题名

論資料分析在政府Web 2.0網站治理中的角色定位

并列篇名

A Study on the Positioning of Data Analytics in Government Web 2.0 Governance

DOI

10.30409/JPA.202309_(65).0002

作者

張巧函(Carol Chiao-Han Chang)

关键词

Web 2.0 ； 社群媒體 ； 數位政府 ； 社群媒體分析 ； 網站治理 ； Web 2.0 ； social media ； E-government ； social media analysis ； Website governance

期刊名称

公共行政學報

卷期/出版年月

65期（2023 / 09 / 01）

页次

41 - 76

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

我國公部門大約從2010年以後開始投入Web 2.0社群媒體經營，但外界對於政府經營社群媒體存在不少質疑，如預算過高、成效不彰等問題。相較於企業如Amazon等成功運用數據分析和社群媒體運營取得成果，政府機關在經營社群媒體時，缺乏清晰的目標定位，也未能有效運用社群媒體資料分析制定適切策略。本文訪談8位負責管理機關Facebook網站的臺北市政府公務員，深入探討現今政府機關經營社群媒體的目標、策略、資料分析應用概況，以及政府機關應該如何「獲得」資料分析能力，以做好社群媒體網站治理的工作。本文也針對政府機關從事社群媒體網站治理的問題現況，給予具體的實務建議，包含：（一）建立明確的社群媒體治理目標；（二）重視資料分析能力，拓展多元化的社群媒體經營策略；（三）培養公務員對資料分析的專業素養，避免過度依賴業務委外。本文希望透過文獻理論回顧及深度訪談，檢視政府機關在網站治理實務中潛在的真實問題，並提出可行的解決策略。
英文摘要

Our government departments have been operating social media since around going back to 2010. However, many doubts abound about the government's social media operations, such as its high budgets and ineffectiveness. Compared to companies like Amazon that have successfully utilized data analysis and social media operations to achieve results, government departments lack clear objectives in managing social media and have not been able to effectively use social media data analysis to formulate appropriate strategies. This study interviews 8 Taipei City government departments with Facebook website operations. It delves into the current objectives, strategies, and data analysis applications of government agencies in managing social media, as well as how government agencies should "acquire" data analysis capabilities to effectively govern social media websites. This study also provides practical suggestions for the current issues faced by government departments in managing social media websites, including: (1) establish clear social media governance objectives; (2) value data analysis capabilities and developing diversified social media management strategies; (3) cultivate civil servants' professional competence in data analysis to avoid over-reliance on outsourcing. Through literature review and in-depth interviews, this study aims to examine the potential real problems faced by government agencies in website governance and propose feasible solutions.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 林佳欣, C.-S.(2018)。修正廣告價值模式：以台灣政府臉書專頁為例。電子商務研究，16(3)，189-210。
    連結：
  2. 林照真, C.-C.(2020)。假新聞類型與媒體聚合：以 2018 年臺灣選舉為例。新聞學研究，142，111-153。
    連結：
  3. Adedoyin-Olowe, M.,Gaber, M. M.,Stahl, F.(2013).A survey of data mining techniques for social media analysis.Journal of Data Mining & Digital Humanities,2014
  4. Andersen, K. V.,Henriksen, H. Z.(2006).E-government maturity models: Extension of the Layne and Lee model.Government Information Quarterly,23(2),236-248.
  5. Anshari, M.,Almunawar, M. N.,Lim, S. A.,Al-Mudimigh, A.(2019).Customer relationship management and big data enabled: Personalization & customization of services.Applied Computing and Informatics,15(2),94-101.
  6. Bradshaw, S.,Bailey, H.,Howard, P. N.(2021).,Oxford Internet Institute.
  7. Cameron, M. P.,Barrett, P.,Stewardson, B.(2016).Can social media predict election results? Evidence from New Zealand.Journal of Political Marketing,15(4),416-432.
  8. Choudhury, N.(2014).World wide web and its journey from web 1.0 to web 4.0.International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies,5(6),8096-8100.
  9. Criado, J. I.,Villodre, J.,Gil-Garcia, J. R.(2022).Social media institutionalization in European local governments: a comparison of administrative traditions.DG.O 2022: The 23rd Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research,Republic of Korea:
  10. Criado, J. I.,Villodre, J.,Meijer, A.(2019).From experimentation to public service delivery in social media. An analysis of institutionalization dynamics in Dutch local governments.Proceedings of the 20th Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research,Dubai, United Arab Emirates:
  11. Dadashzadeh, M.(2010).Social media in government: From eGovernment to eGovernance.Journal of Business & Economics Research,8(11),81-86.
  12. de Kool, D.,van Wamelen, J.(2008).Web 2.0: A New Basis for E-Government?.2008 3rd International Conference on Information and Communication Technologies: From Theory to Applications,Damascus, Syria:
  13. Dekker, R.,van den Brink, P.,Meijer, A.(2020).Social media adoption in the police: Barriers and strategies.Government information quarterly,37(2),101441.
  14. del Fresno García, M.,Daly, A. J.,Segado Sánchez-Cabezudo, S.(2016).Identifying the new influencers in the internet era: Social media and social network analysis.Revista española de investigaciones sociológicas,153,23-40.
  15. Djerf-Pierre, M.,Pierre, J.(2016).Mediatised local government: Social media activity and media strategies among local government officials 1989-2010.Policy and politics,44(1),59-77.
  16. Dubnick, M.(Ed.),Bearfield, D.(Ed.)(2016).Encyclopedia of Public Administration and Public Policy.Taylor & Francis.
  17. Falco, E.,Kleinhans, R.(2018).Beyond information-sharing. A typology of government challenges and requirements for two-way social media communication with citizens.Electronic Journal of e-Government,16(1),18-31.
  18. Foltean, F. S.,Trif, S. M.,Tuleu, D. L.(2019).Customer relationship management capabilities and social media technology use: Consequences on firm performance.Journal of Business Research,104,563-575.
  19. Garrido-Moreno, A.,García-Morales, V.,King, S.,Lockett, N.(2020).Social media use and value creation in the digital landscape: A dynamic-capabilities perspective.Journal of service management,31(3),313-343.
  20. Goncalves, A.(2017).Social media analytics strategy: Using data to optimize business performance.Apress.
  21. Goncalves, J.,Liu, Y.,Xiao, B.,Chaudhry, S.,Hosio, S.,Kostakos, V.(2015).Increasing the reach of government social media: A case study in modeling government–citizen interaction on Facebook.Policy & Internet,7(1),80-102.
  22. Graham, M. W.,Avery, E. J.,Park, S.(2015).The role of social media in local government crisis communications.Public Relations Review,41(3),386-394.
  23. Hansen, D. L.(Ed.),Schneiderman, B.(Ed.),Smith, M. A.(Ed.)(2011).Analyzing social media networks with NodeXL insights from a connected world.Morgan Kaufmann.
  24. Heaselgrave, F.,Simmons, P.(2016).Culture, competency and policy: Why social media dialogue is limited in Australian local government.Journal of Communication Management,20(2),133-147.
  25. Hofmann, S.,Beverungen, D.,Räckers, M.,Becker, J.(2013).What makes local governments’ online communications successful? Insights from a multi-method analysis of Facebook.Government Information Quarterly,30(4),387-396.
  26. Huang, Y.,Wu, Q.,Huang, X.,Bort, J.(2017).A multiplatform investigation of law enforcement agencies on social media.Information Polity,22(2-3),179-196.
  27. Irbo, M. M.,Mohammed, A. A.(2020).Social media, business capabilities and performance: A review of literature.African Journal of Business Management,14(9),271-277.
  28. Kaigo, M.,Okura, S.(2016).Exploring fluctuations in citizen engagement on a local government Facebook page in Japan.Telematics and Informatics,33(2),584-595.
  29. Kane, G. C.(2015).Enterprise social media: Current capabilities and future possibilities.MIS Quarterly Executive,14(1),1-16.
  30. Katigbak, J. J.(2022).Social media adoption and labor migrants protection: The case of the Philippines’ Department of Foreign Affairs.EJournal of EDemocracy and Open Government,14(1),151-171.
  31. Khan, G. F.(2015).Models for social media-based governments.Asia Pacific Journal of Information Systems,25(2),356-369.
  32. Khan, G. F.,Yoon, H. Y.,Park, H. W.(2014).Social media communication strategies of government agencies: Twitter use in Korea and the USA.Asian Journal of Communication,24(1),60-78.
  33. Kim, S. K.,Park, M. J.,Rho, J. J.(2015).Effect of the Government’s Use of Social Media on the Reliability of the Government: Focus on Twitter.Public Management Review,17(3),328-355.
  34. Kurniawati, K.,Shanks, G.,Bekmamedova, N.(2013).The Business Impact of Social Media Analytics.European Conference on Information Systems 2013,Utrecht, Netherlands:
  35. Layne, K.,Lee, J.(2001).Developing fully functional E-government: A four stage model.Government Information Quarterly,18(2),122-136.
  36. Lee, G.,Kwak, Y. H.(2012).An Open Government Maturity Model for social media-based public engagement.Government Information Quarterly,29(4),492-503.
  37. Lee, I.(2018).Social media analytics for enterprises: Typology, methods, and processes.Business Horizons,61(2),199-210.
  38. Linke, A.,Zerfass, A.(2013).Social media governance: Regulatory frameworks for successful online communications.Journal of Communication Management,17(3),270-286.
  39. Lovari, A.,Materassi, L.(2021).Trust me, I am the social media manager! Public sector communication’s trust work in municipality social media channels.Corporate communications: An International Journal,26(1),55-69.
  40. Lu, B.,Zhang, S.,Fan, W.(2016).Social representations of social media use in government: An analysis of Chinese Government microblogging from citizens’ perspective.Social Science Computer Review,34(4),416-436.
  41. Luoma-aho, V.(Ed.),Canel, M. J.(Ed.)(2020).The handbook of public sector communication.Wiley Online Library.
  42. McCormick, R. (2016). Donald Trump says Facebook and Twitter ‘helped him win’. the Verge, November 14. https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/13/13619148/trump-facebook-twitter-helped-win
  43. Meijer, A.,Thaens, M.(2013).Social media strategies: Understanding the differences between North American police departments.Government Information Quarterly,30(4),343-350.
  44. Mergel, I.(2013).Social media adoption and resulting tactics in the U.S. federal government.Government Information Quarterly,30(2),123-130.
  45. Mergel, I.(2010).Government 2.0 revisited: Social media strategies in the public sector.Public Administration,33(3),7-10.
  46. Mergel, I.(2016).Social media institutionalization in the U.S. federal government.Government Information Quarterly,33(1),142-148.
  47. Mergel, I.,Bretschneider, S. I.(2013).A three-stage adoption process for social media use in government.Public Administration Review,73(3),390-400.
  48. Misirlis, N.,Vlachopoulou, M.(2018).Social media metrics and analytics in marketing– S3M: A mapping literature review.International Journal of Information Management,38(1),270-276.
  49. Muninger, M.-I.,Hammedi, W.,Mahr, D.(2019).The value of social media for innovation: A capability perspective.Journal of Business Research,95,116-127.
  50. Nepal, S.(Ed.),Paris, C.(Ed.),Georgakopoulos, D.(Ed.)(2015).Social media for government services.Springer International Publishing.
  51. Neri, F.,Aliprandi, C.,Capeci, F.,Cuadros, M.,By, T.(2012).Sentiment Analysis on Social Media.2012 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining,Istanbul, Turkey:
  52. Picazo-Vela, S.,Gutiérrez-Martínez, I.,Luna-Reyes, L. F.(2012).Understanding risks, benefits, and strategic alternatives of social media applications in the public sector.Government Information Quarterly,29(4),504-511.
  53. Sawalha, S.,Al-Jamal, M.,Abu-Shanab, E.(2019).The influence of utilizing Facebook on e-government adoption.Electronic Government an International Journal,15(1),1-20.
  54. Schwartz, H. A.,Ungar, L. H.(2015).Data-driven content analysis of social media: A systematic overview of automated methods.The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,659(1),78-94.
  55. Seigler, D. J.(2017).Social media responsiveness in the public sector: A study of social media adoption in three functional areas of local government.International Journal of Organization Theory and Behavior,20(1),72-99.
  56. Siau, K.,Long, Y.(2005).Synthesizing e-government stage models - A meta-synthesis based on meta-ethnography approach.Industrial Management & Data Systems,105(4),443-458.
  57. Sivarajah, U.,Irani, Z.,Gupta, S.,Mahroof, K.(2020).Role of big data and social media analytics for business to business sustainability: A participatory web context.Industrial Marketing Management,86,163-179.
  58. Trainor, K. J.,Andzulis, J.,Rapp, A.,Agnihotri, R.(2014).Social media technology usage and customer relationship performance: A capabilities-based examination of social CRM.Journal of Business Research,67(6),1201-1208.
  59. Valaei, N.,Baroto, M. B.(2017).Modelling continuance intention of citizens in government Facebook page: A complementary PLS approach.Computers in Human Behavior,73,224-237.
  60. Wang, X.,Holbrook, A. L.,Feeney, M.(2022).The role of department type in public managers’ attitudes toward social media use.The American Review of Public Administration,52(6),457-471.
  61. Wang, Y.,Rod, M.,Ji, S.,Deng, Q.(2017).Social media capability in B2B marketing: toward a definition and a research model.Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing,32(8),1125-1135.
  62. Wukich, C.(2021).Government social media engagement strategies and public roles.Public Performance & Management Review,44(1),187-215.
  63. Yang, M.,Kiang, M.,Ku, Y.,Chiu, C.,Li, Y.(2011).Social media analytics for radical opinion mining in hate group web forums.Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management,8(1),1-17.
  64. Zhang, Y.,Kimathi, F. A.(2022).Exploring the stages of E-government development from public value perspective.Technology in Society,69,101942.
  65. 何玉華（2017）。新北市府臉書粉專多互動少議員：應整合。自由時報，12 月 9日。https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/local/paper/1158610 [He, Y.-H. (2017). New Taipei City Hall’s Facebook page has many fans and few interactions, councillors: It should be integrated, Liberty Times Net, December 9]
  66. 周韻采, Y.-T.(2003)。電子化政府績效的比較研究：以政府入口網站為例。公共行政學報，9，35-58。
  67. 國家發展委員會（2011）。政府網站 Web 2.0 營運作業參考指引（社會網絡篇）。數位發展部政府網站營運交流平臺。未註明。https://www.webguide.nat.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=450&s=1366 [National Development Council. (2011). Web 2.0 operation reference guide for government websites (social networking chapter). Ministry of Digital Affairs Webguide Service. (n. d.)]
  68. 陳敦源, D.-Y.,潘競恆, J.-H.(2011)。政府就是「我們」：Web 2.0 時代民主治理的希望或幻夢？。研考雙月刊，35(4)，23-35。
  69. 項靖, J.,羅晉, J.,許雲翔, Y.-X.,楊東謀, D.-M.(2016)。,國家發展委員會=National Development Council。
  70. 黃婉婷（2022）。台北城博會砸千萬宣傳挨轟成效差。中國時報，7 月 30 日。https://reader.turnnewsapp.com/ct/20220730/b09aa9/q1rfmjaymja3mzbfqtlfmq2/share [Huang, W.-T. (2022). Taipei Expo’s 10 million dollar publicity campaign bombarded with poor results. China Times, July 30.]
  71. 臺北市政府（未註明）。各機關臉書。檢索日期 2022 年 8 月 9 日，取自https://www.gov.taipei/News.aspx?n=121C309B120E6BEF&sms=2656E3C491B3B9EB [Taipei City Government (2016). Ge jiguan lianshu, August, 9, 2022.]
  72. 劉致昕, Z.-X.(2021).真相製造：從聖戰士媽媽、極權政府、網軍教練、境外勢力、打假部隊、內容農場主人到政府小編.春山出版=SpringHill Publishing Ltd.
  73. 數位發展部（2016）。政府機關社群服務營運指標探討。數位發展部政府網站營運交流平台，5 月 8 日。https://www.webguide.nat.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx? n=531&s=1759 [Ministry of Digital Affairs (2016). Review the Operation Indicators of Community Services of Public Agencies. Ministry of Digital Affairs Webguide Service, May 8.]
  74. 潘競恆, J.-H.(2017)。多媒體潮流下之公共服務行銷與管理。國土及公共治理季刊，5(1)，42-54。
  75. 魯鋼駿（2022）。竹市局處分享林智堅臉書動態時力議員批不恰當。中央社，3月 24 日。https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aloc/202203240131.aspx [Lu, G.-J. (2022). Hsinchu City Government shares Lin Zhi-jian’s Facebook updates, which was criticized as inappropriate by councilor. Central News Agency, March 24.]
print cancel