题名

從哪來創新想法？地方政府創新來源與創新政策特質的分析

并列篇名

Where Do Innovative Ideas Come from? The Relationship between Information Source and Quality of Innovation

DOI

10.30409/JPA.201603_(50).0001

作者

李仲彬(Chung-Pin Lee)

关键词

創新 ； 政策資訊 ； 地方政府 ； 資訊網絡 ； 創新屬性 ； innovation ； policy idea ； local government ； information source ； policy characteristics

期刊名称

公共行政學報

卷期/出版年月

50期（2016 / 03 / 01）

页次

1 - 42

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

政府創新的過程大致可區分成創新想法的出現、想法的採用、及創新想法的執行三階段。然而目前針對政府創新所做的研究，幾乎沒有任何研究系統性地深入探討「創新」在剛開始是如何被提出來的、由誰提出來的問題，忽略上述發展過程中的第一階段。多數研究都假定創新想法的出現是一種理所當然，直接將焦點放在創新被採用之後從一個地方擴散到另外一個地方的速度，使得研究成果無法解釋原始創新資訊來源網絡的問題。本文以地方政府過去幾年所推出的43 個創新個案為例，分析這些創新的初始想法來源以及其政策特質，了解地方政府創新的資訊網絡並提出改善建議。研究結果發現，與預期不同，地方政府的創新想法大多產自政府內部，例如行政首長或其他同事，而且多數認為這些內部想法來源對於後續創新的採用與執行有較高的影響能力，相關政策特質也較明顯；在創新想法的傳遞媒介部分，除了學術性的場合外，互動性質較高之媒介所傳遞出來的創新，在各項特質上也是較為明顯，也就是被採用的機會也是較高的。本研究是第一個系統性分析政府創新來源的研究，在理論上，可為創新政策的過程理論注入更多未來研究的命題，導引出未來更多對於創新想法、創新訊息資訊網絡研究的重視，在實務上則提供健全化政府組織創新資訊來源與管道的建議。
英文摘要

When viewed from the perspective of policy development, both the original sources and the quality of the channels through which policy ideas are communicated and proposed are closely related to whether a given policy can be accomplished within a short span of time. This relationship holds particularly true with regard to innovative policies, which are often characterized by their high levels of uncertainty. This study aims to (1) explore the sources of innovative ideas and (2) reveal the most valuable idea sources. The results indicate that the source for most local government innovative ideas originates from within the government itself. Most respondents also believe that internal sources of innovation are more influential on the later phases of adoption and implementation. Analysis of the different channels of innovative idea delivery reveals that innovations resulting from channels with higher levels of interaction generally score higher in all innovation characteristics, with the sole exception of academic meetings. Thus, channels with greater interactivity generate innovations that have a higher chance of being adopted. This research is the first study to systematically examine the source of government innovation. It is hoped that this research may lead to renewed interest in the area of innovation.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 江大樹(2005)。從創新到執行力：政府改造的變革與困境。政治科學論叢，26，79-128。
    連結：
  2. 李仲彬(2013)。影響地方政府創新產出量的因素。東吳政治學報，31(1)，105-160。
    連結：
  3. 李亭林(2008)。區域創新系統下談社會網絡的學習與能力建構。公共行政學報，26，141-157。
    連結：
  4. Howard, J. H. (2012). Innovation, ingenuity and initiative: The adoption and application of new ideas in Australian local government. Retrieved May 1, 2013, from http://www.acelg.org.au/upload/documents/1347497531_ACELG_Innovative_Councils_Paper_13sep.pdf.
  5. Albrecht, T. L.,Hall, B. J.(1991).Facilitating talk about new ideas: The role of personal relationships in organizational innovation.Communications Monographs,58(3),273-288.
  6. Altshuler, A. A.(Ed.),Behn, R. D.(Ed.)(1997).Innovation in American government: Challenges, opportunities, and dilemmas.Washington, DC:Brookings Institution Press.
  7. Baker, N. R.,Siegman, J.,Rubenstein, A. H.(1967).The effect of perceived needs and means on the generation of ideas for industrial research and development projects.IEEE Transactions for Engineering Management,14(4),156-163.
  8. Bala, V.,Goyal, S.(1998).Learning from neighbors.The Review of Economic Studies,65(3),595-621.
  9. Barnett, H. G.(1953).Innovation: The basis of cultural change.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  10. Bason, C.(2010).Leading public sector innovation: Co-creating for a better society.Bristol, UK:The Policy Press.
  11. Becker, S. W.,Whistler, T. L.(1967).The innovative organization: A selective view of current theory and research.The Journal of Business,40(4),462-469.
  12. Bennett, C. J.(1997).Understanding ripple effects: The cross-national adoption of policy instruments for bureaucratic accountability.Governance,10(3),213-233.
  13. Berry, W. D.,Baybeck, B.(2005).Using geographic information systems to study interstate competition.American Political Science Review,99(4),505-519.
  14. Bigoness, W. J.,Perreault, W. D., Jr.(1981).A conceptual paradigm and approach for the study of innovators.The Academy of Management Journal,24(1),68-82.
  15. Bingham, R. D.(1978).Innovation, bureaucracy, and public policy: A study of innovation adoption by local government.The Western Political Quarterly,31(2),178-205.
  16. Björk, J.,Magnusson, M.(2009).Where do good innovation ideas come from? Exploring the influence of network connectivity on innovation idea quality.Journal of Product Innovation Management,26(6),662-670.
  17. Bland, T.,Bruk, B.,Kim, D.,Lee, K. T.(2010).Enhancing public sector innovation: Examining the network-innovation relationship.The Innovation Journal: The Public Sector Innovation Journal,15(3),1-17.
  18. Bloch, C.,Bugge, M. M.(2013).Public sector innovation-From theory to measuremen.Structural Change and Economic Dynamics,27,133-145.
  19. Block, F.,Keller, M. R.(2009).Where do innovations come from? Transformations in the US economy, 1970-2006.Socio-Economic Review,7(3),459-483.
  20. Boehmke, F. J.,Witmer, R.(2004).Disentangling diffusion: The effects of social learning and economic competition on state policy innovation expansion.Political Research Quarterly,57(1),39-51.
  21. Borins, S.(2002).Leadership and innovation in the public sector.Leadership & Organization Development Journal,23(8),467-476.
  22. Borrás, S.(2011).Policy learning and organizational capacities in innovation policies.Sciecne and Public Policy,38(9),725-734.
  23. Boyd, D.,Goldenberg, J.(2013).Inside the box: A proven system of creativity for breakthrough results.NY:Simon & Schuster.
  24. Bradley, R. B.(1980).Motivations in legislative information use.Legislative Studies Quarterly,5(3),393-406.
  25. Cooper, J. R.(1998).A multidimensional approach to the adoption of innovation.Management Decision,36(8),493-502.
  26. Cooper, R. G.,Edgett, S. J.(2008).Ideation for product innovation: What are the best methods?.PDMA Visions Magazine,32(1),12-17.
  27. Daft, R. L.(1978).A dual-core model of organizational innovation.The Academy of Management Journal,21(2),193-210.
  28. Damanpour, F.(1991).Organizational innovation: A meta-analysis of effects of determinants and moderators.Academy of Management Journal,34(3),555-590.
  29. Damanpour, F.(1988).Innovation type, radicalness, and the adoption process.Communication Research,15(5),545-567.
  30. Damanpour, F.,Schneider, M.(2009).Characteristics of innovation and innovation adoption in public organizations: Assessing the role of managers.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,19(3),495-522.
  31. Damanpour, F.,Walker, R. M.,Avellaneda, C. N.(2009).Combinative effects of innovation types and organizational performance: A longitudinal study of service organizations.Journal of Management Studies,46(4),650-675.
  32. Evans, M.(Ed.)(2004).Policy transfer in global perspective.Burlington, VT:Routledge.
  33. Freeman, P. K.(1985).Interstate communication among state legislators regarding energy policy innovation.Publius,15(4),99-112.
  34. Gray, V.,Lowery, D.(2000).Where do policy ideas come from? A study of Minnesota legislators and staffers.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,10(3),573-598.
  35. Hird, J. A.(2005).Policy analysis for what? The effectiveness of nonpartisan policy research organizations.Policy Studies Journal,33(1),83-105.
  36. Jackson-Elmoore, C.(2005).Informing state policymakers: Opportunities for social workers.Social Work,50(3),251-261.
  37. James, T. E.,Jorgensen, P. D.(2009).Policy knowledge, policy formulation, and change: Revisiting a foundational question.The Policy Studies Journal,37(1),141-162.
  38. Kerr, N. L.,Tindale, R. S.(2004).Group performance and decision making.Annual Review of Psychology,55,623-655.
  39. Kingdon, J. W.(1995).Agendas, alternatives, and public policies.New York:Longman.
  40. Lee, C. K.,Strang, D.(2006).The international diffusion of public-sector downsizing: Network emulation and theory-driven learning.International Organization,60(4),883-909.
  41. Makse, T.,Volden, C.(2011).The role of policy attributes in the diffusion of innovations.The Journal of Politics,73(1),108-124.
  42. Matsuda, N.(2008).Policy information market: Policy analysts' strategies for knowledge utilization.Interdisciplinary Information Sciences,14(2),155-165.
  43. Mintrom, M.,Vergari, S.(1998).Policy networks and innovation diffusion: The case of state education reforms.The Journal of Politics,60(1),126-148.
  44. Mooney, C. Z.(1991).Information sources in state legislative decision making.Legislative Studies Quarterly,16(3),445-455.
  45. Newman, J.,Raine, J.,Skelcher, C.(2001).Developments: Transforming local government: Innovation and modernization.Public Money & Management,21(2),61-68.
  46. Newmark, A. J.(2002).An integrated approach to policy transfer and diffusion.The Review of Policy Research,19(2),151-178.
  47. O'Connor, A.,Roos, G.,Vickers-Willis, T.(2007).Evaluating an Australian public policy organization's innovation capacity.European Journal of Innovation Management,10(4),532-558.
  48. O'Reilly, C. A., III.(1982).Variations in decision makers' use of information sources: The impact of quality and accessibility of information.Academy of Management Journal,25(4),756-771.
  49. Paulus, P. B.,Yang, H. C.(2000).Idea generation in groups: A basis for creativity in organizations.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,82(1),76-87.
  50. Ray, D.(1982).The sources of voting cues in three state legislatures.The Journal of Politics,44(4),1074-1087.
  51. Rogers, E. M.(2003).Diffusion of innovations.New York:Free Press.
  52. Rose, R.(1993).Lesson-drawing in public policy: A guide to learning across time and space.New Jersey:Chatham House.
  53. Rose, R.(1991).What is lesson-drawing?.Journal of Public Policy,11,3-30.
  54. Sabatier, P. A.(Ed.)(2007).Theories of the policy process.Colorado:Westview Press.
  55. Sabatier, P.,Whiteman, D.(1985).Legislative decision making and substantive policy information: Models of information flow.Legislative Studies Quarterly,10(3),395-421.
  56. Sabelli, H.(2008).Bios theory of innovation.The Innovation Journal: The Public Sector Innovation Journal,13(3)
  57. Salter, A.,Gann, D.(2003).Sources of ideas for innovation in engineering design.Research Policy,32(8),1309-1324.
  58. Shepard, H. A.(1967).Innovation-resisting and innovation-producing organizations.The Journal of Business,40(4),470-477.
  59. Simon, H. A.(1960).The new science of management decision.New York:Harper and Row.
  60. Stefl-Mabry, J.(2003).A social judgment analysis of information source preference profiles: An exploratory study to empirically represent media selection patterns.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,54(9),879-904.
  61. Van de Ven, A. H.(1986).Central problems in the management of innovation.Management Science,32(5),590-607.
  62. Walker, R. M.(2006).Innovation type and diffusion: An empirical analysis of local government.Public Administration,84(2),311-335.
  63. Wilson, J. Q.(1989).Bureaucracy: What government agencies do and why they do it.New York:Basic Books.
  64. Woodman, R. W.,Sawyer, J. E.,Griffin, R. W.(1993).Toward a theory of organizational creativity.The Academy of Management Review,18(2),293-321.
  65. 陳暉淵(2009)。地方政府行銷：區域主義下的創新競爭策略。文官制度季刊，1(4)，57-78。
  66. 黃東益(2004)。全球治理下政府知識管理的新面向：府際政策學習。國家政策季刊，3(1)，135-153。
被引用次数
  1. 韓意慈、徐煒勛(2018)。誰在虛擬社會中做什麼？非營利組織資源與官網資訊的內容分析。公共行政學報，55，37-71。
  2. 李仲彬(2017)。政策創新的影響因素：我國地方政府的分析（1999-2013）。東吳政治學報，35(2)，139-206。
  3. 李仲彬(2018)。與生俱來與後天培養：影響公務人員創新態度與行為的因素分析。公共行政學報，54，1-40。
  4. 熊慧嵐、陳東升、周睦怡(2018)。在地社會創新網絡：以人文創新與社會實踐計畫在地實作為例。臺灣政治學刊，22(2)，147-202。
print cancel