錫安主義：「復國」與種族清洗？

Zionism: Nation State Building and the Politics of Ethnic Cleansing?

10.30384/CHNCCU.202009_(35).0007

黃如慧(Huang, Ju-Hui)

猶太問題 ； 錫安主義 ； 〈貝爾福宣言〉 ； 巴勒斯坦問題 ； 種族清洗 ； D計畫 ； Jewish Question ； Zionism ； Balfour Declaration ； Palestine Question ； the ethnic cleansing ； Plan D

政大史粹

35期（2020 / 09 / 01）

183 - 211

繁體中文

猶太人在異邦人的歐洲度過了漫長的「離散」時期，然而猶太人藉著經典建立起來強烈的文化傳統使其與當地社會難以相融，終成棘手的「猶太問題」。藉著十九世紀民族主義影響的廂助，錫安主義認清其原始需求（安全感）並開始實際行動以滿足之，直到一戰以前終於因著〈貝爾福宣言〉而有了初步的成果。然而錫安主義作為歐洲民族主義潮流之一支，來到了巴勒斯坦卻邁向民族主義難以支持的種族主義路線，然而這對猶太人而言並非「隨機應變」決定的政策，而是其意識型態的基礎，本文希望藉由追尋錫安主義思想基礎的脈絡，找出其決策種族清洗的根源。

The Diaspora make the Jews who went into exile everywhere and some of them have been living in Europe for countless generations. These European Jews (or so-called Ashkenazi) who for a long-being have been by their own religion and exceptional identity alienating from the local. It is the reason and the background that the so-called ＂Jewish Question＂ gradually as a great problem which emerged in Europe, especially during the era of nationalism. On the other hand, some Jews utilized the terminology and ideology of nationalism to explain their own political situation in Europe and through it to strengthen their own Jewish identity and after that these two political and cultural elements had been combined with and from that a final solution arose-Zionism. Zionism grasped the opportunity by the guilty, embarrassment and hatred of the Europeans to ＂return＂ to their ＂traditional＂ and by the Bible mandated ＂Homeland＂. By ＂returning＂ the Jews immediately faced the people who for long long-term living here and considered a must-do to handle it-coexistence or ＂purification＂ (or ethnical cleansing or Plan D)? And the later was the solution. Why the contemporaries treated it as the means in superiority and in optimality? One should follow the trail engraved in the Jewish history (all-inclusive-religious, cultural, identic and even political etc.) and it is the goal which trying to be achieved in this essay.

1. 杜子信(2012)。錫安主義的形成、演變及猶太人的復國。興大歷史學報，25，107-147。
   連結：
2. https://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/0/7D35E1F729DF491C85256EE700686136
3. http://www.hagalil.com/israel/verfassung/verfassung.htm
4. “ Theodor Herzl. ” Britannica Academic, Encyclopædia Britannica, 16 Nov. 2009.academic.eb.com/levels/collegiate/article/Theodor-Herzl/40268. Accessed 15 Jul. 2019.
5. https://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/0/07175DE9FA2DE563852568D3006E10F3
6. https://www.trumanlibrary.org/israel/unplan19.gif
7. http://undocs.org/A/Res/1514(XV).
8. https://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/0/7F0AF2BD897689B785256C330061D253
9. Al-Husseini, Jalal(2000).UNRWA and the Palestinian Nation-Building Process.Journal of Palestine Studies,29(2),51-64.
10. Amar-Dahl, Tamar(2012).Das zionistische Israel: Jüdischer Nationalismus und die Geschichte des Nahostkonflikts.Paderborn:Ferdinand Schöningh.
11. Asseburg, Muriel,Busse, Jan(2016).Der Nahostkonflikt: Geschichte, Positionen, Perspektiven.München:C. H. Beck oHG.
12. B. Doumani, Beshara(1992).Rediscovering Ottoman Palestine: Writing Palestinians into History.Journal of Palestine Studies,21(2),5-28.
13. Blecher, Robert(2005).Citizens without Sovereignty: Transfer and Ethnic Cleansing in Israel.Comparative Studies in Society and History,47(4),725-754.
14. Brenner, Michael(2016).Geschichte des Zionismus.München:C. H. Beck oHG.
15. Cohen, Naomi W.(1978).American Jewish Reactions to Anti-Semitism in Western Europe, 1875-1900.American Academy for Jewish Research,45,29-65.
16. Destani, Beitullah(ed.)(2004).The Zionist Movement and the Foundation of Israel 1839-1972, Volume I: 1839-1916.Farnham Common [England]:Archive Editions.
17. Gerber, Haim(2003).Zionism, Orientalism, and the Palestinians.Journal of Palestine Studies,33(1),23-41.
18. Gorny, Yosef(1987).Zionism and the Arabs, 1882-1948: A Survey of Ideology.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
19. Halpern, Ben(1969).The Idea of the Jewish State.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
20. Herzog, Chaim(2005).The Arab-Israeli Wars: War and Peace in the Middle East from the 1948 War of Independence to the Present.New York:Vintage Books.
21. Kayyali, A. W(ed.)(1979).Zionism, Imperialism and Racism.London:Croom Helm.
22. Khalidi, Rashid(2007).The Iron Cage: The Story of the Palestinian Struggle for Statehood.Oxford:Oneworld.
23. Khalidi, Waldi(2009).The Hebrew Reconquista of Palestine: From the 1947 United Nations Partition Resolution to the First Zionist Congress of 1897.Journal of Palastine Studies,39(1),24-42.
24. Kimmerling, Baruch(1995).Academic History Caught in the Cross-Fire: The Case of Israeli-Jewish Historiography.History and Memory,7(1),41-65.
25. Masalha, Nur(1991).A Critique of Benny Morris.Journal of Palestine Studies,21(1),90-97.
26. Massad, Joseph(1996).Zionism’s Internal Others: Israel and the Oriental Jews.Journal of Palestine Studies,25(4),53-68.
27. Morris, Benny(1987).The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947-1949.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
28. Nimni, Ephraim(2010).Point of Departure. Reviewd Works: The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine by Ilan Pappe.Journal of Palestine Studies,39(3),83-84.
29. Pappe, Ilan(2014).The Idea of Israel: A History of Power and Knowledge.London:Verso.
30. Pappe, Ilan(2006).A History of Modern Palestine: One Land, Two Peoples.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
31. Pappe, Ilan(2006).The 1948 Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine.Journal of Palestine Studies,36(1),6-20.
32. Pappe, Ilan(2006).The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine.Oxford:Oneworld.
33. Pappe, Ilan(2009).The Vicissitudes of the 1948 Historiography of Israel.Journal of Palestine Studies,39(1),6-23.
34. Pappe, Ilan(Ed.)(1999).The Israel / Palestine Question.London:Routledge.
35. Pappe, Ilan(ed.),Hilal, Jamil(ed.)(2010).Across the Wall: Narratives of Israeli-Palestinian History.London:I.B. Tauris.
36. Ram, Uri(2008).Arab-Israeli Conflict. Reviewed Works: The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine by Ilan Pappe.Middle East Journal,62(1),150-152.
37. Reich, Bernard(1991).Themes in the History of the State of Israel.The American Historical Review,96(5),1466-1478.
38. Rose, John(2004).The Myths of Zionism.London:Pluto Press.
39. Roy, Sara(2002).Why Peace failed: An Oslo Autopsy.Current History,101(651),233-249.
40. Roy, Sara(2004).The Palestinian-Israeli Conflict and Palestinian Socioeconomic Decline: A place Denied.International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society,17(3),365-403.
41. Sa’di, Ahmad(ed.),Abu-Lughod, Lila(ed.)(2007).Nakba: Palestine, 1948 and the Claims of Memory.New York:Columbia University Press.
42. Said, Edward W.(1979).Zionism from the Standpoint of Its Victims.Social Text,1,7-58.

1. 呂嘉穎(2022)。從Gambia v. Myanmar於ICJ之控訴談起－翁山蘇姬的兩難與緬甸政治局勢之現實。德明學報，45，1-19。