题名

從學校氛圍視角分析華人學生PISA 2018閱讀素養的表現

并列篇名

The Analysis of PISA 2018 Reading Literacy Performance of Ethnic Chinese Students: The School Climate Perspective

DOI

10.6384/CIQ.202210_25(4).0007

作者

麥瑞琪(Soi-Kei Mak)；張國祥(Kwok-Cheung Cheung)；薛寶嫦(Pou-Seong Sit)；楊文佳(Man-Kai Ieong)

关键词

比較教育 ； 華人地區 ； 閱讀素養 ； 學校氛圍 ； PISA ； Comparative education ； Ethnic Chinese region ； Reading literacy ； School climate ； PISA

期刊名称

課程與教學

卷期/出版年月

25卷4期（2022 / 10 / 01）

页次

191 - 224

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究通過中國四省市（北京－上海－江蘇－浙江）、香港、澳門、臺灣和新加坡五個在社會、文化與生活相近，且對學生學習成就都非常重視的華人地區進行學校氛圍跨地區比較，以冀得知華人地區的學校氛圍對學生素養表現的影響，目的是讓學校氛圍的跨地區差異比較得以對各地學生閱讀素養之養成提供另一個觀察的視點。研究結果顯示學生知覺到的學校氛圍對閱讀成績普遍有顯著的預測作用，且在五個地區間具有較高的一致性，同時卻各有側重，教育工作者宜根據當地實際情況改進學校氛圍，以及男女學生感知校園氛圍的性別差異，從而提升學生的素養表現。
英文摘要

This study examines reading performance of PISA 2018 in five ethnic Chinese economies, which includes four provinces/cities of China, Hong Kong, Macao, Taiwan and Singapore, in order to assess the effects of school climate on reading performance from a comparative education perspective. The five ethnic Chinese economies are proximal in social, cultural and everyday life. Secondary analysis revealed that the school climate variables analyzed generally are able to predict students' reading performance with statistical significant effects. Though many of the school climate effects are common across the five economies, there are unique effects as well. Regarding these findings, educational practitioners should consider the local contexts while seeking to improve the school climate as well as students' gender differences in school climate awareness. In so doing, students' reading performance can be further improved.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 李佩珊(2019)。Bronfenbrenner 生態系統理論的近期發展與應用。輔導季刊，55(3)，14-24。
    連結：
  2. 張國祥,薛寶嫦,麥瑞琪(2011)。家長參與和家庭支援對提高澳門青少年閱讀素養的影響。課程與教學季刊，14(4)，93-116。
    連結：
  3. 鄭永福,許瑛玿,李哲迪(2018)。華人地區數學素養教育效率比較。教育科學研究期刊，63(4)，1-28。
    連結：
  4. Bandura, A.(1986).Social foundations of thought and action: A Social-cognitive theory.Prentice Hall.
  5. Bear, G.G.,Yang, C.,Chen, D.,He, X.,Xie, J.,Huang, X.(2018).Differences in school climate and student engagement in China and the United States.School Psychology Quarterly,33(2),323-335.
  6. Borgonovi, F.,Montt, G.(2012).Education Working PapersEducation Working Papers,OECD publishing.
  7. Bradshaw, C.,O’Brennan, L.,McNeely, C.(2008).Core competencies and the prevention of school failure and early school leaving.New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development,122,19-32.
  8. Bradshaw, C.,Sawyer, A.,O’Brennan, L.(2009).A social disorganization perspective on bullying-related attitudes and behaviors: The influence of school context.American Journal of Community Psychology,43(3-4),204-220.
  9. Brand, S.,Felner, R. D.,Seitsinger, A.,Burns, A.,Bolton, N.(2008).A large scale study of the assessment of the social environment of middle and secondary schools: The validity and utility of teachers' ratings of school climate, cultural pluralism, and safety problems for understanding school effects and school improvement.Journal of School Psychology,46(5),507-535.
  10. Bronfenbrenner, U.(1995).Developmental ecology through space and time: A future perspective.Examining lives in context: Perspectives on the ecology of human development
  11. Bronfenbrenner, U.(1979).The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature and design.Harvard University Press.
  12. Bronfenbrenner, U.,Ceci, S. J.(1994).Nature-nuture reconceptualized in developmental perspective: A bioecological model.Psychological review,101(4),568-586.
  13. Bronfenbrenner, U.,Evans, G.(2000).Developmental science in the 21st century: Emerging questions, theoretical models, research designs and empirical findings.Social Development,9(1),115-125.
  14. Bronfenbrenner, U.,Morris, P. A.(1998).The ecology of developmental processes.Handbook of child psychology Vol. 1: Theoretical models of human development
  15. Brookover, W. B.,Schweitzer, J. H.,Schneider, J. M.,Beady, C. H.,Flood, P. K.,Wisenbaker, J. M.(1978).Elementary school social climate and school achievement.American Educational Research Journal,15(2),301-318.
  16. Chen, G.,Weikart, L. A.(2008).Student background, school climate, school disorder, and student achievement: An empirical study of New York City's middle schools.Journal of School Violence,7(4),3-20.
  17. Chen, Q.,Zhu, Y.,Chui, W. H.(2021).A meta-analysis on effects of parenting programs on bullying prevention.Trauma, Violence, & Abuse,22(5),1209-1220.
  18. Chentsova-Dutton, Y. E.,Choi, I-J.,Choi, E.(2020).Perceived parental support and adolescents’ positive self-beliefs and levels of distress across four countries.Frontiers in Psychology,11,353.
  19. Cheung, K. C.,Keeves, J. P.(1990).Hierarchical linear modeling.International Journal of Educational Research,14,289-297.
  20. Chiu, M. M.(2016).Chinese teaching and learning of mathematics.Chinese Education Models in a Global Age
  21. Chiu, M. M.,Zeng, X.(2008).Family and motivation effects on mathematics achievement.Learning and Instruction,18,321-336.
  22. Clifford, M.(1971).Motivational effects of competition and goal setting in reward and non-reward conditions.The Journal of Experimental Education,39(3),11-16.
  23. Cohen, J.(1992).A power primer.Psychological Bulletin,112(1),155-159.
  24. Cohen, J.(1988).Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences.Routledge Academic.
  25. Cohen, J.,McCable, L.,Michelli, N. M.,Pickeral, T.(2009).School climate: Research, policy, teacher education and practice.Teachers College Record,111(1),180-213.
  26. Cohen, J.,Pickeral, T.,McCloskey, M.(2009).Assessing school climate.The Education Digest,74(8),45-48.
  27. Collins, T. N.,Parson, K. A.(2010).School climate and student outcomes.Journal of Cross-Disciplinary Perspectives in Education,3(1),34-39.
  28. Deci, E. L.,Ryan, R. M.(1985).Intrinsic motivation and self-determination in human behavior.Plenum Press.
  29. Dennis, M. L.,Canas, M.,Ortega-Medina, M.(2007).Effects of team competition versus team cooperation in class-wide peer tutoring.The Journal of Educational Research,100(3),155-160.
  30. Dimmock, C.(2013).School-based management and school effectiveness.Routledge.
  31. Domina, T.(2005).Leveling the home advantage: Assessing the effectiveness of parental involvement in elementary school.Sociology of Education,78(3),233-249.
  32. Espelage, D.,Low, S.,Jimerson, S. R.(2014).Understanding school climate, aggression, peer victimization, and bully perpetration: Contemporary science, practice, and policy.School Psychology Quarterly,29(3),233-237.
  33. Fan, W.,Williams, C.(2018).The mediating role of student motivation in the linking of perceived school climate and academic achievement in reading and mathematics.Frontiers in Education,3(50),1-12.
  34. Frederickson, N.(1968).Administrative performance in relation to organizational climate.American Psychological Association Convention
  35. Georgiou, S. N.,Stavrinides, P.(2013).Parenting at home and bullying at school.Social Psychology of Education,16,165-179.
  36. Goddard, R. D.,Sweetland, S. R.,Hoy, W. K.(2000).Academic emphasis of urban elementary schools and student achievement in reading and mathematics: A multilevel analysis.Educational Administration Quarterly,36(5),683-702.
  37. Gregory, A.,Henry, D. B.,Schoeny, M. E.,Metropolitan Area Child Study Research Group(2007).School climate and implementation of a preventive intervention.American Journal of Community Psychology,40(3-4),250-260.
  38. Haynes, N. M.,Emmons, C.,Ben-Avie, M.(1997).School climate as a factor in student adjustment and achievement.Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation,8(3),321-329.
  39. Haynes, N. M.,Emmons, C.,Comer, J. P.(1994).School climate survey: Elementary and middle school version.Yale University Child Study Center.
  40. Heck, R. H.(2000).Examining the impact of school quality on school outcomes and improvement: A value-added approach.Educational Administration Quarterly,36(4),513-552.
  41. Hee, O. C.(2014).Validity and reliability of the customer-oriented behaviour scale in the health tourism hospitals in Malaysia.International Journal of Caring Sciences,7(3),771-775.
  42. Hoy, W. K.,Hannum, J. W.(1997).Middle school climate: An empirical assessment of organization health and student achievement.Educational Administration Quarterly,33(3),290-312.
  43. Hoy, W. K.,Tarter, C. J.,Kottkamp, R. B.(1991).Open schools/healthy schools: Measuring organizational climate.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
  44. Hoy, W. K.,Tarter, C.J.,Hoy, A. W.(2006).Academic optimism of schools: A force for student achievement.American Educational Research Journal,43(3),425-446.
  45. Huang, Y.,Espelage, D. L.,Polanin, J. R.,Hong, J. S.(2019).A meta-analytic review of school-based anti-bullying programs with a parent component.International Journal of Bullying Prevention,1,32-44.
  46. Jia, Y.,Way, N.,Ling, G.,Yoshikawa, H.,Chen, X.,Hughes, D.,Ke, X.,Lu, Z.(2009).The influence of student perceptions of school climate on socioemotional and academic adjustment: A comparison of Chinese and American adolescents.Child Development,80(5),1514-1530.
  47. Johnson, B.,Stevens, J. J.(2006).Student achievement and elementary teachers’ perceptions of school climate.Learning Environments Research,9(2),111-122.
  48. Johnson, D.,Johnson, R.(1974).Instructional goal structure: Cooperative, competitive, or individualistic.Review of Educational Research,44(2),213-240.
  49. Kistruck, G. M.,Lount, R. B., J.,Smith, B. R.,Bergman, B. J., Jr.,Moss, T. W.(2016).Cooperation vs. competition: Alternative goal structures for motivating groups in a resource scarce environment.Academy of Management Journal,59(4),1174-1198.
  50. Konishi, C.,Hymel, S.,Zumbo, B. D.,Li, Z.(2010).Do school bullying and student-teacher relationships matter for academic achievement? A multilevel analysis.Canadian Journal of School Psychology,25(1),19-39.
  51. Kozina, A.,Rožman, M.,Vršnik Perše, T.,Rutar Leban, T.(2012).Predictive values of different school climate evaluations for TIMSS research findings.Didactica Slovenica - Pedagoska Obzorja,27,127-144.
  52. Lee, S.,Niederle, M.,Kang, N.(2014).Do single-sex schools make girls more competitive?.Economics Letters,124(3),474-477.
  53. Lereya, S. T.,Samara, M.,Wolke, D.(2013).Parenting behavior and the risk of becoming a victim and a bully/victim: A meta-analysis study.Child Abuse & Neglect,37(12),1091-1108.
  54. Lester, L.,Pearce, N.,Waters, S.,Barnes, A.,Beatty, S.,Cross, D.(2017).Family involvement in a whole-school bullying intervention: Mothers’ and fathers’ communication and influence with children.Journal of Child and Family Studies,26(10),2716-2727.
  55. Li, J.(2003).US and Chinese cultural beliefs about learning.Journal of Educational Psychology,95(2),258-267.
  56. Lubienski, S. T.,Lubienski, C.,Crane, C. C.(2008).Achievement differences and school type: The role of school climate, teacher certification, and instruction.American Journal of Education,115(1),97-138.
  57. Mak, S.K.,Cheung, K.C.,Soh, K.C.,Sit, P.S.,Ieong, M.K.(2017).An examination of student- and across-level mechanisms accounting for gender differences in reading performance: A multilevel analysis of reading engagement.Educational Psychology,37(10),1206-1221.
  58. Mansor, A. N.,Nasaruddin, M. Z. I. M.,Hamid, A. H. A.(2021).The effects of school climate on sixth form teachers’ self-efficacy in Malaysia.Sustainability,13(4),1-14.
  59. Martinez, R. S.,Aricak, O. T.,Jewell, J.(2008).Influence of reading attitude on reading achievement: A test of the temporal-interaction mode.Psychology in the Schools,45(10),1010-1023.
  60. Maxwell, S.,Reynolds, K. J.,Lee, E.,Subasic, E.,Bromhead, D.(2017).The impact of school climate and school identification on academic achievement: Multilevel modeling with student and teacher Data.Frontiers in Psychology,8,1-21.
  61. Modin, B.,Östberg, V.(2009).School climate and psychosomatic health: A multilevel analysis.School effectiveness and school improvement,20(4),433-455.
  62. Moroni, S.,Dumont, H.,Trautwein, U.,Niggli, A.,Baeriswyl, F.(2015).The need to distinguish between quantity and quality in research on parental involvement: The example of parental help with homework.The Journal of Educational Research,108(5),417-431.
  63. Mullis, I. V. S., Martin, M. O., Foy, P., & Hooper, M. (2017). PIRLS 2016 International results in Reading. TIMSS & PIRLS International Study Center. http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/pirls2016/international-results/
  64. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development=OECD(2019).PISA 2018 assessment and analytical framework.OECD publishing.
  65. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development=OECD(2019).PISA 2018 technical report.OECD publishing.
  66. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development=OECD(2019).PISA 2018 results (Volume III): What school life means for students’ lives.OECD publishing.
  67. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development=OECD(2019).PISA 2018 results (Volume I): What students know and can do.OECD publishing.
  68. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development=OECD(2009).PISA data analysis manual: SPSS.OECD publishing.
  69. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development=OECD(2019).PISA 2018 results (Volume II): Where all students can succeed.OECD publishing.
  70. Osher, D., & Berg, J. (2018). School climate and social and emotional learning: The integration of two approaches. https://www.rwjf.org/content/dam/farm/reports/issue_briefs/2018/rwjf443059
  71. Petrie, K.(2014).The relationship between school climate and student bullying.Teach Journal of Christian Education,8(1),26-35.
  72. Purkey, S. C.,Smith, M. S.(1983).Effective schools: A review.The Elementary School Journal,83(4),427-452.
  73. Reitz, J. G.,Verma, A.(2004).Immigration, race, and labor.Industrial Relations,43,835-854.
  74. Reyes, M. R.,Brackett, M. A.,Rivers, S. E.,White, M.,Salovey, P.(2012).Classroom emotional climate, student engagement, and academic achievement.Journal of Educational Psychology,104(3),700-712.
  75. Rohatgi, A.,Scherer, R.(2020).Identifying profiles of students’ school climate perceptions using PISA 2015 data.Large-scale Assessments in Education,8(4),1-25.
  76. Rutchick, A. M.,Smyth, J. M.,Lopoo, L. M.,Dusek, J. B.(2009).Great expectations: The biasing effects of reported child behavior problems on educational expectancies and subsequent academic achievement.Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology,28(3),392-413.
  77. Scherer, R.,Nilsen, T.(2016).The relations among school climate, instructional quality, and achievement motivation in mathematics.Teacher quality, instructional quality and student outcomes: Relationships across countries, cohort and time
  78. Sit, P.S.,Cheung, K.C.,Ieong, M.K.,Mak, S. K.(2021).Students’ frequentexposure to bullying: Comparing between low-achieving students of Macao and Taiwan in PISA 2015 Well-being Study.Educational Psychology,41(3),302-319.
  79. Steinberg, L.,Morris, A. S.(2001).Adolescent development.Annual review of psychology,52(1),83-110.
  80. Stewart, T.,Suldo, S.(2011).Relationships between social support sources and early adolescents’ mental health: The moderating effect of student achievement level.Psychology in the Schools,48(10),1016-1033.
  81. Thapa, A.,Cohen, J.,Guffey, S.,Higgins-D’Alessandro, A.(2013).A review of school climate research.Review of Educational Research,83(3),357-385.
  82. Tudge, J. R.,Freitas, L. B.,O'Brien, L. T.(2015).The virtue of gratitude: A developmental and cultural approach.Human Development,58(4-5),281-300.
  83. Wang, C.,La Salle, T.,Wu, C.,Do, K. A.,Sullivan, K. E.(2018).School climate and parental involvement buffer the risk of peer victimization on suicidal thoughts and behaviors among Asian American middle school students.Asian American Journal of Psychology,9(4),296-307.
  84. Wang, M. T.,Degol, J. L.(2016).School climate: A review of the construct, measurement, and impact on student outcomes.Educational Psychology Review,28(2),315-352.
  85. Wang, Z.(2016).Confucian education ideology and its impact on Chinese mathematics teaching and learning.Chinese Education Models in a Global Age
  86. Welsh, W.(2000).The effects of school climate on school disorder.Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,567,88-107.
  87. Wilson, D.(2004).The interface of school climate and school connectedness and relationships with aggression and victimization.Journal of School Health,74,293-299.
  88. Yang, C.,Bear, G. G.,Chen, F. F.,Zhang, W.,Blank, J. C.,Huang, X.(2013).Students' perceptions of school climate in the U.S. and China.School Psychology Quarterly,28(1),7-24.
  89. Zhou, Y.,Wang, D.(2016).A Chinese approach to learning? A comparative study on time use patterns of 15-year-old students in PISA 2012.Chinese Education Models in a Global Age
  90. 王玥,趙麗娟,許志星(2016)。課業負擔對學校生活滿意度的影響：學校氛圍的多水準調節作用。心理發展與教育，32(2)，205-213。
  91. 余益兵,葛明貴(2010)。初中生感知的學校氣氛的特點及其與學校適應的關係：學校態度的中介作用。中國臨床心理學雜誌，18(2)，225-227。
  92. 李文燁(2021)。競爭與合作：哪種學校氛圍更利於學生的發展──基於 PISA 2018 的數據分析。教育測量與評價，10，27-34。
  93. 張平平,李凌艷,辛濤(2011)。學校氛圍對學生數學成績影響的跨文化比較：基於多水平分析的結果。心理發展與教育，6，625-632。
  94. 程介明 （ 2017 ， 8 月 21 日 ） 。 科舉、勤奮、競爭。灼見名家。https://www.master-insight.com/%E7%A7%91%E8%88%89%EF%BC%8E%E5%8B%A4%E5%A5%AE%EF%BC%8E%E7%AB%B6%E7%88%AD/
  95. 楊舒涵(2015)。有校歸不得的孩子──由生態系統合作的角度探討校園內的拒學現象。台灣心理諮商季刊，7(4)，15-16。
  96. 劉潔玲(2015)。香港學生在歷屆學生能力國際評估計畫的閱讀表現對中文科課程和教學的啟示。教育學報，43(1)，59-84。
  97. 劉濤,紀明澤(2011).男生教育缺甚麼？.浙江大學出版社.
  98. 蔣帆,姚昊(2022)。家庭背景、學校氛圍如何影響學生抗逆力？基於 PISA 2018的實證分析。基礎教育，19(1)，43-53。
  99. 鄭如珍(2012)。國立中興大學。
  100. 鄭雅婷,許惟翔,邱憲義(2015)。教師組織信任、組織承諾、學校組織氣氛對工作滿意度的影響。朝陽人文學刊，13(2)，97-116。
  101. 謝家樹,肖帥軍,Yang, C.,Bear, G. G.(2017)。中美青少年學校氛圍感知的比較研究。中國臨床心理學雜誌，25(4)，714-718。
print cancel