九年一貫健康教育課程口腔衛生電腦輔助教材發展與成效評估

The Development and Evaluation of the Oral Health Computer Assisted Instruction in the 1st-9th-grades Health Education Curriculum

10.30026/CJSH.200906.0002

劉婉柔(Wan-Jou Liu)；胡益進(Yih-Jin Hu)；林瑞誼(Ruei-Yi Lin)

口腔衛生 ； 九年一貫課程 ； 電腦輔助教學 ； 教育介入 ； 健康教育 ； oral health ； the 1st-9th-grades Curriculum ； computer assisted instruction ； intervention curriculum ； health education

學校衛生

54期（2009 / 06 / 01）

25 - 50

繁體中文

本研究旨在發展九年一貫健康教育課程口腔衛生電腦輔助教材，以供學校健康與體育領域課程之教師與校護於口腔衛生教育教學時使用。因此以國中小學童為研究對象設計教育介入策略，並以準實驗設計之『實驗組對照組前後測設計』，以立意選取的學校作為實驗分組的依據，共有313人參與本研究，前測在介入前一週施測，介入時間為二週，後測於介入後隨即進行，後後測於介入後二個月進行，以了解教育介入成效。重要研究結果歸納如下： 一、口腔衛生電腦輔助教材介入方式對於五年級學童而言，在「口腔衛生知識」、「口腔衛生態度」、「口腔衛生自我效能」與「口腔衛生習慣」等方面的立即成效上有顯著進步；對於七年級學童而言，只有在「口腔衛生知識」方面的立即成效上有顯著進步。 二、口腔衛生電腦輔助教材介入方式對於五、七年級學童而言，在「口腔衛生知識」、「口腔衛生態度」、「口腔衛生自我效能」與「口腔衛生習慣」等方面的延宕成效上無顯著差異產生，也就是本研究介入法無法使五、七年級學童產生上述變項的延宕成效。 三、進一步比較五與七年級學童之介入立即成效影響，發現五與七年級學童在「口腔衛生知識」方面是無顯著差異的，也就是此教育介入可使五年級與七年級學童口腔衛生知識皆產生立即提升效果。然而，在「口腔衛生態度」、「口腔衛生自我效能」與「口腔衛生習慣」方面的立即成效則有顯著差異，也就是五年級學童的教育介入成效會比七年級學生好。綜上所述，本研究研發的口腔衛生電腦輔助介入教材，對於國小五年級學童的教學影響成效較好，若要讓國中生也達相同成效，或許教學內容還需改進。

The main purpose of this study was to develop the oral health computer assisted instruction in the 1st-9th-grades Curriculum for health education teachers and school nurses. The intervention group comprised students of the elementary and junior high schools. This study was constructed on quasi-experimental design with case-control study. These experimental schools were non-randomly assigned by the main purpose of this study. There were 313 samples in this study. Taking the pretest before the intervention curriculum started about one week. The treatment group received the intervention curriculum for two weeks, and the control group received nothing. Taking the posttest after the intervention curriculum terminated immediately. The post-posttest was taken after the intervention curriculum terminated about two months. The major findings of this study were as follows: 1. After the teaching of the oral health education intervened immediately for 5 grade students, the scores of oral health knowledge, oral health attitudes, oral health self-efficiency, and oral health habits in experimental group were significantly increased. Besides, the scores of oral health knowledge for 7 grade students in experimental group were significantly increased. 2. Two months after the teaching of the oral health education intervened, there were no significant differences for 5 & 7 grade students in oral health knowledge, oral health attitudes, oral health self-efficiency, and oral health habits. 3. Further, comparing the posttest for 5 & 7 grade students, and to know which one was more effective. After analyzed, the scores of oral health knowledge were not significantly affected. In another word this intervention curriculum can promote the scores of oral health knowledge for 5 & 7 grade students. However, the scores of oral health attitudes, oral health self-efficiency, and oral health habits for 5 & 7 grade students were significantly increased. In other words, the effect for 5 grade students after intervened was better than 7 grade students. Consequently, the oral health computer assisted instruction had to be reformed, and more suited to 7 grade students.

1. 馬懿慈(2004)。潔牙保健計畫推廣成效之探討－以嘉義縣某國小為例。學校衛生，44，109-117。
   連結：
2. Jones S,Burt BA,Petersen PE,Lennon MA.(2005).The effective use of fluorides in public health. Bull World Health Organ,83(9),670-676.
3. Marcus, B. H.,Banspach, S. W. ,Lefebvre, R. C.,Rossi, J. S.,Garleton, R. A.,Abrams, D. B.(1992).Using the stage of change model to increase the adoption of physical activity among community participants.American Journal of Health Promotion,6(6),424-429.
4. Marcus, B. H.,Owen, N.,Forsyth, L. H.,Cavill, N. A.,Fridinger, F.(1998).Physical activity intervention using mass media, print media, and information technology.American Journal of Prevention Medicine,15(4),362-378.
5. Martin Hobdell,Poul Erik Petersen,John Clarkson,Newell Johnson(2003).Global goals for oral health 2020.International Dental journal,53,285-288.
6. Poutanen R.,Lahti S.,Hausen H.(2005).Oral health-related knowledge, attitude, and beliefs among 11 to 12-year-old Finnish schoolchildren with different oral health behaviors.Acta Odontologica Scandinavica,63(1),10-16.
7. Reid, D.(1996).How effective is health education via mass communications?.Health Educational Jounal,55,332-344.
8. Rong WS,Bian JY,Wang WJ,Wang JD(2003).Effectiveness of an oral health education and caries prevention program in kindergartens in China.Community Dent Oral Epidemiol,31,412-416.
9. S. Friel,A. Hope,C. Kelleher,S. Comer,D. Sadlier(2002).Impact evaluation of an oral health intervention amongst primary school children in Ireland.Health Promotion International,17(2)
10. Sheihan A.,Watt R.G.(2002).Common risk factor a rational basis for promoting oral health.Community Dent Oral Epidemiol,28,399-406.
11. Vanobbergen J,Declerck D,Mwalili S,Martens L(2004).The effectiveness of a 6-year oral health education programme for primary schoolchildren.Community Dent Oral Epidemiol,32,173-182.
12. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol
13. World Health Organization(2003).The world oral health report 2003.Continuous improvement of oral health in the 21st century-the approach of the WHO global oral health programme, Geneva. World health organization.
14. 卜婷芳(2005)。高雄醫學大學口腔衛生科學研究所碩士論文（未出版）。
15. 呂宜珍、金繼春(1999)。國小高年級學童口腔衛生行為及其相關因素。公共衛生，26(2)，115-127。
16. 周志銜、何清松、邱耀章、藍守仁、陳俊凱、劉育能(2004)。嘉義市國小學童口腔健康行為及相關因素之研究。台灣口腔醫學衛生科學雜誌，20，11-22。
17. 林珠莉(2006)。國立台灣師範大學衛生教育學系碩士論文（未出版）。
18. 姚振華、季麟揚、黃耀慧、林麗芳、張進順(2003)。台灣山地鄉口腔醫療保健服務計畫支出其評價。台灣口腔醫學衛生科學雜誌，19，34-37。
19. 姚振華、張曉梅、陳日生、陳孟愔(2001)。牙科公共衛生學。國立編譯館，華泰文化事業公司。
20. 姚振華、黃維勳、康淑惠(1998)。台北市國小六年級學童口腔衛生教育介入對知識態度行為與牙菌斑控制之影響。中華牙誌，17(1)，36-47。
21. 洪榮昭(1992)。電腦輔助教學之設計原理與應用。台北:師大書苑。
22. 孫世明(2005)。論資訊技術與學科課程整合的利弊。教育研究雜誌，11，74-79。
23. 張俊彥、陳盈霖(2000)。不同電腦輔助教學(CAI)模式對高中學生「恆星演化」學習成就及其態度之影響。國立台灣師範大學學報，45(2)，1-20。
24. 張淑玲(2006)。高雄醫學大學口腔衛生科學研究所碩士論文（未出版）。
25. 教育部(2007)。學（幼）童口腔衛生保健實施計畫。96年6月1日台體（二）字第0960080759號核定。
26. 陳俊宏、楊東民(1998)。視覺傳達設計概論。台北:全華科技圖書。
27. 陳淑惠(2002)。國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系在職進修碩士論文（未出版）。
28. 董家莒、張俊彥、蕭建華、載明國(2001)。多媒體電腦輔助學習歷程對學生地球科學學習成就之影響。師大學報，4(1,2)，43-46。
29. 廖美蘭(2003)。高雄醫學大學口腔衛生科學研究所碩士論文（未出版）。
30. 蔡吉政、蕭夢雄、吳逸民(1998)。學校人員意願與口腔衛生教育介入對國小學童口腔衛生影響之探討，14，379-386。
31. 蔡媖媖(2003)。高雄醫學大學口腔衛生科學研究所碩士論文（未出版）。
32. 薛雅明、徐玉瓊(2005)。超媒體學習系統中互動姓對系統認知態度、滿意度與學習成效之影響。國立臺南大學學報，39(1)，175-192。
33. 蘇若蘭、楊奕馨、曾筑瑄、謝天渝(2006)。原住民國中學生實施衛生教育介入對其口腔保健認知與行為影響之研究。中華牙誌，25(2)，103-111。

1. 葉國樑、黃禎貞、曾治乾、莊博閔、范群忠、林建輝(2011)。台北縣某國中學生口腔衛生行為及其相關因素之探討。學校衛生，58，103-122。