reading the e-book than the other achievers, while there was no difference for the LSIMCL group. The findings would be valuable for instructors who intend to develop a mobile cooperative learning environment while taking individual learning differences into consideration.

1. Wang, P.-Y.,Wang, H.-F.,Liu, Y.-C.(2013).Elementary students' reading behaviors of e-books with different adaptive designs.Journal of Educational Media & Library Sciences,51(2),267-291.
   連結：
2. Soloman, B., & Felder, R. (1993). Index of Learning Styles (ILS). Retrieved from http://www.ncsu.edu/felderpublic/ILSpage.html
3. Abdul-Rahman, S.,du Boulay, B.(2014).Learning programming via worked-examples: Relation of learning style to cognitive load.Computers in Human Behavior,30,286-298.
4. Alavi, M.(1994).Computer-mediated collaborative learning: An empirical evaluation.MIS Quarterly,18(2),150-174.
5. Alavi, M.,Gallupe, R. B.(2003).Using information technology in learning: Case studies in business and management education programs.Academic of Management Learning and Education,2(2),139-153.
6. Alavi, M.,Wheeler, B. C.,Valacich, J. S.(1995).Using IT to reengineer business education: An exploratory investigation of collaborative tele-learning.MIS Quarterly,19(3),293-313.
7. Aronson, E.,Blaney, N.,Stephin, C.,Sikes, J.,Snapp, M.(1978).The jigsaw classroom.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
8. Aronson, E.,Patnoe, S.(1997).The jigsaw classroom: Building cooperation in the classroom.New York:Addison Wesley Longman.
9. Bagozzi, R. P.,Yi, Y.(1988).On the evaluation for structural equation models.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,16,74-94.
10. Bannan-Ritland, B.(2002).Computer-mediated communication, eLearning, and interactivity: A review of the research.Quarterly Review of Distance Education,3(2),161-179.
11. Barker, D.,Quennerstedt, M.,Annerstedt, C.(2013).Inter-student interactions and student learning in health and physical education: A post-Vygotskian analysis.Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy,1-18.
12. Bolliger, D. U.,Supanakorn, S.(2010).Learning styles and students perceptions of the use of interactive online tutorials.British Journal of Educational Technology,42(3),470-481.
13. Brown, T. A.(2006).Confirmatory factor analysis for applied research.New York:Guilford Press.
14. Brown, T.,Zoghi, M.,Williams, B.,Jaberzadeh, S.,Roller, L.,Palermo, C.,McKenna, L.,Wright, C.,Baird, M.,Schneider-Kolsky, M.,Hewitt, L.,Sim, J.,Hot, T.-A.(2009).Are learning style preferences of health science students predictive of their attitudes towards e-learning?.Australasian Journal of Educational Technology,25(4),524-543.
15. Bruffee, K. A.(1995).Sharing our toys: Cooperative versus collaborative learning.Change,27,12-18.
16. Çakıroğlu, Ü .(2014).Analyzing the effect of learning styles and study habits of distance learners on learning performances: A case of an introductory programming course.The International Review of Research in Open and Learning,15(4),161-185.
17. Chen, B. H.,Chiou, H.-H.(2014).Learning style, sense of community and learning effectiveness in hybrid learning environment.Interactive Learning Environments,22(4),485-496.
18. Chen, C.-M.(2013).An intelligent mobile location-aware book recommendation system that enhances problem-based learning in libraries.Interactive Learning Environments,21(5),469-495.
19. Chu, H.C.(2014).Potential negative effects of mobile learning on students' learning achievement and cognitive load-a format assessment perspective.Educational Technology & Society,17(1),332-344.
20. Cochrane, T. D.(2010).Exploring mobile learning success factors.Research in Learning Technology,18(2),133-148.
21. Danesh, A.,Inken. K. M.,Lau, F.,Shu, K.,Booth, K. S.,Geney, T. M.(2001).Designing a collaborative activity for the palm handheld computer.Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems,Seattle, USA.:
22. Felder, R. M.,Silverman, L. K.(1988).Learning and teaching style in engineering education.Engineering Education,78(7),674-681.
23. Fornell, C.,Larcker, D.(1981).Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement errors.Journal of Marketing Research,18(1),39-50.
24. Franzoni, A. L.,Assar, S.(2009).Student learning styles adaptation method based on teaching strategies and electronic media.Educational Technology & Society,12(4),15-29.
25. Gambari, A. I.,Kutigi, A. U.,Fagbemi, P. O.(2014).Effectiveness of computer-assisted pronunciation teaching and verbal ability on the achievement of senior secondary school students in oral English.Gist Education and Learning Research Journal,8,11-28.
26. Garcia, J. N.,de Caso-Fuertes, A.(2007).Effectiveness of an improvement writing program according to students' reflexivity levels.Spanish Journal of Psychology,10(2),303-313.
27. Gillies, R.,Haynes, M.(2011).Increasing explanatory behaviour, problem-solving, and reasoning within classes using cooperative group work.Instructional Science,39(3),349-366.
28. Graf, S.,Liu, T.-C.,Kinshuk(2010).Analysis of learners' navigational behavior and their learning styles in an online course.Journal of Computer Assisted Learning,26,116-131.
29. Graf, S.,Liu, T.-C.,Kinshuk, Chen, N.-S.,Yang, S. J.(2009).Learning styles and cognitive traits - Their relationship and its benefits in web-based educational systems.Computers in Human Behavior,25,1280-1289.
30. Heo, H.,Lim, K. Y.,Kim, Y.(2010).Exploratory study on the patterns of online interaction and knowledge co-construction in project-based learning.Computers & Education,55,1383-1392.
31. Hooper, D.,Coughlan, J.,Mullen, M. R.(2008).Structural equation modeling: Guidelines for determining model fit.The Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods,6(1),53-60.
32. Hsieh, S. W.,Jang, Y. R.,Hwang, G. J.,Chen, N. S.(2011).Effects of teaching and learning styles on students' reflection levels for ubiquitous learning.Computers & Education,57(1),1194-1201.
33. Huang, Y. -M.,Huang, T.-C.,Hsieh, M.-Y.(2008).Using annotation services in a ubiquitous Jigsaw cooperative learning environment.Educational Technology & Society,11(2),3-15.
34. Hwang, G. J.,Wu, P. H.,Zhuang, Y. Y.,Huang, Y. M.(2013).Effects of the inquiry-based mobile learning model on the cognitive load and learning achievement of students.Interactive Learning Environments,21(4),338-354.
35. Imielinsky, T.,Badrinath, B.(1994).Mobile wireless computing: Challenges in data management.Communications of the ACM,37,18-28.
36. Jacob, E.(1999).Cooperative learning in context: An educational innovation in everyday classrooms.New York:State University of New York.
37. Jacobs, G. M.,Kimura, H.(2013).Encouraging second language use in cooperative learning groups.Beyond Words,1(1),24-37.
38. Keegan, D.(2002).The Future of Learning: From eLearning to mLearning.Hagen, Germany:FernUniversitat Hagen.
39. Kinshuk, Liu, T.-C.,Graf, S.(2009).Coping with mismatched courses: Students' behavior and performance in courses mismatched to their learning styles.Educational Technology Research and Development,57,739-752.
40. Kline, R. B.(2005).Principles and practice of structural equation modeling.New York:Guilford Press.
41. Kyndt, E.,Raes, E.,Lismont, B.,Timmers, F.,Cascallar, E.,Dochy, F.(2013).A meta-analysis of the effects of face-to-face cooperative learning. Do recent studies falsify or verify earlier findings?.Educational Research Review,10,133-149.
42. Lai, C. Y.,Wu, C. C.(2006).Using handhelds in a Jigsaw cooperative learning environment.Journal of Computer Assisted Learning,22,284-297.
43. Lan, Y.-J.,Sung, Y.-T.,Chang, K.-E.(2009).Let us read together: development and evaluation of a computer-assisted reciprocal early English reading system.Computers & Education,53,1188-1198.
44. Leng, L. H.,Leng, C. H.,Abedalaziz, N.(2013).Using weblog in cooperative learning to improve the achievement of history learning.The Malaysian Online Journal of Education Technology,1(3),30-55.
45. Liu, T. C.,Lin, Y. C.,Tsai, M. J.,Paas, F.(2012).Split-attention and redundancy effects on mobile learning in physical environment.Computers & Education,58(1),172-180.
46. Lou, Y.,Abrami, P. C.,d'Apollonia, S.(2001).Small group and individual learning with technology: A meta-analysis.Review of Educational Research,71,449-521.
47. Nunnery, J. A.,Chappell, S.,Arnold, P.(2013).A meta-analysis of a cooperative learning model's effects on student achievement in mathematics.Cypriot Journal of Educational Sciences,8(1),34-48.
48. Osman, G.,Herring, S. C.(2007).Interaction, facilitation, and deep learning in cross-cultural chat: A case study.The Internet and Higher Education,10(2),125-141.
49. Resta, P.,Laferrière, T.(2007).Technology in support of collaborative learning.Educational Psychology Review,19,65-83.
50. Roschelle, J.,Pea, R.(2002).A walk on the WILD side: How wireless handheld may change computer-supported collaborative learning.International Journal of Cognition and Technology,1(1),145-168.
51. Saleh, M.,Lazonder, A. R.,de Jong, T.(2007).Structuring collaboration in mixed-ability groups to promote verbal interaction, learning, and motivation of average-ability students.Contemporary Educational Psychology,32(3),314-331.
52. Sandman, T. E.(2009).Gaining insight into business telecommunications students through the assessment of learning styles.Decision Sciences Journal of Innovative Education,7(1),295-320.
53. Schumacker, R. E.,Lomax, R. G.(1996).A beginner's guide to structural equation modeling.NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
54. Serce, F. C.,Swigger, K.,Alpaslan, F. N.,Brazile, R.,Dafoulas, G.,Lopez, V.(2012).Exploring the communication behavior among global software development leaners.International Journal of Computer Applications in Technology,40(3),203-215.
55. Shimazoe, J.,Aldrich, H.(2010).Group work can be gratifying: Understanding & overcoming resistance to cooperative learning.College Teaching,58(2),52-57.
56. Shoval, E.,Shulruf, B.(2011).Who benefits from cooperative learning with movement activity?.School Psychology International,32(1),58-72.
57. Slavin, R. E.(1999).Comprehensive approaches to cooperative learning.Theory into Practice,38(2),74-79.
58. So, H.,Tan, E.,Tay, J.(2012).Collaborative mobile learning in situ from knowledge building perspectives.The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher,21(1),51-62.
59. Sun, C. Z.,Lin, S. R.(2007).Web-based cooperative learning.Taipei:Wu-Nan Book Inc..
60. Sweller, J.,Van Merrienboer, J. J. G.,Paas, F. G. W. C.(1998).Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning.Cognitive Science,12,257-285.
61. Tabachnick, B. G.,Fidell, L. S.(2001).Using multivariate statistics.MA:Allyn & Bacon.
62. Tatar D.,Roschelle J.,Vahey P.,Penuel W. R.(2003).Handhelds go to school: Lessons learned.IEEE Computer,36,30-37.
63. Topping, K. J.,Thurston, A.,Christie, D.,Murray, P.,Karagiannidou, E.(2011).Cooperative learning in science: Intervention in the secondary school.Research in Science & Technological Education,29(1),91-106.
64. Tsiatsos, T.,Andreas, K.,Pomportsis, A.(2010).Evaluation framework for collaborative educational virtual environments.Educational Technology & Society,13(2),65-77.
65. Yang, T.-C.,Hwang, G.-J.,Yang, S. J.-H.(2013).Development of an adaptive learning system with multiple perspectives based on students' learning styles and cognitive styles.Educational Technology & Society,16(4),185-200.
66. Zurita, G.,Nussbaum, M.(2004).Computer supported collaborative learning using wirelessly interconnected handheld computers.Computers & Education,42(3),289-314.

1. (2018)。拼圖法在台灣學校教育合作學習之應用。教育研究，26，43-62。