题名

特教人員對資優、ADHD與資優ADHD誤判的可能性:從直覺決策角度初探

并列篇名

Exploring the Possibilities of Misdiagnosis of Giftedness, ADHD, and ADHD with Giftedness: An Intuitive Decision-Making Perspective

DOI

10.6218/GEQ.201206_(123).0002

作者

龔韋勳(Wei-Hsun Kung);王文伶(Wen-Ling Wang)

关键词

ADHD ; 資優ADHD ; 資賦優異 ; 直覺決策 ; 誤判 ; ADHD ; ADHD with giftedness ; intuitive decision-making ; misdiagnosis

期刊名称

資優教育季刊

卷期/出版年月

123期(2012 / 06 / 01)

页次

11 - 19

内容语文

繁體中文

中文摘要

本研究主要目的是延伸國外研究並探討國內特教人員對於資優、ADHD與資優ADHD誤判的可能性。本研究職前對象為臺灣北部某縣市特殊教育學系與心理所心理臨床組學生共71人,在職組為同一縣市特教鑑輔專業人員以及特教教師共23人。研究工具為一段虛擬個案的描述,讓研究對象依照描述特質,進行直覺判斷。研究結果顯示本研究對象並不清楚資優、ADHD與資優ADHD具有類似特質。而研究對象傾向回答ADHD,凸顯ADHD可能會有被過度轉介與鑑定的情形,亦可能導向資優、ADHD與資優ADHD誤判可能性的提高。因此亟需正視特教專業人員與教師對於資優、ADHD與資優ADHD特質以及鑑定的專業訓練。

英文摘要

The main purpose of this study was to explore the potential for the misdiagnosis of giftedness, ADHD, and ADHD with giftedness. Participants included 71 preservice special education teachers and counselors, and 23 inservice special education teachers and diagnosticians. They each read the same vignettes describing a hypothetical case of a boy with overlapping behaviors of giftedness, ADHD and gifted ADHD. The researcher then asked participants for a diagnosis, and finally examined their intuitive decision-making and diagnostic evaluations. The results appeared that participants were unaware of the similar characteristics of students who are gifted, ADHD, and ADHD with giftedness, as well as more likely to provide the diagnosis of ADHD. Therefore, ADHD would likely be over diagnosed and may lead to an increase of the possibilities of misdiagnosis.

主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 吳怡慧、曾薷瑩(2009)。ADHD資優生的特質與區辨。國小特殊教育,47,64-71。
    連結:
  2. 林家五、熊欣華、黃國隆(2006)。認同對決策嵌陷行為的影響:個體與群體層次的分析。臺灣管理學刊,6,157-180。
    連結:
  3. 黃惠玲(2008)。注意力缺陷過動疾患研究回顧。應用心理研究,40,197-219。
    連結:
  4. 黃惠玲(2008)。注意力缺陷過動疾患研究回顧。應用心理研究,40,197-219。
    連結:
  5. 身心障礙及資賦優異學生鑑定標準(2006):中華民國九十五年九月二十九日教育部臺參字第○九五○一四一五六一C號令修正公布。
  6. Buket, Y. G.,Fusun, A.(2006).Comparing overexcitabilities of gifted and non-gifted 10th grades students in Turkey.High Ability Studies,17,43-56.
  7. Concannon, P. E.,Tang, Y. P.(2005).Management of attention deficit hyperactive disorder: A parental perspective.Journal of Pediatrics and Child health,41,625-630.
  8. Edmunds, A.,Martsch, L. S.(2008).ADHD assessment and diagnosis in Canada: An inconsistent but fixable process.Exceptionality Education International,18,3-23.
  9. Goerss, J.,Amend, E. R.,Webb, J. T.,Webb, N.,Beljan, P.(2006).Comments on Mika's critique of Hartnett, Nelson, and Rinn's article, "Gifted or ADHD? The possibilities of misdiagnosis.".Roeper Review,28,249-251.
  10. Graczyk, P. A.,Atkins, M. S.,Jackson, M. M.,Letendre, J. A.,Kimcohen, J.,Baumann, B. L.,McCay, J.(2005).Urban educators' perceptions of interventions for students with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: A preliminary investigation.Behavioral Disorders,30,95-104.
  11. Gupta, R.,Kar, B. R.(2010).Specific cognitive deficits in ADHD: A diagnostic concern in differential diagnosis.Journal of Child and Family Studies,19,778-786.
  12. Handler, M. W.,DuPaul, G. J.(2005).Assessment of ADHD: Differences across psychology specialty areas.Journal of Attention Disorders,9,402-412.
  13. Hartnett, D. N.,Nelson, J. M.,Rinn, A. N.(2004).Gifted or ADHD? The possibilities of misdiagnosis.Roeper Review,26,73-76.
  14. Jean, S. P.(2009).Myth 17: Gifted and talented individuals do not have unique social and emotional needs.Gifted Child Quarterly,53,280-282.
  15. Kevin, M. A.,Stephen, V. F.,Kimberly, S.,Andrea, N.,Felice, A. K.,Alysa, D.,Ronna, F.,Larry, S.,Joseph, B.(2007).Is attention deficit hyperactivity disorder a valid diagnosis in the presence of high IQ? Results from the MGH longitudinal family studies of ADHD.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,48,687-694.
  16. Kimberly, A. O.(2009).,未出版
  17. Kitano, M. K.(1990).Intellectual abilities and psychological intensities in young children: Implications for the gifted.Roeper Review,13,5-11.
  18. Lori, J. F.(2001).Challenges of identifying and serving gifted children with ADHD.Teaching Exceptional Children,33,62-69.
  19. Mika, E.(2006).Giftedness, ADHD, and overexcitabilities: The possibilities of misinformation.Roeper Review,28,237-243.
  20. Nelson, J. M.,Rinn, A. N.,Hartnett, D. N.(2006).The possibility of misdiagnosis of giftedness and ADHD still exists: A response to Mika.Roeper Review,28,243-248.
  21. Piechowski, M. M.,Colangelo, N.(1984).Developmental potential of the gifted.Gifted Child Quarterly,28,80-88.
  22. Rinn, A. N.,Nelson, J. M.(2009).Preservice teachers' perceptions of behaviors characteristic of ADHD and gifted.Roeper Review,31,18-26.
  23. Steven, J. S.,Charles, M. J.,Bernadette, P.(1989).Social cognition.Annual Reviews,40,281-326.
  24. Webb, J. T.(2000).Mis-diagnosis and dual diagnosis of gifted children: Gifted and LD, ADHD, OCD, Oppositional defiant disorder.American Psychology Association Annual Convention,Washington, D.C.:
  25. Webb, J. T.,Amend, E. R.,Webb, N. E.,Goerss, J.,Beljan, P.,Olenchak, F. R.(2005).Misdiagnosis and dual diagnosis of gifted children and adult: ADHD, Bipolar, OCD, Asperger's, depression and other disorders.Scottsdale, AZ:Great Potential.
  26. Webb, J. T.,Latimer, D.(1993).,Reston, VA:The Council for Exceptional Children.
  27. Wu, Y. Y.,Huang, Y. S.,Chen, Y. Y.,Chen, C. K.,Chang, T. C.,Chao, C. C.(2007).Psychometric study of the test of variables of attention: preliminary findings on Taiwanese children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences,61(3),221-228.
  28. 孔繁鐘、孔繁錦(1998)。DSM-IV精神疾病診斷準則手冊。臺北:合記。
  29. 吳昆壽(1999)。資優殘障學生教育現況與問題調查研究。特殊教育與復健學報,7,1-32。
  30. 李佩庭(2008)。臺北,國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系。
  31. 林建平(2006)。注意力缺陷過動症兒童的診斷與處遇。特殊教育季刊,101,1-8。
  32. 侯伯勳、林志堅、遲景上、陳展航(2003)。臺中地區某國小低年級學童注意力不足過動症候群盛行率初探。慈濟醫學,15,163-167。
  33. 孫本初、黃新福(1995)。決策模式的權變運用與整合。中國行政,57,47-65。
  34. 張芳榮(2010)。臺北,國立臺北教育大學特殊教育學系。
  35. 張蓓莉編(1999)。身心障礙及資賦優異學生鑑定原則鑑定基準說明手冊。臺北:國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系。
  36. 陳素秋、臧汝芬、黃武達、楊斐適、黃榮貴、莊奇容(2009)。注意力缺陷過動症及相關磁振頻譜檢查。臺灣應用輻射與同位素雜誌,5,613-622。
  37. 黃文慧(2002)。臺北,國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系。
  38. 謝佳諺(2009)。注意力缺陷過動症資優生干擾行為輔導實務。資優教育季刊,112,20-28。
  39. 謝梅芳、胡濤、李暉(2006)。直覺決策及其可信度評估方法研究。武漢理工大學學報,28,104-106。
  40. 謝寶梅(1991)。影響教師評量學生的主觀因素。國教輔導,31,22-25。
  41. 蘇筠涵(2010)。淺談ADHD資優生的鑑定困境。特殊教育與輔導科技季刊,5,8-13。