促進科技輔助自主學習之教師教學輔助策略指標建構之研究

A Study on Developing Teaching Strategy Indicators for Promoting Technology-Enhanced Self-Regulated Learning

10.6384/CIQ.202307_26(3).0001

高台茜(Tai-Chien Kao)；張維珊(Wei-Shan Chang)

科技輔助自主學習 ； 教師自主學習輔助策略指標 ； 德懷術專家調查 ； technology-enhanced self-regulated learning ； teaching strategy indicators for enhancing self-regulated learning ； Delphi technique for expert survey

課程與教學

26卷3期（2023 / 07 / 01）

1 - 30

繁體中文;英文

本研究以自學、共學、互學、導學四種學習方式與定標、擇策、監評、調節四個自我調節步驟為雙向架構，發展教師可以善用科技發展學生自主學習能力的教學輔助策略指標。本研究邀請15位具科技輔助自主學習計畫講師資格的專家，針對策略指標的重要性與難易度，進行三個輪次德懷術問卷調查。研究發現：1.指標均具重要性，有利教師在教學現場進行課堂實踐；2.可依指標難易度，為教師專業發展搭建鷹架；3.各指標可以善用的科技輔助，需有一般性；4.自學與互學中監評步驟的輔導策略，需強化培訓與輔導；5.可依指標發展評量工具，追蹤教師專業成長。

Since the launch of "Technology-Enhanced Self-Regulated Learning Program (TESRL)" by Taiwan's Ministry of Education in November 2019, making use of technology to enhance students' self-regulated learning has become an important issue for elementary and secondary teachers' professional development. This study incorporates personal and social oriented self-regulated learning theories and strategies to develop a two-dimension indicator framework with the four types of learning, which is also known as the "four-learning model" (self-learning, co-learning, mutual learning, and guided learning), and four steps of self-regulation cycle. Based on the framework, the practical and feasible teaching strategies for enhancing TESRL were investigated. The study conducted three rounds of expert survey with Delphi technique. Fifteen qualified instructors of TESRL workshops with practical teaching experience in primary or secondary school were invited to participate the expert survey. The findings of the study are: 1. All teaching strategy indicators are important, and they all support teachers' classroom practices on the teaching sites; 2. According to the degree of difficulty of the indicators, scaffolding can be applied in teachers' professional development; 3. To master the monitoring and evaluation steps in self-learning and mutual learning which are part of the guidance strategy, teachers need more training and guidance; 4. Based on the above indicators, assessment tools should be developed to track teachers' professional development.

1. Brevik, L. M.,Gunnulfsen, A. E.,Renzulli, J. S.(2018).Student teachers’ practiceand experience with differentiated instruction for students with higher learning potential.Teaching and Teacher Education,71,34-45.
2. Buss, A. R.(2001).A Delphi study of educational telecollaborative projects: Identifying critical elements and obstacles.Journal of Educational Computing Research,24(3),235-248.
3. Dignath, C.,Dickhäuser, O.,Büttner, G.(2013).Assessing how teachers enhance self-regulated learning: A multiperspective approach.Journal of Cognitive Education and Psychology,12(3),338-358.
4. Dignath, C.,Veenman, M.(2020).The role of direct strategy instruction and indirect activation of self-regulated learning-Evidence from classroom observation studies.Educational Psychology Review,33,489-533.
5. Dixon, F. A.,Yssel, N.,McConnell, J. M.,Hardin, T.(2014).Differentiated instruction, professional development, and teacher efficacy.Journal for the Education of the Gifted,37(2),111-127.
6. Faherty, V.(1979).Continuing social work education: Results of a Delphi survey.Journal of Education for Social Work,15(1),12-19.
7. Hadwin, A.,Oshige, M.(2011).Self-regulation, coregulation, and socially shared regulation: Exploring perspectives of social in self-regulated learning theory.Teachers College Record,113(6),240-264.
8. Haelermans, C.(2022).The Effects of Group differentiation by students’ learning strategies.Instructional Science,50,223-250.
9. Harding, S.,Nibali, N.,English, N.,Griffin, P.,Graham, J.,Alom, M.,Zhang, Z.(2018).,Assessment Research Centre, Melbourne Graduate School of Education.
10. Ho, S. M.(2014).The development of a school-based model of self-regulated learning in Hong Kong secondary school classrooms.Asia Pacific Journal of Educational Development,3(2),25-36.
11. Hwang, G. J.,Wang, S. Y.,Lai, C. L.(2021).Effects of a social regulation-based online learning framework on students’ learning achievements and behaviors in mathematics.Computers, & Education,160,104031.
12. Kaliisa, R.,Rienties, B.,Mørch, A. I.,Kluge, A.(2022).Social learning analytics in computer-supported collaborative learning environments: A systematic review of empirical studies.Computers and Education Open,100073.
13. Lai, C. L.,Hwang, G. J.(2021).Strategies for enhancing self-regulation in e-learning: a review of selected journal publications from 2010 to 2020.Interactive Learning Environments
14. Melesse, T.(2015).Differentiated instruction: Perceptions, practices and challenges of primary school teachers.STAR Journal,4(3),253-264.
15. Panadero, E.,Broadbent, J.,Boud, D.,Jason, M.(2019).Using formative assessment to influence self-and co-regulated learning: the role of evaluative judgement.European Journal of Psychology of Education,34,535-557.
16. Persico, D.,Steffens, K.(2017).Self-regulated learning in technology enhanced learning environments.Technology enhanced learning
17. Quackenbush, M.,Bol, L.(2020).Teacher support of co- and socially-shared regulation of learning in middle school mathematics classrooms.Frontiers in Education,5
18. Roman, T. A.,Callison, M.,Myers, R. D.,Berry, A. H.(2020).Facilitating authentic learning experiences in distance education: embedding research-based practices into an online peer feedback tool.TechTrends,64,591-605.
19. Scheibe, M.,Skutsch, M.,Schofer, J.(2002).Experiments in Delphi methodology.The Delphi Method Techniques and Applications
20. Zimmerman, B. J.(1994).Dimensions of academic self-regulation: A conceptual framework for education.Self-regulation of learning and performance: Issues and educational applications
21. Zimmerman, B. J.,Bonner, S.,Kovach, R.(1996).Developing self-regulated learners: Beyond achievement to self-efficacy.American Psychological Association.
22. 林堂馨(2018)。自主學習的五大發展趨勢。教育研究月刊，295，126-145。
23. 教育部（2021）。教育部「推動中小學數位學習精進方案」。https://pads.moe.edu.tw/
24. 教育部（2019a）。「數位校園·智慧學習科技輔助自主學習」。https://srl.ntue.edu.tw/
25. 教育部（2019b）。「數位學習工作坊簡報」。教育部因材網。https://adl.edu.tw/HomePage/account-apply/
26. 教育部（2022）。教育部數位教學指引 1.0。教育雲數位學習入口網。https://ws.moe.edu.tw/001/Upload/23/relfile/8006/86277/2d47608d-1cb3-4477-9069-8e6e797d4f65.pdf
27. 郭伯臣(2020)。校園防疫與中小學數位學習之現況與未來。國土及公共治理季刊，8(4)，72-79。
28. 郭伯臣,劉文惠(2020)。數位學習新趨勢─個人化學習與人工智慧導入。師友雙月刊，620，11-14。
29. 楊語承,吳宇凡,施君潔,陳淑蕙(2020)。科技輔助自主學習。師友雙月刊，620，11-14。

1. (2024)。國中基礎學科教科書編審者對素養導向教科書設計之觀點與實踐。教科書研究，17(1)，67-109。
2. (2024)。國中基礎學科素養導向教科書設計指標之建構。中等教育，75(2)，70-95。