學習共同體變革歷程中的教師關注

Teacher Concerns in the Process of Change via Learning Community

10.6384/CIQ.201807_21(3).0006

潘慧玲(Hui-Ling Wendy Pan)；洪祥瑀(Hsiang-Yu Hung)

教師關注 ； 關注本位採用模式 ； 學習共同體 ； teacher concerns ； learning community ； concern-based adoption model

課程與教學

21卷3期（2018 / 07 / 01）

145 - 167

繁體中文

學習共同體是促進學校變革的重要取徑，其以學習為中心，除帶動師生成為學習者，致力於共學，也改變課堂實踐幫助學生自主學習。為了解教師在參與學習共同體變革的歷程中，所關注的是什麼，本研究以「關注本位採用模式」為視角，進行一所國中之個案研究。透過訪談、文件分析與觀察之資料蒐集，發現因應學習共同體之方案特性，教師在實作過程中展現的關注，雖具發展性，然有不同類型的教師關注在方案各實施期中以類似強度共存的現象。準備期中的定向與準備出現自我關注；摸索期的機械式使用及開展期的例行性使用，則各皆同時存在任務與影響關注。而上述三類關注在不同方案實施期中，有著相異內涵的呈現。綜觀本研究所得，除可增添教師關注學術風貌的多采性，亦可提供學校領導者了解如何掌握教師面對變革的感受與關心的事務，從而運用適當策略落實創新方案。

Learning community is a vital approach for school change. Based on the learning-centered philosophy, it aims to trigger learning together in schools, as well as to flip the classroom for the enhancement of students' learning autonomy. To explore what teachers are concerned in the process of implementing learning community, the study used the concern-based adoption model as an analytic perspective. A junior high school was involved in the present study. Interview, document analysis and observation were used for data collection. It was found that teacher concerns demonstrated the developmental nature. However, the same types of teacher concerns appeared with similar intensity in the same stage of program implementation. In the stage of preparation, concern of self was present. But, in the stage of trial and development, concerns of task and impact coexisted. It was also noted that the three types of teacher concerns vary in content for each of the three stages. To sum up, the findings of the present study made great contribution to the body of research in the teacher concern field. Additionally, the results of the present study also provided implications for school leaders to employ appropriate coping strategies.

1. 孫志麟、陳建銘(2007)。學校組織變革中的教師關注：發展階段與類型分析。師大學報，52，159-180。
   連結：
2. 馬郁凝、柯皓仁(2012)。以關注本位採用模式探討大學教師參與開放式課程之研究。圖書資訊學刊，10(1)，117-153。
   連結：
3. 游秀靜、唐淑華(2015)。因「被看見」而「能看見」：「學習共同體公開授課」對促進教師專業成長之個案研究。中等教育，66(1)，16-39。
   連結：
4. 潘慧玲、陳玟樺(2015)。教師開展學習共同體的反思性實踐。中等教育，66(1)，40-57。
   連結：
5. 薛雅慈(2014)。國中教師以學習共同體啟動新學習型態之研究。教育科學研究期刊，59(1)，101-140。
   連結：
6. 鍾志長(2011)。國小教師的課程改革關注探究。弘光學報，63，137-155。
   連結：
7. Alias, N. A.,Zainuddin, A. M.(2005).Innovation for better teaching and learning: Adopting the learning management system.Malaysian Online Journal of Instructional Technology,2(2),27-40.
8. Cochran-Smith, M.,Lytle, S. L.(1999).Relationships of knowledge and practice: Teacher learning in communities.Review of Research in Education,24(1),249-305.
9. Cole, P.(2004).Professional development: A great way to avoid change.Melbourne, Australia:Center for Strategic Education.
10. Connelly, F. M.,Clandinin, D. J.(1988).On narrative method, biography and narrative unites in the study of teaching.The Journal of Educational Thought,21(3),130-139.
11. Creswell, J. W.(1998).Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
12. Elbaz, F.(1983).Teacher thinking: A study of practical knowledge.London, England:Croom Helm.
13. Ellsworth, J. B.(2000).Surviving change: A survey of educational change models.Syracuse, NY:ERIC clearinghouse on information and technology.
14. Fullan, M. G.,Steigelbauer, S.(1991).The new meaning of educational change.New York, NY:Teachers College Press, Columbia University.
15. Fuller, F. F.(1969).Concerns of teachers: A developmental conceptualization.American Educational Research Journal,6(2),207-226.
16. Goodson, I.(2001).Social histories of educational change.Journal of Educational Change,2(1),45-63.
17. Hall, G. E.,George, A. A.,Rutherford, W. L.(1977).Measuring stages of concern about the innovation: A manual for the use of the SoC Questionnaire.Austin, TX:Southwest Educational Development Laboratory.
18. Hall, G. E.,Hord, S. M.(1987).Change in schools: Facilitating the process.Albany, NY:SUNY Press.
19. Hargreaves, A.(Ed.),Lieberman, A.(Ed.),Fullan, F.(Ed.),Hopkins, D.(Ed.)(1998).International handbook of educational change.Dordrecht, Netherlands:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
20. Hord, S. M.,Rutherford, W. L.,Huling, L.,Hall, G. E.(2014).Taking charge of change (Revised Version).Alexandria, VA:Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
21. Isoda, M.(2011).Problem solving approaches in mathematics education as a product of Japanese lesson study.Journal of Science and Mathematics Education in Southeast Asia,34(1),2-25.
22. Lee, C. K. J.(1996).Hong Kong,Chinese University of Hong Kong.
23. Leung, W. L. A.(2008).Teacher concerns about curriculum reform: The case of project learning.The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher,17(1),75-97.
24. Marsh, S.,Waniganayake, M.,Gibson, I. W.(2014).Scaffolding leadership for learning in school education: Insights from a factor analysis of research conducted in Australian independent schools.Educational Management Administration & Leadership,42(4),474-490.
25. Schön, D.(1982).The reflective practitioner.New York, NY:Basic Books.
26. Sergiovanni, T. J.(2001).The principalship: A reflective practice perspective.Needham, MA:Allyn and Bacon.
27. Vygotsky, L. S.,Cole, M.(ed. trans.)John-Steiner, V.(ed. trans.)Scribner, S.(ed. trans.),Souberman, E.(ed. trans.)(1978).Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
28. Wenger, E. (2012). Communities of practice and social learning systems: The career of a concept. Retrieved from http://wenger-trayner.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/09-10-27-CoPs-and-systems-v2.0.pdf
29. 佐藤學、黃郁倫譯、鍾啟泉譯(2012)。學習的革命：從教室出發的改革。臺北市:親子天下。
30. 佐藤學、鍾啟泉譯、陳靜靜譯(2012)。教師的挑戰：寧靜的課堂革命。上海市:華東師範大學。
31. 李子建、尹弘颷(2005)。教師對課程變革的認同感和關注：課程實施研究的探討。教育研究與發展，1(1)，107-128。
32. 教育部十二年國民基本教育專案辦公室（2015）。十二年國民基本教育實施計畫。取自http://12basic.edu.tw/Detail.php?LevelNo=43
33. 陳向明(2002)。社會科學質的研究。臺北市:五南。
34. 潘慧玲編(2004)。教師研究的取徑－概念與應用。臺北市:高等教育文化。
35. 潘慧玲、李麗君、黃淑馨、余霖、薛雅慈(2016)。學習領導下的學習共同體1.2版。新北市:學習領導與學習共同體計畫辦公室。
36. 潘慧玲、李麗君、黃淑馨、余霖、薛雅慈(2014)。學習領導下的學習共同體1.1版。新北市:學習領導與學習共同體計畫辦公室。
37. 潘慧玲、陳佩英、張素貞、鄭淑惠、陳文彥(2014)。從學習領導論析學習共同體的概念與實踐。市北教育學刊，45，1-28。
38. 潘慧玲、黃淑馨、李麗君、余霖、劉秀嫚、薛雅慈(2015)。學習領導下的學習共同體進階手冊2.0 版。新北市:學習領導與學習共同體計畫辦公室。

1. 潘慧玲,許筠萱(2019)。分散性領導在推動學習共同體中的實踐：以一所國中國文教師學習社群為案例。學校行政，119，197-214。
2. 吳美瑤(2020)。認知與學習的新觀點：體現認知在課程與教學之應用。課程與教學，23(1)，193-215。
3. 周芳怡(2019)。通識課程落實大學社會責任之行動研究。通識學刊：理念與實務，7(1)，1-31+33。