题名

縣市低碳發展效率評估與其影響成因之探討

并列篇名

Evaluating the Low-Carbon Efficiency of the City and Analyzing Its Influential Factors

DOI

10.30409/JPA.201603_(50).0002

作者

沈育生(Yu-Sheng Shen)；劉小蘭(Hsiao-Lan Liu)

关键词

縣市低碳發展效率 ； 非意欲產出 ； 不良產出模型 ； 低碳政策 ； Tobit 模型 ； low-carbon efficiency of city ； undesirable outputs ； bad Outputs model ； low-carbon policy ； Tobit model

期刊名称

公共行政學報

卷期/出版年月

50期（2016 / 03 / 01）

页次

43 - 76

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

面對全球暖化之課題與威脅，各國政府大多以低碳發展，作為發展的訴求及目標。而縣市於發展中，雖產生許多效益，卻也消耗不少資源，連帶也產生不少碳排放量與環境污染，因此，地方政府在獲得規劃管理權限後，如何在永續及低碳的框架中，综合地衡量各種效益與耗損，調和並予以共存，並且落實於縣市發展政策之中，亦為一重要之課題。目前在低碳發展上的評估，多採用指標評估的方式進行分析，且甚少考慮發展所產生的負的外部性（即非意欲產出，undesirable outputs），亦多將非意欲產出忽略不計，故在評估上存在許多侷限與缺失；此外，對於影響低碳發展效率之政策或成因亦未有深入探討。故本文以台灣各縣市作為實證案例，在考量非意欲產出下（碳排放威脅、環境污染衝擊），透過「資料包絡分析」（data envelopment analysis, DEA）中的不良產出模型，評估縣市低碳發展效率，並藉由Tobit 模型，釐清低碳政策對縣市低碳發展效率之影響效果，以作為未來低碳發展或政策研擬之參考。根據不良產出模型的評估結果，顯示臺北市、新竹市、臺東縣、花蓮縣在低碳發展效率上相對具有效率，且已達最適規模水準。另外，透過Tobit 模式的實證分析，對於影響縣市低碳發展效率具顯著的變數，包括工廠家數、資源回收量、市區公車系統路線總長、具綠建築標章的建物數、綠地面積。其中，除工廠家數對縣市低碳發展效率有負向影響外，其餘變數皆呈正向影響效果。
英文摘要

Facing the disasters and threats stemming from global warming and climate change, most city governments in the world have set up low-carbon development as a goal, and drawn up low-carbon policies to achieve this goal. However, the effects of those low-carbon policies are not possible to clarify. The development of the city/county has brought about economic benefits, but it also consumed significant resources and produced carbon emissions and environmental pollutants. Therefore, how to evaluate benefit and loss comprehensively and offer improvable recommendations is a key issue in the sustainable and low-carbon development of the city/county. In the past, most researchers evaluated low-carbon efficiency by indicators, and proceeded to their evaluation without considering the negative externalities arising from development, therefore, making inaccurate assessments of low-carbon efficiency evaluation. Thus, this paper assesses the low-carbon efficiency of the city by the Bad Outputs model of the DEA, and analyzes its influential policies by the Tobit model. According to the results of the Bad Outputs Model, Taipei City, Hsinchu City, Taitung County, and Hualien County are efficient, and have achieved an optimal scale level. Another result of the Tobit model indicates that the industrial unit has a negative impact on the low-carbon efficiency of the city. Moreover, resource recovery, the total length of the urban bus route, green buildings, and green areas all have a positive impact on the low-carbon efficiency of the city.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 林楨家、楊恩捷(2006)。都市型態對旅運需求影響之結構化分析。運輸學刊，18(4)，391-416。
    連結：
  2. 行政院（2014）。國家綠能低碳總行動方案103 年度工作計畫。臺北：行政院。
  3. Aragón-Correa, J. A.(1998).Strategic proactivity and firm approach to the natural environment.The Academy of Management Journal,41(5),556-567.
  4. Arcelus, F. J.,Arocena, P.(2005).Productivity differences across OECD countries in the presence of environmental constraints.Journal of the Operational Research Society,56(12),1352-1362.
  5. Barkalow, G.,Bemis, G.,McKeever, N.,Phinney, S.,Vinton, J.(2007).The role of land use in meeting California's energy and climate change goals.California:California Energy Commission.
  6. Barney, J.(1991).Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage.Journal of Management,17(1),99-120.
  7. Bi, J.,Zhang, R. R.,Wang, H. K.,Liu, M. M.,Wu, Y.(2011).The benchmarks of carbon emissions and policy implications for China's cities: Case of Nanjing.Energy Policy,39(9),4785-4794.
  8. Boussofiane, A.,Dyson, R. G.,Thanassoulis, E.(1991).Applied data envelopment analysis.European Journal of Operational Research,52(1),1-15.
  9. Cai, B. F.,Wang, J. N.,Yang, W. S.,Liu, L. C.,Cao, D.(2012).Low carbon society in China: Research and practice.Advances in Climate Change Research,3(2),106-120.
  10. Cervero, R.(1996).Mixed land-uses and commuting: Evidence from the American housing survey.Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice,30(5),361-377.
  11. Cervero, R.,Kockelman, K.(1997).Travel demand and the 3Ds: Density, diversity, and design.Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment,2(3),199-219.
  12. Chang, Y. T.,Zhang, N.,Danao, D.,Zhang, N.(2013).Environmental efficiency analysis of transportation system in China: A non-radial DEA approach.Energy Policy,58,277-283.
  13. Charmondusit, K.,Keartpakpraek, K.(2011).Eco-efficiency evaluation of the petroleum and petrochemical group in the Map Ta Phut Industrial Estate, Tailand.Journal of Cleaner Production,19(2),241-252.
  14. Chen, F.,Zhu, D. J.(2013).Theoretical research on low-carbon city and empirical study of Shanghai.Habitat International,37,33-42.
  15. Chiu, Y. H.,Wu, M. F.(2010).Environmental efficiency evaluation in China: Application of 'Undesirable' data envelopment analysis.Polish Journal of Environmental Studies,19(6),1159-1169.
  16. Choy, L. H. T.,Ho, W. K. O.,Mak, S. W. K.(2013).Toward a low carbon Hong Kong: A proposal from the institutional perspective.Habitat International,37,124-129.
  17. Coli, M.,Nissi, E.,Rapposelli, A.(2011).Monitoring environmental efficiency: An application to Italian provinces.Environmental Modelling & Software,26(1),38-43.
  18. Cooper, W. W.,Seiford, L. M.,Tone, K.(2007).Data envelopment analysis: A comprehensive text with models, applications, references and DEA-solver software.Boston:Springer-Verlag.
  19. Cooper, W. W.,Seiford, L. M.,Zhu, J.(2011).Handbook on data envelopment analysis.Boston:Springer.
  20. Deetman, S.,Hof, A. F.,van Vuuren, D. P.(2015).Deep CO2 emission reductions in a global bottom-up model approach.Climate Policy,15(2),253-271.
  21. Demchuk, P.,Zelenyuk, V.(2009).Testing differences in efficiency of regions within a country: The case of Ukraine.Journal of Productivity Analysis,32(2),81-102.
  22. Dodman, D.(2011).Forces driving urban greenhouse gas emissions.Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability,3(3),121-125.
  23. Dunphy, R.,Fisher, K.(1996).Transportation, congestion, and density: New insights.Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board,1552,89-96.
  24. Efron, B.(1979).Bootstrap methods: Another look at the jackknife.Annals of Statistics,7(1),1-26.
  25. Ewing, R.,Pendall, R.,Chen, D.(2003).Measuring sprawl and its transportation impacts.Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board,1831,175-183.
  26. Färe, R.,Grosskopf, S.,Hernandez-Sancho, F.(2004).Environmental performance: An index number approach.Resource and Energy Economics,26(4),343-352.
  27. Färe, R.,Grosskopf, S.,Lovell, C. A. K.,Pasurka, C.(1989).Multilateral productivity comparisons when some outputs are undesirable: A nonparametric approach.The Review of Economics and Statistics,71(1),90-98.
  28. Färe, R.,Grosskopf, S.,Pasurka, C. A., Jr.(2001).Accounting for air pollution emissions in measures of state manufacturing productivity growth.Journal of Regional Science,41(3),381-409.
  29. Färe, R.,Grosskopf, S.,Pasurka, C. A., Jr.(2007).Environmental production functions and environmental directional distance functions.Energy,32(7),1055-1066.
  30. Fortes, P.,Simões, S.,Seixas, J.,Van Regemorter, D.,Ferreira, F.(2013).Top-down and bottom-up modelling to support low-carbon scenarios: Climate policy implications.Climate Policy,13(3),285-304.
  31. Giuliano, G.,Narayan, D.(2003).Another look at travel patterns and urban form: The US and Great Britain.Urban Studies,40(11),2295-2312.
  32. Grazi, F.,van den Bergh, J. C. J. M.,van Ommeren, J. N.(2008).An empirical analysis of urban form, transport, and global warming.Energy Journal,29(4),97-122.
  33. Greene, W. H.(2012).Econometric analysis.Boston:Prentice Hall.
  34. Haselip, J.,Hansen, U. E.,Puig, D.,Trærup, S.,Dhar, S.(2015).Governance, enabling frameworks and policies for the transfer and diffusion of low carbon and climate adaptation technologies in developing countries.Climatic Change,131(3),363-370.
  35. He, F.,Zhang, Q.,Lei, J.,Fu, W.,Xu, X.(2013).Energy efficiency and productivity change of China's iron and steel industry: Accounting for undesirable outputs.Energy Policy,54,204-213.
  36. Honma, S.,Hu, J. L.(2008).Total-factor energy efficiency of regions in Japan.Energy Policy,36(2),821-833.
  37. Honma, S.,Hu, J. L.(2009).Efficient waste and pollution abatements for regions in Japan.International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology,16(4),270-285.
  38. Hu, H. H.,Qi, Q. H.,Yang, C. H.(2012).Analysis of hospital technical efficiency in China: Effect of health insurance reform.China Economic Review,23(4),865-877.
  39. Hu, J. L.,Wang, S. C.(2006).Total-factor energy efficiency of regions in China.Energy Policy,34(17),3206-3217.
  40. Hu, J. L.,Wang, S. C.,Yeh, F. Y.(2006).Total-factor water efficiency of regions in China.Resources Policy,31(4),217-230.
  41. Huang, R.,Li, Y.(2013).Undesirable input-output two-phase DEA model in an environmental performance audit.Mathematical and Computer Modelling,58,971-979.
  42. Kennedy, C.,Steinberger, J.,Gasson, B.,Hansen, Y.,Hillman, T.,Havranek, M.,Mendez, G. V.(2009).Greenhouse gas emissions from global cities.Environmental Science and Technology,43(19),7297-7302.
  43. Kharel, G. P.,Charmondusit, K.(2008).Eco-efficiency evaluation of iron rod industry in Nepal.Journal of Cleaner Production,16(13),1379-1387.
  44. Kumar, S.(2006).Environmentally sensitive productivity growth: A global analysis using Malmquist-Luenberger index.Ecological Economics,56(2),280-293.
  45. Li, X. G.,Yang, J.,Liu, X. J.(2013).Analysis of Beijing's environmental efficiency and related factors using a DEA model that considers undesirable outputs.Mathematical and Computer Modelling,58,956-960.
  46. Lin, J. Y.,Cao, B.,Cui, S. H.,Wang, W.,Bai, X. M.(2010).Evaluating the effectiveness of urban energy conservation and GHG mitigation measures: The case of Xiamen city, China.Energy Policy,38(9),5123-5132.
  47. Lu, C. C.,Chiu, Y. H.,Shyu, M. K.,Lee, J. H.(2013).Measuring CO2 emission efficiency in OECD countries: Application of the hybrid efficiency model.Economic Modelling,32,130-135.
  48. Meadows, D. H.,Meadows, D. L.,Randers, J.,Behrens, W. W., III(1972).The limits to growth: A report for the club of rome's project on the predicament of mankind.New York:Universe Books.
  49. Meng, F. Y.,Fan, L. W.,Zhou, P.,Zhou, D. Q.(2013).Measuring environmental performance in China's industrial sectors with non-radial DEA.Mathematical and Computer Modelling,58,1047-1056.
  50. Oh, D. S.(2014).The comparative analysis on critical planning methods and application condition of low-carbon green city.Journal of Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society,15(4),2491-2502.
  51. Olesen, O. B.,Petersen, N. C.(1995).Incorporating quality into data envelopment analysis: A stochastic dominance approach.International Journal of Production Economics,39,117-135.
  52. Phdungsilp, A.(2010).Integrated energy and carbon modeling with a decision support system: Policy scenarios for low-carbon city development in Bangkok.Energy Policy,38(9),4808-4817.
  53. Pittman, R. W.(1983).Multilateral productivity comparisons with undesirable outputs.Economic Journal,93(372),883-891.
  54. Rao, X.,Wu, J.,Zhang, Z. Y.,Liu, B.(2012).Energy efficiency and energy saving potential in China: An analysis based on slacks-based measure model.Computers & Industrial Engineering,63(3),578-584.
  55. Revetz, J.(2000).City-region 2020: Integrated planning for a sustainable environment.London:Routledge.
  56. Russo, M. V.,Fouts, P. A.(1997).A resource-based perspective on corporate environmental performance and profitability.The Academy of Management Journal,40(3),534-559.
  57. Seiford, L. M.,Zhu, J.(2002).Modeling undesirable factors in efficiency evaluation.European Journal of Operational Research,142(1),16-20.
  58. Skea, J.,Nishioka, S.(2008).Policies and practices for a low-carbon society.Climate Policy,8(sup1),S5-S16.
  59. Song, M.,Song, Y.,An, Q.,Yu, H.(2013).Review of environmental efficiency and its influencing factors in China: 1998-2009.Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,20,8-14.
  60. Su, M. R.,Chen, B.,Xing, T.,Chen, C.,Yang, Z. F.(2012).Development of low-carbon city in China: Where will it go?.Procedia Environmental Sciences,13,1143-1148.
  61. Tao, Y.,Zhang, S.(2013).Environmental efficiency of electric power industry in the Yangtze River Delta.Mathematical and Computer Modelling,58,927-935.
  62. Tone, K.(2001).A slacks-based measure of efficiency in data envelopment analysis.European Journal of Operational Research,130(3),498-509.
  63. Tone, K.(2003).Dealing with undesirable outputs in DEA: A slacks-based measure (SBM) approach.Tokyo:National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies.
  64. Tsolas, I. E.(2011).Performance assessment of mining operations using nonparametric production analysis: A bootstrapping approach in DEA.Resources Policy,36(2),159-167.
  65. Tyteca, D.(1996).On the measurement of the environmental performance of firms: A literature review and a productive efficiency perspective.Journal of Environmental Management,46(3),281-308.
  66. Vaccari, F. P.,Gioli, B.,Toscano, P.,Perrone, C.(2013).Carbon dioxide balance assessment of the city of Florence (Italy), and implications for urban planning.Landscape and Urban Planning,120,138-146.
  67. Wang, H. S.,Wang, Y. X.,Wang, H. K.,Liu, M. M.,Zhang, Y. X.,Zhang, R. R.,Bi, J.(2014).Mitigating greenhouse gas emissions from China's cities: Case study of Suzhou.Energy Policy,68,482-489.
  68. Wang, K.,Wei, Y. M.,Zhang, X.(2012).A comparative analysis of China's regional energy and emission performance: Which is the better way to deal with undesirable outputs?.Energy Policy,46,574-584.
  69. Wang, N. N.,Chang, Y. C.(2014).The development of policy instruments in supporting low-carbon governance in China.Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,35,126-135.
  70. Weissert, L. F.,Salmond, J. A.,Schwendenmann, L.(2014).A review of the current progress in quantifying the potential of urban forests to mitigate urban CO2 emissions.Urban Climate,8,100-125.
  71. Wu, F.,Fan, L. W.,Zhou, P.,Zhou, D. Q.(2012).Industrial energy efficiency with CO2 emissions in China: A nonparametric analysis.Energy Policy,49,164-172.
  72. Wu, J.,An, Q. X.,Xiong, B. B.,Chen, Y.(2013).Congestion measurement for regional industries in China: A data envelopment analysis approach with undesirable outputs.Energy Policy,57,7-13.
  73. Zaim, O.,Taskin, F.(2000).Environmental efficiency in carbon dioxide emissions in the OECD: A non-parametric approach.Journal of Environmental Management,58(2),95-107.
  74. Zhang, B.,Bi, J.,Fan, Z.,Yuan, Z.,Ge, J.(2008).Eco-efficiency analysis of industrial system in China: A data envelopment analysis approach.Ecological Economics,68,306-316.
  75. Zhang, L. X.,Feng, Y. Y.,Chen, B.(2011).Alternative scenarios for the development of a low-carbon city: A case study of Beijing, China.Energies,4(12),2295-2310.
  76. Zhang, L. X.,Yang, Z. F.,Liang, J.,Cai, Y. P.(2011).Spatial variation and distribution of urban energy consumptions from cities in China.Energies,4(1),26-38.
  77. Zhang, N.,Choi, Y.(2013).Environmental energy efficiency of China's regional economies: A non-oriented slacks-based measure analysis.Social Science Journal,50(2),225-234.
  78. Zhou, P.,Ang, B. W.,Han, J. Y.(2010).Total factor carbon emission performance: A Malmquist index analysis.Energy Economics,32(1),194-201.
  79. Zhou, P.,Ang, B. W.,Poh, K. L.(2006).Slacks-based efficiency measures for modeling environmental performance.Ecological Economics,60(1),111-118.
  80. Zhou, P.,Poh, K. L.,Ang, B. W.(2007).A non-radial DEA approach to measuring environmental performance.European Journal of Operational Research,178(1),1-9.
  81. Zofio, J. L.,Prieto, A. M.(2001).Environmental efficiency and regulatory standards: The case of CO2 emissions from OECD industries.Resource and Energy Economics,23(1),63-83.
  82. 鄧振源(2005)。計畫評估：方法與應用。基隆:運籌規劃與管理研究中心。
被引用次数
  1. 邱啟新(2018)。陽光下之非正式性：綠能導向違建治理之發展願景與城市管理意義。地理學報，90，27-54。
  2. 邱啟新(2020)。非正式城市之永續性修補：高雄市違章住宅轉型之空間與環境策略。都市與計劃，47(2)，111-147。
print cancel