社會排除風險與不穩定就業風險之間：台灣長期失業者的尋職困境

Between Social Exclusion Risk and Precarious Employment Risk: Job Search Dilemma of Long-Term Unemployed in Taiwan

10.30388/BLR.200909_(25).0002

李健鴻(Chien-Hung Lee)

長期失業 ； 社會排除風險 ； 不穩定就業風險 ； Long-term Unemployment ； Social Exclusion Risk ； Precarious Employment Risk

政大勞動學報

25期（2009 / 09 / 01）

57 - 114

繁體中文

本文分析台灣的長期失業者在面臨社會排除風險威脅的情形下，如何決定尋職策略與因應生存困境。研究發現，當長期失業者在失業後面臨「雇主拒絕」、「社會關係疏離」、「家庭支持降低」等社會排除風險的威脅，生計出現困境時，會藉由從事不穩定工作以暫時舒解生活經濟來源中斷的生存問題，但是從事不穩定工作，卻同時必須面臨「工作時間極不穩定」、「低度就業保障」、「薪資發放隨便化」等多項高度的工作風險。如何在「社會排除風險」與「不穩定就業風險」之間進行選擇，成為長期失業者的難題，相對有利且可行的「風險平衡」策略，就成為尋職時考量的新策略，就是在各項工作風險之間尋求平衡，重新設定尋職目標，進行各項工作風險比較，尋求「風險程度相對可承受的工作機會」，此時工作的「穩定性」才是尋職時的首要考量因素，薪資、職位與工作條件都不是主要考量。

This article analyzes how long-term unemployed form their job search strategy dealing with the social exclusion risk in Taiwan. There are three main finds. Firstly, precarious employment has been used as a means of solving economic break down, resulting from social exclusions, such as refusing employment, alienating social relation, and decreasing family support. Secondly, the interviewed precarious employed had to face higher precarious employment risks, including unstable working time, poor employment protection, and arbitrarily paid. Thirdly, by comparing job risks, risk balanced strategy is used as a means of resolving the dilemma between social exclusion risks and precarious employment risks in order to find out job opportunity, based on tolerable risk relativity of employment expected by long-term unemployed. In this case, job stability is the first consideration rather than wage, position or work conditions.

1. 李健鴻(2008)。差序治理體制與治理矛盾：台灣就業體制變革分析。台灣社會福利學刊，6(2)，109-147。
   連結：
2. Atkison, H.(ed.)(1998).Exclusion, Poverty and and Opportunity.Centre for Analysis of Social exclusion. London School of Economics.
3. Auer, P.,Cazes, S.(2003).Employment stability in an age of flexibility: Evidence from Industrialized Countries.Geneva:International Institute for Labour Studies.
4. Beck, Ulrich原著、汪浩譯(2004)。風險社會－通往另一個現代的路上。台北:巨流。
5. Paper presented to the EU Worhshop on Unemployment, Work and Welfare Directorate General Research of the European Commission
6. Burchell, B.,Gallie, D.(eds.),Marsh C.(eds.),Vogler, C. (eds.)(1994).Social Change and the Experience of Unemployment.Oxford:Blackwell.
7. Cottle, Thomas J.(2001).Hardest Times: The Trauma of Long Term Unemployment.London:Westport, Connecticut.
8. Council of Europe(1992).The role of employment and training services in fighting long-term unemployment.Strasbourg:Council of Europe Press.
9. Working paper
10. Esping-Andersen, Gosta(1999).Social Foundations of Postindustrial Economies.London:Oxford University Press.
11. Gallie, D.(eds),Gershuny, J.,Vogler, C.(eds),Marsh C.(eds)(1994).Social Change and the Experience of Unemployment.Oxford:Blackwell.
12. Goldthorpe, J.(2000).On Sociology: Numbers, Narratives, and the Integration of Research and Theory.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
13. Granovetter, M.(1973).The strength of weak ties.American Journal of Sociology,78,1360-1380.
14. Key Indicators of Labour Market, 5th Edition KILM10
15. Paper present at Social Exclusion
16. Paper to The 3. EXSPRO meeting workshop: The Concept and Evaulation of Social Exclusion
17. Kronauer, M.,H.-J. Andreb (ed.)(1998).Empirical poverty research in a comparative perspective.Aldershot, England:Ashgate.
18. Precarious Employment in Europe: A Comparative Study of Labour Market related Risks in Flexible Economy
19. Leonard, M.(1998).The long-term unemployed, informal economic activity and the underclass in Belfast: rejecting or reinstating the work ethic.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,22(1),42-59.
20. OECD(2002).Employment Outlook: The ins and outs of long-term unemployment.Paris:OECD press.
21. Pollmann-Schult, M.,Buchel, F.(2005).Unemployment Benefits, Unemployment Duration and Subsequent Job Quality: Evidence from West Germany.Acta Aologica,48(1),21-39.
22. Schmid, Günther(2006).Social risk management through transitional labor Markets.Socio-Economic Review,4(1),1-33.
23. Silver, H.(1994).Social Exclusion and Social Solidarity: Three Paradiams. Prepared for the institutions and Economic Development Programme of ILO International Institute for Laour studies.International Labour Review,33,531-578.
24. Saltsa-Joint Programme, Report No l
25. Walsh, Kenneth(1987).Long-Term Unemployment: An International Perspective.The Macmillan Press Ltd.
26. Wilson, W.J.(1987).The truly Disadantaged: The inner City, the Underclass, and Public policy.Chicago:The Chicago University Press.
27. 人力資源統計年報
28. 朱柔若、童小珠(2006)。高屏地區勞工失業與再就業經驗探討。社區發展季刊，115，275-289。
29. 吳岱憶(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。中正大學社會福利研究所。
30. 劉文浩(2003)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中正大學勞工關係研究所。

1. 陳柏睿(2018)。父母親負面職場經驗對台灣大學在學學生工會態度之影響：以工作信念為中介變項。臺灣大學國家發展研究所學位論文。2018。1-63。