障礙資優流動狀態中的模糊性：論雙重殊異之鑑定困境

The Ambiguous Flow between Disability and Gifted: Difficulties in Identifying Twice-Exceptional Students

10.6218/GEQ.201712_(145).11-20

梁斐瑜(Feei-Yu Liang)

雙重殊異 ； 鑑定 ； twice-exceptional ； identification

資優教育季刊

145期（2017 / 12 / 01）

11 - 19

繁體中文

長久以來身心障礙與資賦優異之鑑定皆採平行方式。然介於障礙與資優雙重殊異學生卻因其定義之模糊性而處於卓越邊緣，因此如何建立一套鑑定程序極為重要。本文旨在回顧美國與臺灣雙重殊異之歷史背景與現況發展，並探討雙重殊異之定義及其鑑定困境，最後提出一套鑑定模式以供參考。

Identification of students with disabilities and gifted students has long been studied via differing approaches. ＂Twice exceptional＂ students are at the edge of excellence due to ambiguities associated with disabilities and gifted. Therefore, it is extremely important to establish a set of identification procedures. This article is intended to review the historical background and development of twice exceptional students of Unites States of America and Taiwan. It also aims to explore the definition of twice exceptional and the difficulties in identification and classification. Finally, drawing on evidence, a set of identification models will be proposed.

1. 吳昆壽(2004)。資優障礙學生學校生態系統研究。特殊教育與復健學報，12，81-97。
   連結：
2. 梁斐瑜(2016)。一位星星王子的音樂特殊才能發展歷程：同儕師徒學習模式。特殊教育研究學刊，41(2)，89-116。
   連結：
3. 鄒小蘭、盧台華(2011)。身心障礙資優生優弱勢分析結果之探究。特殊教育學報，33，57-92。
   連結：
4. 特殊教育法（2012）。中華民國103年6月18日總統(103)華總（一）義字第10300093311 號令修正公布。
5. Assouline, S. G.,Nicpon, M. F.,Huber, D. H.(2006).The impact of vulnerabilities and strengths on the academic experiences of twice-exceptional students: A message to School Counselors.Professional School Counseling,10(1),14-24.
6. Brody, L. E.,Mills, C. J.(1997).Gifted children with learning disabilities: A review of the issues.Journal of Learning Disabilities,30,282-296.
7. Coleman, M. R.,Gallagher, J. J.(1995).State identification policies: Gifted students from special populations.Roeper Review,17,268-275.
8. Coleman, M. R.,Harradine, C.,Williams King, E.(2005).Meeting the needs of students who are twice Exceptional.Teaching Exeptional Children,38(1),5-6.
9. Heaton, P.,Hermelin, B.,Pring, L.(1998).Autism and pitch processing: A precursor for savant musical ability?.Music Perception,15(3),291-305.
10. Jeweler, S.,Barnes-Robinson, L.,Shevitz, B. R.,Weinfeld, R.(2008).Bordering on excellence: A teaching tool for twice exceptional students.Gifted Child Today,31(2),40-46.
11. Karnes, F.(2004).Gifted students with disabilities: Are we finding them?.Gifted Child Today,27(4),16-21.
12. Lovett, B. J.,Lewandowski, L. J.(2006).Gifted students with learning disabilities: Who are they?.Journal of Learning Disabilities,39,515-527.
13. Morrison, W. F.,Rizza, M. G.(2007).Creating a toolkit for identifying twice-exceptional students.Journal for the Education of the Gifted,31(1),57-76.
14. Mottron, L.,Peretz, I.,Menard, E.(2000).Local and global processing of music in high-functioning persons with autism: Beyond central coherence?.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,41(8),1057-1065.
15. Prior, S.(2013).Transition and students with twice exceptionality.Australasian Journal of Special Education,37(1),19-27.
16. Reis, S. M.,McCoach, D. B.(2000).The underachievement of gifted students: What do we know and where do we go?.Gifted Child Quarterly,44(3),152-170.
17. Renzulli, J. S.(1978).What makes giftedness? Reexamining a definition.Phi Delta Kappan,60,180-184.
18. 吳昆壽(2016)。資賦優異教育概論。臺北:心理。
19. 張玉佩(2008)。身心障礙資優生鑑定的相關議題。資優教育季刊，106，24-30。
20. 梁斐瑜(2017)。自閉症兒童的音樂教策略。雲嘉特教期刊，25，30-38。
21. 鄒小蘭譯、Beverly A.Trail, Ed. D.(2013)。特殊族群資優教育：身心障礙資優學生與低成就族群。臺北:華騰。
22. 蔡典謨(1999)。低成就資優生的家庭影響。資優教育季刊，72，1-9。
23. 蔡桂芳、侯雅齡(2006)。協助資優障礙者發揮特殊才能。屏師特殊教育，13，38-46。

1. 謝依珊,何宜真(2022)。一位具資優潛能的視覺障礙學生如何發展天賦～融合教育與身心障礙資優學生鑑定的觀察與討論。特教論壇，33，27-45。