以歷史取向論教學輔導教師制度的時代背景與發展趨勢

The Contextual Background and Developing Trend of Mentor Teacher Program: From a Historical Approach

10.6384/CIQ.202101_24(1).0004

張德銳(Derray Chang)；丁一顧(Yi-Ku Ding)

教學輔導教師 ； 初任教師導入輔導 ； 歷史觀點 ； 發展趨勢 ； mentor teachers ； beginning teacher induction ； historical approach ； developing trends

課程與教學

24卷1期（2021 / 01 / 01）

93 - 112

繁體中文

「教學輔導教師制度」在歐美先進國家已有四十多年的歷史，在我國則有二十年的歷史。本文以歷史的取向論述其發展沿革與時代背景脈絡，並據以提出我國未來發展趨勢的建議。教學輔導教師制度在先進國家已進入「教育界深化期」，在我國仍介於「教育界推動初期」、「教育界發展期」之間。教學輔導教師制度具有「教學實踐智慧的傳承」、「教師信任文化的彰顯」等五個之時代背景。鑑往知來，本文乃對我國教學輔導教師制度的未來發展提出：「建立教學輔導教師制度的實施法源」、「建置專任教學輔導教師」、「與實習輔導教師制度結合」等九項建言。

The Mentor Teacher Program has implemented more than 40 years in Western countries, while the program has been introduced in Taiwan for only two decades. The paper aims to analyze the development and the contextual background of the Mentor Teacher Program from historical perspective and to propose suggestions for its future practice in our nation. The Mentor Teacher Program has actually been growing to an educational mature period in those developed countries, while in our nation the program is still at an incubation and incipient stage. This study concludes five dimensions in terms of the contextual background of the Mentor Teacher Program, including ＂passing on the wisdom of instructional practice,＂ ＂demonstrating the culture of trust among teachers,＂ et cetera. This author proposes nine suggestions for the future program development such as ＂establishing the legitimate basis＂, ＂implementing official positions for full-time mentor teachers,＂ ＂keeping the alignment with the teaching practicum tutors＂ and so forth.

1. 丁一顧(2003)。美、英、紐、日初任教師導入方案及其對我國之啟示。課程與教學季刊，6(3)，87-103。
   連結：
2. 丁一顧,丁儒徵(2014)。學校層級教師專業發展評鑑之「社會-情緒」支持系統建構初探。教育資料與研究，114，203-227。
   連結：
3. 李玉馨(2009)。新手教師的使命與困境：從 Dewey 哲學論臺北市教學輔導教師制度之改進。當代教育研究，17(1)，107-136。
   連結：
4. 翁振益,徐韻淑,盧美玲,熊明禮(2017)。國際觀光飯店烘焙師傅師徒關係之探討。蘭陽學報，16，50-66。
   連結：
5. 張德銳(2003)。中小學初任教師的教學輔導與考核。課程與教學季刊，6(3)，67-85。
   連結：
6. 張德銳(2016)。攜手向專業走－教學輔導教師制度的緣起、發展與運作。攜手向專業走－教學輔導教師的故事，臺北市:
   連結：
7. 張德銳,簡賢昌(2009)。教學輔導教師與夥伴教師互動歷程與專業發展之研究。臺北市立教育大學學報教育類，40(1)，1-34。
   連結：
8. (2006)。教育部補助試辦教師專業發展評鑑實施計畫（2006）。
9. 臺北市立高級中等以下學校教學輔導教師及研究教師作業要點（2018）。
10. 臺北市立高級中等以下學校教學輔導教師設置試辦方案（2000）。
11. 教育部補助辦理教師專業發展評鑑實施要點（2011）。
12. 師資培育法（2002 修正）。
13. Boreen, J.,Johnson, M. K.,Niday, D.,Potts, J.(2009).Mentoring beginning teachers: Guiding, reflecting, coaching.York, ME:Stenhouse.
14. Burke, L.,Dauksas, L.(2020).The old college try can’t find good mentors for new special education teachers in your area? Look to colleges and universities.Principal,99(3),36.
15. Büyükgöze, H.,Kavak, Y.(2015).An investigation of support measures for beginning teachers in EU countries and Turkey.International Online Journal of Education and Teaching (IOJET),2(4),223-237.
16. Carnegie Commission on Education and the Economy(1986).A nation prepared: Teachers for the 21st century.New York, NY:Carnegie Corporation.
17. Clement, M.(2019).A dozen things effective teacher mentors do.Delta Kappa Gamma Bulletin,85(4),27-29.
18. Doering, S. A.(2018).Los Angeles, California,Pepperdine University.
19. Dunne, K.,Villani, S.(2007).Mentoring new teachers through collaborative coaching: Linking teacher and student learning.San Francisco, CA:WestEd.
20. Fagan, M.,Fagan, P.(1983).Mentoring among nurses.Nursing and Health Care,4(2),77-82.
21. Feiman-Nemser, S.,Schwille, S.,Carver, C.,Yusko, B.(1999).,未出版
22. Galey, S.(2016).The evolving role of instructional coaches in U.S. policy contexts.The William & Mary Educational Review,4(2),53-71.
23. Garcia, N. D.(2012).Albuquerque, New Mexico,The University of New Mexico.
24. Gold, Y.(1996).Beginning teacher support: Attrition, mentoring, and induction.Handbook of research on teacher education,New York, NY:
25. Goldrick, L. (2016). Support from the start: A 50-state review of policies on new educator induction and mentoring. Retrieved from https://newteachercenter.org/wpcontent/uploads/2016CompleteReportStatePolicies.pdf
26. Gray, L. S.,Beamesderfer, A. O.(1980).Apprenticeship training: Where does it stand today?.Vi/fit Issues,29(5),1-4.
27. Gray, W. A.,Gray, M. E.(1985).Synthesis of research on mentoring teachers.Educational Leadership,43(3),37-43.
28. Hepner, M. M.,Faaborg, L.(1979).,未出版
29. Holmes Group(1990).Tomorrow's schools: Principles for the design of professional development schools.East Lansing, MI:Author.
30. Irby, B. J.,Boswell, J.(2016).Historical print context of the term, “mentoring”.Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning,24(1),1-7.
31. Joyce, B.,Showers, B.(1982).The coaching of teaching.Educational Leadership,40(1),4-10.
32. Joyce, B.,Showers, B.(1988).Student achievement through staff development.New York, NY:Longman.
33. Killion, J.(2012).Coaching in the k-12 context.The Sage handbook of mentoring and coaching in education,Thousand Oaks, CA:
34. Learning Professional(2019).How mentors can support new teachers.Learning Professional,40(1),60-66.
35. Lowney, R. G.(1986).,未出版
36. National Commission on Excellence in Education(1983).A Nation at Risk: The imperative for educational reform.Washington, DC:U.S. Government Printing Office.
37. Odell, S. J.(1990).Mentor teacher programs.Washington, D C:National Education Association.
38. OECD(2014).TALIS 2013 results: An international perspective on teaching and learning.
39. Phillips, G. M.(1979).The peculiar intimacy of graduate study: A conservative view.Communication Education,28,39-345.
40. Pierce, C. A.(1983).Austin, TX,The University of Texas at Austin.
41. Rawles, B.(1980).Columbus, Ohio,Ohio State University.
42. Serpell, Z.(2000).,未出版
43. Smith, T. M.,Ingersoll, R. M.(2004).What are the effects of induction and mentoring on beginning teacher turnover?.American Education Research Journal,41(3),681-714.
44. Stîngu, M.(2013).Induction of newly qualified teachers: Limits, needs and opportunities.Journal of Education Culture and Society,13(1),148-157.
45. Strong, M.(2009).Effective teacher induction and mentoring: Assessing the evidence.New York, NY:Teachers College Press.
46. Weimer, K. R.(2017).Pennsylvania,The Pennsylvania State University, State College.
47. Zeichner, K. M.(1979).Teacher induction practices in the US and Great Britain.annual meeting of American Educational Research Association,San Francisco, CA:
48. 丁一顧(2016)。教學輔導教師制度實施展望。攜手向專業走－教學輔導教師的故事，臺北市:
49. 丁一顧,王淑麗(2018)。臺北市教學輔導教師同儕式領導與夥伴教師教學效能關係之研究。教育政策論壇，21(1)，31-58。
50. 丁一顧,張德銳(2009)。校本教學輔導制度推動模式之建構研究－以臺北市教學輔導教師制度為例。優化課堂教學：教師發展、伙伴協作與專業學習共同體，北京市:
51. 江雪齡(1989)。由美國良師制度探討實習教師的問題與輔導途徑。國教研究雙月刊，7，49-52。
52. 李秀蘭(2012)。花蓮縣，國立東華大學學校行政碩士學位學程。
53. 林心茹（譯）,Boreen, J.,Johnson, M. K.,Niday, D.,Potts, J.(2004).啟導初任教師.臺北市:遠流.
54. 林官蓓,陳建志,陳瑞庭(2015)。高雄市國民中小學教學輔導教師制度之研究。臺灣教育評論月刊，4(7)，152-181。
55. 俞涵鈺(2009)。臺北市，國立臺灣師範大學教育學系。
56. 張芬芬(2012)。「教學輔導教師制度」：成功的人性實驗。臺灣教育評論月刊，1(4)，54-56。
57. 張德銳(2006)。從教學輔導教師到領導教師─我國教師分級規劃之另類構想。臺北市立教學大學學報，教育類，37(1)，77-98。
58. 張德銳(1992).國民小學教師評鑑之研究.新竹市:國立新竹師範學院.
59. 張德銳(2006)。臺北市教學輔導教師制度的回顧、現況與前瞻。教育行政與評鑑學刊，1，1-22。
60. 張德銳,張芬芬,鄭玉卿,萬家春,賴佳敏,楊益風,張清楚,高永遠,彭天建(2001)。台北市中小學教學輔導教師制度規劃研究。初等教育學刊，9，23-54。
61. 盧政春(2012)。德國師徒制產學合作復合雙軌體制。Talent 前瞻國際創新人才雙月刊，17，10-15。