题名

工作場所戀情與性騷擾關連性之理論探討

并列篇名

Investigating the Association between Workplace Romances and Sexual Harassment

DOI

10.30409/JPA.200806_(27).0005

作者

黃煥榮(Huan-Jung Huang)

关键词

工作場所戀情 ； 辦公室戀情 ； 戀情關係 ； 性騷擾 ； 社交性行為 ； workplace romance ； office romance ； romantic relationships ； sexual harassment ； social-sexual behavior

期刊名称

公共行政學報

卷期/出版年月

27期（2008 / 06 / 01）

页次

161 - 186

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

近年來隨著女性大量進入就業市場，女性在組織的地位日益受到肯定，男女在組織中的互動關係也受到關注，其中工作場所戀情和性騷擾則是最常見和被關注的兩種現象。然而，過去學者的研究通常將這兩者視為不相干的獨立現象，並分開來探討。事實上，在工作場所中一段分手的戀情，有很高的可能性會演變成性騷擾的爭議。本文主要目的是要連結工作場所戀情和性騷擾的關係。從相關文獻的推演，本文認為在分手後的不同工作場所戀情類型與不同類型性騷擾行為之間的關聯性，會隨著1.伴侶的社會地位；2.戀情關係分手的提議；3.男性伴侶的性騷擾傾向；以及4.組織對性騷擾行為容忍度等四個主要調節變數而有所差異。最後，本文根據這些變數之間的關係，建立分析架構和可檢證的研究命題，做為後續經驗研究的基礎。
英文摘要

Workplace romances and sexual harassment are pervasive and widespread problems in today's organizations. However, despite the fact that these two phenomena share a social-sexual component, they have primarily been treated as unrelated organizational issues. In fact, the processes through which dissolved workplace romances are most likely to foster sexually harassing behavior between former romantic partners. This paper attempts to advance a link between workplace romances and sexual harassment. The author proposes that the following factors play a critical role in influencing the likelihood that terminated workplace romances lead to sexually harassing behavior: (a) partners' social power, (b) initiation of romantic relationship dissolution, (c) male partner's sexual harassment proclivity, (d) organization's tolerance for sexual harassment. Based on the role of these factors, the author provides a framework and propositions that serve to guide future research addressing the link between dissolved workplace romances and sexually harassing behavior.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 羅燦煐(2001)。他的性騷擾？她的性騷擾？性騷擾的性別化建構。台灣社會研究季刊，46，193-249。
    連結：
  2. Aguinis, H.,S. K. R. Adams(1998).Social-Role versus Structural Models of Gender and Influence Use in Organizations: A Strong Inference Approach.Group & Organization Management,23,414-446.
  3. Anderson, C. I.,P. L. Hunsaker(1985).Why There`s Romancing at the Office and Why It`s Everyone`s Problem.Personnel,62(2),57-63.
  4. Anderson, C. J.,C. Fisher(1991).Male-Female Relationships in the Workplace: Perceived Motivations in Office Romance.Sex Roles,25(3-4),163-180.
  5. Brown, T. J.,E. R. Allgeier(1996).The Impact of Participant Characteristics, Perceived Motives, and Job Behaviors on Co-Workers Evaluations of Workplace Romances.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,26(7),577-595.
  6. Clawson, J. G.,K. E. Kram(1984).Managing Cross-Gender Mentoring.Business Horizons,27(3),22-32.
  7. Cleveland, J. N.,M. E. Kerst(1993).Sexual Harassment and Perceptions of Power: An Under-Articulated Relationship.Journal of Vocational Behavior,42(1),49-67.
  8. Dillard, J. P.(1987).Close Relationships at Work: Perceptions of the Motives and Performance of Relational Participants.Journal of Social and Personal Relationships,4,179-193.
  9. Dillard, J. P.,J. L. Hale,C. Segrin(1994).Close Relationships in Task Environments: Perceptions of Relational Types, Illicitness, and Power.Management Communication Quarterly,7,227-255.
  10. Dillard, J. P.,S. M. Broetzmann(1989).Romantic Relationships at Work: Perceived Changes in Job-Related Behaviors as a Function of Participant`s Motive. Partner`s Motive, and Gender.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,19,93-110.
  11. Driscoll, J. B.(1981).Sexual Attraction and Harassment: Management`s New Problems.Personnel Journal,60,33-37.
  12. Eidelhoch, A. M.,B. M. Russell(1998).Consensual Relationship Agreements: One More Weapon in the Arsenal for Fighting Sexual Harassment in the Workplace.Preventive Law Reporter,17(3),21-23.
  13. Fitzgerald, L. F.,F. Drasgow,C. L. Hulin,M. J. Gelfand,V. J. Magley(1997).Antecedents and Consequences of Sexual Harassment in Organizations: A Test of an Integrated Model.Journal of Applied Psychology,82,578-589.
  14. Fitzgerald, L. F.,M. J. Gelfand,F. Drasgow(1995).Measuring Sexual Harassment: Theoretical and Psychometric Advances.Basic and Applied Social Psychology,17,425-445.
  15. Fitzgerald, L. F.,S. L. Shullman,N. Bailey,M. Richards,J. Swecker,Y. Gold,M. Ormerod,J. Weitzman(1988).The Incidence and Dimensions of Sexual Harassment in Academia and the Workplace.Journal of Vocational Behavior,32,152-175.
  16. Foley, S.,G. N. Powell(1999).Not All is Fair in Love and Work: Coworkers` Preferences for and Response to Managerial Interventions Regarding Workplace Romances.Journal of Organizational Behavior,20(7),1043-1056.
  17. Gutek, B. A.(1985).Sex and the Workplace: The Impact of Sexual Behavior and Harassment on Women, Men, and Organizations.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
  18. Gutek, B. A.,A. G. Cohen,A. M. Konrad(1990).Predicting Social-Sexual Behavior at Work: A Contact Hypothesis.Academy of Management Journal,33(3),560-577.
  19. Henry, D.(1995).Wanna Date? The Office May Not Be the Place.HR Focus,72(4),14.
  20. Homans, G. C.(1958).Social Behavior as Exchange.American Journal of Sociology,63,597-606.
  21. Hovick, S. R. A.,R. A. Meyers,C. E. Timmerman(2003).E-Mail Communications in Workplace Romantic Relationships.Communication Studies,54(4),468-482.
  22. Jamison, K.(1983).Managing Sexual Attraction in the Workplace.Personnel Administrator,28(8),45-51.
  23. Jenner, L.(1993).Office Dating Policies: Is There is Workable Way?.HR Focus,70,5.
  24. Jones, G. E.(1999).Hierarchical Workplace Romance: An Experimental Examination of Team Member Perceptions.Journal of Organizational Behavior,20,1057-1072.
  25. Karl, K. A.,C. L. Sutton(2000).An Examination of the Perceived Fairness of Workplace Romance Policies.Journal of Business and Psychology,14(3),429-442.
  26. Levinger, G.,R. L. Bins,T. L. Huston (Eds.)(1979).Social Exchange in Developing Relationships.San Diego:Academic Press.
  27. Mainiero, L. A.(1989).Office Romance: Love, Power, and Sex in the Workplace.New York:Rawson Associates.
  28. Mainiero, L. A.(1986).A Review and Analysis of Power Dynamics in Organizational Romances.Academy of Management Review,11,750-762.
  29. Mainiero, L. A.,E. A. Fagenson (Ed.)(1993).Women in Management: Trends, Issues and Challenges in Managerial Diversity.Newbury Park, CA.:Sage.
  30. Mano, R.,Y. Gabriel(2006).Workplace Romances in Cold and Hot Organizational Climates: The Experience of Israel and Taiwan.Human Relations,59(1),7-35.
  31. Morgan, L. A.(1998).Glass-Ceiling Effect or Cohort Effect? A Longitudinal Study of the Gender Earnings Gap for Engineers, 1982 to 1989.American Sociological Review,63,479-483.
  32. Paul, R. J.,J. B. Townsend(1998).Managing the Workplace Romance: Protecting Employee and Employer Rights.Review of Business,19(2),25-30.
  33. Pierce, C. A.,B. Broberg,J. R. McClure,H. Aguinis(2004).Responding to Sexual Harassment Complaints: Effects of a Dissolved Workplace Romance on Decision-Making Standards.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,95,66-82.
  34. Pierce, C. A.,D. Byrne,H. Aguinis(1996).Attraction in Organizations: A Model of Workplace Romance.Journal of Organizational Behavior,17,5-32.
  35. Pierce, C. A.,H. Aguinis(2001).A Framework for Investigating the Link between Workplace Romance and Sexual Harassment.Group & Organization Management,26(2),206-229.
  36. Pierce, C. A.,H. Aguinis(2005).Legal Standards, Ethical Standards, and Responses to Social-Sexual Conduct at Work.Journal of Organizational Behavior,26(6),727-732.
  37. Pierce, C. A.,H. Aguinis(1997).Bridging the Gap between Romantic Relationships and Sexual Harassment in Organizations.Journal of Organizational Behavior,18,197-200.
  38. Pierce, C. A.,H. Aguinis,S. K. R. Adams(2000).Effects of Dissolved Workplace Romance and Rater Characteristics on Responses to a Sexual Harassment Accusation.Academy of Management Journal,43(5),869-880.
  39. Powell, G. N.(2001).Workplace Romances between Senior-Level Executives and Low-Level Employees: An Issue of Work Disruption and Gender.Human Relations,54(11),1519-1544.
  40. Powell, G. N.(Ed.),S. Foley(1999).Handbook of Gender & Work.Newbury Park, CA.:Sage.
  41. Powell, G. N.,L. A. Mainiero(1990).What Managers Need to Know about Office Romances.Leadership and Organization Development Journal,11,i-iii.
  42. Powell, G. N.,S. Foley(1998).Something to Talk about: Romantic Relationships in Organizational Settings.Journal of Management,24,421-448.
  43. Powers, D. M.(1999).Consensual Workplace Relationships: The Stereotypes, Policies, and Challenges.Compensation & Benefits Management,15(3),20-32.
  44. Powers, D. M.(1999).The Office Romance: Playing with Fire without Getting Burned.New York:American Management Association.
  45. Pryor, J. B.,C. M. LaVite,L. M. Stoller(1993).A Social Psychological Analysis of Sexual Harassment: The Person/Situation Interaction.Journal of Vocational Behavior,42,68-83.
  46. Quinn, R. E.(1977).Coping with Cupid: The Formation, Impact and Management of Romantic Relationships in Organizations.Administrative Science Quarterly,22(1),39-45.
  47. Quinn, R. E.,P. L. Lee(1984).Attraction and Harassment: Dynamics of Sexual Politics in the Workplace.Organizational Dynamics,13(2),35-46.
  48. Schaefer, C. M.,T. R. Tudor(2001).Managing Workplace Romances.Sam Advanced Management Journal,66(3),4-9.
  49. Schaner, D. J.(1994).Romance in the Workplace: Should Employers Act as Chaperons?.Employee Relations Law Journal,20(1),47-71.
  50. Schwartz, R. M.,L. M. Storm(2002).Romance at the Workplace: The Issues, the Law, and Some Suggestions.Journal of Individual Employment Rights,9(2),139-151.
  51. Simon, J.(1995).The "Double-Glazed Glass Ceiling" in Australian Libraries.Women in Management Review,10(8),19-29.
  52. Snyder, R. A.,K. S. Verderber,L. Langmeyer,M. Myers(1992).A Reconsideration of Self and Organization Referent Attitudes as `Causes` of the Glass Ceiling Effect.Group & Organization Management,17(3),260-278.
  53. Society for Human Resource Management(1998).Workplace Romance Survey.VA.:SHRM Public Affairs Department.
  54. Sprecher, S.,D. Felmlee,S. Metts,B. Fehr,D. Vanni(1998).Factors Associated with Distress Following the Breakup of a Close Relationship.Journal of Social and Personal Relationships,15,791-809.
  55. Spruell, G. R.(1985).Daytime Drama: Love in the Office.Training and Development Journal,39(2),20-23.
  56. Sternberg, R. J.(1986).A Triangular Theory of Love.Psychological Review,93,119-135.
  57. Summers, R. J.,K. Myklebust(1992).The Influence of a History of Romance on Judgments and Responses to Complaints of Sexual Harassment.Sex Roles,27(7/8),345-357.
  58. Terpstra, D. E.,D. D. Baker(1992).Outcomes of Federal Court Decisions on Sexual Harassment.Academy of Management Journal,35,181-190.
  59. Thacker, R. A.,G. R. Ferris(1991).Understanding Sexual Harassment in the Workplace: The Influence of Power and Politics within the Dyadic Interaction of Harasser and Target.Human Resource Management Review,1,23-37.
  60. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission(1993).Proposed Guidelines on Harassment Based on Race, Color, Religion, Gender, National Origin, Age or Disability.Federal Register,58,5126-5129.
  61. U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board(1994).Sexual Harassment in the Federal Workplace: Trends, Progress, and Continuing Challenges.Washington, D. C.:Government Printing Office.
  62. Westhoff, L. A.(1986).What to Do about Corporate Romance.Management Review,75,50-55.
  63. Whaley, G. L.,S. H. Tucker(1998).A Theoretical Integration of Sexual Harassment Model.Equal Opportunities International,17(1),21-29.
  64. Williams, C. L.,P. A. Giuffre,K. Dellinger(1999).Sexuality in the Workplace: Organizational Control, Sexual Harassment, and the Pursuit of Pleasure.Annual Review of Sociology,25,73-93.
  65. Wilson, R. J.,C. Filosa,A. Fennel(2003).Romantic Relationships at Work: Dose Privacy Trump the Dating Police.Defense Counsel Journal,70(1),78-88.
  66. Witteman, H.,G. L. Kreps (Ed.)(1993).Sexual Harassment: Communication Implications.Cresskill, NJ.:Hampton Press.
  67. 王惠玲(1993)。由勞動法學觀點論工作場所性騷擾。勞工行政，61，22-23。
  68. 台北市婦女救援基金會(1990)。婦女性暴力調查報告。台北:台北市婦女救援基金會。
  69. 呂寶靜(1995)。工作場所性騷擾之研究：臺灣地區案例探討。國立政治大學學報，70，131-158。
  70. 俞慧君(1993)。工作場所性騷擾之法律問題。法學叢刊，152，18-19。
  71. 俞慧君(2002)。各國對工作場所性騷擾之法律規範。法學叢刊，186，81-83、92。
  72. 高鳳仙(2001)。性騷擾法律概念之探究。法令月刊，50，104-105。
  73. 高鳳仙(1999)。性騷擾防治法之立法問題之研究。萬國法律，105，60-62。
  74. 現代婦女基金會(1992)。台北市上班族兩性差異對性騷擾經驗與對性騷擾態度影響之研究。台北:現代婦女基金會。
  75. 焦興鎧(2003)。性騷擾爭議新論。台北:元照。
  76. 焦興鎧(2002)。向工作場所性騷擾問題宣戰。台北:元照。
  77. 焦興鎧(1997)。工作場所性騷擾問題在美國所引起之法律爭議。台北:中華民國勞資關係協進會。
  78. 焦興鎧(2002)。工作場所性騷擾問題與法律對策。台北:元照。
  79. 黃煥榮(2005)。組織中戀情關係之理論探討：研究命題與整合性分析架構之建立。行政暨政策學報，41，117-150。
  80. 黃煥榮(1995)。組織中之潛在權力和權力運用－結構面與行爲面之探討。法政學報，3，47-64。
  81. 黃煥榮(2000)。臺北市政府社會局八十九年度婦女議題研究委託暨補助案發表會。台北:台北市政府社會局。
  82. 黃煥榮(2007)。突破玻璃天花板－女性行政菁英事業生涯發展的問題與展望。國家菁英季刊，3(4)，85-107。
  83. 黃煥榮(2000)。博士論文(博士論文)。台北，政治大學公共行政系。
  84. 黃煥榮(2003)。危險的親密關係？影響工作場所戀情之因素分析。意識、認同、實踐－2003年女性主義學術研討會，新竹:
  85. 楊培珊(2000)。女性居家照顧服務員工作中遭受性騷擾之經驗探討。台大社會工作學刊，2，99-149。
  86. 鄭津津(1998)。美國工作場所性騷擾相關法制之研究。國立中正大學法學集刊，1，233-265。
被引用次数
  1. 黃煥榮(2010)。組織中戀情關係之管理：問題與建議。公共行政學報，36，125-153。
  2. 鍾成鴻,廖紀華,林燕卿(2021)。台灣性騷擾研究發展與展望：文獻回顧報告。性學研究，12(1)，87-103。
  3. (2024)。內心的恐懼誰來伸張－以職場性騷擾後的補救措施為中心。管理資訊計算，13(特刊1)，22-34。
print cancel