题名

公共服務動機：回顧、反思與未來方向

并列篇名

Public Service Motivation: Review, Reflection, and Reorientation

DOI

10.30409/JPA.201609_(51).0003

作者

陳重安(Chung-An Chen)；許成委(Cheng-Wei Xu)

关键词

公共服務動機 ； 公共服務行為 ； 自我決定理論 ； 利他動機 ； 親社會動機 ； public service motivation ； public service behavior ； selfdetermination theory ； altruistic motivation ； prosocial motivation

期刊名称

公共行政學報

卷期/出版年月

51期（2016 / 09 / 01）

页次

69 - 96

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

在上世紀末美國政府的信任危機的背景下，同時也是對公共選擇理論的反思，「公共服務動機」（public service motivation, PSM）的概念於1990年被正式提出並迅速成為公共管理研究的焦點議題。本研究回顧了過去25年快速增長的文獻，發現PSM在定義與測量方面出現了不一致的問題。現有文獻中，PSM被賦予23種以上的定義以及42種以上的測量方式，這難免對未來的研究者造成困惑。進一步分析發現，PSM常常被界定為利他動機、親社會動機或內在動機，同時被注入了價值、信念及態度等諸多要素，不只在內涵上失去獨特性，定義上更偏離了動機本身的意義。鑒於PSM在華人社群被關注程度不斷升高，華人社會的研究者應用更謹慎與批判的眼光看待這個議題；我們並認為，未來研究或許該更大膽地捨棄當代文獻中根基於Perry（1996）的定義與測量，並讓其回歸其最原始的樣貌：「驅動公共服務行為的動機」。因為公共服務行為具多樣性，公共服務動機並不應該有一個放諸四海皆準的量表，故我們建議未來的研究應該基於成熟的動機理論，如「自我決定理論」（self-determination theory, SDT），根據不同行為而發展出不同類型的測量方式，並審慎地開展未來數年的本土化研究。
英文摘要

The public's trust in the US government has declined significantly since the 1960s. In 1990, Public Service Motivation (PSM) was introduced as a 'steering mechanism' and reflection of public choice theory. PSM literature has increased at a rapid pace over the last 25 years, and has become one of the hottest research topics in the field of public administration. Despite its quick growth, the conceptualization of PSM is unclear. PSM has been defined in 23 ways with 42 different measures. In addition, values, beliefs and attitudes are mixed with existing PSM definitions, making PSM less of a motivation. To study PSM in the future, scholars should focus on the literal meaning of PSM: ＂motivations for public service behaviors.＂ As public service behaviors are not limited to a single category, scholars may want to develop multiple tools of measurement tailored for different public service behaviors. Self-determination theory (SDT), we suggest, can be more widely applied.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 吳宗憲(2012)。台南市政府文官公共服務動機與工作滿意、工作努力意願之實證研究—以個人／組織配適度作為調節變項。公共行政學報，43，91-126。
    連結：
  2. 張其祿(2015)。公共服務動機概念操作與應用之研究紀要。中國行政評論，21(1)，1-14。
    連結：
  3. 許建民、范良誌(2011)。以自我決定理論探討體育志工參與動機過程模式之研究。體育學報，44(4)，549-570。
    連結：
  4. 潘瑛如、李隆盛(2014)。中文版公共服務動機量表之信效度驗證。測驗學刊，61(1)，135-158。
    連結：
  5. 潘瑛如、李隆盛(2015)。初薦任公務人員公共服務動機及其前因之探究。文官制度季刊，7(1)，35-69。
    連結：
  6. Alonso, P.,Lewis, G. B.(2001).Public service motivation and job performance: Evidence from the federal sector.The American Review of Public Administration,31(4),363-380.
  7. Anderfuhren-Biget, S.,Varone, F.,Giauque, D.,Ritz, A.(2010).Motivating employees of the public sector: Does public service motivation matter?.International Public Management Journal,13(3),213-246.
  8. Andersen, L. B.,Jørgensen, T. B.,Kjeldsen, A. M.,Pedersen, L. H.,Vrangbæk, K.(2013).Public values and public service motivation: Conceptual and empirical relationships.The American Review of Public Administration,43(3),292-311.
  9. Baard, P. P.(1994).A motivational model for consulting with not-for-profit organizations: A study of church growth and participation.Consulting Psychology Journal,46(3),19-31.
  10. Batson, C. D.(1987).Prosocial motivation: Is it ever truly altruistic?.Advances in Experimental Social Psychology,20,65-122.
  11. Batson, C. D.,Shaw, L. L.(1991).Evidence for altruism: Toward a pluralism of prosocial motives.Psychological Inquiry,2(2),107-122.
  12. Bellé, N.(2014).Leading to make a difference: A field experiment on the performance effects of transformational leadership, perceived social impact, and public service motivation.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,24(1),109-136.
  13. Bellé, N.(2013).Experimental evidence on the relationship between public service motivation and job performance.Public Administration Review,73(1),143-153.
  14. Bellé, N.,Ongaro, E.(2014).NPM, administrative reforms and public service motivation: Improving the dialogue between research agendas.International Review of Administrative Sciences,80(2),382-400.
  15. Blais, M. R.,Sabourin, S.,Boucher, C.,Vallerand, R. J.(1990).Toward a motivational model of couple happiness.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,59(5),1021-1031.
  16. Blau, P. M.(1960).Orientation toward clients in a public welfare agency.Administrative Science Quarterly,5(3),341-361.
  17. Bozeman, B.,Feeney, M. K.(2011).Rules and red tape: A prism for public administration theory and research.Armonk, NY:M. E. Sharpe.
  18. Bozeman, B.,Su, X.(2015).Public service motivation concepts and theory: A critique.Public Administration Review,75(5),700-710.
  19. Brænder, M.,Andersen, L. B.(2013).Does deployment to war affect public service motivation? A panel study of soldiers before and after their service in Afghanistan.Public Administration Review,73(3),466-477.
  20. Brewer, G. A.,Ritz, A.,Vandenabeele, W.(2012).Introduction to a symposium on public service motivation: An international sampling of research.International Journal of Public Administration,35(1),1-4.
  21. Brewer, G. A.,Selden, S. C.(1998).Whistle blowers in the federal civil service: New evidence of the public service ethic.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,8(3),413-440.
  22. Brewer, G. A.,Selden, S. C.,Facer, R. L., II(2000).Individual conceptions of public service motivation.Public Administration Review,60(3),254-264.
  23. Bright, L.(2005).Public employees with high levels of public service motivation who are they, where are they, and what do they want?.Review of Public Personnel Administration,25(2),138-154.
  24. Bright, L.(2008).Does public service motivation really make a difference on the job satisfaction and turnover intentions of public employees?.The American Review of Public Administration,38(2),149-166.
  25. Bright, L.(2007).Does person-organization fit mediate the relationship between public service motivation and the job performance of public employees?.Review of Public Personnel Administration,27(4),361-379.
  26. Camilleri, E.(2007).Antecedents affecting public service motivation.Personnel Review,36(3),356-377.
  27. Carpenter, J.,Doverspike, D.,Miguel, R. F.(2012).Public service motivation as a predictor of attraction to the public sector.Journal of Vocational Behavior,80(2),509-523.
  28. Chen, C. A.,Bozeman, B.(2013).Understanding public and nonprofit managers' motivation through the lens of self-determination theory.Public Management Review,15(4),584-607.
  29. Chen, C. A.,Hsieh, C. W.(2015).Does pursuing external incentives compromise public service motivation? Comparing the effects of job security and high pay.Public Management Review,17(8),1190-1213.
  30. Chen, C. A.,Hsieh, C. W.,Chen, D. Y.(2014).Fostering public service motivation through workplace trust: Evidence from public managers in Taiwan.Public Administration,92(4),954-973.
  31. Christensen, R. K.,Wright, B. E.(2011).The effects of public service motivation on job choice decisions: Disentangling the contributions of person-organization fit and person-job fit.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,21(4),723-743.
  32. Clerkin, R. M.,Coggburn, J. D.(2012).The dimensions of public service motivation and sector work preferences.Review of Public Personnel Administration,32(3),209-235.
  33. Clerkin, R. M.,Paynter, S. R.,Taylor, J. K.(2009).Public service motivation in undergraduate giving and volunteering decisions.The American Review of Public Administration,39(6),675-698.
  34. Cook, S. L.,Ma, Z.(2014).The interconnectedness between landowner knowledge, value, belief, attitude, and willingness to act: Policy implications for carbon sequestration on private rangelands.Journal of Environmental Management,134,90-99.
  35. Costa, H. A.,Collins, J.,Levi, I.(1995).Desire-as-belief implies opinionation or indifference.Analysis,55(1),2-5.
  36. Crewson, P. E.(1997).Public-service motivation: Building empirical evidence of incidence and effect.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,7(4),499-518.
  37. Deci, E. L.(1971).Effects of externally mediated rewards on intrinsic motivation.Journal of personality and Social Psychology,18(1),105-115.
  38. Deci, E. L.,Connell, J. P.,Ryan, R. M.(1989).Self-determination in a work organization.Journal of applied psychology,74(4),580-590.
  39. Deci, E. L.,Ryan, R. M.(2000).The "what" and "why" of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior.Psychological Inquiry,11(4),227-268.
  40. Deci, E. L.,Ryan, R. M.(1985).Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior.New York:Plenum Press.
  41. DeHart-Davis, L.,Marlowe, J.,Pandey, S. K.(2006).Gender dimensions of public service motivation.Public Administration Review,66(6),873-887.
  42. Eagly, A. H.,Chaiken, S.(1993).The psychology of attitudes.Fort Worth:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich College Publishers.
  43. Fagin, R.,Halpern, J. Y.(1987).Belief, awareness, and limited reasoning.Artificial Intelligence,34(1),39-76.
  44. Francois, P.(2000).'Public service motivation' as an argument for government provision.Journal of Public Economics,78(3),275-299.
  45. Frey, B. S.,Jegen, R.(2001).Motivation crowding theory.Journal of Economic Surveys,15(5),589-611.
  46. Gagné, M. (Ed.)(2014).The Oxford handbook of work engagement, motivation, and self-determination theory.New York:Oxford University Press.
  47. Gagné, M.,Deci, E. L.(2005).Self-determination theory and work motivation.Journal of Organizational Behavior,26(4),331-362.
  48. Gagné, M.,Forest, J.,Gilbert, M. H.,Aubé, C.,Morin, E.,Malorni, A.(2010).The motivation at work scale: Validation evidence in two languages.Educational and Psychological Measurement,70(4),628-646.
  49. Gagné, M.,Forest, J.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Crevier-Braud, L.,Van den Broeck, A.,Aspeli, A. K.,Westbye, C.(2015).The Multidimensional Work Motivation Scale: Validation evidence in seven languages and nine countries.European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,24(2),178-196.
  50. George, J. M.,Jones, G. R.(2012).Understanding and managing organizational behavior.Boston:Prentice Hall.
  51. Georgellis, Y.,Iossa, E.,Tabvuma, V.(2011).Crowding out intrinsic motivation in the public sector.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,21(3),473-493.
  52. Georgellis, Y.,Tabvuma, V.(2010).Does public service motivation adapt?.Kyklos,63(2),176-191.
  53. Goldman, A. I.(1979).What is justified belief?.Justification and knowledge: New studies in epistemology,Dordrecht:
  54. Grant, A. M.(2007).Relational job design and the motivation to make a prosocial difference.Academy of Management Review,32(2),393-417.
  55. Hayamizu, T.(1997).Between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation: Examination of reasons for academic study based on the theory of internalization.Japanese Psychological Research,39(2),98-108.
  56. Hickey, R.(2014).Prosocial motivation, stress and burnout among direct support workers.Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities,27(2),134-144.
  57. Houston, D. J.(2000).Public-service motivation: A multivariate test.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,10(4),713-728.
  58. Houston, D. J.(2006)."Walking the walk" of public service motivation: Public employees and charitable gifts of time, blood, and money.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,16(1),67-86.
  59. Houston, D. J.,Cartwright, K. E.(2007).Spirituality and public service.Public Administration Review,67(1),88-102.
  60. Kim, S.(2006).Public service motivation and organizational citizenship behavior in Korea.International Journal of Manpower,27(8),722-740.
  61. Kim, S.(2012).Does person-organization fit matter in the public-sector? Testing the mediating effect of person-organization fit in the relationship between public service motivation and work attitudes.Public Administration Review,72(6),830-840.
  62. Kim, S.(2009).Revising Perry's measurement scale of public service motivation.The American Review of Public Administration,39(2),149-163.
  63. Kim, S.,Vandenabeele, W.,Wright, B. E.,Andersen, L. B.,Cerase, F. P.,Christensen, R. K.,De Vivo, P.(2013).Investigating the structure and meaning of public service motivation across populations: Developing an international instrument and addressing issues of measurement invariance.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,23(1),79-102.
  64. Kjeldsen, A. M.(2012).Vocational study and public service motivation: Disentangling the socializing effects of higher education.International Public Management Journal,15(4),500-524.
  65. Kleinginna, P. R., Jr.,Kleinginna, A. M.(1981).A categorized list of motivation definitions, with a suggestion for a consensual definition.Motivation and Emotion,5(3),263-291.
  66. Leisink, P.,Steijn, B.(2009).Public service motivation and job performance of public sector employees in the Netherlands.International Review of Administrative Sciences,75(1),35-52.
  67. Li, D.(2014).Value Theory: A Research into Subjectivity.New York:Springer.
  68. Liu, B. C.,Tang, T. L. P.(2011).Does the love of money moderate the relationship between public service motivation and job satisfaction? The case of Chinese professionals in the public sector.Public Administration Review,71(5),718-727.
  69. Liu, B.,Tang, N.,Zhu, X.(2008).Public service motivation and job satisfaction in China: An investigation of generalisability and instrumentality.International Journal of Manpower,29(8),684-699.
  70. Maio, G. R.,Haddock, G.(2010).Psychology of attitudes and attitude change.London:SAGE.
  71. Martocchio, J. J.(Ed.),Ferris, G. R.(Ed.)(2003).Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management.Oxford:Elsevier Science Ltd.
  72. Masden, K. B.(1974).Modern theories of motivation: A comparative metascientific study.Oxford, England:John Wiley & Sons.
  73. Moynihan, D. P.(2010).A workforce of cynics? The effects of contemporary reforms on public service motivation.International Public Management Journal,13(1),24-34.
  74. Moynihan, D. P.,Pandey, S. K.(2007).The role of organizations in fostering public service motivation.Public Administration Review,67(1),40-53.
  75. Myers, D. G.,Twenge, J. M.(2013).Social psychology.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  76. Naff, K. C.,Crum, J.(1999).Working for America does public service motivation make a difference?.Review of Public Personnel Administration,19(4),5-16.
  77. Pandey, S. K.,Wright, B. E.,Moynihan, D. P.(2008).Public service motivation and interpersonal citizenship behavior in public organizations: Testing a preliminary model.International Public Management Journal,11(1),89-108.
  78. Pelletier, L. G.,Fortier, M. S.,Vallerand, R. J.,Tuson, K. M.,Briere, N. M.,Blais, M. R.(1995).Toward a new measure of intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, and amotivation in sports: The sport motivation scale (SMS).Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,17,35-53.
  79. Perry, J. L.(1996).Measuring public service motivation: An assessment of construct reliability and validity.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,6(1),5-22.
  80. Perry, J. L.(2014).The motivational bases of public service: Foundations for a third wave of research.Asia Pacific Journal of Public Administration,36(1),34-47.
  81. Perry, J. L.(1997).Antecedents of public service motivation.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,7(2),181-197.
  82. Perry, J. L.(2000).Bringing society in: Toward a theory of public-service motivation.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,10(2),471-488.
  83. Perry, J. L.(Ed.),Hondeghem, A.(Ed.)(2008).Motivation in public management: The call of public service.New York:Oxford University Press.
  84. Perry, J. L.,Brudney, J. L.,Coursey, D.,Littlepage, L.(2008).What drives morally committed citizens? A study of the antecedents of public service motivation.Public Administration Review,68(3),445-458.
  85. Perry, J. L.,Hondeghem, A.(2008).Building theory and empirical evidence about public service motivation.International Public Management Journal,11(1),3-12.
  86. Perry, J. L.,Hondeghem, A.,Wise, L. R.(2010).Revisiting the motivational bases of public service: Twenty years of research and an agenda for the future.Public Administration Review,70(5),681-690.
  87. Perry, J. L.,Porter, L. W.(1982).Factors affecting the context for motivation in public organizations.Academy of Management Review,7(1),89-98.
  88. Perry, J. L.,Vandenabeele, W.(2015).Public service motivation research: Achievements, challenges, and future directions.Public Administration Review,75(5),692-699.
  89. Perry, J. L.,Wise, L. R.(1990).The motivational bases of public service.Public Administration Review,50(3),367-373.
  90. Prebble, M.(2016).Has the study of public service motivation addressed the issues that motivated the study?.The American Review of Public Administration,46(3),267-291.
  91. Rainey, H. G.(1982).Reward preferences among public and private managers: In search of the service ethic.The American Review of Public Administration,16(4),288-302.
  92. Rainey, H. G.,Steinbauer, P.(1999).Galloping elephants: Developing elements of a theory of effective government organizations.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,9(1),1-32.
  93. Ritz, A.(2009).Public service motivation and organizational performance in Swiss federal government.International Review of Administrative Sciences,75(1),53-78.
  94. Ritz, A.,Brewer, G. A.,Neumann, O.(2016).Public service motivation: A systematic literature review and outlook.Public Administration Review,76(3),414-426.
  95. Ryan, R. M.,Connell, J. P.(1989).Perceived locus of causality and internalization: Examining reasons for acting in two domains.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,57(5),749-761.
  96. Ryan, R. M.,Deci, E. L.(2000).Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being.American Psychologist,55(1),68-78.
  97. Scott, P. G.,Pandey, S. K.(2005).Red tape and public service motivation findings from a National Survey of Managers in State Health and Human Services Agencies.Review of Public Personnel Administration,25(2),155-180.
  98. Steijn, B.(2008).Person-environment fit and public service motivation.International Public Management Journal,11(1),13-27.
  99. Taylor, J.(2008).Organizational influences, public service motivation and work outcomes: An Australian study.International Public Management Journal,11(1),67-88.
  100. Taylor, J.(2007).The impact of public service motives on work outcomes in Australia: A comparative multi-dimensional analysis.Public Administration,85(4),931-959.
  101. Tremblay, M. A.,Blanchard, C. M.,Taylor, S.,Pelletier, L. G.,Villeneuve, M.(2009).Work extrinsic and intrinsic motivation scale: Its value for organizational psychology research.Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science,41(4),213-226.
  102. Vallerand, R. J.,Pelletier, L. G.,Blais, M. R.,Briere, N. M.,Senecal, C.,Vallieres, E. F.(1992).The academic motivation scale: A measure of intrinsic, extrinsic, and amotivation in education.Educational and Psychological Measurement,52(4),1003-1017.
  103. Van den Broeck, A.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Witte, H. D.,Soenens, B.,Lens, W.(2010).Capturing autonomy, competence, and relatedness at work: Construction and initial validation of the workrelated basic need satisfaction scale.Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,83(4),981-1002.
  104. Vandenabeele, W.(2011).Who wants to deliver public service? Do institutional antecedents of public service motivation provide an answer?.Review of Public Personnel Administration,31(1),87-107.
  105. Vandenabeele, W.(2008).Development of a public service motivation measurement scale: Corroborating and extending Perry's measurement instrument.International Public Management Journal,11(1),143-167.
  106. Vandenabeele, W.(2007).Toward a public administration theory of public service motivation: An institutional approach.Public Management Review,9(4),545-556.
  107. Vandenabeele, W.,Scheepers, S.,Hondeghem, A.(2006).Public service motivation in an international comparative perspective: The UK and Germany.Public Policy and Administration,21(1),13-31.
  108. Ward, K. D.(2014).Cultivating public service motivation through AmeriCorps service: A longitudinal study.Public Administration Review,74(1),114-125.
  109. Weinstein, N.,Ryan, R. M.(2010).When helping helps: Autonomous motivation for prosocial behavior and its influence on well-being for the helper and recipient.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,98(2),222-244.
  110. Williams, G. G.,Gagné, M.,Ryan, R. M.,Deci, E. L.(2002).Facilitating autonomous motivation for smoking cessation.Health Psychology,21(1),40-50.
  111. Wright, B. E.(2007).Public service and motivation: Does mission matter?.Public Administration Review,67(1),54-64.
  112. Wright, B. E.,Pandey, S. K.(2008).Public service motivation and the assumption of person-organization fit: Testing the mediating effect of value congruence.Administration & Society,40(5),502-521.
  113. 朱春奎、吳辰(2012)。公共服務動機對工作滿意度的影響研究。公共行政評論，1，83-104。
  114. 李小華(2007)。西方公共服務動機研究。理論探討，3，146-149。
  115. 孟凡蓉、吳建南(2014)。公共服務動機視角下績效工資公平感對工作投入的影響。西安交通大學學報（社會科學版），34(1)，61-69。
  116. 林玉雯(2015)。博士論文(博士論文)。南投，國立暨南國際大學公共行政與政策學系。
  117. 孫同文、許耿銘(2014)。橘淮為枳：公共服務動機指標適用性的分析。民主與治理，1(1)，33-52。
  118. 張劍、張建兵、李躍、Deci, E. L.(2010)。促進工作動機的有效路徑：自我決定理論的觀點。心理科學進展，18(5)，752-759。
被引用次数
  1. 董祥開,陳敦源,陳揚中,張鎧如(2021)。「合得來」重要嗎？公務人員個人組織配適度對工作滿意度之影響。社會科學論叢，15(1)，45-84。
  2. 董祥開,陳重安,許成委(2023)。年金改革、自利傾向及自我犧牲關聯之實證研究。行政暨政策學報，76，43-69。
  3. 董祥開,高于涵(2022)。國考分發與類科對資淺公務人員轉調傾向之影響：公共服務動機為調節變項。文官制度季刊，14(2)，51-93。
  4. 董祥開,黃政勛(2020)。選擇沈默還是發聲？影響公務員揭弊意願因素之實證研究。東吳政治學報，38(3)，1-63。
  5. 董祥開,柳嘉蕙(2020)。情緒智力對工作滿意度之影響： 公共服務動機的中介效果與調節效果。文官制度季刊，12(1)，51-92。
  6. 黃建勲,陳敦源(2019)。繁文縟節如何影響公共服務動機？ 2011 年臺灣文官調查資料之分析。文官制度季刊，11(1)，35-71。
  7. 黃清宗,陳思先(2023)。策略性培育青年公共服務動機－大學生參與臺北市中山區里鄰發展的行動實證分析。中國地方自治，76(9)，36-75。
  8. 黃婉玲(2019)。為何選擇就讀軍警院校？公共服務動機的角色。公共行政學報，57，83-118。
  9. 李俊達(2020)。公共服務動機析論：兼論後年改時代提升公共服務動機之策略。文官制度季刊，12(2)，57-87。
  10. 李仲彬(2018)。與生俱來與後天培養：影響公務人員創新態度與行為的因素分析。公共行政學報，54，1-40。
  11. 劉皓仁,陳芙萱(2022)。神的職業vs.人的工作：為什麼公共服務動機很重要？。公共行政學報，63，135-147。
  12. 邱文智(2023)。公共服務動機對公務人員創新影響之研究：兼論情緒智力中介效果。行政暨政策學報，76，71-99。
  13. 孫同文(2018)。芝麻掉了？讀〈公共服務動機：回顧、反思與未來方向〉有感。公共行政學報，54，127-138。
  14. 謝儲鍵、陳敦源、張鐙文(2018)。臺灣公共行政領域智識流動的研究：治理概念擴散與連接之初探。行政暨政策學報，66，39-83。
  15. (2019)。公務員社會支持、公共服務動機影響工作倦怠、離職意願之因果模式分析。空大行政學報，33，1-20。
  16. (2024)。企業社會責任新方向：桃園捷運公司策略性發展。中國地方自治，77(8)，3-37。
print cancel