不同教育階段之資優學生參與服務學習的動機與成效探究

The Research of Motivations and Effects of Service-Learning for Gifted Students at Different Educational Stages

10.6218/GEQ.201706_(143).13-22

陳勇祥(Yung-Hsiang Chen)；賴翠媛(Tsuei-Yuan Lai)

資優 ； 服務學習 ； 動機 ； 成效 ； gifted ； service-learning ； motivation ； effect

資優教育季刊

143期（2017 / 06 / 01）

13 - 22

繁體中文

本研究旨在探討不同教育階段資優學生參與服務學習的動機與成效，採立意取樣方式，從南部地區之高中、國中、國小，選取曾參與服務學習達20小時以上者，共12位，進行訪談。研究發現：各階段資優學生之服務動機為自主意願，且期望能透過服務學習，提升自我概念與培養勇氣，其差異處為國、高中學生較國小學生關注偏鄉、社會服務與重視社會連結。服務成效方面，國小、國中、高中學生多數認為服務學習能培養同理接納態度與促進人際關係和諧，差異處在於國中、高中學生較國小學生能試探生涯目標，培養公民責任，提升問題解決技能與溝通能力。

The purpose of this research is to explore the motivation and performance of service learning for gifted students at different educational stages. The findings show that all stages of gifted students volunteer to participate in service-learning, but high school students raise more concerns about rural areas, social services and attention to social links than primary school students. All stages of gifted students agree that the experiences of service learning help them develop empathy for others and promote interpersonal harmony, but as compared with the other two groups, the engagement of high school students in service learning also help them explore life goals, learn the importance of civic participation, and improve problem solving skills and communication skills.

1. 陳勇祥(2014)。資優學生服務學習課程之設計與實施。資優教育季刊，131，21-28。
   連結：
2. 志願服務法(2001)。中華民國九十年一月二十日總統華總一義字第九○○○○一一八四○號令發布。
3. Amtmann, J.(2004).Perceived effects of a correctional health education service-learning program.Journal of Correctional Education,55(4),335-348.
4. Baldwin, S. C.,Buchanon, A. M.,Rudisill, M. E.(2007).What teacher candidates learned about diversity, social justice, and themselves from service-learning experiences.Journal of Teacher Education,58(4),315-327.
5. Bamber, P. M.,Pike, M. A.(2013).Towards an ethical ecology of international service learning.Journal of Curriculum Studies,45(4),1-25.
6. Bloom, M.(2008).From the classroom to the community: Building cultural awareness in first semester Spanish.Language, Culture, and Curriculum,21(2),103-119.
7. Crabtree, R. D.(2013).The intended and unintended consequences of international service-learning.Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement,17(2),43-65.
8. Crabtree, R. D.(2008).Theoretical foundations for international service-learning.Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning,15(1),18-36.
9. Davis, G.,Rimm, S. B.(2004).Education of the gifted and talented.Boston:Pearson Education.
10. Denson, N.(2009).Do curricular and co-curricular diversity activities influence racial bias? A metaanalysis.Review of Educational Research,79(2),805-838.
11. Dorfmann, L. T.,Murty, S. A.,Ingram, J. G.(2004).Incorporating intergenerational service-learning into an introductory gerontology course.Journal of Gerontological Social Work,39(1),219-240.
12. Durlak, J. A.,Weissberg, R. P.,Dymnicki, A. B.,Taylor, R. D.,Schellinger, K. B.(2011).The impact of enhancing students' social and emotional learning: A meta-analysis of school-based universal interventions.Child Development,82,405-432.
13. Echenique, F.,Fryer, R. G.(2007).A measure of segregation based on social interactions.Quarterly Journal of Economics,122(2),441-485.
14. Einfeld, A.,Collins, D.(2008).The relationships between service learning, social justice, multicultural competence, and civic engagement.Journal of College Student Development,49(2),95-109.
15. Elwell, M. D.,Bean, M. S.(2001).Editor's choice: The efficacy of service-learning for community college ESL students.Community College Review,28(4),47-61.
16. Feldman, A. M.,Moss, T.,Chin, D.,Marie, M.,Rai, C.,Graham, R.(2006).The impact of partnership-centered, community-based learning on first-year students' academic research papers.Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning,13(1),16-29.
17. Flournoy, C.(2007).Investigative reporting and service learning.Journalism and Mass Communication Educator,62(1),47-61.
18. Grantham, T. C.(2012).Eminence focused gifted education: concerns about forward movement void of an equity vision.Gifted Child Quarterly,56(4),215-220.
19. Hale, A.(2008).Service learning with Latino communities: Effects on preservice teachers.Journal of Hispanic Higher Education,7(1),54-69.
20. Handa, V.,Tippins, D.,Thomson, N.,Bilbao, P.,Morano, L.,Hallar, B.,Miller, K.(2008).A dialogue of life: Integrating service-learning in a community-immersion model of preservice science-teacher preparation.Journal of College Science Teaching,37(6),14-20.
21. Hatcher, J. A.,Bringle, R. G.,Muthiah, R.(2004).Designing effective reflection: What matters to service learning?.Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning,11(1),38-46.
22. Holbrook, A. L.,Krosnick, J. A.(2010).Social desirability bias in voter turnout reports: Tests using the item count technique.Public Opinion Quarterly,4,37-67.
23. Hughes, C.,Boyd, E.,Dykstra, S. J.(2010).Evaluation of a university-based mentoring program: Mentors' perspectives on a servicelearning experience.Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnerships in Learning,18(4),361-382.
24. Jakubowski, L. M.(2003).Beyond book learning: Cultivating the pedagogy of experience though field trips.Journal of Experiential Education,26(1),24-33.
25. Lee, S. Y.,Olszewski-Kubilius, P.,Donahue, R.,Weimbolt, K.(2008).The civic leadership institute: A service-learning program for academically gifted youth.Journal of Advanced Academics,19(2),272-308.
26. Patton, M. Q.(2002).Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
27. Plitt, L.,Daughtery, L.(2011).Introducing assetbased models of social justice into servicelearning: A social work approach.Journal of Community Practice,19(1),80-99.
28. Prentice, M.(2007).Service learning and civic engagement.Academic Questions,20(2),135-145.
29. Simmons, C. H.,Zumpf, C.(2011).The gifted child: Perceived competence, prosocial moral reasoning and charitable donations.The Journal of Genetic Psychology,147(1),97-105.
30. Stewart, T.,Bai, H.(2010).Community service self-Efficacy and summer service-learning: comparative analyses among academically talented youth.Gifted Education International,27(2),149-160.
31. Teranishi, C. S.(2007).Impact on experiential learning on Latino college students' identity, relationships, and connectedness to the community.Journal of Hispanic Higher Education,6(1),52-72.
32. Terry, A. W.(2003).Effects of service learning on young, gifted adolescents and their community.Gifted Child Quarterly,47(4),295-308.
33. Terry, A. W.(2008).Student voices, global echoes: Service-learning and the gifted.Roeper Review,30,45-51.
34. Tryon, E.,Stoecker, R.(2008).The unheard voices: Community organizations and service-learning.Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement,12(3),47-59.
35. Umbach, P. D.,Wawrzynski, M. R.(2005).Faculty do matter: The role of college faculty in student learning and engagement.Research in Higher Education,46(2),153-184.
36. Webster, N. S.,Worrell, F. C.(2008).Academically talented students' attitudes toward service in the Community.Gifted Child Quarterly,52(2),170-179.
37. Weerts, D. J.,Sandmann, L. R.(2008).Building a two-way street: Challenges and opportunities for community engagement at research universities.The Review of Higher Education,32(1),73-106.
38. 吳珮榕(2016)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系。
39. 汪王道(2014)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。高雄，國立高雄師範大學教育系。
40. 游盈楨(2011)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺北教育大學國民教育學系。
41. 楊翠凌(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系。
42. 顏巧怡(2009)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系。

1. 陳宥妤(2023)。走出教室的學習：資優教育的社會參與與實踐。資優教育論壇，21(2)，35-46。
2. 黃楷茹,王玟淇(2023)。國小資優學生在獨立研究課程中「社會參與」素養之展現。資優教育論壇，21(2)，3-33。
3. 潘裕豐,洪欣妤(2022)。國小資優生道德認知對新冠疫情病患態度之現況與其關聯：以對新冠疫情之情緒為調節變項。教育科學研究期刊，67(4)，143-175。