「差異的共融」：從Inclusive Recreation的理念探討休閒平權的契機與道德正確

10.6162/SRR.2009.102.03

陳渝苓；童瑋琳

融合 ； 身心障礙 ； 休閒參與 ； 公平

大專體育

102期（2009 / 06 / 01）

16 - 24

繁體中文

目前在現有學術文獻上有關於身心障礙者的討論並不少，但從平權的角度來思慮，學術上對身心障礙的觀點多半是採取一個「缺乏」的立場，此「需要幫忙」的角度來發展學門，進而達成公平參與休閒或是運動的目的。近期學者認為此類公平的論述乃是基於憐憫的心態，甚至讓休間及運動成為執行此種「假性公平」的手段。因此「inclusiverecreation」的概念伴隨著後現代社會對弱勢權力與權利的討論一併興起，呈現了一種社會觀看弱勢團體的新視角，並且重新站在人權的議題上討論休間與運動參與。為了更深入的瞭解身心障礙者在社會上參與休閒或運動的公平性，本篇將討論「inclusiverecreation」的推展價值，並從「融合」的觀點探討身心障礙者參與休間的根本問題，並試圖對造成問題的價值認知提出修正與呼籲。

1. 陳渝苓、徐譽桓(2008)。「當身體成為權力的戰場」從身體的學術觀點探討運動場域中父權與賦權概念之具象化與衝突。大專體育學刊，10(3)，1-12。
   連結：
2. 廖柏森（2006，11月21日）。「政治正確」不正確。台灣翻譯學學會。資料引自http://tati.org.tw/
3. International Paralympic Committee. (n. d.). Paralympics games. Retrieved November 20, 2008, from http://www.paralympic.org/release/Main_Sections_Menu/Paralympic_Games/
4. Allen, A.(1999).The power of feminist theory: Domination, resistance, solidarity.Boulder, CO:Westview Press.
5. Anderson, L.,Brown, C.,Soli, P.(1996).Inclusion: Strategies for including people with disabilities in parks and recreation opportunities.Bismarck, ND:Rural Recreation Integration Project.
6. Austin, D.,Crawford, M.(2000).Therapeutic recreation: An introduction.Boston, MA:Allyn & Bacon.
7. Choi, P. Y. L.(2000).Femininity and the physically active woman.London:Routledge.
8. Coakley, J.(2007).Sports in society: Issues and controversies.Boston, MA:McGraw-Hill Press.
9. Dattilo, J.(2002).Inclusive of leisure service: Responding to the rights of people with disabilities.State College, PA:Venture.
10. Devine, M. A.,Broach, E.(1998).Inclusion in the aquatic environment.Parks and Recreation,33(2),60-67.
11. Devine, M. A.,Dattilo, J.(2000).Social acceptance and leisure lifestyles of people with disabilities.Therapeutic Recreation Journal,34,306-322.
12. Driver, B. L.,Bruns, D.(1999).Concepts and uses of the benefits approach to leisure.Leisure studies: Prospects for the twenty-first century,State College, PA:
13. Henderson, K. A.,Binsworth, B. E.(2001).Researching leisure and physical activity with women of color: Issues and emerging questions.Leisure Sciences,23,21-34.
14. Johnson, A. G.、成令方、林鶴玲、吳嘉苓(2003)。見樹又見林：社會學作為一種生活、實踐與承諾。台北市:群學出版社。
15. Kelly, J. R.,Freysinger, V.(1999).Leisure in 21st century: Current issues.Boston, MA:Allyn and Bacon.
16. Kozub, F. M.,Porretta, D.(1996).Including athletes with disabilities: Interscholastic athletic benefits for all.Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance,67(3),19-24.
17. Lewkowicz, B.(2006).Opening the door to nature for people with disabilities.Bay Nature,6(4),21-23+34.
18. Livengood, J.,Stodolska, M.(2004).The effects of discrimination and constraints negotiation on leisure behavior.Journal of Leisure Research,36(2),183-218.
19. Moulder, E.(2003).Focus on inclusion: Parks and recreation departments welcome all.Public Management,85(7),18-23.
20. National Therapeutic Recreation Society(1997).National therapeutic recreation society position statement on inclusion.Ashburn, VA:National Therapeutic Recreation Society.
21. Rimmer, J.,Riley, B.,Wang, E.,Rauwouth, A.,Jurkowski, J.(2004).Physical activity participation among persons with disabilities: Barriers and facilitators.American Journal of Preventive Medicine,26(5),419-425.
22. Rynders, J. E.,Schleien, S. J.(1991).Together successfully.Arlington,TX:Association for Retarded Citizens of the United States.
23. Schleien, S.,Stone, J.,Rider, C.(2005).A paradigm shift in therapeutic recreation: From cure to care.Constraints to leisure,State College, PA:
24. Shaw, S. M.(2001).Conceptualizing resistance: Women's leisure as political practice.Journal of Leisure Research,33(2),186-201.
25. Sherrill, C.(2003).Adapted physical activity, recreation and sport: Crossdisciplinary and lifespan.Boston, MA:McGraw-Hill.
26. Smith, R. W.,Austin, D. R.,Kennedy, D. W.(2001).Inclusive and special recreation: Opportunities for persons with disabilities.New York:McGraw-Hill Press.
27. Stein, J. U.(1985).Mainstreaming in recreational settings: It can be done.Journal of Physical Education. Recreation and Dance,56(5),3+52.
28. Stewart, W. P.,Parry, D. C.,Glover, T. D.(2008).Writing leisure: Values and ideologies of research.Journal of Leisure Research,40(3),360-384.
29. Sylvester, C.,Voelkl, J.,Ellis, G.(2001).Therapeutic recreation programming: Theory and practice.State College, PA:Venture Publishing, Inc..
30. US Department of Health and Human Services(2000).Health People 2010.Washington, DC:US Government Printing Office.
31. World Health Organization(2004).A strategy for rehabilitation, equalization of opportunities, poverty reduction and social inclusion of people with disabilities.Geneva, Switzerland:World Health Organization.
32. 吳昇光(2003)。殘障奧運、遠男運動會與台灣身心障礙運動會之游泳選手肢體障礙類別比較分析。中臺灣醫學科學雜誌，8，49-55。
33. 張鐸嚴(1999)。休閒生活與青少年情緒教育。社會科學學報，7，1-32。
34. 畢恆達(2001)。空間就是權力。台北:心靈工坊出版社。
35. 許雅雯、蔡佳良(2007)。運動與休閒之無障礙環境探討。大專體育，91，82-87。

1. 陳渝苓(2016)。從單一到多元：休閒概念中的族群限定與新社會秩序。中華體育季刊，30(4)，251-260。
2. 陳渝苓、張淑涵(2011)。臺灣新移民的休閒參與－社會排斥理論的觀點。大專體育，114，13-19。