心智圖法運用於質性資料分析課程的學習成效評估

The Study of Mind Mapping Instruction for Project Study Curriculum in Qualitative Data Analysis Conducted for University Students

10.6384/CIQ.201604_19(2).0008

常雅珍(Ya-Jane Chaung)

心智圖法 ； 專題課程研究 ； 質性資料分析 ； mind mapping ； project study ； qualitative data analysis

課程與教學

19卷2期（2016 / 04 / 01）

193 - 228

繁體中文

本研究目的在解決學生在專題課程中遇到的問題，將心智圖法應用於專題課程質性資料分析，提出編碼之後，進行版模式心智圖法、統整式心智圖法、文獻對話心智圖法之創新。本研究進行兩年，第一年進行研究一，透過初探性質性研究了解學生對創新教學方式的接受度、助益、再使用度、應用度，以評估創新教學法之可行性，第二年進行研究二，採用準實驗研究設計，自編量表，以瞭解學生的學習成效。主要研究結果顯示本研究提出的專題課程質性資料分析方式，可以顯著提昇實驗組學生「專題課程質性資料學習成效評估」中「課程接受度」、「課程助益性」、「課程應用性」分量表上的後測得分。根據本研究結果提出一個以心智圖法分析專題課程質性資料的學習方式，作為大學生專題課程應用之參考，並提出相關結論及建議。

The researcher wants to solve the student's questions during their research process. She also wants to integrate with her many years' teaching and research experience, so she used the mind mapping instruction for the project study curriculum in qualitative data analysis. Five stages in the process including: open coding, axial coding, modeling mind mapping, integrate mind mapping, and literature mind mapping. Conducting for two years, the researcher used the qualitative research to assess the practicality of the study in the first year, then followed by the quasi-experimental design later. The participants were divided into two groups as the experimental group took project study curriculum combining with a mind mapping while the control group took a regular curriculum. Later the data collected were analyzed by ANCOVA. There were significant differences between the two groups on the subscales of ＂curriculum acceptance＂, ＂curriculum benefit＂, and ＂curriculum application＂. Finally, the mind mapping based on the project study learning model and some suggestions are proposed for future studies as possible guidelines for using learning technology to scaffold possible results.

1. Bandura, A.(1977).Social learning theory.NJ:Prentice-Hall..
2. Barritt, L.,Beekman, T.,Bleeker, H.,Mulderij, K.(1984).Analyzing phenomenological descriptions.Phenomenology and Pedagogy,2,1-17.
3. Boley, D. A.(2008).Use of premade mind maps to enhance simulation learning.Nurse Educator,33(5),220-223.
4. Brinkmann, A.(2003).Graphical knowledge display-mind mapping and concept mapping as efficient tools in mathematics education.Mathematics Education Review,16,35-48.
5. Buzan, T.(2003).Use your memory.Edinburgh:BBC Active..
6. Buzan, T.(2005).Mind map: The ultimate thinking tool.London:Thorsons..
7. Buzan, T.,Buzan, B.(2010).The mind map book unlock your creativity, boost your memory, change your life.Harlow, England:Pearson..
8. Crowe, M.,Sheppard, L.(2012).Mind mapping research methods.Quality and Quantity,46,1493-1504.
9. D'Antoni, A. V.,Zipp, G. P.,Olson, V. G.,Cahill, T. F.(2010).Does the mind Map learning strategy facilitate information retrieval and critical thinking in medical students?.BMC Medical Education,10,61.
10. Davies, M.(2010).Concept mapping, mind mapping and argument mapping: What are the differences, and do they matter?.Higher Education,62(3),279-301.
11. Evrekli, E.,Balim, A. G.,Inel, D.(2009).Mind mapping applications in special teaching methods courses for science teacher candidates and teacher candidates' opinions concerning the applications.Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences,1(1),2274-2279.
12. Farrand, P.,Hussain, F.,Hennessy, E.(2002).The efficacy of the 'mind map' study technique.Medical Education,36,426-431.
13. Fun, C. S.,Maskat, N.(2010).Teacher-centered mind mapping vs student-centered mind mapping in the teaching of accounting at pre-U level-An action research.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,7,240-246.
14. Gray, L.(1991).Marketing education.Buckingham:Open University Press..
15. Huxham, M.(2010).The medium makes the message: Effects of cues on students' lecture notes.Active Learning in Higher Education,11,179.
16. Mento, A. J.,Martinelli, P.,Jones, R. M.(1999).Mind mapping in executive education: Applications and outcomes.Journal of Management Development,18(4),390-416.
17. Nesbit, J. C.,Adescope, O.(2006).Learning with concept and knowledge maps: Ameta-analysis.Review of Educational Research,76(3),413-448.
18. Noonan, M.(2013).Mind maps: Enhancing midwifery education.Nurse Education Today,33(8),847-852.
19. Popil, I.(2011).Promotion of critical thinking by using case studies as teaching method.Nurse Education Today,31,204-207.
20. Rosciano, A.(2015).The effectiveness of mind mapping as an active learning strategy among associate degree nursing students.Teaching and Learning in Nursing,10,93-99.
21. Wheeldon, J.(2011).Is a picture worth a thousand words? Using mind map to facilitate participant recall in qualitative research.The Qualitative Report,16,509-522.
22. Wickramasinghe, A.,Widanapathirana, N.,Kuruppu, O.,Liyanage, I.,Karunathilake, I.(2007).Effectiveness of mind maps as a learning tool for medical students.South East Asian Journal of Medical Education Inaugural Issue,1,30-32.
23. Williams, C.,Williams, S.,Appleton, K.(1997).Mind maps: An aid to effective formulation.Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy,25(3),261-267.
24. Worrell, J. A.,Profetto-McGrath, J.(2007).Critical thinking as an outcome of context based learning among post RN students: A literature review.Nurse Education Today,27,420-426.
25. Zhao, Y.(2003).The use of a constructivist teaching model in environmental science at Beijing Normal University.The China Papers,2,78-83.
26. Zipp, P. G.,Maher, C.,D'Antoni, A. V.(2009).Mind maps: Useful schematic tool for organising and integrating concepts of complex patient care in the clinic and classroom.Journal of College Teaching and Learning,6(2),59-68.
27. 王保進(1999)。視窗版SPSS 與行為科學研究。臺北:心理。
28. 胡翠茵(2011)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺灣師範大學創造力發展研究所。
29. 常雅珍(2010)。心智圖法應用於大學「教育研究法」課程之實例─以某校幼保系大三學生上課為案例。長庚科技學刊，13，65-84。
30. 常雅珍(2012)。心智圖法暨多元化記憶策略融入大學「課後托育與實務」課程之研究。長庚科技學刊，16，125-140。
31. 莊景益(2007)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。屏東縣，國立屏東教育大學教育科技研究所。
32. 陳瑋玲(2006)。實務專題課程製作：觀念、方法與應用。臺北:全華。
33. 楊純雅(2008)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺灣師範大學創造力發展研究所。
34. 葉容樁、林建仲、任永潔、鐘盼兮(2010)。應用專題課程導向學習法於企管系大三實務專題課程學生之行動研究：以美和技術學院為例。工業教育學刊，3，113-121。

1. 蔡諭回,劉寶珠,張雲英,姚愛珠(2022)。運用心智圖創新教學於氣切滑脫處置能力訓練之學習成效。嘉基護理，22(1)，1-11。
2. 常雅珍(2017)。小學生代間教育課程實施及其成效之研究。課程與教學，20(1)，159-200。
3. 常雅珍(2017)。桌上遊戲課程與教學之應用—以小學六年級學生為例。科學教育學刊，25(2)，119-142。
4. 常雅珍,林昌本,李雨錚,王亭惠,王成翠(2020)。多功能創意積木組的研發與創新之研究。大仁學報，54，21-45。
5. 郭金國,吳信廷(2020)。大學生觀看語言知識型youtuber頻道之著重點與學習意願之質性研究－以英文教學頻道為例。中華印刷科技年報，2020，349-356。
6. 黃寶園,許菀云,常雅珍,邱耀儀,邱慧芳(2022)。多功能哺乳巾的研發與創新之研究。設計學報，27(4)，21-43。
7. 黃寶園,黃詩庭,常雅珍,洪錦益,李佩綺(2019)。心智圖法與ATDE模式應用於創新研發專題課程之研究。教育研究與發展期刊，15(1)，61-63+65。
8. (2021)。十字分析創意思考法應用於紙材結構設計教學之研究。臺東大學教育學報，32(2)，1-33。