合作學習參與公平性影響因素的多層次分析

A Multi-level Analysis on the Factors Influencing Equitable Participation in Cooperative Groups

10.6384/CIQ.202207_25(3).0004

黃永和(Yung-Ho Huang)

合作學習 ； 參與公平性 ； 期望地位 ； 目標互賴 ； cooperative learning ； equitable participation ； expectation status ； goal interdependence

課程與教學

25卷3期（2022 / 07 / 01）

83 - 106

繁體中文

本研究目的乃探討期望地位與正向目標互賴等學生層變項對合作學習參與公平性的預測力，班級層班平均正向目標互賴的脈絡效果，以及其對學生層正向目標互賴的調節效果。本研究以具有合作學習經驗的八年級學生作為研究對象，施以小組學習參與公平性量表、期望地位問卷與正向目標互賴量表，收回30個班級714位學生的有效問卷。多層次分析結果顯示：（1）期望地位對學生小組學習參與公平性經驗有正向預測力；（2）正向目標互賴對學生小組學習參與公平性經驗有正向預測力；（3）正向目標互賴對學生小組學習參與公平性經驗有正向預測力，而且可以調節學生層正向目標互賴與小組學習參與公平性經驗之間的關係。

This study investigated the predictive effects of student-level variables such as expectation status and positive goal interdependence on equitable participation in the cooperative learning. It also explored the contextual effect of the class-level aggregate positive goal interdependence, as well as the moderating effect of the class-level aggregate positive goal interdependence between the positive goal interdependence and equitable participation. The subjects were 714 students from 30 classes with cooperative learning experience. The results were as follows: (1) The student-level variables, expectation status and positive goal interdependence, could predict significantly students' equitable participation; (2) The class-level aggregate positive goal interdependence could predict significantly students' equitable participation, and moderate the relationship between the positive goal interdependence and equitable participation.

1. Bales, R. F.(1950).Interaction process analysis: A method for the study of small groups.Addison-Wesley.
2. Berger, J.,Cohen, B. P.,Zelditch, M., Jr.(1972).Status characteristics and social interaction.American Sociological Review,37(3),241-255.
3. Bertucci, A.,Hilk, C. L.,Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.(2016).Effect of task and goal interdependence on achievement, cooperation, and support among edlemetary school students.AASCIT Journal of Psychology,2(1),1-8.
4. Bianchini, J. A.(1999).From here to equity: The influence of status on student access to and understanding of science.Science Education,83(5),577-601.
5. Bruffee, K. A.(1999).Collaborative learning: Higher education, interdependence, and the authority of knowledge.Johns Hopkins University.
6. Cambridge Dictionary (n.d.). Equity. https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/
7. Cohen, E. G.(1984).Talking and working together: Status, interaction, and learning.The social context of instruction: Group organization and group processes
8. Cohen, E. G.,Lotan, R. A.(2014).Designing groupwork: Strategies for the heterogeneous classroom.Teachers College.
9. Dembo, M. H.,McAuliffe, T. J.(1987).Effects of perceived ability and grade status on social interaction and influence in cooperative groups.Journal of Educational Psychology,79(4),415-423.
10. Deutsch, M.(2006).Cooperation and competition.The handbook of conflict resolution: Theory and practice
11. Eggen, P. D.,Kauchak, D. P.(2012).Strategies for teachers: Teaching content and thinking skills.Allyn and Bacon.
12. Esmonde, I.(2009).Mathematics learning in groups: Analyzing equity in two cooperative activity structures.Journal of the Learning Sciences,18(2),247-284.
13. Frykedal, K. F.,Chiriac, E. H.(2018).Student Collaboration in Group Work: Inclusion as participation.International Journal of Disability, Development and Education,65(2),183-198.
14. Hand, V. M.,Quindel, J.,Esmonde, I.(2010).Status and competence as entry points into discussions of equity in mathematics classrooms.Mathematics teaching and learning in K-12: Equity and professional development
15. Horn, I. S.(2012).Strength in numbers: Collaborative learning in secondary mathematics.National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
16. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, F. P.(1994).Joining together: Group theory and group skills.Allyn and Bacon.
17. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.(2005).New developments in social interdependence thoery.Genetic, Social, and General Psychology Monographs,131(4),285-358.
18. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.(2017).The use of cooperative procedures in teacher education and professional development.Journal of Education for Teaching,43(3),284-295.
19. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.(1999).Learning together and alone: Cooperative, competitive, and individualistic learning.Allyn and Bacon.
20. Johnson, D. W.,Johnson, R. T.,Anderson, D.(1983).Social interdependence and classroom climate.The Journal of Psychology,114,135-142.
21. Kalaian, S. A.,Kasim, R. M.(2014).A meta-analytic review of studies of the effectiveness of small-group learning methods on statistics achievement.Journal of Statistics Education,22(4),1-20.
22. Lave, J.,Wenger, E.(1991).Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation.Cambridge University Press.
23. Levi, D.(2014).Group dynamics for teams.SAGE.
24. Mayer, R. E.(Ed.),Alexander, P. A.(Ed.)(2017).Handbook of research on learning and instruction.Routledge.
25. Meeker, B. F.(2004).Expectation status and interpersonal behavior.Social psychology: Sociological perspectives
26. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics(2000).Principles and standards for school mathematics.The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
27. OECD(2018).Equity in education: Breaking down barriers to social mobility.OECD Publishing.
28. Pai, H.,Sears, D. A.,Maeda, Y.(2015).Effects of small-grpup learning on transfer: A meta-analysis.Educational Psychology Review,27(1),79-102.
29. Ritzer, G. (Ed.)(2016).The Blackwell encyclopedia of sociology.John Wiley & Sons.
30. Schniedewind, N.,Davidson, E.(2014).Open minds to equality: A sourcebook of learning activities to affirm diversity and promote equity.Rethinking Schools.
31. Shah, N.,Crespo, S.(2018).Cultural narratives and status hierarchies: Tools for identifying and disrupting inequity in mathematics classroom interaction.Mathematical discourse that breaks barriers and creates space for marginalized learners
32. Theobald, E. J.,Eddy, S. L.,Grunspan, D. Z.,Wiggins, B. L.,Crowe, A. J.(2017).Student perception of group dynamics predicts individual performance: Comfort and equity matter.PLOS ONE,12(7),e0181336.
33. Tjosvold, D.,Johnson, D.(2000).s theory of cooperation and competition.Work teams: Past, present and future
34. Truijen, K. J. P.,Sleegers, P. J. C.,Meelissen, M. R. M.(2013).What makes teacher teams in a vocational education context effective?.Journal of Workplace Learning,25(1),58-73.
35. Vygotsky, L. S.(1978).Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes.Harvard University.
36. Webster, M.,Walker, L. S.(2016).The theories of status characteristics and expectation states.Handbook of contemporary sociological theory
37. Wieselmann, J. R.,Dare, E. A.,Ring-Whalen, E. A.,Roehrig, G. H.(2020).I just do what the boys tell me”: Exploring small group student interactions in an integrated STEM unit.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,57(1),112-144.
38. 張新仁（編）(2019).分組合作學習：自發、互動、共好的實踐.教育部國民及學前教育署.
39. 教育部（2014）。詞條名稱：教育公平。教育百科網站，http://pedia.cloud.edu.tw/
40. 陳芳如,段曉林(2007)。課室試行合作學習之行動研究。科學教育，13，91-108。
41. 黃永和(2016)。期望地位對小組學習的影響與因應策略。教育論叢，4，15-32。
42. 黃永和(2019).小組學習：環境、動機與公平性之研究.五南.
43. 黃永和(2009).情境學習與教學研究.國立編譯館.
44. 楊文金(1999)。「期望地位」對同儕互動的影響分析。科學教育學刊，7(3)，217-232。

1. 黃永和(2023)。合作小組目標互賴與精緻互助行為關係研究。課程與教學，26(3)，91-124。